ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



First thoughts: A missed opportunity?

Posted: Friday, September 05, 2008 9:35 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, and Domenico Montanaro
ST. PAUL, MN -- Last night, John McCain wrapped up the final night of a two-week convention and VP rollout blitz as we now head into the 60-day sprint until Election Day. But McCain's speech seemed to be a missed opportunity. It appears the campaign decided it simply needed to get through it -- there wasn't anything new, except a longer description of his POW days. Perhaps Sarah Palin is new enough, and last night's speech was about reassurance. McCain used the word fight (or a variation of it) some 25 times, change 10 times, and experience just three. So by the numbers, McCain was trying to send the message that he was a fighting-warrior-for-change candidate that has enough experience to make it happen. That was the goal, but we'll know in a few days if that message was received. The number to look for in the polls isn't the head-to-head; it'll be whether the percentage of voters who believe McCain will follow Bush's policies closely has actually dropped.

VIDEO: NBC News Political Director Chuck Todd weighs in on John McCain's nomination acceptance speech and looks at the road ahead for the campaign.

*** It was Palin's convention: If the McCain camp was counting on one speech to move the ball forward, it didn't succeed. But thanks to the Palin pick, it has done more to re-invent McCain as a reforming change than the candidate has done on his own in the last three months. And the Alaska governor also has done more to reinvigorate McCain's candidacy than any speech he could have given. In fact, this turned out to be Sarah Palin's convention -- that was made clear when Heart’s “Barracuda” was the song that played as she joined McCain after his speech ended. But is it ever a good thing to be upstaged by your VP pick? McCain was never going to win a speech contest with Obama. But his "celebrity" attack over the past couple of months was a good way of blunting Obama's speech in Denver and lowering expectations for his own. Yet when McCain unveiled his own celebrity -- Palin, who wowed the GOP crowd on Wednesday night -- it made his speech pale in comparison....

*** Waiting for the interview: There are now about 60 days until Election Day and just three weeks until the debates. And who knows whether we'll get the first Sarah Palin serious issue interview before then. This morning on JOE, McCain manager Rick Davis wouldn't commit to putting her out to media interviews unless they saw it as helping their campaign. This Sunday is interesting in that three of the four principles are doing sunday shows, the lone holdout: Palin.

*** Obama vs. O'Reilly: If you were on the convention floor last night, you probably missed Obama’s interview with Bill O’Reilly. And if so, you missed quite a show. It was a heated -- yet respectful -- interview over the surge in Iraq, Iran, and Pakistan. One thing is for sure: Obama seems more intent on confronting his media opponents...

*** It's the economy, stupid: By the way, the latest jobs report is out, and it shows that the unemployment rate jumped to 6.1% in August and employers cut 84,000 jobs. According to the AP, it was the eighth month in a row of job losses. Thnk McCain wishes he put a little more meat on the bones in the economic portion of his speech last night?

*** Downballot watch: The AP also is reporting that the National Republican Senatorial Committee has canceled its $2.3 million TV buy in New Mexico, "an indication that it's leaving the GOP candidate there to fend for himself as the party braces for losses." Not only does that seem to mean that the GOP is giving up on a second Senate contest (the first was Virginia), but how will that impact the presidential race in that battleground state? 
 
*** On the trail: McCain and Palin begin the day after their convention campaigning in Cedarburg, WI and then hold a rally in Sterling Heights, MI. Meanwhile, Obama and Biden are both in Pennsylvania: Obama stumps in Duryea and Biden is in Philadelphia and Langhorne.
 
