ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



First thoughts: Teddy’s Night

Posted: Tuesday, August 26, 2008 9:19 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, and Domenico Montanaro
DENVER -- For Democratic partisans and those who love feel-good convention moments, it's hard to see how the Republicans could duplicate last night, particularly with first-night speakers George W. Bush and Dick Cheney (then again, they won't try -- instead they'll keep their eye on the Obama ball). While Michelle Obama’s speech was the marquee event, and while the Obama girls helped steal the show at the end, there's no doubt there will be at least one address beyond Thursday night that won't be forgotten when the dust settles on this convention. Modern conventions have become more about the speeches than the mechanics of nominating. And given Ted Kennedy’s health, his speech will go down as one of the most memorable ever for reasons nobody wants to put in writing. Kennedy's had his share of uncomfortable conventions, but this was not one of them. Yet considering Teddy's history with presidential politics, one wonders what was going on inside the head of tonight’s featured speaker, Hillary Clinton, as she was watching Kennedy's reception and the honoring of his legacy. Of the two Clintons, Hillary has always been more adept at believing there's always another chapter to be written.

*** Up-Hil night: The Washington Post's Cocco may have nailed tonight better than anyone today: Hillary can't win. She may not be able to find her Goldilocks moment and strike a "just right" balance tonight of both advancing her own political future and proving that she really does want Obama to win and that she really does believe Obama can be president. Everything in Clinton's speech will be parsed, and not just the words, but her body language. The good news for her, the expectations are very low in this sense. No one expects her to be able to pull this off convincingly. Of course, this isn't the only Clinton night and one wonders given all the Bill drama that's bubbled up over the last 24 hours (particularly over the content of his speech), why Obama chose to give the Clintons two convention nights. Shouldn't Obama have gotten all of this Clinton stuff out of the way tonight? By the way, there is another speech on the docket tonight that is technically labeled the "keynote." Mark Warner, a candidate for US Senate in the swing state of Virginia, has the unenviable task of speaking not just on Hillary night but also having to follow Barack Obama in a sense since Obama was the LAST keynote speaker. In an interview on MSNBC, Warner seemed to hint that his speech would be more in line with Obama's (at least in tone) than, say, an Ann Richards from 1988. 

*** McCain survives night one: As we've noted before, Obama has three goals at this convention: 1) making contrasts with McCain, 2) filling in his biography, and 3) uniting the party. Last night, the convention attempted to begin dealing with all three issues. Early in the evening, viewers were treated to a taste of some anti-McCain speeches; of course, only C-SPAN viewers may have received the full impact of those diatribes. As for the other two goals, between Kennedy and Michelle, the campaign can claim it made progress on unity (don't the Clinton-Obama rifts seem petty after seeing Teddy?) and on biography (Michelle O. was as pitch perfect as she can be in presenting her story, but if there's one critique of her speech is that it was more about her than Barack, but maybe that was the point.)  As for the attempts to contrast with McCain, the GOP campaign and other strategists we've communicated with believe McCain went a lot more unscathed than, say, Obama will be after Night One of the Republican convention. Then again, with Michelle as the marquee speaker, the Dems were never going to go guns blazing the first night. Expect that tonight (which is focused on the economy) and tomorrow (foreign affairs).

*** Stoking the flames: The McCain camp has done an excellent job stoking the Clinton-Obama feud narrative. This morning, the camp is releasing another ad that is supposedly airing in "key states" (translation: maybe it gets a rotation on the noon news today in Denver). Regardless, the aggressiveness the McCain camp is showing against Obama during his convention week is notable. And speaking of the McCain camp, remember when one-time Bush media guru and McCain champion Mark McKinnon decided to step away from the '08 campaign once it became clear Obama would be the Dem nominee? Well, he's back -- sort of. Per NBC's Kelly O'Donnell, McKinnon's helping Cindy McCain with her convention week prep, including a family video. When pressed, the campaign acknowledged that while McKinnon is largely on the strategic sidelines, he does provide occasional advice on the campaign ad efforts. 

