ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Reviews of Day 3: By acclamation

Posted: Thursday, August 28, 2008 9:35 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under: , , ,

 

The Washington Post’s lead story: “Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois completed an improbable and historic journey here Wednesday when he was nominated by acclamation as the Democratic candidate for president, becoming the first African American to lead a major political party into a general-election campaign. Obama, who just eight years ago attended his first Democratic National Convention and who four years later shot to national prominence with an electrifying keynote address at the gathering in Boston, was given a final symbolic boost Wednesday by Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, who moved from the convention floor to suspend the roll call of the states and formalize her former rival's nomination by acclamation.”

The New York Times says that Obama’s nomination “brought to an end an often-bitter two-year political struggle for the nomination with Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York, who, standing on a packed convention floor electric with anticipation, moved to halt the roll call in progress so that the convention could nominate Mr. Obama by acclamation. That it did with a succession of loud roars, followed by a swirl of dancing, embracing, high-fiving and chants of ‘Yes, we can.’”

However, it’s worth pointing out that Obama will officially be the "nominee" until the conclusion of his acceptance speech," per the language of the Democrats' "Call to Convention.”

Clinton biographer David Maraniss of the Washington Post says that Bill Clinton’s speech last night “framed the case for Sen. Barack Obama and against the Republicans in a way that no one at this convention had done before. Only a day earlier, when there was some unease among Clinton's associates about whether he was being straitjacketed in what he could say in his speech, Obama tried to defuse the situation by saying Clinton could say whatever he wanted. Good call, as it turned out.”

“Perhaps not even Obama himself could have conjured up an oration so powerful on his behalf. Not only did Clinton utter the words ‘Barack Obama’ 15 times, they came in his first sentence and his last, and there were long riffs about the candidate in between.”

Bill Clinton strode onstage to Fleetwood Mac's "Don't Stop" and promised that "America must always be a place called Hope," endorsing Barack Obama as an inheritor to the spirit of his first presidential run."

The New York Daily News' cover: "My man Bam."

The New York Times notes that Joe Biden accepted his party’s VP nomination “with an ode to his middle-class upbringing and a blistering attack on Senator John McCain. On tax policy and the war in Iraq, on health care and terrorism, on the minimum wage and on Russia, Mr. Biden said, the contrast was clear between Mr. McCain and the Democratic presidential nominee, Senator Barack Obama.”

More: Mr. Biden, who referred to his childhood struggle with stuttering, made a few verbal slips, including referring to Mr. McCain as ‘George.’ ‘Freudian slip, folks,’ he said. ‘Freudian slip.’ … And in another apparent slip, he also referred to $200 million in taxes on corporations when he meant to say $200 billion in tax cuts for companies.”

More on Biden’s speech: "It was red-meat stuff for the 4,233 Democratic delegates packed into the Pepsi Center for the party's national convention, many of whom were looking to Biden to fill a role they say presidential nominee Barack Obama badly needs - that of an aggressive and experienced attacker. 'The choice in this election is clear,' Biden said. 'These times require more than a good soldier. They require a wise leader.'"

John Kerry, the party’s nominee four years ago, went after both the Bush Administration and the McCain camp with fervor last night, NBC’s Abigail Williams observes. "They misread the threat and misled the country! Instead of freedom, it’s Hamas, Hezbollah, the Taliban and dictators everywhere that are on the march. North Korea can build more bombs, and Iran is defiantly chasing one," he said.

Speaking with unusual precision, Kerry soothed nagging fears about Obama's foreign policy experience while bringing doubt to McCain's. "When Barack Obama promised to honor the best traditions of both parties and talk to our enemies, John McCain scoffed, George bush called it the false comfort of appeasement, but today Bush's diplomats are doing exactly what Obama said, talking with Iran so who can we trust to keep America safe?"

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It's way cool how Hillary Clinton sounds like Barack and Obama sounds like Hllary...They are truly for each other for the better part of the Democratic Party..

The Republicans will have a lot of ground to make up on this one...
McCain picks anybody on his short list it won't even come close to echo how unified the Dem's are...
Romney..to left wing and wrong religion for GOP
Pawlenty..to unknown and bottom blender
Lieberman..to mother hen-ish...
anyone else, a dark horse, a women...
it looks like pandering and flops on the unity issue...to much ground to make up...
'These times require more than a good soldier. They require a wise leader.'
******************************************************

Indeed.  Succinct and to the point.

http://thepajamapundit.com/
The Commerce Department reported Thursday that gross domestic product, or GDP, increased at a 3.3 percent annual rate in the April-June quarter.
Clinton, Kerry, and Biden all made superb speeches last night and outlined the case for Obama very well.

judgement and wisdom trumps experience.

integrity and honesty trumps slander.

vision and hope trumps fear.

