ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Obama: Organizers fight back

Posted: Friday, September 05, 2008 9:28 AM by Mark Murray

"Angry community organizers defended their work, and that of former colleague Barack Obama, as they fought back yesterday against a series of gibes by speakers at the Republican convention. Organizers described themselves as an antidote to the influence of big-money lobbyists. They cited helping the powerless join forces to demand better schools and safer streets, often by working through churches.

"If people in office were doing their jobs, perhaps we wouldn't need community organizers," said John Baumann, executive director of PICO National Network. Joshua Hoyt, executive director of the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights, said, "I don't like seeing the really hard work that goes on in really poor communities being demeaned by cheap politicians. "Community organizing is as American as democracy."

“In a much-anticipated interview with conservative nemesis Bill O'Reilly, Senator Barack Obama said yesterday the troop surge in Iraq had 'succeeded in ways that nobody anticipated' and 'beyond our wildest dreams.' But despite expressing his most positive assessment of a military buildup he opposed, the Democratic presidential candidate made no concession on what he said is the more critical issue of Iraq's political stability. 'The Iraqis still haven't taken responsibility,' Obama said during the seven-minute segment on Fox News Channel's 'The O'Reilly Factor,' an interview the talk-show host had sought for months. 'And we still don't have that kind of political reconciliation.'"

The New York Times’ Stanley reviews the interview. “The topic was national security, and their tone was civil, but thankfully not too civil: Mr. O’Reilly, as is his wont, spoke brusquely, interrupted, argued and didn’t let his guest off the hook. He told Mr. Obama he had ‘bloviated’ in parts of his convention speech, but congratulated him on his early opposition to the war, saying he had been ‘perspicacious.’ … Mr. Obama gave no hint of rancor and remained pleasant, respectful and good-humored, but he did adjust his pace and wording to suit his speed-talking host.” 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

"Someone needs to remind Sarah Palin that Jesus Christ was a community organizer and Pontius Pilate was a governor."
I honestly believe John McCain does not have as rational bone in his body..except when this twinkle of what appears to be like Bob Dole coming out of his persona...
I like Bob Dole and he would have been an outstanding President.
But John McCain possess to little of Bob Dole to make a real difference in my vote...
He's to open ended and to phony ...
I sense there some hidden agenda that looms in he back that he has a difficult time dealing with...
We don't need a President that has a hard time finding his core but sure knows how your going to get yours...

We need Obama/Biden even more now...
Angry community organizers defended their work, and that of former colleague Barack Obama, as they fought back yesterday against a series of gibes by speakers at the Republican convention.
*******************************************************

Damn right!  How can that be a bad thing?

http://thepajamapundit.com/
Question: how many Sarah's does it take to make one Hillary?

Want the answer?

About 18 million and one....
Oh please!
Look up 'Community Organizers' on monster or careebuilder. None. No jobs. Zipo. No where in the country.

Go to any college or university and look up the disipline 'Community Organizer' - None. Zipo.

Lets call it what it is Obama. You were just scoring political points and lining up lobbyists for a run at a state senate seat. You couldn't have cared less about the community you were "working" in.
Every person who is considering voting in November MUST watch this video. It shows three things:

1. Karl Rove criticized the fact that Virginia Governor Tim Kaine was a possible VP pick for Obama. He said that because he used to be the Mayor of Richmond which has a small population (about 200,000) in comparison to others in the US, and also that he'd only been governor for 3 years (population 7 million), he claimed that this did not constitute sufficient executive experience and would just be a "political pick" rather than concern of the person's capability to be present of the U.S.  It then shows him complimenting Sarah Palin's executive experience as Mayor of Wasila (population 9,000) and then as Governor of Alaska (population about 700,000) for 2 years.

2. It shows Fox News host Bill O'Reilly arguing that the pregnancy of Bristol Palin is a personal family issue and they should not be bothered.  Then it shows another video of him blaming Jaime Lynn Spears' parents for her teenage pregnancy.  