*** Today’s convention schedule: Tuesday’s convention theme is Renewing America’s Promise, and it has a focus on the economy and energy. Hillary Clinton gives the primetime speech, and former Virginia Gov. (and current Senate candidate) Mark Warner delivers the keynote address. Check out some of the additional speakers, a slew of folks who aren't afraid of showing off their sharp tongues (yes, Rahm and Eddie, we mean you): Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell, Rep. Rahm Emanuel, Rep. Steny Hoyer, Arizona Gov. Janet Napolitano, former Energy and Transportation Secretary Federico Pena, Kansas Gov. Kathleen Sebelius, Pennsylvania Sen. Bob Casey Jr., Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick, and Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer.

*** The RNC’s response: Mitt Romney and Reps. Eric Cantor, Lincoln Diaz-Balart, and Marsha Blackburn hold a press conference at the RNC’s Denver headquarters at 3:15 pm ET to counter Obama on the economy.

*** Also in Denver: Nancy Pelosi, Hillary Clinton, and Michelle Obama attend an Emily’s List gala at 4:300 pm ET… Pelosi and Reps. Steny Hoyer, James Clyburn, and Rahm Emanuel talk energy independence at Union Station at 1:00 pm ET… Bill Richardson discusses the Hispanic vote at the Colorado Convention Center at 4:30 pm ET

*** On the trail: McCain begins his day in Phoenix, where he addresses the American Legion and raises money. After that, he heads to a fundraiser in San Diego with the actor Jon Voight. Obama, meanwhile, campaigns in Kansas City, MO.
 
Countdown to GOP convention: 6 days
Countdown to Election Day 2008: 70 days
Countdown to Inauguration Day 2009: 147 days
 
Click here to sign up for First Read emails. 
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Simply Amazing, that's all i can say about this campaign and the first night of the Democratic convention. Yes there will be hater's , but you can't help but be touched by both Teddy Kennedy's speech and Michele Obama's speech. I truly believe in the Obama's family values, it came off as real and genuine and i felt it, i mean really felt it in my heart! What an emotional way to start the convention off, now we can take the gloves off and go upside Mcshames head! By the way which family will McShame have with him next week, the one he married into or the one he abandoned after Viet Nam?? Just asking that's all!!
I get so sick of some pundits being so critical of Obama for not attacking McCain/Bush enough.  Why do we want to elect the most divisive, unscrupulous, dishonest, mean person?  We've elected that type before - Bush/Cheney.  How has that worked for us?  We need to refuse to vote for candidates who run dirty campaigns.  We need honorable leaders with intelligence, common sense, good ideas, stability under pressure, good judgement, diplomatic skills, and respect for others.  

I don't see McCain having those traits. Let's not screw up again by electing a Bush clone.  We have a rare chance to elect a great leader - Obama.
I tried to watch the MSNBC coverage of the convention last night.  However I got so disgusted with the reporters and political analysts that I finally switched to CSPAN to watch the actual convention.  Please MSNBC SHUT UP!  I used to think MSNBC had the best balanced coverage around - now the only decent ones left are Olberman and Maddow.  Stop talking about what the Clintons are doing - this is not their convention!
I have heard over and over the McCain camp declare that by choosing Biden as a VP, Obama is admitting that he is not ready to lead our Country.  I have yet to hear a "journalist" make the obvious follow-up question asking if they really believe it is a weakness to choose the best possible running mate.  I thought that was the responsibility of the Candidate ...  give the Country a VP who would be able to step in and lead in the case he was unable to serve.
Let me explain to you why SENILE OLD MCFLIPFLOP - "Mush-head" is guaranteed to be the next President of the United States.

