ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain criticizes Obama's Berlin speech

Posted: Tuesday, August 26, 2008 3:46 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy and NBC's Mark Murray
PHOENIX, AZ -- Speaking before the American Legion National Convention here today, McCain said that it fell upon him to officially welcome the 89-year-old group to his home state. 

“Our governor is out of town, up in Denver for some big party they're throwing there,” McCain said, jokingly referring to the Democrat’s convention. “I guess my invitation got lost in the mail.”

Although the group will hear a video from Obama tomorrow, McCain used his speech today to criticize his opponent’s stance on America’s role as a superpower. Referring to Obama’s speech in Berlin, McCain said that he had a “chance to express such confidence in America” -- but passed it up.

“He was the picture of confidence, but in some ways the confidence in one's self and confidence in one's country are not the same,” McCain said.

In fact, in that Berlin speech, Obama expressed plenty of confidence in America. "I also know how much I love America," the Illinois senator said that day. "I know that for more than two centuries, we have strived -- at great cost and great sacrifice -- to form a more perfect union; to seek, with other nations, a more hopeful world... What has always united us -- what has always driven our people; what drew my father to America’s shores -- is a set of ideals that speak to aspirations shared by all people: that we can live free from fear and free from want; that we can speak our minds and assemble with whomever we choose and worship as we please."

Also in his speech today, McCain criticized Obama for implying that the United States’ involvement in Iraq had not been a good model for Russia, quoting Obama as saying, “We've got to send a clear message to Russia and unify our allies. They can't charge into other countries. Of course it helps if we are leading by example on that point.”

“I guess we are left to figure out the rest for ourselves,” McCain said before listing off several humanitarian conflicts that Obama could have been referring to.

“If I catch Sen. Obama's drift,” McCain continued. “Then our failure to ‘lead by example’ was the liberation of Iraq. And if he really thinks that, by liberating Iraq from a dangerous tyrant, America somehow set a bad example that invited Russia to invade a small, peaceful, and democratic nation, then he should state it outright -- because that is a debate I welcome.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It is so sad to see a man I respected so much in the 90's and during most of the 2000 election, sell his soul to get elected. It's pathetic. I never thought I could have feelings of utter disgust for him, and yet when I see what he's allowed to become I'm sickened.
McWarmonger is absolutely without any shame.  How can you fault the speech Obama made in Berlin?  What is the problem with uniting us with our allies again.  Would you rather see them burning American flags (like they do when Bush visits there)?  
Why is it ok for Cindy McCain to go to Tblisi, Georgia, in the  middle of war zone, with no flak? But not ok if the roles were reversed.  
  McCain is beginning to sound increasingly like the 'old boyfriend' role, when the girlfriend goes on and he is still blasting away at the guy that took his place. Old and whiney!
Now that some punks tried to put an assasination attemt into play on him, Obama can answer every criticizm with "I was a target".  You know- kind of like "I was a POW" is a one-size-fits-all response uttered by another candidate a lot lately whenever an uncomfortable situation arises.
This guy has nothing...
America did invade Iraq on false pretense by the adminastration that he supports.
Russia has done the same as the Americans has, by invading a small country that they know can not survive their attacks.
JM is pundering again and knows not a thing about foriegn policy.
Try to spin that FR as I know only you and FOX can.

Obama/Biden 08'
“If I catch Sen. Obama's drift,” McCain continued. “Then our failure to ‘lead by example’ was the liberation of Iraq. And if he really thinks that, by liberating Iraq from a dangerous tyrant, America somehow set a bad example that invited Russia to invade a small, peaceful, and democratic nation, then he should state it outright -- because that is a debate I welcome.”

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Why did the small, peaceful, and democratic nation go into South Ossetia with it's military?

*insert uncomfortable silence here*

And for the record John McCain - do as I say, not as I do is not a governing strategy.