The convention has set up Obama to deliver the knock out blow tonight, and i can't wait to see it.

Great Job Dems!  i'm a registered independent, but you have my vote this election because of your platform, the clean way that you have run your campaign and convention, and because of the american values that your candidates showcase.
Nice speeches, nice message, nice McCain attacks BUT....

Too bad Obama LOST the perception race.

The republicans already won because they succeeded in the perception war...getting most americans to perceive him as not ready to lead, not ready to be commander in chief, all of which Obama cannot overcome, or change.  And this, my friends, will be why Obama will lose in November, despite the unity stuff and nice speeches this week.

Oh, and when McCain picks Romney as VP, watch McCain's poll numbers soar through the roof because Romney is perceived as an economic wiz, even though he's a flip flopping panderer of the worst kind.

Again, its all about how you are perceived, not reality, not the issues, and because Democrats never get this through their thick skulls, they will always lose the White House.
You know, I will only believe what the Clintons say if they go immediately from the convention and campaign for him in the swing states.  My guess is that many of these former Clinton supporters are waiting for the same thing.  They want to look them in the eyes and hear it straight from them, not hear them reading from a teleprompter with a gun to their heads.

I'm a HUGE Obama supporter, but this "unity" has a very staged and uncomfortable look to it.  It's way too fresh to be reflected in the polls anytime soon, and that will get the poll-watcher hand-wringing started in a few days, I'm afraid.

Will sure be some nice Karma to have Gustav in the picture next week, though.  I expect the birthday cake shots of McBush will get plenty of play.
Ian:
Don't be fooled by yesterday's post by Andress.  He is not a real Obama supporter, he's just a limp wristed conservative coward who's trying to masquerade as an Obama supporter in order to divide and conquer us.  Go back and reread his post and you'll see the repugnant one's talking points all over his clueless comment.  Note him saying Hillary ought to bow down and give oral pennance and that Bill did bad things in the Oval Office.  To top it off he then goes on to try to paint Obama as some godlike figure.  All repugnant one talking points.

There are many limp wristed conservative cowards here posting stuff falsely as Obama and Clinton supporters trying to fool us real Democrats into thinking we're still at war with each other.  They are nothing but card carrying members of Nixon's "Plumbers Union" who are too cowardly to post as "Bush Hugger" McCain supporters because they're ashamed of their repugnant party.  If a comment from a purported Obama or Clinton supporter sounds too negative towards the other candidate then it's just a dirty political trick of the repugnant ones.

These agents of Satan are most likely paid members of the repugnant one's party who are trying to steal the White House again.  Understand the clueless rantings of these limp wristed conservative cowards for what they are.  Isn't it ironic that these agents of Satan preach morality yet practice devilry?

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
For his speech, Biden just read the Democratic playbook. More unions, more taxes on corporations, "free" health care for everyone, take a pacifist head up his a** view of foreign policy. The Democrats have bleating this garbage for 40 years, it's no wonder they've only had only two Presidents in that timespan.
I am proud of both Clinton's.  They showed they are true blue.  I thought the speech by Tammy Duckworth, the video and Beau Biden were so incredibly powerful.  Saw it all on C-span.  MSNBC really let me down on the convention coverage.

Go to youtube and find these three items.  (Also LOVED John Kerry!)

Joe Biden is an excellent VP pick, I can't wait for tonight!
The Democratic Party better get ready to salute John McCain.

Not b/c Bill didn't make the case.
Not b/c Hillary didn't make the case.

But b/c there is no case to be made for Obama. He has no experience, no accomplishment.

Bill did his best last night. But you got to have something to work with, for God's sake.

We love Bill. We love Hillary. And we are voting for McCain.
Awesome. The dems ripped!
Stage? I've seen the stage. Will Barack be wearing a toga? And one thing that is a little confusing, is Obama running for President, or Roman Emperor?
Bill gave a great speech last night.  I've started watching the convention on CSPAN as I am tired of David Gregory's got'ya questions and Moron Joe and Racist Pat.  A few days ago FR had three goals for the convention.  Yes, there will be unity (minus 5%). Yes, they did frame Barack and Joe as Americans with American values.  Forgot the third critieria.  Getting more like McOld every day.
Where was AlGore in all this hoopla? Stage not big enough to support him?
It's way cool how Hillary Clinton sounds like Barack and Obama sounds like Hillary...They are truly for each other for the better part of the Democratic Party..