1) Mush-Head and his Republican minions don't care about the truth.  They will make up whatever lie they need to make-up about Obama in order to win and the American electorate is way too stupid to understand that.  Every word that comes out of Mush-head's mouth is a lie but American's will believe it.

2) Hillary Clinton supporters will support and vote for Mush-head as a punishment to Obama.  Although I will make one caveat here.  If Clinton were the nominee, I guarantee that Obama supporters would not support her.

3) People already believe the negative attacks on Obama by Mush-head the hypocrit.

Mush-head is absolutely guaranteed to be the next President of the United States.  There is absolutely zero chance (and if it were possible there would be a negative chance) of Obama winning the presidency.  The race is already over and the next two months is just a formality.

But remember this.  Women will lose the right to choose.  The United States will be at war with another country perhaps even Russia.  And Mush-head will destroy the American economy.  Just remember that WHEN you pull that lever for Mush-head.

Sorry Obama supporters but it is OVER and our guy Obama has lost.  Looking forward to another Democratic defeat in 2012 as well.
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...zzzzzzzzzzzzz......(yawn)

Tell me about the rest of Michelle's speech. I fell asleep after the first 30 seconds.  Same ol, same ol. boring, boring, boring

And, I thought BHO saiud they wouldn't be "using" their children in the campaign again.  One more lie.

And, while you've been raging aobut how many houses McCain has, why don't you ask Teddy how many he has? And, did you see that sailboat?  Taht's only one he has.  But, Teddy understands MY life? BS. And, while you're bagging on McCain for a divorce, why don't you ask Teddy about his and how many affairs he had.  Of course, one person who could tell you about his filandering can't speak since he left her DEAD and then claimed "amnesia."  
I was so happy to see President Carter get the ovation he received last night. His video was quite moving.
when is a hero no longer a hero...when he keeps telling you what a hero he is....there is an old saying that self praise stinks and some people should be reminded of that not to mention that is getting so boring when every query is answered with the hero response...most hereoes say they are not hereos they just did what was needed.
I truly do not understand how anyone, but the most partisan Republicans, could vote for John McCain. I just don't see it. John McCain is just old, in every way. He has old ideas, old messages, old wars, old, old, old. I'm old too, but I sure don't want to see my face up there in DC, I want a new fresh look! Let's face it, it can't get any worse unless we don't change the narrative!
when is a hero no longer a hero...when he keeps telling you what a hero he is....there is an old saying that self praise stinks and some people should be reminded of that not to mention that is getting so boring when every query is answered with the hero response...most hereoes say they are not hereos they just did what was needed.
Seems like the Republicans have their strategy and responses all lined up.  I wonder if we Democrats will be as vicious when the Republicans have their convention next week? Hmm.. Something tells me no.  We'll let them walk all over Obama....smear him into the dirt and there will be very little push back from us.  For the life of me I just don't know why we are so weak at attacking these thugs.  There's no room for nice in this game this time.  There's too much at stake for our country.  We all better get real tough real fast.  "Feel good" doesn't win elections!!
Note to McCain camp--let the Democrats have their week. You all are looking desperate here. It's like trying to talk during a Metallica concert. Nobody hears you!!!
And..MSM, I understand and accept that you will give the GOP convention glowing and gushing reviews and commentary, but also give those of us who are not GOP affiliated a chance to see our party without your scathing and often annoying (Pat Roberts, Chris Matthews, Joe Scarborough) commentators. We get it, you don't want a Democratic president.
Larry, Roseville Ca.,

Didn't catch footnote at bottom of screen, speech was at '88 convention, 'til after post. Totally embarassed. Thanks.

