ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Reviews of Day 1: Ted and Michelle

Posted: Tuesday, August 26, 2008 9:08 AM by Domenico Montanaro

The New York Times: “Senator Edward M. Kennedy, struggling with brain cancer, arrived on Monday night at the Democratic National Convention in a triumphant appearance that evoked 50 years of party history as Democrats gathered to nominate Senator Barack Obama for president. Mr. Kennedy’s appearance wiped away, at least for the evening, some of the tension that continued to plague the party in the wake of the primary fight between Mr. Obama and Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton. It also represented an effort by the Obama campaign to claim the Kennedy mantle, and it set the stage for the second part of what was designed to be an emotionally powerful two-act evening: an appearance later by Michelle Obama, who began a weeklong effort to present her husband - and his entire family - as embodiments of the American dream.” 

The Washington Post: After an emotional speech by an ailing Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, the face of the Democratic Party shifted on Monday night to a new generation of leaders, as Michelle Obama opened the Democratic National Convention with a tribute to her husband and a call to the country to listen ‘to our hopes instead of our fears,’ and ‘to stop doubting and to start dreaming.’”

USA Today has more on Michelle’s speech: “Michelle Obama, whose husband calls her ‘the star’ of their family, introduced herself Monday to the Democratic convention in a heartfelt speech invoking the dreams of her father and the hopes of her husband for the nation. ‘Barack and I were raised with so many of the same values: that you work hard for what you want in life; that your word is your bond and you do what you say you're going to do,’ Obama said. ‘You treat people with dignity and respect, even if you don't know them, and even if you don't agree with them.”

The Los Angeles Times' Z. Barabak: "For all of the upbeat talk, tensions continued to stir between supporters of the Illinois senator and Hillary Rodham Clinton, threatening the unity that Democrats desperately seek as they face a rugged fight against Republican John McCain. None of that friction was visible, however, during the official program beamed worldwide from the star-spangled inside of Denver's Pepsi Center sports arena. The agenda was clear and two-pronged: Build an image of Obama as an everyman and start ripping McCain apart." 

Ted Kennedy and Michelle Obama are six columns wide on the Boston Globe's cover. Headline: "Democrats share their dreams."

The Globe's Canellos: “But Kennedy's speech was much more than a moving acknowledgment of the tribute being paid to him - it was much more than anyone could have expected. It was, in fact, the party's real keynote address - a call to arms that brought together past and present, and set the agenda for all the speeches to follow… He also - and perhaps most importantly - bequeathed the 'dream' of charismatic liberalism that was embodied by President Kennedy to Barack Obama; with the martyred president's daughter at his side, he made it clear that Obama, more than any member of the Kennedy family, would be the future custodian of the Camelot legacy."

Kennedy is also the cover of the NY Post: "Old Lion Roars."

Michelle and a mic-carrying Sasha Obama are on the cover of the NY Daily News: "Love You Dad." Subhead: "Michelle and kids wow 'em on night of high drama at convention."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Kennedy was awesome.  I don't agree with all of his politics -- but that was indeed an inspiring moment.

http://thepajamapundit.com/
‘Barack and I were raised with so many of the same values:
so nice that her baby daddy and her have so much in common like that America is a "Down right mean nasty place"
All her words not mine so keep your "your a raciest" comments to yourself
Day one was a snoozer. Hope it picks up tonight.
Great first night!

Carville's missed point aside, last night accomplished exactly what it was supposed to.

Ted Kennedy helped push everyone together and Michelle really improved her image and that of her husband.

Stellar first night... McCain can go do stupid human tricks tomorrow on Letterman. Side-show McCain is anti-climactic no matter what he does at this point.

http://www.rodneyhopper.com
decent reviews but still doesn't tell me why I need to vote for Obama
I thought Day 1 of the convention was Awesome.  I was completely disenthralled with MSNBC coverage and the fact that they didn't show all of the speeches.  That was a huge disappointment.  Further, Ann Curry was just plain appalling with her, "but what about PUMA - can you really achieve Unity?  Aren't half your constituency bitter..." crap.  That was by far the LOW point.  I plan to watch PBS or CSPAN tonight.  Unfortunately, I had tivoed it last night and there wasn't a way to 'recover' since I didn't start watching until 9:30p.  Life with three kids is definitely challenging during this convention - Ha Ha

From Yesterday - “American girl- McCain collectables will be treasured for years by Nazi memorabilia collectors.”  Scooter (Sent Monday, August 25, 2008 6:29 PM) Actually, McCain himself is the real collectible – problem is – he is not increasing in value!
I thought Day 1 was great!

What wasn't so great was listening to media pundits complaining about a lack of attacks against John McCain.

