ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Reviews of Day 3: By acclamation

Posted: Thursday, August 28, 2008 9:35 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

 

The Washington Post’s lead story: “Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois completed an improbable and historic journey here Wednesday when he was nominated by acclamation as the Democratic candidate for president, becoming the first African American to lead a major political party into a general-election campaign. Obama, who just eight years ago attended his first Democratic National Convention and who four years later shot to national prominence with an electrifying keynote address at the gathering in Boston, was given a final symbolic boost Wednesday by Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, who moved from the convention floor to suspend the roll call of the states and formalize her former rival's nomination by acclamation.”

The New York Times says that Obama’s nomination “brought to an end an often-bitter two-year political struggle for the nomination with Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York, who, standing on a packed convention floor electric with anticipation, moved to halt the roll call in progress so that the convention could nominate Mr. Obama by acclamation. That it did with a succession of loud roars, followed by a swirl of dancing, embracing, high-fiving and chants of ‘Yes, we can.’”

However, it’s worth pointing out that Obama will officially be the "nominee" until the conclusion of his acceptance speech," per the language of the Democrats' "Call to Convention.”

Clinton biographer David Maraniss of the Washington Post says that Bill Clinton’s speech last night “framed the case for Sen. Barack Obama and against the Republicans in a way that no one at this convention had done before. Only a day earlier, when there was some unease among Clinton's associates about whether he was being straitjacketed in what he could say in his speech, Obama tried to defuse the situation by saying Clinton could say whatever he wanted. Good call, as it turned out.”

“Perhaps not even Obama himself could have conjured up an oration so powerful on his behalf. Not only did Clinton utter the words ‘Barack Obama’ 15 times, they came in his first sentence and his last, and there were long riffs about the candidate in between.”

Bill Clinton strode onstage to Fleetwood Mac's "Don't Stop" and promised that "America must always be a place called Hope," endorsing Barack Obama as an inheritor to the spirit of his first presidential run."

The New York Daily News' cover: "My man Bam."

The New York Times notes that Joe Biden accepted his party’s VP nomination “with an ode to his middle-class upbringing and a blistering attack on Senator John McCain. On tax policy and the war in Iraq, on health care and terrorism, on the minimum wage and on Russia, Mr. Biden said, the contrast was clear between Mr. McCain and the Democratic presidential nominee, Senator Barack Obama.”

More: Mr. Biden, who referred to his childhood struggle with stuttering, made a few verbal slips, including referring to Mr. McCain as ‘George.’ ‘Freudian slip, folks,’ he said. ‘Freudian slip.’ … And in another apparent slip, he also referred to $200 million in taxes on corporations when he meant to say $200 billion in tax cuts for companies.”

More on Biden’s speech: "It was red-meat stuff for the 4,233 Democratic delegates packed into the Pepsi Center for the party's national convention, many of whom were looking to Biden to fill a role they say presidential nominee Barack Obama badly needs - that of an aggressive and experienced attacker. 'The choice in this election is clear,' Biden said. 'These times require more than a good soldier. They require a wise leader.'"

John Kerry, the party’s nominee four years ago, went after both the Bush Administration and the McCain camp with fervor last night, NBC’s Abigail Williams observes. "They misread the threat and misled the country! Instead of freedom, it’s Hamas, Hezbollah, the Taliban and dictators everywhere that are on the march. North Korea can build more bombs, and Iran is defiantly chasing one," he said.

Speaking with unusual precision, Kerry soothed nagging fears about Obama's foreign policy experience while bringing doubt to McCain's. "When Barack Obama promised to honor the best traditions of both parties and talk to our enemies, John McCain scoffed, George bush called it the false comfort of appeasement, but today Bush's diplomats are doing exactly what Obama said, talking with Iran so who can we trust to keep America safe?"

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

John Kerry's speech was the best of the whole convention so far.  And to think we could of had him as president instead of that buffoon GWB that we have now. I hope the country doesn't make the same mistake this time around.
I would like to say as a africian american female living in CT, I never thought that this was possible.  When I say possible, I mean having a viable candidate who could and should be elected President of the United States.

You see, I am 42 years old and in two months will be 43 years old living in CT.  I remember going to elemetry school and having teachers move me out of class once they found out that I was black.  I remember growing up and having to fight every year because someone would use the "N" word, something they learned at home.  Make no mistake about it, I had to fight a boy to show them all I was tough.  I remember in 1980 and having our families mailbox blown up because we were the only black family on the block.  I also remember in 1983 being behind a white teacher that referred to a black student as a "N" word, just, to be excepted by some students.  

I say all of this to say, that I too was moved when Barack Obama was officially nominated as the Democratic Nominee for President of the United States.  An MSNBC personality said to him he didn't see his color because he grew up with 50% African American at his school in Mississippi and that is great. What he doesn't get and will never get is that he is looking at this from his point of view, being a white man.  I am looking at this as a Black woman, African American woman who has lived through covert biases throughout my life as recent as 1993.  What he is missing is that while he lived through intergration which was positive on his side, the other children if they were honest and if he ever asked their stories, there memories would be a little different, but I think I get what was meant by his comment.

