ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Axelrod responds to Palin's speech

Posted: Thursday, September 04, 2008 12:44 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones
PITTSBURGH -- Obama chief strategist David Axelrod said that Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin's speech at the Republican Convention last night was full of distortions and showed she was a typical politician and not the outsider she portrays herself to be.

"We respect her. She's a skilled politician, as she proved last night. She's deft at going on the attack," Axelrod told reporters here before taking off for Harrisburg Thursday morning. "For someone who makes the point that she's not from Washington, she looked very much like she'd fit in very well there when you see how she brings these attacks, they all felt very familiar to Americans who are used to this kind of thing from Washington." 

Axelrod argued that "there wasn't one thing that she [Palin] said about Obama or what he's proposing that's true" and talked specifically about the Illinois senator's plans for tax cuts. He said Obama's tax cuts would benefit more people than McCain's proposals.

As has been the case on the stump over the last several weeks, the message during the brief gaggle with reporters on the plane -- in addition to senior strategist Robert Gibbs' appearance on television this morning  -- was that McCain and the Republican Party have no ideas to help middle-class and working-class families.

Axelrod hit back against Rudy Giuliani's and Palin's attacks on Obama's work as a community organizer, saying that while rebuilding communities may not mean much for a former New York mayor who gets paid millions of dollars to keep low cost drugs from entering the country while he works "as an agent for Pharma" that everyday people appreciate the kind of work Obama did.

"I think Sen. Obama's taking the whole thing in stride," Axelrod said. "I don't think he expected gingerly treatment for the reasons that I said. I think he understands they don't really have a record to run on and this is what politicians do when they don't have a record to run on."

He also responded to a McCain campaign spokesperson's suggestion on MSNBC's Morning Joe that it doesn't matter whether Palin appears before the press to take questions. "I think anybody's who's running for president or vice president of the United States ought to be willing to answer questions and certainly she should as well," he said. "I don't even think that's a disputable fact. I don't think the American people are gonna tolerate candidates who are unwilling to answer basic questions about their record, about issues, about where they'd lead the country."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

WOW! Rudy Giuliani! Nice job setting off the good ol' smear and fear machine! And to think you were my mayor. LISTEN! To all you sheeple out there that decide how you are going to vote based on fear of terrorism. A few facts.

You're twice as likely to die crushed under a vending machine as you are to die in a terrorist attack
You are 225,409 times more likely to die in an auto accident
More people accidentally shoot themselves to death than die in terror attacks
You are more likely to be legally executed than die in a terrorist attack
You are more likely to be struck by lightning three times than die in a terrorist attack
You are much more likely to die by bear or shark attack than die in a terrorist attack
These are scientific facts.
C'mon people wake up. Don't give into it this time. I am from NY. My best friend died in those towers that day. My sister lived on 5th and saw the plane fly over while getting coffee. Heard the explosion. Walked down to see if somehow she could help. She got there just after the second plane hit. All she could see was smoke and all she could hear was the constant thud of bodies hitting the ground. I personally know the pain of terrorism. I know what it feels like to see those you love killed and permanently affected by it and let me tell you this.
I AM NOT AFRAID!
I will not let the threat of terrorism affect my daily life and I have no reason too. I am a proud American and I carry on. As a proud American I refuse to accept that attacking soveriegn nations reduces terrorism. I believe quite the opposite. It has promoted terrorism. As a proud american and proud native New Yorker I believe that the Republicans let us all down by letting Bin Laden sit and rebuild on the border of Pakistan while we kill Iraqi civilians and American soldiers in the name of the war on terrorism. As a proud American I am ashamed that we took a noble cause and perverted it into a war for American economic interests.
Please America. Don't let them scare you. That is the very tactic of the enemy we have not yet defeated. We Americans are better than that. We won't be brainwashed by fear. We will be the shining light of democracy to the world by example, not by a gun.
Hey, I quit voting for nutjobs years ago, but I thought it was a pretty entertaining speech anyway, but man, didn't anybody fact check her speech before she gave it? Maybe they don't care, but in about 10 seconds any hack like me can find out that speech was fiction.


Thank you.  Thank you!

Ahh... a few meat scraps for those in the cheap seats... just for fun...

I love the smell of truth in the morning...


Let's face it Hillary couldn't compete with the big boys and Palin can't either. Let's face it, Obama will wipe the ground with this girl too. To all the women out there. Let me give this shout out. Nothing you do can stop Obama. Please if this is the best woman this country has to offer it will be another 200 years before you even get on another ticket for President. Too many of your kinf love our man Obama. So put your claws back in and relax. It is easy to see who's the smartest of the bunch and it's Obama. By all means try, but we'll see who is the best come November. What a joke!
Now the McCain/Bush/Rove group has to keep Palin away from the press (and town meetings) until they can teach her what she thinks about the real issues - like the economy, healthcare, foreign affairs, etc.