Here's a friendly reminder: You guys are REPORTERS - so REPORT what did happen instead of WHINE about what DIDN'T happen. The convention is not designed to ENTERTAIN reporters and it is not a boxing match for you to keep score on.

It must be a sad existence to be so very jaded.
Good first day for the Democrats. Those two presentations - Ted Kennedy and Michelle Obama - were powerful. In Kennedy's case, almost heroic.

Regardless of what you think of Kennedy and his politics, its noteworthy when we see a person for whom an election means more than his own health.
You know...it's not "the Clinton's" that are not welcome... because I personally and I think the majority of Obama supporters would have been so excited if she was (because she is) our team mate...

but Bill needs to grasp his time has moved on.

Hillary's time is now with us.

Hillary is part of this new generation and I think (personally as a die hard obama supporter that originally volunteered for Hill) most are hopeful that people will stop referring to them as the Clintons...

it's not Bill time...

It's Hill's time. and She is part of the NEW leadership.

How amazing Hillary would be if there was no such thing as Bill Clinton's id.

The fact that Michelle Obama had to "stress Obama’s American values" something that should be self evident in a presidential candidate but is not means that the Democrats are in trouble. DO any of you understand they needed to make the case to American voters that they are patriotic. They are already losing this election...
It was an awesome nite for the Democrats!

Is it me or do they totally disrespect Mika on Morning Joe?  They never let her finish a sentence, they talk over her like her opinion does not count and Joe makes rude jokes about her and she just sits there with a blank look on her face, like she is scared to really speak back to him.
I know she is his ‘Side Kick’, but does that mean he can kick her (back) side at his whim?

Just my observation…

Michelle was GREAT last night, wasn’t she?  Love it !!!  She’ll be a lovely and gracious First Lady.

P.S. Why are you still on the air Joe?
  You are such a HATER!!!
I don't think that anyone has realized what kind of civil war that would start in America. I do not believe that anyone could ever prove that it was not planned.  The African American community would never forgive this country!!! Some people want them to forget the past atrocities that fell upon this country and to them and to a degree most have.... Please, please... do not let this ever happen!!!
Bill should just say

Here is what worked for us...but it's a new time and new challenges...but maybe this will help to know our knowledge will be accessible behind the scenes"

He seems to be becoming the great Class President that graduated and doesn't like his newfound role in college...
so he gets mad when he comes back starts planning his younger girlfriend's prom by saying all the things that he did great... and when they don't listen he gets PO'd... and storms out telling his girlfriends to also...


You know...it's not that "the Clinton's" are not welcome... because I personally and I think the majority of Obama supporters would have been so excited if she was (because she is) our team mate...

but Bill needs to grasp his time has moved on.

Hillary's time is now with us.

Hillary is part of this new generation and I think (personally as a die hard obama supporter that originally volunteered for Hill) most are hopeful that people will stop referring to them as the Clintons...

it's not Bill time...

It's Hill's time. and She is part of the NEW leadership.

How amazing Hillary would be if there was no such thing as Bill Clinton's id.
Uncle Ted and Mom Michelle. Peace of mind , a life bounce and efficiently established last evening.
Teddy spoke and barely left a dry eye in the house.  WOW !!!!!! He is a great man Teddy K.  Michelle spoke and dispite the stupid comentary about all the black women crying,it was all the women in the house crying,heck I almost cried it was really a great speech. MSNBC I think Chris Matthews is a nice guy but him and that minster went way overboard on there discussion on slavery, drawn from Michelle's speech.That minster was so full of himself that he almost slobbered on hisself as he spoke. I find him to be almost as offensive as Reberand Joe Watkins. As a black christian man I find that neither of these men have much God in them and are used to validate Republican talking points by the media saying,see we have a black man saying it. Thank you Keith Olberman for bringing thise guys back to earth last night with that smooth transition back to the Brady Bunch.  Oh in case anyone didn't know let me help John McBush out, He was a POW so if he seems a little out of touch with any issue remember he was a POW. If he voted for the war, cheated on his wife , gets mad and starts a war with Russia,Iran ,North Korea or any other God forsaken country it's ok care because he was a   P O W .  
Michelle Obama gave the speech I expected her to give: long on emotion, short on facts.  Her narrative betrayed her philosophy-socialism good, capitalism, bad.  It is everlastingly amazing to me that socialists believe themselves to be 'good', others of means to be 'bad', and the poor to be 'noble'.  Unfortunately, they see the poor as a class, and not as human beings like themselves; therefore, if any one of 'them' dare occupy the same space, they are dispatched forthwith.  The hypocracy of this woman speaking passionately about a college student, working to provide healthcare for his sick sibling, while she herself embarked on a program to rid University of Chicago hospitals of the very poor she proclaims to be working for, is breathtaking.  Heaven forfend that her husband actually get elected.
How many times can a person shed tears watching a convention? Last night was a record for me.