Barack Obama has an excellent chance of being the next President of the United States and I will do everything in my power to get the vote out and help him get elected.  Not because he is an African American, but, because he is the only man in this election that can lead our country effectively.  He is the only man for the job and he has my vote because his whole message has been one of including not segregating and asking for the nation as a whole to take our country back, that is the person we should elect and that is the person with whom I shall vote.
For the first time during the whole campaign, I was reminded last night of why I voted for Clinton twice. His speech was riveting and captivating and drove home every point that needed to be made. In addition to the speeches, the roll call itself was a moving experience and I feel that we are lucky to be witnessing such historic events.
I saw President Clinton's speech last night and I was floored.  I love that man!  *S*  I felt that he was sincere in his backing of Sen. Obama like he had never been before. He was a good president and he recognized that it was time to pass the torch to Obama, because like him, they attack Obama on not being "experienced" enough.  Even Clinton had to admit, that no man (or woman) is actually prepared for that job because it's a job like no other.

Good job President Clinton.  My hats off to you!

[ ...was given a final symbolic boost Wednesday by Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, who moved from the convention floor to suspend the roll call of the states and formalize her former rival's nomination by acclamation.]
--Here's what I don't understand.  During the primary, Sen. Clinton was supposedly so focused on everybody having a voice and all the delegates counted (MI & FL).  Yet, she called the role call short.  (Obviously for unity and in conjunction with the Obama campaign).  But I ask what happened to everybody being counted?
The Dems' hit a home run last night.
Senator Kerry did an outstanding job with the speech he gave.

McCain is toying with you guys again.  He hasn't made his VP decision yet.  Everybody knows he has serious withdrawal symptoms if he thinks somebody else is taking away the media attention that he craves.
Clinton's speech was great. Classic Clinton.  He took the listener all around the problem so that in the end they could say "oh of course!  I should be supporting Obama."  His logic was impeccable.

Joe Biden was terrific.  He seemed at times overcome with emotion.  He's going to make a great vice president!  

Where was THIS John Kerry in 2004? This John Kerry would have won! He did a wonderful job highlighting the flip-flopping position of Senator McCain versus Candidate McCain.  In the end he made it look like McCain had sold his soul to the Rovian devils for a shot at his parties' candidacy.
Both speeches are well worth looking up on  a web-site and watching.  Kerry's is dynamite - not hateful but strong, so very strong.  Biden's is strong also, very knowledgabel --  and the personal part in the beginning matches Michelle Obama's word-picture of the Obama's upbringing and values.  No one can complain that the candidates aren't letting us know who they are.  To some (Biden, esp) the open warmth comes naturally and to others (Barack, esp) that much disclosure goes against his nature and experience.  But Biden grew up with love and acceptance in a community (blue class Catholic) that was solid and known and established.  Barack Obama grew up as a black child in a white family with a rich but dizzying and unique upbringing here and abroad: he had no models, no pre-established structure supporting him.  So their attitudes are understandable. What's uncanny is that they have come to so similar a place and outlook.  Two rather fascinating people.
I saw Bill Clinton speak as well as most of Biden's speech.  Both did well and knew what was going on and how to say what needed to be said: Obama is ready to be president.  This should be inspiring to all Democrats to vote for the ticket.  This should be fear inspiring to many Republicans as well because it seems that the Democrats have unified.  Those who claim to support Hillary Clinton need to be willing to do as she requests and support Obama.
I have been watching both MSNBC and CSpan coverage, I listen to the complete speeches on CSpan, then watch MSNBC for commentary.  I am the first to say I love Keith and Chris together, plus love to hear Rachel Maddow and Gene Robinson.  I am extremely disappointed with the feed from Fox News, I understand there is nothing that can be done.  However, realizing that the Country missed a beautiful moment last night when John Kerry gave a shout out to Obama's Uncle Charlie  With Michelle helping him to his feet to accept the recognition, the fact that Fox doesn't want the Country to see that Barack has (gasp) white relatives, that they are heros in their own right, is absolutely disgusting.   It was a truly beautiful moment that the viewers missed because of Faux News. I realize that MSNBC is doing the best it can with the feed they are receiving but somehow they need to develop some sort of plan to help viewers see the whole picture, not just the parts faux wants us to see.
I am pleased that the Democrats are not sinking down to the Republicans level. I hear everyone talking about why they don't 'GUT" them. Why, they have done it to themselves for the last 7 1/2 yaers. America desrves better than one man bashing the other. Let them keep talking about where we as a country needs to go and stop trying to make it about bashin Mccain and the Republicans!
Well last night ended the Dems chance at the white house. I realize her doing the acclaimation thing was set up by obama to keep her supporters from voicing their opions.  He made that part of the deal. He would allow her name in nomination, ONLY if she did the acclaimation.

And so ended the best chance we had. So, now time to move on. McCain 08


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1300316

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google