3. It shows a video of Dick Morris criticizing people for the supposed sexism against Sarah Palin.  It then shows a video of him saying that when Hillary Clinton comes under fire she hides behind the sexism defense and can't handle the big boys.  It also shows a video of Sarah Palin back in March saying that women shouldn't whine when there's excess criticism or a sharper microscope put on them but rather work harder and prove themselves. It also shows McCain Senior Policy Advisor Nancy Pfotenhauer criticizing Hillary Clinton for playing the gender and victimization card and complaining of sexism, then saying that Sarah Palin is a victim of sexism.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zM6AapgG_D0
Looks like it is going to be a great interview.  I am not an O'Really fan but I'm looking forward to the rest of it.  
So now Obama says the Surge worked. This was one of John McCains 90% voting with Bush votes Barack. So was that the right thing to do?
McCain:  "If you find faults with our country, make it a better one. If you’re disappointed with the mistakes of government, join its ranks and work to correct them. Enlist in our Armed Forces. Become a teacher. Enter the ministry. Run for public office. Feed a hungry child. Teach an illiterate adult to read. Comfort the afflicted. Defend the rights of the oppressed."

And someday, you too can be ridiculed by a Vice Presidential candidate for the good work you've done!
http://voices.washingtonpost.com/channel-08/2008/08/hillary_clinton_denounces_new.html

How many Sarah's does it take to make one Hillay?

18 million and one...
Chuck Todd and Mark Murray and MSNBC:

Why are your blogs sooooo slanted in Obama's favor?? You always present Obama favorably and McCain unfavorably.

Please note that Obama is NOT the Messiah. Obama seeks public power. Obama must be srutinized.

Report the growing concerns that the Obama Camp is sexist. Your title could be "Obama Camp Sexist?"

Community organizers and those who work with individuals in the public at large are key to our nation's progress McCain and Palin attacking this aspect of Obama's background are making a big mistake for the simple fact there are more people who need community organization than need what McCain and Plain offer, which is what exactly?
i thought that the cracks on community organizers would create an uproar... Rudy wouldn't have made those comments if he were running for office... Palin just lacks judgement, unless her god whispers what to do in her ear...

and this right here is why Obama is qualified to be President:  He can adjust his message to the audience, and change his own style to the situation he is presented with.

quite a difference from "my way or the highway" McCain.

i can say with utmost confidence, that Sen. McCain would not have allowed an interview with me, because i wouldn't stick to a script or read questions that i'm given.  no thought process, just reaction McCain.  sell your lies to someone else McCain/Palin/Rove clones, i'm not buying your product.

http://horneddevil.proboards98.com/index.cgi#general
Wasn't it George Bush's father who encouraged Americans to be "1000 points of light" in their communities through volunteerism?  He had it right.  The most effective way to implement change is from the grassroots up - not by being beaten down with change not necessarily of our own making from Washington.  

Is this really the message that Sarah Palin and Rudy Guiliani want to send to the American people?  That community work, volunteering, and bringing people together as a force for making one small change at a time is something to be sneered at?  What would Mayor Guiliani have done in New York after 9/11 without the help of community organizers and volunteers?

I thought this was the essence of Republicanism - taking charge of your future and your community's future, giving of yourself to a cause greater than yourself.

This is what Barack Obama did as a community organizer.  He was and is a public SERVANT.  It is a high calling no matter what your politics - why would anyone denigrate it?
FR - Joshua Hoyt, executive director of the Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights.


Ohhh, so Community Organizers are nothing but activists and lobbyists. Look up Mr. Hoyt. He's an activist for open boarders. Nice little coverup story, calling yourself a Community Organizer instead of a Community Activist. It sounds more, official.
Mr. Community Organizer had TWICE as many murders in his community this summer than they did in the entire war-zone country of Iraq!!!

Sure, he can organize a community to vote for him, but he never gets anything accomplished!

Twice as many murders?  Is this change you can believe in?
Let's get back to the blatant disrespect that the RNC showed towards community organizers.  As a youth, I was the beneficiary of the work of community organizers.  Seeing and hearing the mocking tone at the RNC went a long way to making me feel like my town, my community was unimportant.  Community organizers provided me with educational programs during my summer months away from school, exposed me to the arts, to my town and greater AA history, encouraged me to pursue my education, provided aid for my family when both my parents were laid off, I could go on and on.  Their work helped to reinforce all the things my parents taught me home.  My parents gave me the foundation and my community gave me the opportunity to put those lessons in practice.  

Barack, I saw the first excerpts of your interview on the O'Reilly factor.  Glad to see you stepping into the lion's den again.  Was O'Reilly combatitive?  Of course, but its good to see that you are willing to take some heat and be challenged.
Good going Barack Obama.