Absolutely true, Here is one american who wont tolerate the shroud of secrecy surrounding this scary lady. And i dont care about her gaggle of kids or their various problems. I want to know how she could use the fact that she has a special needs child as a campaign promise, when she slashed her Alaskan budget for those very children. Does she consider that the same as getting rid of the jet plane and cook???  Obama and Biden look better and better to me.......
It is amazing that Millionaire Rudy, Cindy in her $300,000 outfit, and an East Coast Ivy League educated former governor of Mass. can claim that Obama is an elitist with a straight face.
At the end of the day it comes down to this (especially for us women) if you are comfortable with the last eight years and you feel comfortable giving up your rights as a woman. Then Vote for Mcsame.  .....THINK ABOUT IT...
It's politics folks.  Both sides attack and distort.  Don't take it personal.  McCain picked Palin and it was a smart pick.  She's no less qualified than Obama.  Obama didn't pick Hillary and that was a major mistake.  We have a race and a good one.  Enjoy it!  
Are Evangelicals that excited about someone being so mean and angry.  I thought that they believe in god.  God is not angry.
Once again Obama has demonstrated that he is classy, and will not lower himself to counter the half-truths and lies. He is going to stick to issues, as McCain camp has clearly stated that "This election is NOT about issues".
I thought the speech was brilliant! She answered that she could handle the pressure, introduce herself effectively, and point out all the inexperience of Obama - who has no track record of proven results to speak of. He has not reached out across the isle and achieved reform and is has nothing on John McCain in terms of record & history of change. She didn't need to go crazy on policy last night - she was perfect - showing her stuff & background - and illustrating the huge difference between John McCain & Obama. A star was born last night as the liberals are scrambling for something to counter this maverick, genius pick. It's actually quite poetic.
Personally I was offended by her "Hockey Mom-Pit Bull" joke.

As a working women, this bar room humor, is exactly what we have to fight against and belittles us.

Obviously not in touch with main stream.  

Offensive comment.
Funny. Tuesday, the Obama campaign and its media lapdogs were selling the "inexperienced rube" meme. Now it's the "skillful politician" meme. Have you no shame, MSDNC ?

Oh, Lynette? Palin is increasing the budget for special needs from 22k/per child to 75k per child. Quit lying.
"Lynette, NYC: I want to know how she could use the fact that she has a special needs child as a campaign promise, when she slashed her Alaskan budget for those very children". THANK YOU!!!!!!

I have two special needs children, on that I adopted who has behavioral issues related to a seizure disorder, and the other with CF. I'll be damn that having her in office is going to change the lack of funding for services and that she is availalbe to talk with me. Thanks for the tip about her own state budget for those with special needs. As long as the administration continues not to fund education and mental health nothing will change. I'm not going to place my bet on the 10% chance of change.

I may be eligible to run for VP....2 special needs kids, tons of work experience in child abuse and mental health, and I'm just about completed a doctorate. Hell....I even raised my 3 kids alone as a widow.
John, Miami, FL (Sent Thursday, September 04, 2008 2:29 PM)
Are you dreaming, if you call her a star you must don't aim really high for excellence?

She said nothing about what she would do for this country, although, her first time on the scene has convinced me she is no Washington Outsider; she is Bush in a skirt.  She's not change, she is just wearing a skirt!  
John, Miami, FL :

What is so amazing is how you actually believe all that.  Never did much independant research have you.  It shows.
 As a small town mayor, Sarah Palin HAD MORE RESPONSIBILTY THAN DID OBAMA AS A COMMUNITY ORGANIZER.  That is not a put-down; it is a FACT.

What responsibility for personnel and budget does a Community Organizer have?  

Community Organizers do work hard, in many cases, and often perform needed social services ---- BUT THAT DOES NOT EQUATE TO THE RESPONSIBILITY OF BEING A MAYOR OR A GOVERNOR.

Obama will have a hard time matching Governor Palin's experience and qualifications --- and he's running for President and she for VP !!!!
SaraCuda alias pink lip Barracuda   what a joke that was last night!!!! sounded like the churchlady now tonight we get to hear the opposite    monotone McSame and all his war stories. Get on with the important issues of this election already!!!!! Liked the way they used the children for props and they trash the media  yeah right!!!!!
Hey Mark in Seattle...I may be twice as likely to die from a vending machine as I am in a terrorist attack, but tell me about the last vending machine death that had a direct impact on the nation's economy, business, travel, etc as a terrorist attack would.  You say you won't let the threat of an attack affect your daily life, but it already has.  Have you been to an airport in the last seven years?
I saw the speech and to me Palin is a Joke!

I can't believe a guy like McCane would be so stupid as to pick her for Vice President.

Not one thing she said about Obama is true concerning taxes, or anything else.  That's very republican of her.

Yep, She proved hockey mom can spit curses and cuss with the best of men.

Too bad she can't read:  

Sarah Palin-go to Obama.com and learn something about it is you are giving speeches on.


What a joke.
Palin was terrific and if B. Hussein Obama could have made any desisions in his voting either yes or no he might be a viable candidate for office. Voting present shows just one thing that a person cannot make a clear judgement on an issue. When president, sitting in that chair, the buck stops there!
Let's face it Hillary couldn't compete with the big boys and Palin can't either. Let's face it, Obama will wipe the ground with this girl too. To all the women out there. Let me give this shout out. Nothing you do can stop Obama. Please if this is the best woman this country has to offer it will be another 200 years before you even get on another ticket for President. Too many of your kinf love our man Obama. So put your claws back in and relax. It is easy to see who's the smartest of the bunch and it's Obama. By all means try, but we'll see who is the best come November. What a joke!  

Are you insane or are you just a Rethug pot stirrer?
I am a nurse and The best bosses I have ever had were women. I have worked in the trauma bay and the ICU and I have never met a group of public servants more dedicated, self sacrificing, and perseverent. A woman can do any thing a man can do and many can do it better. Your statements are nonsensical. The problem with Palin is she just doesn't get it. It is a way of thinking that the Repubs get wrong. And BO is smart, politically savvy, and here when we need him the most. That is why Obama will win. Not from some prehistoric desire to keep women in their place. What stupid post.
I am surprised and heartened by these responses.Thank you
Re: Palin's acceptance speech
Looks to me like the strategists bought into their own negative spin by putting style at the podium instead of substance.
"Oh, Lynette? Palin is increasing the budget for special needs from 22k/per child to 75k per child. Quit lying."

Bruce, NV (Sent Thursday, September 04, 2008 2:34 PM)

Please provide a link to your source for this rather than just stating it as fact. Thanks.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1345548

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google