ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



First thoughts: Hillary delivers

Posted: Wednesday, August 27, 2008 9:42 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, and Domenico Montanaro
DENVER, Colo. -- With a backdrop of PUMAs on the prowl here, Clinton donors upset they’re not staying at the Ritz-Carlton (as the New York Times wrote), and word that Bill Clinton won’t attend Obama’s speech tomorrow night, Hillary Clinton last night delivered on two fronts: 1) she gave a full-throated endorsement of Obama, and 2) she made it clear to her troops that voting for McCain was unacceptable. “No way. No how. No McCain,” she said. As some Hillary watchers told us, it was her finest speech. It was an impressive balance of anti-McCain sound bites and the case for the Democratic way of governing. She really did strike a Goldilocks balance of preserving her own political future and being for Obama. Yet even better than her speech were the pictures on TV. For all the tension and hard feelings that exist here in Denver, you couldn’t tell when you watched her speech. It looked like a unified party. To be sure, last night’s speech won’t end some of the tension and hard feelings. But both ObamaNation and Hillaryland got what they wanted out of last night’s speech. (PUMAs, for those that don't know, are the "Party Unity My A--" crowd -- ardent Hillary backers, refusing to vote for Obama.)

VIDEO: Clinton urges her supporters to back Obama. NBC's David Gregory Reports.

*** When your staff doesn’t do you any favors: All that said, who in Hillaryland thought it was a good idea to step on the best speech of her political career by giving blind quotes about a future presidential campaign? She got tremendous accolades from Team Obama, but some Clinton staffer had to spill beans about the speech's motivation to the New York Times. “Mrs. Clinton is almost certain to run for president in 2012 if Mr. Obama fails this time, several Clinton advisers said Tuesday, and any such plan could possibly founder if the Clintons’ negative feelings show through this year.” It's actually a good example of how no good deed goes unpunished by her staff, and it’s another reminder of how undisciplined her campaign would be right now had she won the Dem nomination. It's no wonder there's so little trust between the candidates when staff  -- particularly hers, in this case -- undermines her unity efforts.

VIDEO: NBC's Andrea Mitchell and Chuck Todd weign in on Clinton's DNC speech and her husband's upcoming speech.

*** Just askin’: Did anyone else notice those “Hillary” signs that had the “hillaryclinton.com” address at the bottom? Always be debt retiring! Indeed, immediately after her speech, her folks sent out an email to contribute money.

*** The gloves come off: After last night’s round of speeches, we don’t think anyone is now going to wonder whether the Democratic convention is going too soft on McCain. In speech after speech, Democrats unloaded on the Arizona senator. They brought up his multiple houses, pointed out that he has said he doesn’t understand the economy, and (of course) tied him to President Bush at every opportunity. Beyond those attacks, though, they hit him hard in two ways that could end up proving especially damaging -- because McCain’s campaign doesn’t seem to have a clear response to them. The first was Mark Warner’s future-vs.-the past hit. “The race for the future is on,” he said, “And it won't be won with a president who is stuck in the past.” The McCain camp issued this tepid response to defend a candidate who admits he’s not a big computer user: “Whether it’s been rooting out corruption in politics, fighting global climate change or calling for a new strategy in Iraq John McCain has a record of making bipartisan change, and Barack Obama does not.” The second hard hit came with this line by Hillary: “[McCain] still thinks it's okay when women don't earn equal pay for equal work.” How does a candidate losing women by double digits respond? We’ll find out next week…

*** Schweitzer’s stem-winders: By the way, last night's keynote was supposed to be Mark Warner, but the governor with unlimited ambition who lit up the hall was Montana's Brian Schweitzer. Who knew he could give the rah-rah stem-winder? While he didn't get much attention from the networks, he was on in the 10:00 pm hour, and he got the crowd so worked up, the anchors had to take notice. One of the few surprises so far…

*** Biden's big moment: Now we turn to tonight’s program… Before last Thursday, it appeared Joe Biden would never get a moment like this. He wanted it, ran for president twice to get it, but it seemed the dream was going to die. And then, Obama gave Biden political redemption. The Delaware senator has been preparing for this moment for half his life. He's been a senator for more than half his life. As he likes to point out, he was the Obama of the '88 campaign. Biden may have the unenviable task of having to follow Bill Clinton tonight, but if anyone is up to the task, it's him. Ask any union member about Biden's ability to bring down a house. He's got it in him; let's see if he can pull it off.

*** Elvis is in the building: We swear that tonight's featured speech is Joe Biden, seriously, it is. But it's not the speech that's getting the early buzz -- that belongs to the anticipated remarks of Bill Clinton. What will he say? How will he say it? Will he make an Obama pitch or a generic argument for the Democratic way of governing? Our sense: Bill's a competitive guy, he wants to show Obama why he'd be an asset and why he might be better suited at making the case against McCain.  The one thing that would surprise us: If someone ends up describing the speech as unremarkable.