And you WILL get to have that debate - so work on an answer that doesn't include the fact that you are a POW, 'kay?
So McCain is fibbing again....what's new... WHY?! Are the rest of you out there becoming more disheartened by the constant attacks. Do you not feel he is lowering the level of politics in this country by treating his counterpart this way?
I think it would be pretty cool if Ted Kennedy dropped dead at the convention.
Mark, Phx (Sent Monday, August 25, 2008 5:39 PM)


Give them Hell, Biden and the chimp , The monkey and the organ grinder! Uncle tom and the great white hope! Such lavish fools at the expense of the tax payer, Both residing in the derailed congress.Nothing being new and everything about America is negative. Now what else would you expect from a couple of Washington self serving Paper Hangers.
Stinks so bad! (Sent Monday, August 25, 2008 7:12 PM)


This is allowed to post, while mine get trashed. Not a Single post of mine today, thanx 1st read, for Nothing.
The new Diageo/Hotline national poll shows Obama with a 4 point lead over McCain (August 18-24, 1022 RV, MoE +/- 3.0%). 70% feel Obama is at least somewhat "in touch" with the "average American," while 61% feel the same way about McCain. 74% feel McCain is prepared to lead the country, while 58% feel Obama is. Although the poll's outcome shows a tight race, 52% said Obama has a better chance of winning.

Obama 44
McCain 40
Und 12

Obama believes he can talk his way out of any situation. The Iraq war? He could have sat down and showed Hussein the error of ways, and convinced him to Change. Russia? Putin just needed a phone call from Barack. Barack would have taken care of the Georgia problem before it even started.

Sarcasm for sure. But not for Obama. He really believes he is the Golden Child, The Choosen One. Obama has never had to make a decision that affects the lives of many, but he knows deep down that he can. Me, I'm more a skeptic. I think Obama will get a lot people killed in the world, and will cause a lot of pain for people back in the United States. Mostly because his arrogance and inexperience will get in the way of him making good judgements.
LMBO! Isn't Cindy McCain in Georgia for a photo op?!?!?!!?!?  The hypocrisy is appalling!
McCain sold his soul to Karl Rove!
McCain is the most bitter old man I have seen in a while. Instead of talking about how qualified he is, he would rather whine about how unqualified Obama is.
95% of McCains congressional votes were with bush. In essence he put our economy in the trash can, he will keep us at war with out justification or right. McCain is wrong.
It is so sad to see a man I respected so much in the 90's and during most of the 2000 election, sell his soul to get elected. It's pathetic. I never thought I could have feelings of utter disgust for him, and yet when I see what he's allowed to become I'm sickened.

Jodi, Georgia (Sent Tuesday, August 26, 2008 3:56 PM)



I know. I have the same feelings you do about Obama.
McCain is the same as bush. 911 would not have been if BUSH was not in office. If we put McCain in we can definately count on another attack and that is what this warmonger wants...to keep in fighting.  
John McCain can't read a teleprompter or from a text......let alone give a speech.  He showed how well he can speak on the night Obama won the nomination.

Mr McCane - Let's talk about what YOU will do for this country.

Answer: I was a POW (thumps chest).

Wow, you got my vote.

Does McCain know that Russia has now reached its goal in Georgia by gaining controll of the disputed areas?   If the US had not gone into Iraq and we had a strong relation with Russia this would not have happened.  But McCain thinks war solves everything.
America will get what it votes for, McCain? Really? The continued destruction of the United States as we know it. Good job Clintonites. We will remember this if you get a chance in '012. Trust me. You are disgusting Americans.
Nice job John McCain - Keep the focus where it belongs - on Barack Obamas stumblings through the woods of Europe. Anyone notice when McCain started catching Obama in the polls? It was when Obama did his little photo opportunity in the Middle East and in Europe. No one likes some wet behind the ears liberal apologizing to the Europeans for the USs so called 'wrongs'. No one likes anyone disrespecting our troops by not seeing them only because Obama couldn't get the photos he wanted.  Well, no one in the US that is. The Europeans loved it. They like seeing US leaders appear as doofuses in front of them. Makes them feel less inferior. Thats why they like Obama.
I urge all Obama supporters to go to the the Head of The Top Crime Family's convention next week!

Go there and pretend that you are former Rethuglicans and now you are for Obama!  This way the low information voter can see some former GOP members are now with Obama!
That was weak criticism and highlights McCain's lack of clarity and judgement on pragmatic issues.
I urge all Obama supporters to go to the the Head of The Top Crime Family's Convention next week!