- Caroline Kennedy
- The Ken Burns Tribute
- Senator Kennedy himself
- Michelle Obama's speech, as moving a speech as I have ever heard; watching her up there on that stage spoke volumes about our country in the 21st Century.  
- Keith Olbermann & Chris Matthews after her speech, each speaking so eloquently about Michelle's family history going back to South Carolina. And each speaking quite eloquently as well about the path our country has taken to get to this point in time. You were both superb. Very moving words from both of you.

The Democratic Party, this is what we have been waiting for. Senator Ted Kennedy must be awfully proud. He's been there every step of the way.  

The United States of America - Barack Obama/Joe Biden - Nothing can stop us now.
Nice night all together.  Just listened to some guy on CNN say it was a wasted opportunity to attack the Repubs.  I am so sick of that mentality.  It was so upbeat, from John Legend's beautiful song to Michelle Obama's speech.  

We may lose this election and the country will be worse off for it, but at least we will have our dignity.  Like it says in the Bible "What good is it to inherit the world if you had to forfeit your soul?"

The Kennedys looked great and he gave a great speech. Words can't express how happy I was with Michelle's speech. Breath taking!
It was absolutely electrifying to see and hear the "Lion of the Senate", Ted Kennedy last night. He represents the true themes of the Democratic party and I hope the former Hillary supporters will see that we must unify behind Sen. Obama.

Last week, right after watching the USA squeak by Spain in the Olympics, C-Span aired the keynote speakers of former Dem conventions. I was moved to tears by the words of the late, great Congresswoman Barbara Jordan from Texas, who spelled out the platform of the Democratic party. (1) Equality for all and priviledge for none; (2) Provide a way for all citizens to be involved in the government; (3) All people, not just interest groups, have the real voice of government; (4)Work to remove all obstacles of race, sex, and economic conditions; (5) Be innovative, but do not reject our traditions that is the promise of America; (6) None of the above are negotiable!

Ted Kennedy, Joe Biden, and now Barack Obama are standing on the Dem platform. The Democratic party is a party of inclusion and we are all family. Together we can make John McCain and his failed policies a nightmare diverted. Let's get busy!

GO OBAMA/BIDEN
Teddy is amazing.  What an American!  Starting tonight I hope they start ripping into the GOP disaster awaiting if Bomb Iran McBush gets elected.  
Michelle Obama is cool and has class and brillance and charm and wisdom and love...
She'll be a Great First Lady for this country...

OBAMA/BIDEN'08
Great moments.
Great Moments.
who picked that dress for her - awful.
i've never been one moved by words, until last night.

The final two speeches of the evening surpassed anything i could have foreseen, and i was moved by the tone and conviction that both speakers used in their delivery.

i have to say that all of the evenings speakers were excellent, i was especially moved by Jesse Jackson Jr.'s speach, and found myself drawn to the Dem's platform as i heard more about it.

congrats on pulling off a positive opening, that moved those of us who took the time to watch all of the speakers.  I hope that the tone and message of the first night continues through the rest of the convention, and that the negative backstabbing politics are avoided until next week.

one thing that i noticed in watching the coverage online: the number of women, minority, and female minority speakers was astounding.  i saw a handful of old, white males speaking early on, and i was forced to grab my wife and inform her when the first white male speaker proudly announced that he was gay.  

That is truly America, and i love America!
..
Headlining in Denver --- THE NEW OBAMA DEMOCRATIC PARTY.

The New Democrats --- free of SELFISH special interest groups;  free of hucksters like Sharpton & Jackson; free of the Clintons, and, free of whining white women like the Hillary Supporters.

GO OBAMA --->  GO NEW DEMOCRATS  ............>>

***********************************************************
I just have to say the best speeches of the evening were Ted Kennedy, Michelle Obama and Claire McCaskill (sp) in that order.  They were just amazing.

And the Obama's daughters are just beautiful.  I have three daughters myself and I made the two oldest (youngest is only three) watch Michelle's speech.  They need something more to look up to than just Hannah Montana and since there are so few young, black, female role models out there this was just a golden opportunity for them to see black women as more than what they see in magazines and on TV.  I really hope that my girls took her speech to heart and are striving for more than just being famous for the sake of being famous. (although my oldest has said she wants to be a teacher....here's hoping she means that and will work for it).