Level headiness, consistency, intelligence, integrity, and honesty will always win the day.
I remain horrified at Ms. Palin's snippy, nasty, irrelevant, and inappropriate swipe at community organizers.  But it had one silver lining.

If you have been, are now, or have had someone close to you positively impacted by, a community organizer, then stand up and be counted.  This is your time to shine.  There are a lot of us out there (apparently, non-GOP types) who truly support what you do.
I couldn't believe the MSM didn't pick up on how that was going to play in middle America.  Out here our community organizers are the people that get things done.  Maybe you are the "elite"  media.
I was FURIOUS with Chris Matthews yesterday for bashing community organizers on CSPAN, I don't think Mr. Matthews understands that Community Organizers work for charities, churches, and many other areas, helping the less fortunate. What the hell is wrong with that? Obviously the Republicans don't respect that but I expected more from an educated Catholic boy from PA. His disrespect showed his true colors as a weasel! Between that and saying Sarah Palin would be the first woman president (like the American people would elect someone so divisive and conservative as she is, just because she's attractive?) he has lost one fan as of today!
While Obama was orgainzing a community, John McCain was fighting for his country. And John has the scars to prove it.
What's with this "Executive Service" crap, do Mr. McCain or any of their "Executive Service"? I'm had served my country for more than 20 years. I guess I can say that there are some lies in his POW story.  1) Why was Mr. McCain the fattest POW that was seen at that location? 2) Was his broken bones from the crash or from his captors...I do believe it was from the crash. 3) When did the captors give prisoners the choice of who goes home first? Mr. Obama has shown much respect for his service however, some of us who have served can ask these questions.....
Obama has the coonfidence and the guts to give O'Reilly a shot at him.

What does Sarah Palin have?
 Mayors do something too.  Obama thought it was perfectly appropriate to look down on his nose at her mayoral experience...yet there's outrage at her comments about community organizers.  Of course, the media won't comment that perhaps Obama opened the door to this by ridiculing her experience.    
Typical that the repugnant ones would attack such selfless people as community organizers, people who truly put Country First.  They pick up the pieces of the shattered lives of people who have paid the price of the policies of the repugnant ones.  All the repugnant ones have to offer is an endless list of self serving lobbyist elitists who help dictators and oil princes.

Barack Obama has proven that he will walk into the Idiot's Den and speak truth to Stupidity by going on Whacko Billo's show.  Too bad the clueless culture creep has his ears permanently shut to truth and honesty.  Can't wait for Keith Olbermann and Countdown tonight.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
ALL SARAH PALIN IS A CLONE OF PHYLLIS SCHLAFLY
So, Obama is willing to confront his media opponents but McCain would rather sulk in the corner when it comes to his.

If you can't handle Keith Olbermann how do you expect to handle Vladimir Putin?
here in chicago, the community organizers really  started poping up during the reagan years!! in late 1980, the reason is that the steel mills closed after reagan gave all those tax cuts to the big business,and the jobs were goan with in a matter of months, including there pensions!!! rosland, morgan park, and pullman neighborhoods were hurting big time!!! so mrs palin, the next time you want to talk carp about community organizers shut the hell up because it was one of your own who caused that movement to really take off!!!
they helped older workers get new training, they helped neighborhoods stay afloat with donations for food banks, healthcare for teens, consulated teens about abstance and well as birth control, and believe this sarha, they even helped teens with the decision to either give the child up for adoption was well as keeping the child or as a LAST resort, have an abortion. so as your up in alaska, there are real problems here in the lower 48 that you have no idea whats going on.

sarah who are you crapping!!!!
if mccain, as is his wont, takes credit for the "more troops on the ground" surge four years and thousands of lives into the war and billions of dollars spent, then why didn't he support gen. shinseki's recommendation at the beginning of the war for more troops on the ground. instead, he supported sec. rumsfeld's limited engagement and gen. shinseki was fired.
The question to ask is what did Obama accomplish as a community orginizer.. anyone anyone.......
Yeah thats right Nothing.
And maybe just maybe he shouldnt have attacked her on the fact that she was a small town mayor. Man talk about thin skin.
Orally is just a faux news barking dog with no training or teeth.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1353889

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google