ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Palin: More Troopergate drip, drip

Posted: Thursday, September 04, 2008 9:29 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:



The Washington Post reports, that Palin “wrote e-mails that harshly criticized Alaska state troopers for failing to fire her former brother-in-law and ridiculed an internal affairs investigation into his conduct. The e-mails were shown to The Washington Post by a former public safety commissioner, Walter Monegan, who was fired by Palin in July. Monegan has given copies of the e-mails to state ethics investigators to support his contention that he was dismissed for failing to fire Trooper Mike Wooten, who at the time was feuding with Palin's family.”

“‘This trooper is still out on the street, in fact he's been promoted,’ said a Feb. 7, 2007, e-mail sent from Palin's personal Yahoo account and written to give Monegan permission to speak on a violent-crime bill before the state legislature. ‘It was a joke, the whole year long “investigation” of him," the e-mail said. ‘This is the same trooper who's out there today telling people the new administration is going to destroy the trooper organization, and that he'd “never work for that b****', Palin”.)’”

”Asked about the e-mails, Palin's campaign spokeswoman, Maria Comella, said that Palin was merely alerting officials to potential threats to her family and that there is no evidence that Palin ever ordered Wooten to be fired. ‘Let's be clear, Governor Palin has done nothing wrong and is an open book in this process. Mr. Monegan even stated himself that no one ever told him to fire anyone, period,’ Comella said later in a statement. ‘The Governor was rightly expressing concern about Mr. Wooten.’”

Per NBC’s Aram Roston and Amna Nawaz, the head of the troopers Union in Alaska, John Cyr, says that Gov. Palin is using her office to "demonize" her ex-brother-in-law, Trooper Mike Wooten. Cyr also says the union is filing an ethics complaint against Palin on behalf of Wooten. He says the union is accusing the governor's office of violating Wooten's rights. "The Governor is using her bully pulpit to demonize this man," Cyr said.

It’s worth noting that the troopers union, the Public Safety Employees Association, is an AFSCME local.

The New York Times writes that governing Alaska is in many ways much easier than in the other 49 states. “Alaska’s economic well-being - sustained, as most things are here, by oil and federal spending - has allowed Ms. Palin to avoid some of the tough budgetary choices vexing governors in dozens of other states. That in turn raises questions for some people about how much her experience is relevant to the rest of the nation and how much she can relate to the troubles of struggling blue-collar workers in places like Ohio and Pennsylvania, worried about the winter gas bills and the mortgage.”

“That said, by other measures, Alaska is harder to govern than a smaller, more settled realm in the Lower 48. With vast distances, large numbers of indigenous peoples and a narrowly based extraction economy - with a handful of giant multinational oil corporations dominating the game - some economists say a country like Nigeria might be an apter comparison. ‘Alaska really is a colonial place,’ said Stephen Haycox, a professor of history at the University of Alaska, Anchorage. ‘One third of the economic base is oil; another third is federal spending. The economy is extremely narrow and highly dependent. It’s not to say that Alaska is a beggar state, but it certainly is true that Alaska is dependent on decisions made outside it, and over which Alaskans don’t have great control.’”

Her first passport was in 2006? "Palin got her first passport in 2006 and has visited just four countries, and has had little involvement in her state's cross-border issues, raising questions about her supporters' assertions that Alaska's proximity to Russia has given her unique experience on foreign affairs. In seeking to demonstrate the first-term Alaska governor's readiness to be John McCain's second-in-command, campaign officials have maintained that Palin has had to deal with unusual security challenges and a variety of diplomatic and trade issues in a state sandwiched between Russia and Canada.”

"However, a review of Palin's 20 months in office shows that aside from overseeing the National Guard's state-level emergency missions, as all governors do, the first-term governor played no role in any territorial defense or other national defense operations involving military forces. Palin has also visited one fewer country than originally stated by her Alaska office. Earlier in the week, the governor's Alaska spokeswoman was quoted as saying Palin had traveled to Iraq, Kuwait, Germany, and Ireland, in addition to Canada." But Ireland was just for a refueling stop."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Palin is definitely a go-getter who is ahead of the game. Most people wait until AFTER they are in the White House before getting involved in scandals - but not Palin, she isn't wasting any time at all!

Was she wearing an Alaskan First pin?
Went to bed feeling bad. But, woke to another juicy open mic!

Lovin it!
Drippity drip drip.  For those who continue to go after Palin's family stories, you don't need to.  There is plenty of ammunition in her professional background.

http://thepajamapundit.com/
The dems at their convention attacked McCain for being out of touch, his voting record, and his stance on the issues, ie., Iraq, the economy, drilling, etc.


The dem chorus had a constant theme throughout their convention. They consistently  honored McCain's service as a veteran, and his suffering as a POW.