Obama/Biden 08/12
There were some very important things missing from last nights speechs, specifically Teddy's unfortunately incident at Chappaquidick and Barak's associates such as Ayers and Wright. Please tel the whole truth
What was that? MSNBC's coverage of the first night at the convention was disgusting. I would think that after being there for several days now with all your spot reporting, that you people would at least have checked that the sound feed from the convention was working - thanks for missing the first minute of Pelosi's speech. And what the hell is the deal with reporting from some glass top desk on a rooftop across the highway from the arena - didn't you guys get a pass to get in the place?  And all your time spent with panel discussions - instead of being IN THE ARENA - I didn't even know when the convention started. I guess you'd rather hear yourselves talk. And when you did get around to plugging in the sound from inside, you had Anne Curry playing some version of Jerry Springer pushing for a fight between the Hillary and Obama people. She kept dogging Speaker Pelosi about Hillary to the point Ms. Pelosi literaly told her that she'd like to stop so that she could listen to President Carter. And then she dogged Mr. Carter. YOUR COVERAGE SUCKED!!!!!  If it were the first moonwalk, I guess you people would have sat there with your panel, waxing philosophically about how surreal it must be to walk on the moon, and describe to your viewers what you saw on the monitors. Horrible reporting - you guys get an F-.  Oh, and by the way - by what I seen through CNN, the convention was BORING and a total waste of a full night of sticking it to the Bush/McCain group. WHAT A BUCH OF WUSSIES!!!!!!
They were both an inspiration, Ted Kennedy who is suffering for an ailment, came and gave and incredible speech and Michelle Obama proved herself once again tonight that she will be the best first lady ever after Eleanor Roosevelt.
The beauty of this Country is the collective minds of its people. Over the past 8 years we've gone absolutely nowhere. And it's easy to throw blame around, but when you strip in down to what's really been going on in our great nation, you quickly realize that "We The People" are the cause of this. We are stagnant because of us. WE DID THIS!!! We are a democracy... We vote people in... We're responsible for the predicament of this country because we choose to pick out of fear rather than for the best interest of our Country. We are slowly becoming a nation of nothing. Where we were once strong, we are now laughed at and frowned upon... And we take it lying down, accepting things at face value simply because someone says so... All that was sacrificed for the greater good of our futures are proving to have been in vain...

I looked at how some folks said that Obama lost Rick Warren's forum conversation because he was too thorough, expressive, detailed, and intelligent... WOW!!! What have we come to where we expect anything less??? The integrity and intelligence of this Country has been seriously insulted... We choose to become a failing and falling nation all for the sake of stubbornness and ignorance... It's like there's a dying breed of courage in America.

"We The People" choose our paths... We decide the direction of our Country, and we now stand at a folk in the road... We decide what our tomorrows hold.

The bottom line is, we're either going to wake up November 5th with Barack Obama as our President, willing, and able to lead us back down the path of greatness, or We're going to wake up with John McCain as our President, bringing the same failed policies of the past 8 years... Do realize though, that we are the ones who decide this... If y'all can live with that, then we'll all have no choice but to...

It's rather interesting actually to see how on the surface so much has changed over the last 200+ years, yet deeply rooted remains the same ignorant, prejudiced, tainted mindset of so many in this Country... {Just calling a spade a spade}

WOULD WE REALLY RATHER HAVE ANOTHER 4 YEARS OF GOING BACKWARDS, AS OPPOSE TO BEGINNING TO REALIZE THE TRUE GREATNESS OF OUR COUNTRY???

Obama/ Biden 2012...
WITHOUT A DOUBT, BABY!!!
It was wonderful to see Sen. Kennedy. He looked great, but you could tell he was a little shaky.
I thought Michelle knocked it out of the park. She was cordial, classy and looked lovely.

I'll be glad when Hillary exits stage left tonight, I am so sick of this woman and the media bias that goes along with her.

I don't know what the media has to gain from all the slanted coverage of this convention, but if Barack loses it'll be on the media's head.
I was overjoyed with the tone and content of Michelle Obama's message last evening.  I had my 19 year old son and 17 year old daughter watch the speech in its entirety with me so we could experience this historical moment together.  I am a white, middle aged, single mom and have supported Obama from day one.  Michele reinforced my view of the country and the way it should be.  I thought the speech was spot on.
My eyes were filled with tears as Ted Kennedy came on stage last night.  He is the true leader of the Democratic Party and we so need his wisdom, guidance, compassion and leadership during these trying times in America.  

My goodness, Michelle Obama, is the pride of Chicago's southside this morning.  Her story is truly an American story.  And Sasha and Malia stole the show with their unrehearsed words, "Hi, Daddy!  We love you Daddy!"  I would just love to see the White House filled with the laughter of children again -- something America has not seen since Caroline and John-John.