VIDEO: Romney appears on Morning Joe, handicapping Biden as a VP contender.

*** No rest for the weary: Politico reports that McCain’s pick is coming Friday, and the CW is back pointing in Romney's direction, who happens to be in Denver. He was pretty solid today on Morning Joe, talking up the need for McCain to carry Michigan. He sounded like a guy ready for the call.

*** A good day for the DSCC, a bad day (maybe) for the DCCC: Alaska held its primaries last night, offering the possibility that the state’s longest-serving Republicans -- Ted Stevens and Don Young, both whom face legal/ethical troubles -- could go down to defeat. Well, it turns out that one may. Per the Anchorage Daily News, Young trails GOP challenger Sean Parnell by fewer than 200 votes. A Parnell win would complicate the Democrats’ chances of winning the seat. Somewhat surprisingly, however, Stevens -- who is indicted and faces a trial on corruption charges in the fall -- easily won his primary. And that’s good news for Democratic challenger Mark Begich, who now seems even more in the driver’s seat in that contest. [***UPDATE*** Young is actually now ahead by 145 votes with 429 of 438 precincts reporting. Democrats are gearing up either way, believing that Parnell's inability to pull away from a candidate under investigation by the FBI, signifies, one strategist said, "the more Alaskans saw of Parnell, the less they liked him."]

*** Today’s convention schedule: Wednesday’s theme is Securing America’s Future (a focus on foreign affairs, as well as a tribute to veterans, active duty military, and military families). The marquee speakers are Bill Clinton and Joe Biden. Also speaking: Sen. Evan Bayh, Sen. Jack Reed, former Sen. Tom Daschle, Sen. John Kerry, Gov. Bill Richardson, Rep. Chet Edwards, and ex-congressional candidate Tammy Duckworth. Also, the formal roll-call vote takes place in the afternoon.

*** The RNC’s response: Rudy Giuliani, former Maryland Lt. Gov. Michael Steele, and former Treasury Secretary Rosario Marin hold a press conference in Denver to rebut the Democrats on the issue of national security.

*** Also in Denver: Harry Reid, Chuck Schumer and Dem Senate candidates hold a press conference at 1:15 pm ET at the Colorado Convention Center to discuss the upcoming Senate races, 1:15 pm ET... Officials with the Western Majority Project discuss energy issues at 4:30 pm ET at the Colorado Convention Center.

*** On the trail: McCain is in Arizona, where he does some filming for his campaign. Obama holds a discussion with military families in Billings, MT.

Countdown to GOP convention: 5 days
Countdown to Election Day 2008: 69 days
Countdown to Inauguration Day 2009: 146 days

Click here to sign up for First Read emails.
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hillary did all she needed to last.  All of the GOP trolls who will be on the blogs today will no doubt try to say that "The most important issue was not brought up in her speach".  Well, as a former Hillary supporter, I can honestly say that I am 110% satisfied.  Rachel Maddow said it best last night, she reached the reachables, and if there are those who will still not vote for Obama, than at this point they never will.

NO WAY, NO HOW, NO MCCAIN!!!!
IF Billy-boy will put away his pride and cough up the goods, he could really go after Mclame in some serious, hard-to-rebut ways, as could Joe Biden.  Give us an idea of what your man intends to do in the insane world Bush made, Joe, and use Bill as an attack dog. They can't run "Hillary should be veep" ads, so keep 'em on the run, boys! Hit 'em HARD!!
After listening to HRC's terrific speech last night and then Chris and Keith's effusive praise about it, I was stunned to tune in to Morning Joe and listen to Mica and Joe complaining about what they think she didn't do. Now, I've heard all the complaints about Moron Joe (and have largely agreed), but I expected better from Mica. I don't guess the outlyers on both ends of the Democratic spectrum -- the rabid Obamanites and rabid Clintonites -- will EVER be satisfied.

Obama/Biden 2008 -- if you believe in the Democratic principles, how can you vote any other way??

VIVA CHUCK TODD!
Hillary has done her part.  Now, it's up to Obama. She is not responsible for trying to close the deal for him.
Hillary knocked our socks last night with her speech. I know Bill will do the same tonight, but, no matter how well the Clintons perform, they will never be given the credit they deserve. If the truth be told, and we as a country were not so vain, Dennis Kuchinch would be our Democrat nominee for president, because he is THE ONLY ONE who speaks truth to power.
Treasurer != Treasury Secretary
Senator Clinton did an amazing job on a speech that had to be extremely difficult for her to deliver. She deserves credit and admiration for her poise and courage.