The Republicans will have a lot of ground to make up on this one...
McCain picks anybody on his short list it won't even come close to echo how unified the Dem's are...
Romney..to left wing and wrong religion for GOP
Pawlenty..to unknown and bottom blender
Lieberman..to mother hen-ish...
anyone else, a dark horse, a women...
it looks like pandering and flops on the unity issue...to much ground to make up...

4 years of I'm a POW..yuck ..no thanks..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k5dPwegqgDU&feature=related

McCain is not the man he claims to be. The POW’s and military despise this man for all his lies and manipulation. Watch the video and see the real John McCain and I guarantee nobody will vote for this lying skunk.

http://www.vietnamveteransagainstjohnmccain.com/

Bill did well with an outward and definative speech and endorsement of Sen. Obama.

Surprisingly, Much more convincing that Hillary...

Glad to have them onboard.

But NO ONE was hard enough on mccain.
Is it because he is their 'friend'?
Will mccain be as gracious.  We already know the answer to that, don't we...  

He has No Class, Just Houses...
I watched and enjoyed Biden's speech last evening and found him to be positive, energetic and forthright.

I think Obama picked the correct partner & running mate.
<a href="http://davedragon.rilysi.com">Dave</a>

Bill did well with an outward and definative speech and endorsement of Sen. Obama.

Surprisingly, Much more convincing that Hillary...

Glad to have them onboard.

But NO ONE was hard enough on mccain.
Is it because he is their 'friend'?
Will mccain be as gracious.  We already know the answer to that, don't we...  

He has No Class, Just Houses...
What about Huckabee?? Am I the only one who thinks that this would go a long way with the conservatives & evangelicals?
Funny how so many of you who "despised" the Clintons during the primary, are now gushing on about how wonderful they are.  Remember that a speech is "just words".  The Clintons did it this way to ensure that Hilary will have a chance to run again in 2012.  Slick, very slick.  As for myself - no way I ever vote for a Clinton.  They are manipulators and ALWAYS have an agenda.  You can bet Chelsea will be running for something when she decides that bidding up oil futures isn't working any more.  
Clinton, Kerry, and Biden were superb last night.

Clinton's references back to the knocks he took in his 1992 quest for the presidency were so appropriate and I think will help put it into perspective for a lot of independents. I think his line of the night was "The world has always been more impressed with the power of our example than in the example of our power."

Kerry delivered on many fronts. I was wondering when someone would hit McCain and Bush for being behind the Obama plans for Iraq, Iran, and Afghanistan. Line of the night on Candidate McCain vs Senator McCain: "Talk about being for it before your were against it."

Biden ripped McCain a new one: "Again and again, on the most important national security issues of our time, John McCain was wrong and Barack Obama was proven right."

Red meat... enough to fill 7 houses.

http://www.rodneyhopper.com
Watching Cspan, Kerry, Clinton and Biden had very satisfying speeches. Thanks guys. Bidens sons (Beau) intro was very touching as well. I love the way they handled things down there and things were well put together. After watching that, the Demos are as united as ever, despite what the pundits think and Repubs.
Joe Biden as an attack dog sounds like that annoying little rat of a dog chihuahua my neighbor has. Just like with the dog, just give Joe a good kick, and watch him sling off whimpering to some remote corner.
Does stuttering cause you to plagiarize?
I was very impressed by the First Lady of Class, Hillary Clinton, as she pushed aside personal political ambition for party unity during the roll call vote.  As an ardent and long time Obama supporter I am very pleased with Hillary's personal sacrifice for the party's good.  I've watched conventions since 1968 and never saw a man do that!

Hey and how about Bill Clinton and his excellent speech last night?  I'm so glad that he has gotten over it and now is working for the good of the party and the nation by backing Obama/Biden.  He waxed eloquent on the evils of the "NeoNazi" Bush legacy of lies and stealing from our future generations while polluting the planet without care.

With the Clinton's help the Obama/Biden ticket will be the winning ticket this fall.  We will take back our great secular democracy from the clueless lunatic fringe who sought to destroy it.