I am an enthusiastic supporter of Obama/Biden, but last night was Ted's, Michelle's and the Obama children's night.  God bless them.  I am so proud they belong to us, America.
OBAMA/BIDEN '08

The Obama's are trying so hard to make themselves out as "Average Americans", but, they just aren't. Obama, for all of his skills, continually comes off as this elitist arrogant snob. He has an answer for everything, and he knows better then anyone else on every subject. He talks like a lawyer, pausing after a question so he can come up with the answer he expects his adience wants to hear. And for some reason, a lot of his supporters just love being led around by the nose by this man. Both Barack and Michelle have tons of education. But it appears that they are both just "Book Smart", and not "Life Smart".
Big Teddy, you go boy!
Ted Kennedy and Michelle Obama gave wonderful speeches last night.
The media cannot find fault with what they said
but sure will try.
Michelle was refreshing, sincere and those who say
they do not know her after this are not listening.
Anyone who does not realize she and Barack
struggled just like all of us are not thinking.
Voters who vote for Mccain are people who enjoy
being victimns.
I can't remember a time when I was so moved.  I was skeptical of Michelle Obama, but now I am convinced that she can and will be an eloquent first lady.
It was a beautifully moving night.  I wept uncontrollably.  In my lifetime is all I kept saying...in my lifetime!  And thank you Ted Kennedy for all you have done for the United States.  You are a good man.  Anyone unmoved by this is heartless.
Awsome speeches!  Homerun!  Touchdown!  

I would like ya'll to quit asking the ignorant, arrogant repugligans what they think and spinning everything negatively.  I don't care what they think about our convention anymore than they care about my belief that mccain is a lying, cheating,mean, evil,adulterer, war-mongering oil robber who kisses Bush for fun!
Senator Kennedy seemed to be in good spirits during his speech.  There was the allusion to his speech in 1980 Democratic convention.  Since there was no attempt to run this year, it didn't sound like he was trying to upset Obama.  

It was good to see Michelle and girls take center stage to say that they are a normal family.  Given what is going on, it is unlikely that they can really be called normal at this time; a member of the family is running for president isn't normal.  
I can't remember a time when I was so moved.  I was skeptical of Michelle Obama, but now I am convinced that she can and will be an eloquent first lady.
Awsome speeches!  Homerun!  Touchdown!  

I would like ya'll to quit asking the ignorant, arrogant repugligans what they think and spinning everything negatively.  I don't care what they think about our convention anymore than they care about my belief that mccain is a lying, cheating,mean, evil,adulterer, war-mongering oil robber who kisses Bush for fun!
Michelle Obama did an amazing job Monday night.  Those of us that have been paying attention know that the warm, loving, intelligent woman on stage is the REAL Michelle Obama, and always has been.  This woman is working- alongside her husband- to make this world a better place for all of our children.

The Obamas have been saying all along that if you work hard and be the best person you can be, you can succeed in this country.  There is nothing "scary" or "radical" in that.  Like Chris Matthews said (rather eloquently) last night:

"People need to open their minds, open their hearts."

Yes, we can.
Good Old Ted would have had me at hello and I was truly impressed that after suffering through such a medical malady not too long ago he was able to get up on stage and give a great stirring speech.  It was great to see the Liberal Lion of the Senate give another great speech and rally the base for Obama.

Michelle also gave a stirring speech.  I informed my Daughter that she should download it and watch it with her Daughters as I thought Michelle gave a great speech about Family Values and Moms and Daughters.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
Awsome speeches!  Homerun!  Touchdown!  

I would like ya'll to quit asking the ignorant, arrogant repugligans what they think and spinning everything negatively.  I don't care what they think about our convention anymore than they care about my belief that mccain is a lying, cheating,mean, evil,adulterer, war-mongering oil robber who kisses Bush for fun!
What a First Night of the Convention. I hope the Clintons were watching to see who the true leaders of our party are.
Ted Kennedy is truly the greatest leader of the Democratic party and he has passed the torch to the Obamas. Hilary could do so much good in the Senate if she could get rid of this entitlement attitude of hers.
Bill this is how you should act as a senior statesmen of our party. Stop Whinning and join the party behind the Obamas like we all got behind you.
Michelle GREAT JOB AND I LOVE YOUR KIDS

All I know is, if disgruntled Hillary supporters ruin Barack's chances at becoming President, their girl will NEVER get elected for national office.  What they fail to recognize is, as much as we need their support now, they will need our future support, and Obama's supporters will NEVER forget.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1292724

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google