She remains a bright, mmotivated and formidable woman.

Did anyone catch Bill Clinton as Hillary came on stage last night, mouthing "I love you, I love you" as he clapped for her?  Quite touching.  I believe that much of his over-the-top behavior, including the word that he won't attend Sen. Obama's speech tomorrow night, is based in his utter guilt at the way he has treated Hillary in their marriage.  Could it be that he's not so much against Obama as he's trying to atone for the past?
WOW !
Thank you Hillary
THAT was a great speech !

Let's elect Obama and enact a Democratic agenda
Health Care, Tax reform, alternative energy, saving social Security, restoring the rule of law to the White House....

No Way, No How, NO McCain !!


Hey Ceindy !
Where'd you find that midget


In comparison to Joe Biden, McCain's VP choices are WEAK.... Flip Flop Romney ?
Are you for or against Women's rights, Willard ?
Are you for or agsinst Gay rights, Willard ?
Which is it this time ?

Are you for or against the war, Willard ?

Rudy G ?
COME ON !!

Joe Lieberman ???

Bye, bye Shorty
Bottom Line – Hillary and Her Supporters:

I appears that some Hillary supporters did not get the message from Hillary last night. When asking those who supported her "was it about me" or was it about those examples of people needing help like the Marine she referred too, Hillary was asking her supporters not to disappoint her by sitting on the sidelines and not supporting Obama.

If some Hillary supporters feel like jumping in a river or to go drinking or to skip Obama's speech Thursday evening, or not to support Obama, then won't they be disappointing Hillary? And if they are so committed to her and love her so much as they say they do then I ask you, why would they want to disappoint Hillary? Is it natural to disappoint someone you love when you have the control and power not to disappoint that person.  Where does reason exist if one intentionally disappoints someone they love.

Once again. I agree with Hillary regarding some of her so-called supporters. It was not about her. It was about their own self-serving petty and selfish desires whatever they might have been. And if they are willing to disappoint her although claiming to love her, then they also could care less about that Marine or that single mom raising two kids while battling cancer, or those without health care,  or women’s rights, etc. And if this is how they feel then win or lose this election, we don't want them on our team.  

Hillary did great last night and she is to be commended. She clearly showed that unlike some of her supporters she has the strength, intelligence,  toughness to say ok, I lost the nomination and it may even in the eyes of some have been stolen from under my feet, but I am going to buckle under and continue to fight for what I believe in and that includes supporting Barack Obama.  Hillary showed last night why she has ” class” and some of her supporters who continue to deny Obama are clearly showing that unlike Hillary, why they have none.
Senator Clinton did hit it out of the park, she is a class act, out of disapointment sometimes comes greatness that we may not see today but Hillarys future is brighter than you will ever know. Now the truley important thing is to get Obama and Biden elected, without them Senator Clintons dreams for this country is lost. I am already seeing the talking points in the MSM trying to keep the devide open and widen it, so beware the MSM, we cant trust them their
CEOs and High paid excutives vote republican every time, we let them steal the 2004 election by letting them swift boat Senator Kerry. Democrats dont let it happen again.

Obama/Biden
Tonight, all eyes will be on Bill and he will continue where HRC left off.  He will think about his impeachment proceedings and use that built up raw emotion to squash McCain and the Repukes.  

He will say that Obama is ready to lead on day one and we need Obama to answer the 3:00 am phone call.

Bill's legacy is on the line.  He will not blow it.
For those of us who have supported Sen.Obama since the beginning and who have been aghast at the behaviour of the Clintons during the Primary, this continued focus on them has got to stop.

The media has a responsibilty to report happenings not opinionate on what they see thru whatever prism they are looking at events.  Last night, Hillary Clinton, gave a good speech, said all the right things about the campaign. However, make no mistake, she is looking out for herself and no one else, and tonight, Bill will do the same.

They are both extremley selfserving people and I am disappointed that the Obama Campaign has given them so much time on the agenda.  It is time for them to move off stage, this continous attention by the media is destructive to the objective of winning this very important election.

The MSM including MSNBC is being taken for a ride by the Clintons and the Republicans so much so, I rarely watch TV anymore and when I do, I come away with the feeling you guys are trying to make news rather than reporting what you see.  I will do my own interpreting.
Last night's line up was killer.

Even Kucinich got the crowd going. Wake up America!

Warner's speech hit all the high notes. Great speech.

Casey delivered the line of the night: "That's not a maverick, that's a sidekick."

And Hillary... my god... She kicked McCain's butt last night. Her staff, though, has always been her Achilles heel.

I can't wait for Bill to rip Johnny Mac a new one tonight!

http://www.rodneyhopper.com


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1297182

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google