Countdown to the first presidential debate: 21 days
Countdown to the vice presidential debate: 27 days
Countdown to the second presidential debate 32 days
Countdown to the third presidential debate: 40 days
Countdown to Election Day 2008: 61 days
Countdown to Inauguration Day 2009: 138 days
 
Click here to sign up for First Read emails.
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

This is stupid; 3 of 4 principles on the Sunday talk shows, but no Palin.  No Palin for interviews.  Can Mcbush and his operatives say any louder "No Experience, empty Suit"?!? And who's going to corner Mcbush on the rise in unempployment? How can he put meat on the bones when the meat is "Do what Bush did, because I can't think of anything else, he's screwed things up so badly"? I watched the O'Reilley-Obama showdown.  I was proud of Obama for his courage in confronting his biggeest media critics.  I wish Mcbush and Palin had that much guts...
How many Sarah's does it take to make one Hillary?

18 million and one...

With or without lipstick?

It doesn't matter if you look like a bull dog....maybe Sarah meant  bitch dog..
McCain/Palin are offering nothing. We just saw 84,000 new job losses giving us a 6.1% unemployment rate.

They have no new ideas, their policies are just rehashing old failed Bush policies, and they're hiding Sarah Palin from interviews.

You can't talk economics when you don't have a plan for the economy.

The only ones talking about a plan to improve the economy is Obama/Biden.

http://www.rodneyhopper.com
God bless America - McSame stunk up the joint - you gotta love it..!!  Hey Repukelicans.., you want some jam with that toast..?  LOL..!!

Thank the lord - we WILL get a Democratic president and we can CHANGE the country for the better..!!

Obama/Biden '08
Noun-Verb-POW: The Director's Cut

http://www.rodneyhopper.com
It seems to me that it you want to get things done in Washington that it makes a lot more sense to WORK WITH people rather than FIGHT them all the time.  That's what Obama means when he talks about CHANGE in Washington, and in this way, he will be far more effective in "fighting" for US (vs. fighting for fighting's sake) than the tired old Mepublican ticket.  That's why this independent Texan is voting for Obama/Biden!!
Nancy Wilson from Heart send Cease and Desist order to McCain campaign: "Sarah Palin's views and values in NO WAY represent us as American women. We ask that our song 'Barracuda' no longer be used to promote her image. The song 'Barracuda' was written in the late 70s as a scathing rant against the soulless, corporate nature of the music business, particularly for women. (The 'barracuda' represented the business.) While Heart did not and would not authorize the use of their song at the RNC, there's irony in Republican strategists' choice to make use of it there. I think it's completely unfair to be so misrepresented,I feel completely f---ed over."
I honestly believe John McCain does not have as rational bone in his body..except when this twinkle of what appears to like Bob Dole coming out of his persona...
I like Bob Dole and he would have been an outstanding President.
But John McCain possess to little of Bob Dole to make a real difference in my vote...
He's to open ended and to phony ...I sense there some hidden agenda that looms in he back that he has a difficult time dealing with...
We don't need a President that has a hard time finding his core but sure knows how your going to get yours...

We need Obama/Biden even more now...

Chuck Todd: What you reported today seems to be a fair assessment and summary of the GOP convention. Personally, McCain put me to sleep last night so I didn't hear it all or the spin.  The written media described the event accurately. Grandpa giving a speech.

Palin is the story for a lot of reasons.  She has to be sequestered because she knows nothing about foreign and domestic policy. It's strange that Liebermann is the tutor.  He doesn't get it either. You bet they will keep her away from the media as long as they can.  Rove handlers realize how little she knows. It will be the responsibility of the media to ask reasonable questions. Not David Gregory got'ya questions, but fair, probing questions. Also not stupid questions like how to you fix your hair questions.
The third Palin point is Troopergate.  Between now and the time the final report is released, there will be eyebrow raising questions about her leadership style in Alaska.  In a lot of ways Alaska is still a frontier state and rough and tumble may be the norm there, but not for the rest of the country.  It is good (for Obama) that the final report will be coming out before the election.  My guess is that there were no laws broken, but questionable activity on her part that will diminish the shine she currently enjoys.  The unspoken thought will be, "If something happens to McCain, do we really want her to be President?" That answer will be a resounding NO for moderate, swing voters. The evangelical/neocons will love her, but reasonable, sensible Americans can and will be SCARED OF HER.  
 