At the repub convention last night, they attacked Senator Obama with insults, sarcasm, mockery, and lies. The crowd dismissed him as a 'zero'. When they were called to recognize America’s historic achievement in his nomination, very few had the capacity to even acknowledge, let alone honor it.


Obama stood up for Palin, and her family. In response to his firm rebuke, the press backed off. In her speech last night, she spoke of him only with taunting disdain.

Senator Obama, remember what Christ taught.

"Do not cast your pearls before swine, lest they turn, and rend you".....

Senator Biden, do not spot this woman passes in the debates. Since she relishes the fight with the big boys, (for the big job), pull no punches. Let her have it. She is a lying neocon. Put. Her. Down.
Palin and that hack job of a speech.  She desreves everything she gets.

She is a pitbull with lipstick.  
Not to mention...the republican call Obama and empty suit, well she is "empty skirt".

That was a hatchet job out of the Rove play book and energize I am...more determined to send her back to her small town of Wasilla or is it Wa--Silly Politics.

We are in a crisis and is this all she has.

The Republican Party, THE PARTY OF SLANDER AND NO SOLUTIONS FOR AMERICA!  
Let's Review:

Republican Presidential candidate: 847 out of 849 in his class at the Naval Academy, paid for by his Legacy Dad?

Vice Presidential candidate: BA in Journalism, Beauty Queen, and last 8 years issuing ice fishing permits and using her office to help her sister in a custody battle with her State Trooper husband?

WHAT'S WRONG WITH THIS PICTURE????

Why do we insist, as Americans, to hire/nominate the worst underachievers(GW Bush included)we can find to the MOST important jobs in Government...

...and yet our job markets demand PHDs, MAs and a ton of experience for good entry level positions!?

We used to call that "backasswards"!
Nothing is more dangerous in all of human experience than a politician who thinks that those who make war are sent from God.
What would you expect from a self-described "pit bull with lipstick?"
anyone who questions if this is an abuse of power needs to have their head examined.  Palin's history shows her to be a cutthroat when it comes to furthering her political career.

i've never seen more hypocrisy than last night with all the attacks by republican speakers while whining about legitimate concerns about her credentials and ethical standing.  just because you call yourself a christian and preach your god's word doesn't make you ethical.

let the truth of her actions ring from sea to shining sea, and i hope that all the negativity spun from the webs of Rove and his students falls against deaf ears.

http://horneddevil.proboards98.com/index.cgi#general
THANK YOU to Tom Brokaw, who stood alone in telling the truth today about what the Palin speech was, and what it wasn't.

I have to disagree with Mike Barnicle that said women look at her and say, I know her. Well, I don't have any friends like that: rude, sarcastic, mocking. Why can't she just say what she can bring to the ticket without all that crap. Won't play well around here!

Mika should be ashamed, look how you questioned Obama when he was first on the scene, let's go back and get the transcripts. The black guy is put through hell, but heaven forbid we question Palin's qualifications, after all, she's a woman with five kids!! Whoopee!  You are showing your disgusting colors today Mika!

And that Nicole woman working for McCain has taken a page right out of Rove/Palin's playbook: snarky and rude! Telling that guy from Time that Palin didn't need to answer questions from the Press? This isn't looking good for democracy people!
Sara Palin pretends to be this holier than thou church lady type with her "hockey mom" status and her mid western accent.  But don't let that fool you. Like she herself says, she's a pit bull and she scares me. She should scare all of us.
I think we Obama supporters should start forgetting about any fallout from troopergate right now.  Suppose from more or less direct experience she's discovered that Wooten is actually dangerous.  What if she'd done nothing?

This may not be the obvious call that it's being treated as.

I know these may not be the facts as the whole thing develops, but it is a plausible defense for what she appears to have done.
Palin is the Wicked Witch of the West.

And, she's the 21st Century Anita Bryant!

Palin, a shrilling, sarcastic, witch!  

Nothing more than a beauty queen and hockey mom...sorry, but not what I want as my VP!
You know, just quit dragging NY Times quotes out and try to present them as facts. We know the Times, just like MSNBC, is totally in the tank for Obama. The opinion, (and that's what it is, opinion), pieces they trot out as news are laughable. The so called TrooperGate story is nothing more then another smoke-screen put up by the DNC, and put out as news by the Times. It's used as bait for the mindless Obama fanatics to find yet another reason to keep their hate alive. And the drip you keep hearing is nothing more then liberal rags like the Times losing yet another drop of their credibility, and the tank appears to almost dryed up.
E-mails don't lie. So Sarah lipstick pit-bull, said thanks but no thanks to the bridge to nowhere after she first supported the bridge. Why’d she keep the money and had lobbyist for the pork. Those are 2 more lies.