Proud Texan: At least I don't take pride in my ignorance, like you do in yours.
Lots of swing state polls were released this morning (including Quinnipiac's latest big state wave). McCain gains in Ohio and in two Florida polls, though Obama remains stable in Pennsylvania: http://campaigndiaries.com/2008/08/26/pre-convention-polling
All I know is, if disgruntled Hillary supporters ruin Barack's chances at becoming President, their girl will NEVER get elected for national office.  What they fail to recognize is, as much as we need their support now, they will need our future support, and Obama's supporters will NEVER forget.
I heard Ben Stein on CNN being really nasty to Ted Kennedy.  What is his problem.  The senator is not allowed to speak.  Give me a break, these neocons are abnormal.
Unfortunately, no one saw Claire McCaskill or Nancy Pelosi's great contrast speeches because all the major networks including MSNBC had their pundits and anchors blithering on about the Clinton/Obama civil war. They also didn't pickup any of ex-GOP Congressman Jim Leach's endorsement of Obama.

But then to be fair, I'm sure they and MSNBC probably won't give any coverage to Leiberman next week either, right?
Congratulations to Chris Matthews for taking Pat Buchanan to task for attempting to invoke RELIGION in last nights review of Michelle Obama’s speech.

Pat Buchanan is so full of himself that he attempts to take control of all discussions.  He attempts to talk over/and or interrupt everyone else with his thoughts on the subject.  Obviously he thinks he is the only one with anything of importance to say.

He attempted to interrupt Eugene Robinson last evening but Mr. Robinson held his ground.

And shame on Tom Brokaw for allowing Kelly O’Donnell, a supposed reporter covering the McCain campaign, to state that Obama SENT Joe Biden to Georgia before he was selected as VP.

That was an obvious lie.  Obama did not SEND Biden.  Biden went at the request of the Georgian embassy, conveying to the Foreign Relations chairman that Saakashvili wanted Biden to come as soon as possible, as the former Soviet republic sought a ceasefire with Russia.

So we are to believe that McCain did not send his own campaign allies to the region?

Kelly O’Donnell is not a reporter.  She is a surrogate for the McCain campaign.

Whenever I see Buchanan or Scarborough speaking I change the channel.

Kelly O’Donnell, Pat Buchanan and yes Joe Scarborough all a blight on MSNBC
I think rhe republicans would be better served if they paid closer attention to McCains campaign - they're obcessed with Obama - always worrying about what they're doing.  Once again, mccain is proving himself to be a follower rather than a leader.
A lot of punditry dissing the Democrats for not attacking McCain on day one of the Convention. Had the first night been a full on attack night then the punditry would have been a lot of tongue clucking on how Obama lied about "New Politics" and that a lot of vindictiveness on "Michelle's night" was probably not a good idea.
Bottom line: Run your own campaign Barrak, the media is NOT there to help you.
There was one very effective line of attack that has not been mentioned enough. Ted Kennedy's straight in the eye sum up of the Iraq war as mistake.

"And Barack Obama will be a commander-in-chief who understands that young Americans in uniform must never ever be committed to a mistake, but always to a mission worthy of their bravery and sacrifice."

I see iraq now wants a definte time table for foreigner troops out of iraq, will bush/cheney/rove/rush respect a soverein nation or will they keep imposing and bullying to keep troops there?
Why is there no mention of the speech that Nancy Pelosi gave? I had to tune out because she was so boring and talked as if she was addressing a kindergarten class. Let us hope she remains quite.
For you younger voters, did you get anything of a reality check last night when you saw that clip of Teddy Kennedy from 1980 promising national  health care?  Here we are 28 years later, and the Dems STILL haven't gotten it done. Yet, you believe Merlin the Magician Obama is going to get it up and functioning in four years?   If you believe that, you've had way too much koolaid.  The Dems are always really good at taking your money for all their wonderful "causes" and then nothing happens or changes.  
They should've esplained in detail just what Obama's policies wre, and just how they'd help workiing families---that should've been the first (pretty much dead) two hours' business---that and making sure Bush and McCain did NOT get off easily last night.I look forward to seeing some explanation and McCain-bashing---and for the flag-wavers, more mention of the troops and their families, I hope---tonight on night 2.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1292798

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google