Go there and pretend that you are former Rethuglicans and now you are for Obama!  This way the low information voter can see some former GOP members are now with Obama!
Well now, it's Hillary Night at the Convention. That ought to be worth another 5 or so points in the polls for McCain.
For all of McCain's supposed experience he can't get one decision right.  We never belonged in Iraq.  We invaded, as an aggressor.

No one asked for liberation.  
I am extremly dissappointed in MSNB and they way they allow Olbermann to express his views and biases towards Obama. It really does a disservice to the networks credible anchors (Broakaw, Mathews, Todd, Scarborough, etc..). I garuantee you Russert would not above of his biased and inconsiderate rants. Please have him fired
McLame, the warmongering philandering North Vietnamese collaborator/traitor who gained his political career by nepotism and gold digging, should not offer ANY opinions on Obama's speech.
He is a worthless coward; he's like the bully on the playground who slithers away when he gets punched in the mouth.
McCain sold his soul to Karl Rove, and his demons are here to drill here and drill now!
This guy makes me want to vomit every day. I guess being last in your class at the navel academy leads you to say anything; or the age is making him recall Obama speeches differently ... or wait his flashing temper? Real safe to put some one with a bad temper and old age in the white house.
Rasmussmen daily tracking poll shows Obama declined each of the last three days. He dropped by 3 from just yesterday.  Obama-McCain tied at 46 today.

Hope Chuck T comments on this. This has to be a first that the candidate DROPS after naming his veep and during his convention!
One thing I've noticed different from McCain on this point is that when Obama went to Germany he criticized him for saying that he was a citizen of the world.

Could that have something to do with McCain saying that we are all Georgians not two weeks ago?

Naw....
We have all heard the story about the Old bull and the New bull in the pasture, ready for battle to see who will be the Head bull. But did you know what the cows said as they looked on?  Aren't you tired of the SAME OLD BULL?.......
Ugh! I can't believe the polls are even CLOSE!!  And again, why should we vote FOR McCain...can he tell us- or is he going to model his entire campaign after fifth grade playground name-calling and insults?
"The Prophet" is correct.  O-bummer thinks he can solve the world's problems over tea and conversation.  He continuously bashes this country, it's no wonder the terrorists love him.  He wants us to be more like China because he was jealous of them after watching the olympics.  Does he even realize that China is a totalitarian socialist country where half the people are starving?  Maybe his terrorist buddy Ayers can help him flush this country down the tubes!!
McCain sold his soul to Karl Rove!

I urge all Obama supporters to go to the  Head of The Top Crime Family's Convention next week!

Go there and pretend that you are former Rethuglicans and now you are for Obama!  This way the low information voters can see some former GOP members are now with Obama!
I could have given that speech but not me.  I'm an American who's been without his Ritz crackers and house shoes for years for God's sake.  The rest of the world, what do they know!  Listen I got Obama's drift my friends.  Just because America invades other countries for no reason doesn't give a bunch of reds an excuse.  What I've been through?!  Oy! The stories.
Based on Obama's thinking and that of his supporters, the Civil War shouldn't have happened, and Abraham Lincoln was a Republican warmonger. South Ossetia was part of the nation of Georgia, so trying to restore order was not an "invasion" - it was part of their own country.
McCain sold his soul to Karl Rove!

Capt. Smash Salt Lake City, Utah (Sent Tuesday, August 26, 2008 4:06 PM)


And now the Democrats and Obama want to tax him for it!!
McCain is right on the money. Obama is nothing more than someone who lives for the lime light. He is the worst thing that could happen to this counrty. His lack of experience and running his mouth about everything he knows NOTHING about is proof this man is Completely unfit to run this country. He is a attention whore and says ANYTHING and will do anything just to get attention. As a former Clinton supporter, I am Proud to do my part and save us from the likes of him.
It is so sad to see a man I respected so much in the 90's and during most of the 2000 election, sell his soul to get elected. It's pathetic. I never thought I could have feelings of utter disgust for him, and yet when I see what he's allowed to become I'm sickened.
Jodi, Georgia (Sent Tuesday, August 26, 2008 3:56 PM)
******************************************************

I understand your feelings od distrust in Mr McCain, you are absolutly correct in your assesment of this election, it is a sad time for Americans.
Not that I am a republican because I am not, but I do agree with you. Thank you for speaking what others are most likely still thinking.