As a community organizer Obama helped inner city young mothers reshape their lives. Sarah Palin didn’t.
Sarah Palin slashed funds from $5 million to $3.9 million for a transitional home for teenage mothers. That project helps to provide young mothers a place to live with their babies for up to eighteen months while they gain the necessary skills and resources to change their lives and help teen moms become productive, successful, independent adults who create and provide a stable environment for themselves and their families.

Watch what she says. I don’t think Obama’s millions of volunteer across the 50 states liked hearing stinging remarks about our community organizer.

Enough!
No way
No how
No McCain/Palin
You should google the firing of John Bitney by Sarah Palin.  She fired him for having an affair with Debbie Richter - the wife of one of Todd Palin's business associates.  There seems to be a pattern of pushing firings to even personal vendetas.  I believe that is called "abuse of power".

From trying to fire the town librarian to trying to get a trooper fired it's obvious Palin means it when she describes herself as a pit bull in lipstick.  Do we really want a VP who sees power and public office as a means of vengeance against opponents?
Would someone ask Biden about the "Violence Against Women Act".  Since h was the primary sponsor perhaps he could tell you why this trooper should have been dismissed.

Why don't you ask Barack about Bill Ayers?  It seems like a VP candidate is getting more examination than a Presidential candidate.
After watching Mika on Morning Joe practically swoon when she said she could so relate to Palin's family vs work situation.  I must ask her and anyone else who is so taken with this woman's ability to manage 5 kids and a job if anyone realizes that the "average" woman with 5 kids pays thousands of dollars per year in day care, can't just stay home or hire a nanny when the kids are sick.  Juggling a job and 5 kids isn't something the average woman can even consider doing because the cost of daycare far out weighs the cost of going to work.
So to compare Palins situation to any regular american woman (by regular I mean the one with normal jobs whose wages and not in triple digits) is just not even close to reality.  And I resent the implication that we are all the same as Palin.  She isn't anything close to being the kind of woman that impresses me.
She is dishonest, she is power hungry, and she puts herself before her family.  If she wanted to be a big political player then she should have made the choice before she had 5 young children.  Will she still have time to be a soccer mom if she is VP?  She shouldn't, not if she does a good job.  If you were to ask those little kids if they wanted mommy to be busy all the time or be their soccer mom, which do you think they would choose?  Don't tell me I am sexist, I am not.  Family values are "family values".  Mom is mom for a reason.
This crap about her being super mom is insulting.
Chuck, I admire your work, but please do not reference Palin as the GOP Obama. It is a true insult to the senator. Gov. Palin is not in his league by a long shot. mcf
If ignorance is bliss, the RNC must be absolutely ecstatic....and high......on something......but I guess they don't share.....'cause I sure don't get it.......unless it's a joke.......
Russia is close to Alaska, thus she has experience.
That just has to be one of the dumbest things I've ever heard.  
They're reaching now.
This woman fit's in with the repukes very well. Lie ,lie  and more lies.  The funny thing is how she claims sexism and leave her family alone. Yet she used them and that poor kid that who supposedly got her daughter pregnant. There is a saying in my neck of the woods" Mom's baby , Daddy's maybe". Levi wait for DNA lil buddy.
How about all the rest!  "Creationism", hunting from helicopters, vetoing funding for an unwed mother's home expansion (I assume this was before the "Studmuffin") and so much else.

You'd think Palin was a "Daily Show" joke.  Unfortunately she isn't.  Come on "Fourth Estate" do the vetting job McCain didn't.  It's our America to lose.
Take one look at the speech she gave last night and think to yourself, Palin would never do anything like that.  If anything, I think her speech and attitude last night just gives more cause that she's potential guilty on some underhanded accounts of troopergate.
Please do yourselves a favor and look at her record. It is thin and frightening. As mayor, she was so incompetent they had to hire a city administrator for the first time in the town's history, she left them with a 20 million dollar debt. She lies constantly--she took that money for the bridge to nowhere and kept it! They only show the people in her town that like her because everyone is afraid of her vindictive spirit, which she showed last night. This is not the woman for the second highest office in the land!
Gov. Sarah Palin gave a nice speech and she is pretty but there is something I can't quite put my finger on that bothers me deep in my soul. I fear she does not represent mainstream America and I am a retired social worker with Cerebral Palsy and a mother of two grown children and was the mother of two foster children. I am also the proud grandmother of an 18 month old granddaughter.

I worry her primary interest in Alaska not America. I think she is too focused on her fundamentalist beliefs and I don't think she is very tolerant of most Americans.

I have grave questions about her handling of this Troopergate allegation and especially her postion about the library in Wasilla.  It's the seemingly small things that can be so revealing.  I thank the media for researching her and I hope they will keep it up and I am trusting my intuition.

I have said it before and I will say it again...Please cherish your vote and remember 2000.