Unity is a beautiful thing and the repugnant ones are scared to death that we Democrats are going to take back the White House and restore law and order to our country.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
Wow!  Bill Clinton's speech!  When he began speaking about Obama's qualifications for office, I squeezed by eyes shut, clapped my hands, and repeated, over and over, :I DO believe in fairies, I DO, I DO, I DO. . .
Oops! The comment about Huckabee was supposed to post to the one about McCain's Veep pick.
Its probably just me, but last night's choreographed thing didn't work as well as I thought it might. It seemed too artificial, and actually a little, well, wrong.

If you're going to do the roll call, do it. By starting it and the interrupting it, I thought it came across as a slight to all the states that didn't get to give their intro.

But I was already in a sour mood. Its impossible to pay attention to commentators during that much background activity, and its impossible to pay attention to the background activity while commentators were jabbering on and on. And most of the comments were, well, stupid.

Chuck, the only thing missing from your smart aleck comments about people doing the state intros was the Beavis and Butthead laugh.

The whole thing was surreal. It was like Mystery Political Convention Theatre 3000, except not funny.
First Read: “Perhaps not even Obama himself could have conjured up an oration so powerful on his behalf. Not only did Clinton utter the words ‘Barack Obama’ 15 times"


Oh, dear Lord! Now we're just going to have to find someone to say John McCain's name 16 times!
Bill Clinton was brilliant. Kerry's brilliance is more introverted, but clearly, he is twice the man, twice the hero, twice the American patriot John McCain or George Bush is. Biden stikes me as the most normal and healthiest in personality of any national politician to make it to the top since Gerald Ford. Who are the Republicans going to showcase: Cheney? What famous progeny are going to show up at the Republican convention? The Reagan kids are Democrats. The Eisenhauers and Julie Nixon support Obama. Guess the Republicans will have to go with their ususual theme: fear, fear and fear.
I thought Kerry laid some serious groundwork for the Dems.
President Clinton is the master of communications and showed it again last night.
Joe Biden was clearly scripted and going forward the Obama team needs to give him the theme and then let Joe go.

MSNBC, how about ratcheting up the quality of posts going forward?  What do I mean?
Instead of letting people just rant, require that they at least put some bullet points behind their arguments if they criticize one of the two campaigns.
For example, and this is probably most prevalent, looking at the Hillary or McCain people.
That's fine, but at least require that they show one point that they agree with McCain on that either they disagree with from Obama OR that Hillary also championed.
Or, for Obama people, if you don't think that being the same is good for us going forward, articulate points why not.  After all, we haven't had an attack on US soil since 9/11.  So, is that so bad to not want to be the same in that regard?

Look, I'm an avid supporter of Senator Obama and want him to win.  But, I'm also hopeful that we can change the discourse of our discussion and push the level of intellect even higher.

Links of actual words from the candidate, or video of them saying something, or a specific vote would be great.  THEN, your argument carries a lot of weight.
Thank Cable for CSPAN. Unfiltered content is what we need.
I was so impressed - first with the Arkansas delegation and Mrs. Gwatney (tough dedicated lady)whose husband Bill, the head of the Arkansas democratic party was murdered so recently; cast all their votes for Obama...talk about party unity.  And then watching Hillary and the NY delegation moving to go to acclimation was great.  The democratic party is poised and ready to elect Obama/Biden.  NO HOW NO WAY NO MCCAIN
Uh, Obama will be the official "nominee" of the Democratic Party until he's elected in November.  You may want to look up the word.
Lost in all this is the Democrats 'giving' full voting rights to Michigan and Florida. So the message is that you're only accountable to the rules when your votes might matter. When they don't matter, then Howard Dean and his merry men can do what they damn well please.
John Kerry's red meat moment was spot on.  Sen. McCain of 2000 is not the same man as Candidate McCain of 2008.  This theme and the McCain and Bush attached at the hip theme will go along way.

Sen. McCain's worst enemy is Candidate McCain.  
See Hillary supporters, your votes don't matter. Just lay back and enjoy the screwing you're getting.
If Kerry gave a speech like that in 2004 he would have been President.

The Dems are hammering McCain for turning from Maverick to Sidekick. From promising a respectful campaign to a despicable Rove right-wing-radio personal attack campaign, and for caving in to the agents of intolerance he once despised.

The choice became very clear Wednesday night and will become even more obvious after Obama's acceptance speech.

We will never have an opportunity like this to look ahead instead of looking behind!
Oh what a night!  History was made yesterday as the party united behind the Obama-Biden ticket to victory! The parade of speakers with their personal endorsements moved me to tears!  Veterans spoke out!  The speeches by John Kerry, Bill Clinton and Joe Biden were historic.