We are experiencing this Bearish market and I see a Mc Cain behind a Bush.
A number of years ago we experienced the failure of the Savings and Loan and again, there was Mc Cain behind another Bush.
When are we going to learn?
The RNC Freak Show is scared to have "Sinner" Sarah talk on the talk show circuit because she's so clueless and no telling what truth might slip out that will embarass them.  Ofcourse "Skirt Chaser" McCain thinks she's a little child, to be seen but not heard unless she reads a script prepared by her male handlers.

How about her clueless answer of a month ago when she said that someone would have to tell her what a VP does daily?  Yes she's just a submissive Stepford Wife who can't think for herself and must be told what to do by her male superiors.  Where was her intellectual curiosity and initiative to find out herself?  Beat out of her by her false god and her male chauvinist pig political party.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
The quasi-journalism continues on this now lame network.  It's a wonder Brian Williams, Tom Brokaw, and Andrea Mitchell would allow their names to be attached to such garbage and lopsided coverage.  I think your coverage has actually made me less inclined to vote for the party to which I belong.  You all need to get back into the business of reporting news with reliable sources as opposed to blog-esque reporting, relying on blogs written by quasi-journalists (if journalists at all) as sources, and using text-message or internet polling to suggest "news" knowing full well that those results are derived from younger generations and are inherently unreliable.  (Often such internet and text-message polls come with Chris Matthews' disclosure that they're not scientific.  If not, what purpose do they show other than the composition of your viewers, which already is common knowledge?)  Finally, I'm not sure who thought it would be a good idea to start putting surrogates and former party bigwigs on panels of "journalists" to discuss conventions, speeches, and other political events.  They're not journalists.  They're one-sided party hacks that offer nothing to the conversation.  Certainly no news.  These criticisms are not unique to MSNBC, although these days you're certainly at the top of the pile of manure.  Tim Russert would be ashamed.  Before he died, I did not know that he was the Washington, D.C. bureau chief for NBC news.  It's obvious now what a grounding force he was at MSNBC (even when cutting Hillary Clinton out of the race).  Your coverage, including these ridiculous blogs, is insulting.
How DARE they use 9/11 footage to promote their campaign! Sickening politicizing of a major national tragedy that happened on THEIR watch!
This country has eight weeks to get to know who Sarah Palin is, and thus far, the McCain camp is "sequestering" her from the press, and more importantly from the American people.

I don't care about the salacious details of her personal life, but I would like some questions answered about her policies and stand on important issues:  

Questions that MUST be answered:
Abuse of power when mayor and governor?
Trying to ban books and fire a librarian who would not?
Raising taxes in her small town of Wasilla?
Taking over 27 million dollars in Federal earmarks for a town of less than 10,000.
Religious extremist whose religion does NOT believe in separation of church and state?


Sure, she can read a prepared speech (which was written before she was selected, personal stuff added when she was picked)  BUT

WHO IS SARAH PALIN?
John McCain ..crashed and burned again tonight..along with every republican ever born..he took on the misery of the past and claimed it to be his right of passage to the White House...sick...
His dementia is not our guilt trip...
Now that the Republican POW-9/11-Hockey Mom gabfest is over, let’s do a reality check. Ask yourself: Are you better off today than you were 8 years ago? Is our country? The Republican Party has trashed the economy, shoved aside the Constitution, and made a joke of our country for long enough. We cannot continue the same failed policies with the same failed politicians and expect different results.

Republicans can wrap their candidates in the American flag, Mom and Apple Pie all they want.  I hope my fellow citizens are smarter than that. Identity politics is a losing proposition for all Americans. We must elect leaders with the best plans to solve our significant challenges.

Every American should be outraged by the Republicans expressing disrespect for community organizers during their convention. Every American who has stepped from a church pew to help the homeless, stood behind a fundraising table at a school, or raced to register voters, should tell the Republican Party that individuals standing up to organize their communities isn’t a weakness. It’s one of America’s most valued strengths and contributions. Senator Barack Obama built a life and campaign on that ideal. Obviously, Republicans just don’t get it.