Smoke screen Palin. I'm sad to say we will fall for it again. I didn't hear what she knows. This is what I heard:

No talk of healthcare.
No talk of HOW to get jobs.
Iraq bad US good.
Obamas = terrorist.
The rich will get richer and the poor will vote for "someone like me".
Don't ask me any questions because repubs are good and dems are bad.

The difference between the repub and dem convention is the dems stayed away from personal attacks and attacked the issues. I'm soooo sick of personal attacks between politicians. I expect parts of the media to go overboard but not our leaders.

Lies, half truths, deception, malfeasance...four more years of the same?  Is America really this stupid.  Enough already!  They're more of the same old game, same old failed republican politicians. Wake up! If they say it over and over and over, it doesn't make it true or right.
TrooperGate is no WrightGate/AyersGate/RezkoGate/DopeGate, etc..
I did NOT tell the Commissioner to fire that man, Trooper Wooten!

I did NOT have sex with that woman, Ms. Lewinski!

...ironic.
[The New York Times writes that governing Alaska is in many ways much easier than in the other 49 states.]

Why does the New York Times continue this trend of embarrassing themselves on a daily basis?
The republicans will say or do anything to get elected.  How is naming an unexperienced person that was educated in journalism a heartbeat away from the presidency of a 72 yr old cancer survivor putting America First.  Republicans are so out of touch.
And do you really think woman are that stupid.  We will not fall for this obvious ploy to get our votes.  Our children and the future of this country is too important to vote based on gender.

McCain I used to admire you, put you are just playing to the right wing base.


Obama '08
All these things coming out about her - no wonder republican strategists are outraged by the pick:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CrG8w4bb3kg
WHAT HAPPENED TO MIKAH?(Morning Joe's)

Lately, Mikah has been reduced to just a sidekick of Scarborough completely overshadowed by his rants uttering only fluff and very little substance. I was amazed by Mikah's assessment of Palin's speech which focused on the style rather than the substance and 'truthiness' of what she was saying. I like Mikah and I want her to do well but she needs to be cerebral and tough and objective at examining the issues.
And here I was thinking that she sat and spoke to Putin on a regualar base for GW in her spare time.  Leave it to Cindy McPOW to mislead us just like she did when she said that we would not hear any negatives from that side if the campaign.  Who can you trust these days.  Its ashame when you can't even trust a recovering addict these days.
This woman is frightening!  It really says something about McCains judgement.  Also  are the republicans so used to the unethical way some many of them behave that this misuse of power doesn't bother them?

OBAMA/BIDEN 2008
"But Ireland was just for a refueling stop"

Now that's foreign policy experience Americans can't afford.  The VP is sent to talk with leaders of foreign countries.  

I can't wait for a mayor of less than 9000 people to be telling over a billion Chinese they aren't running their country very well.  Particularly when the mayor who became governor treated her police force just like the Chinese treat anyone who disagrees with them.
Women don't belong in the workforce. They belong at home taking care of their babies, and their husbands. I could never vote for Sarah Palin, she's just another uppity woman trying to make it in a mans world. Shame on her.
I am glad to see that the print press has not been cowered by the ludicrous complaints that the GOP is making that the press is "picking on Sarah Palin because she is a woman".  Talk about whining!  To listen to Mika and Joe on Morning Joe this morning you would think that they have seen the next coming..."Sarah Palin will be the first female president of the US".  They are kidding,right?
You all know that the Trooper that was fired tasered his 10 year old step son. Quite the mans man.
Just what we need.  Another Bush acolyte who thinks that trashing the Constitutional protections afforded us by the Founding Fathers is their own personal right.

Time for the national media to demand answers from this woman.
Phony Pony...don't mount this philly on the wall just yet John..
First Read: "Palin's campaign spokeswoman, Maria Comella, said that Palin was merely alerting officials to potential threats to her family and that there is no evidence that Palin ever ordered Wooten to be fired."

I don't think too many folks would read Palin's e-mails anyway other than expressing a strong desire for Wooten to be gone. If they want to drag this out over a parsing of whether she ever "ordered" the firing, well... I suspect that only will serve to make her look like less of a straight talker.
This is the stuff we need to hear more about. Please...we hardly know this women! After last nights hate filled speech void of any policy substance we need the media to fill us in.
"Ireland was just for a refueling stop" LOL, she's a joke.
Here we go, more lies, lies, lies, cover-ups and deceit from the Republicans!!! Not 4-8 more years!! Think about our children and the world we are leaving them!!! WAKE UP AMERICA!!!
So I guess the media is not going to print the whole story. At least one NBC broadcaster did lastnight. The ex-brother in-law trooper pulled a taser on his child and was abusive towards his wife. The court papers for the restraining order  show that. The troopers supervisor said it was not proper conduct for a trooper and warranted dissmisal. Lets start telling the truth and not going on witch hunts.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1342726

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google