Obama-Biden 08
Is there much point in making a comment. It seems Mark Muarry has already called McCain on his BS about Obama not mentioning pride in America while in Germany. Obama has it so over McCain it is beginning to look sad if you once thought highly of McCain.      

Mccain has not a clue oabout foreign policy and foreign affairs. He sees all other perceptions about the U.S. through his eyes and is not able to see how other nations might see us through their eyes. It matters not who is right and who is wrong. What matters is that you have the empathy to view yourself from the outside, from the persepctive of others so that you are able to confront all foreign plicy issues with a clear and well rounded persepctive. McCain is stuck in a box. Alll sides are either painted balck or white. There is no grey areas and certainly no lighter colors representing hope by way of global cooperation. I tell you, McCain will continue to isolate the U.S. with this agressive, unsympathetic and enthnocentric attitude. Does that make Russia right. Hell no. But it also does not make the U.S. right for an error in judgement when invading Iraq because of a desire to get revenge against the perpetrators of 911.  
Will this rag of a website please post another view other than an anti-mccain democratic view point.. disgraceful!
the man(mccain) is a sham....a phoney, an adulterer and more.....his platform is "I spent 5 1/2 years in a POW Camp" ditto ditto ditto.....after that? what....nothing...he is an empty slate...
I hope it's just an oversight that the racist comment above has not been deleted.  To mar this exciting time with such talk is depressing, but we know such people are out there. What it means for me is that there's much work to do.  
HERE WE GO AGAIN TYING IRAQ TO RUSSIA JUST LIKE THE REPUBLICANS TIED 9/11 TO IRAQ KNOWING IT WAS A LIE

MCCAIN AND THE REPUBLICANS HAD A WOMAN REPRESENTATIVE ON MSNBC THE TALKING POINTS NOW ARE

IRAQ & RUSSIA ARE TIED TOGETHER BE AFRAID AMERICANS

THIS TRIED OLD RHETORIC WILL STOP NOW AND THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WON'T BE FOOLED.

WE WILL SHOUT THIS LIE FROM THE ROOF TOP, IN EVERY BLOG AND MAKE MANY WAKE UP CALLS TO AMERICANS

FOR AS LONG AS IT TAKES

GEORGIA'S HOT HEAD PRESIDENT INVADED RUSSIAN TERRITORY AND TRYING TO SEND OUR TROOPS TO FIGHT A WAR BECAUSE YOU HAVE SOME BIG MOUTH THAT'S A BULLY IS ABSOLUTELY ABSURE

EVEN PAT BUCHANAN OF ALL PEOPLE AGREE THAT JOHN MCCAIN, THE REPUBLICANS AND THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION WILL GET THE U.S. IN A WHOLE LOT OF TROUBLE IF THEY KEEP DOWN THIS BULLY PATH
*5* Facts About McCain

1  * McCain was *5th* from the bottom of his class at the Naval Academy -- Admiral's son thinks he's a prince
2  * McCain wrecked *5* jets before he was taken prisoner -- A military failure for Commander in Chief
3  * Three out of every *5* people in the world are Asian. McCain famously said "I hate Gooks and always will"
4  * With his two wives, Carol and Cindy combined, McCain has *5* children in two families -- maybe he's Mormon
5  * McCain was the *5th* member of the infamous Keating *5*, one of the dirtiest scandals ever in Congress

Bonus Fact: McCain would be THE OLDEST man to ever become president, turning *75* during his first term.
McCain does NOT talk about the ISSUES, just Barack Obama... I guess he doesn't know enough to do so effectively.

“I’m John McCain and I approve lies, fears and smears.” — Lee-Dallas, TX
Kendall Livelee, Tampa FL -

Give me a break, pal. Vote for McCain if you feel you must, but don't pretend he didn't sell his soul for the nomination.

Oh, and did McCain really think he'd get an invitation to the Democratic convention? Did the Repubs invite Obama? He did say he'd meet unconditionally with unsavory warmongers...

Obama/Biden '08
Jack Lennon,Philly,PA
Why on earth do you think that Europeans feel inferior?  Have you ever been to Europe? How many Europeans do you know personally?  If your logic was correct (and it isn't) they haven't had to wait very long  these last eight years for visits from "doofus" American leaders.  That happens pretty much every time "W" sets foot on European soil.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1294701

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google