WAY to Retro. there Johnny Boy...
Wow, who let Mark do the First Thoughts for the day after the Republican Convention?

I don't at all think the speech last night was a missed opportunity. McCain went with a well defined 'this is what I want to do...these are our issues, this is my strategy and this is why it is superior to the oponent's' approach and summed it up with a call to action for all of us.

This speech defined what it means to be a Republican. Service to each other...service in our community as well as our goverment, which is how this country was set up. As a Rebublican I was proud to hear him call us all, as Americans, to action. We are, after all, a government 'by the people, for the people' and in order for it to work properly we must all take personal responsibility. I think he did an excellent job of defining his character, his leadership and executive strengths and his desire to lead us all (which in itself implies that we, as citizens, have a role in this whole thing)in a way that drew contrasts with his oponents without grossly attacking them. He also effectively drew a line between the administration of the past 8 years and his own plan of action. Good Job!

...Then again, I thought Sarah Palin did the same thing!!!

Go McCain/Palin
By going on O'Reilly, Obama makes the subtle point that he is willing to do hard interviews, while Palin in MIA.  A good way to make the "Ready to Lead" point without saying anything.
I learned from the Huffington Post that Gov. Palin LIED about selling the State Airplane on EBAY.  WHY??  Will someone ask her the reason for lying.  Oh, oh, the McCain people are keeping her from the media so I guess we will never know.
So it was "Palin's Convention" huh? If that's the case, considering we still can't get any straight talk about policy and reform on real issues from the "executive experienced mother of 5" who can't be legitmatelly questioned on anything of relevance for cries of sexism on how to turn this country around, I wouldn't call that a glowing recommendation for a McCain presidency.

The RNC may have flaunted their shiny new "barracuda" as a force to be reckoned with, but she did nothing to instill confidence in her ability to run this country should for whatever reason McCain become unable to finish the job himself. I do know Palin can be smug, condescending, holier-than-thou, and quick on the sarcasm button but can she sit in a room with foreign dignitaries, allies and foes alike, and prevent a war or diffuse the potential for a nuclear or terrorist attack? Can she increase jobs that won't be outsourced, put more money in the taxpayers' pockets to sustain a respectable quality of life, save families' homes, allow their children to go to college, have healthcare for all, or provide a solution to global meltdown?

Seems to me the "empty suit" rhetoric of the RNC against Obama applies as an "empty dress" for their girl Palin and the fact that McCain allowed her to upstage him for the privilege of gaining "maverick points" within his party with no viable substance other than fire, brimstone, and contempt, doesn't speak highly of his nomination and acceptance as the supposed leader of his party let alone that of this country.
My biggest impression of the McCain speech, other than the largely lifeless delivery, was how much it sounded like GW Bush speeches of the past.  GW was from outside Washington and therefore change would come naturally.  GW would save Social Security by privatizing and eliminating it.  GW would retrain workers displaced by a changing economy, but like McCain didn't explain how.  GW would allow tax money to be diverted from public to private schools, destroying them in the process.  GW promised the highest standards ever in transparency and ethics--then delivered the most corrupt administration since at least the Teapot Dome Scandal of Warren Harding. If by change you mean more of the same then John McCain made a strong case.
She doesn't do interviews, she's repeating the same exact speech in Wisconsin she just gave at the RepubliCon...why isn't the media calling the McCain camp on this.

She doesn't just lack experience, she lacks more than a single script, for crissakes!
You Obama zombies are all going to be so disappointed when your hero isn't chosen by the people of this nation. Oh, it is going to be so sweet to see what you all have to say after that!