As I observed the lady who was a pilot in Iraq passionately defend veterans, walk away from the podium ... I noticed she had no legs!  They were amputated after her chopper was shot down.  She ran for office in 2006,was vilified and attacked by the republican party with no mercy or compassion.  She lost the election but not her spirit.  She reminded me last night of why I am no longer a republican! Her name slips my mind this morning ... but not her sacrifice and service.  She didn't remind us of her missing legs and pain.  Perhaps McCain will learn from her and stop reminding us of his POW years!  Stop using the POW smoke screen and answer the questions!

Biden simply captured it all last night when he stated the GOP is no longer the grand old party its simply ... OLD!

I was never as proud of my Party as I was last night with the official nomination of Senator Barack Obama as the Democratic nominee for the next President of the United States. It was a proud moment in history and for all those who came before us in order to make this event happen. I never thought I would see it in my lifetime and am so pleased I did. I will now work feverishly between now and November to get our nominee elected and see yet another milestone. I am proud to be an American.......again. Obama/Biden '08!
Madame Senator, I am profoundly sorry I ever doubted you!
Whoever was presiding over the roll call had the MOST ANNNOYING VOICE EVER!

I had to mute the TV because she was giving me a headache!!
I am so tired of Polls. I only wish all the news media were tired of them too. National Polls seem useless. It might be because 36% of young voters do not have land lines, just cell phones.

I have found a website that seems to provide unbiased accurate analysis.

http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/

This was created by the same guy who created the baseball analysis website. For those of you that want the truth, instead of looking for a poll that favors your candidate. This might be the place. If you think you have a better one, let me know.    
It was a great and wonderful moment in US history.
America cannot trust more of Bush's and McCain's cowboy diplomacy.  America cannot trust McCain's reckless, maverick foreign policy.  America cannot trust McCain's maverick economic, health care and energy policies that let Americans fend for themselves.  America cannot trust another Maverick in the White House!!!
"However, it’s worth pointing out that Obama will officially be the "nominee" until the conclusion of his acceptance speech," per the language of the Democrats' "Call to Convention.”
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Whether this was indeed "worth pointing out" is indeed debatable. I'm leaning towards NOT.

-----------------------------------------------
"It was red-meat stuff for the 4,233 Democratic delegates packed into the Pepsi Center for the party's national convention"

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Clearly, the Democratic Party and the Obama campaign have made the RIGHT CALL in moving his acceptance speech to a larger venue - 4,233 seats will NOT HOLD the dreams of a generation of Americans.

This is a fitting send off to Senator Obama's HISTORIC candiacy. Not just historic because of his race - but also because of his unprecedented organization, fund raising, and uplifting message.

It is ashamed that his accomplishments have been so muted by the politics of ridicule and ridiculousness.

But this is what America has become . . .

TIME TO TURN THE PAGE!

Obama/Biden '08/'12
If you are thinking of voting for john mcain please check this site out as a long life conservative this idiot will bring down the Republican party.
http://www.nojohn.com/
Who indeed.  Bush is following Obama's advice, because Obama is RIGHT a great deal of the time. And Bush/Cheney and Mclame are very often WRONG. I became an Obama supporter just after he declared when I saw him on TV being asked a question by some cable news talkiing head. I saw Obama pause and actually THINK about the question, not just spew some prepackaged soundbite. I thought, "My God, the man THINKS!!! Too bad he's black, the country will never accept him." I was RIGHT in that the man does think, but WRONG in thiniking the country wouldn't accept him.And it's Obama's capacity to think and treat every question as an intelligent and thought-provoking one that makes him RIGHT so much of the time when so many Repiglicans are thinking with their macho swagger and being proven time and again that they are WRONG!!
They got it right.  Kerry showed that Barack's judgement is spot on in foreign policy since McCain and the Bush administration are now doing the things that Barack called for a long time ago.  Biden showed that McCain won't make the changes we need because he doesn't think any thing is wrong. And Clinton demonstrated that Barack is ready to be President. Ready to take on and solve the massive problems we face.

Listening to Morning Joe, you'd never know it with all their critiques of what should have been said and how it could have been said better.  The American people are more than capable of hearing and analyzing the issues without name calling and spin, which seem to be what the pundits want to hear.

Whats the mater MSM?  Don't you know how to discuss actual issues instead of dirt and fluff?        


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1300316

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

More First Read

Recent Posts:


Archives:


Topics:

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google