McCain/Palin '08
I have yet to here any politition actually say anything about what they are going to do. Obama talks a lot about a failed presidency. as far as Bush goes he has been the first to actually lower my taxes, and I am lower middle class, 40,000 a year. I even recieved money back. The only thing Dems promise is higher taxes. I did not like the war in Iraq. but we have it. it had very little to do with 9/11. But I ask How many attacks on Americans especially on American soil do we allow. I don't want to die any more than any body else. The Dems did nothing while American people were bing singled out and killed. The reason we have problems in Iraq is the Dems inpower interfered with the military and turned this into a police action instead of a war. Our country is falling appart at the seams. we have 2 main parties and have to except when our candadate loses. and work with who wins. if we do not, we will see.
I would vote for the devil himself, after this Bush/Cheney fiasco, before I would ever cast another Republican vote, not too crazy about the Dems either, but what other choice is there, we need an independent party, that truly supports the middle class, and is not funded by big business.      Obama/Biden all the way
The only thing Senator McCain showed is why he would be 4 more years of the same. He blamed ALL our economic problems on the price of oil, if you can believe it!

No, the reason the economy continues to free-fall towards a full-blown recession is because the REPUBLICANS DON’T GET IT!

GIVING A HUGE TAX BREAK TO THE WEALTHY IN THE MIDDLE OF A RECESSION WILL RESULT IN DISASTER! In 2001, George W. Bush did exactly that, and as a result of his failure to provide adequate short-term stimulus, the FED was forced to do his job for him and rescue the economy by dropping rates to THEIR LOWEST POINT IN HISTORY and keeping them there. That, in turn, set up the present problem with the housing industry, while dropping the worth of the dollar into the toilet.

AND SENATOR MCCAIN WANTS MORE OF THE SAME!

There’s only one way out of this, and that is to THROW THE BUMS OUT and put REAL change in place.

THANK GOD for Senator Barack Obama. The country needs him, and it needs him NOW!

ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!

GO BAMA!
Good Morning Morning Joe,
 At least Neidermier was killed in Vietnam serving our country. All you liberals who make fun of our
men and women in uniform should be ashamed. Freedom isn't free, but apparently your opionions are, & I am
one vote who is tired of all TV people telling the American people what's wrong with our country. Our goal as a country is to end socialism, redistribution of tax funds.  We should have one consumption tax, and do away with everything else.  The first
course of business when Miss. Pelosi returns from her book tour is the weekly reader of where every penny of our tax money goes, with receits. Governor Jindal,
of Lousiana has it right, see if the democrats pass it
or as in Lousiana resign due to corruption. 300 less retirement checks. Let's discuss this in the first debate in Mississippi.
Wow, I take it from all these opinions that republicans do not read msnbc! I'm amazed at how both sides demonize each other and blame each other for everything wrong in our country. Obama had it right in his convention speech when he touched on the importance of personal responsibility. I think the failure to take ownership of that responsibility has far more to do with it than our government's role in "ruining our lives".
Businesses cut 84,000 jobs in August.

Obama: "I know, let's raise taxes on big business.  That should help them hire more workers."

Awesome.
Yes - I'm astounded that the media is being held hostage by the McCain campaign. You guys put Obama through the grinder the last 20 months. I want Palin to answer questions or the media to make the American public aware that she is isolating herself. Note she is the only candidate that is not on the sunday morning shows. Come on Chuck you have a responsibility to get this woman to answer questions about accusations of abuse of power, flip flopping on the Bridge to Nowhere etc. If Tim Russert were alive I would feel better. He would never allow himself to be held hostage by a campaign or candidate. He loved this country too much. We miss you Tim.
I have never blogged before, but I fell compelled to post a comment regarding DL, Exter, NH. That was not a diatribe. Your questions pose the minimal standards that all of the canidateds need to be able to address and understand. I need to feel confident that the people you get my vote( regardles of age, race, gender or party affiliation) can be an effective and informed leader on the world stage.
Is it really true that Palin threatened to fire a librarian in Alaska if she didn't take books off the shelf like shakespeare, Tom Sawyer etc????

If this is true, its unbelievable. CAn somebody confirm this?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1353954

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google