ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama announces new ed proposals

Posted: Tuesday, September 09, 2008 12:04 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Athena Jones
DAYTON, Ohio -- Obama bashed his Republican rival, as he announced new education proposals his campaign estimates will cost $1 billion a year.
 
Arguing that a strong education policy was essential to America’s ability to compete in a global economy, Obama said McCain had been in Washington for nearly 30 years but had done little to strengthen America's schools.

“In those three decades, he has not done one thing to truly improve the quality of public education in our country. Not one real proposal or law or initiative. Nothing,” he said. “After three decades of indifference on education, do you really believe that John McCain is going to suddenly make a difference now? John McCain doesn’t get it. He doesn’t understand that our success as a nation depends on our success in education and our success in public education. That’s something I do understand.”

The criticism of McCain was in line with his campaign’s latest argument that Republicans just do not understand the kitchen-table concerns of hardworking families, it’s a line he hopes will work well, especially in economically depressed states like Ohio, an important battleground. The education speech here at a high school marked the senator’s eighth trip to the state during the general election.

The McCain campaign points the finger back at Obama, charging that he's the one who hasn't done much on education.  

“According to a leading non-partisan education magazine, Barack Obama 'hasn't made a significant mark' on education policy, so rather than tout his own record he's left with no option but to attack John McCain," McCain spokesman Tucker Bounds said in a statement. "The truth is Barack Obama joined John McCain in supporting education reforms in the Senate -- if he thinks that's 'nothing,' then Barack Obama is in the odd position of attacking his own record.”

Obama said partisan bickering had stood in the way of education reform and that his Republican rival had “marched with the ideologues in his party” by opposing efforts to expand Head Start, hire more teachers, make college more affordable, fully funding No Child Left Behind and by proposing to close the Department of Education.

Investing in early childhood education and a $4,000 college tuition tax credit, in exchange for public service, have long been parts of the senator’s education proposals.

Today he proposed programs that would provide $500 million in matching funds for investments in technology, increase access to Advanced Placement courses in high schools and double funding for charter schools.

He also wants to provide parents with a report card to help them keep abreast of their child’s educational development, institute pay-for-performance programs for teachers, in addition to help for struggling teachers. He also pledged to report to the American people yearly on the state of the country’s schools.

The programs would be funded with savings from a “comprehensive effort to cut government spending, including reforming federal contracting, reducing the number of federal earmarks, improving federal procurement processes and ending wasteful unnecessary federal programs,” according to a fact sheet provided by the campaign.

In his speech, Obama spoke about paying for his proposals by winding down the war in Iraq.

In keeping with recent efforts to portray himself and his family as people who can relate to the concerns of ordinary Americans, Obama touched on the importance of education in helping him overcome modest beginnings.

“This is a country that let the child of a teenage mom and an absent father reach for his dreams. You see, I wasn’t born with a lot of advantages. But I was given love, and support and an education that put me on a pathway to success,” he said, adding that education had also helped his wife Michelle. “I know that the only reason Michelle and I are where we are today is because this country we love gave us the chance at an education and the reason I’m running for President is to give every single American that same chance.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

...a vain attempt to trump McCain-Palin ticket. Too late, the horse is already dead.
Can't wait for the not-so-interested-in-change half of the McCain/ Palin national debacle respond: "Senahhter Obaaaaaama is a three-eyed Cammunist who want's to eat your grandmother!"
i love that obama's taking a proactive approach, unlike john mccain who only continues to attack.  john mccain voted against the new GI bill, something that he should surely understand and support.  i have about as much hope for anything he would propose for our educational system.
I liked the idea of posting progress notes and grades online for parents. Some parents may not be able to attend the meetings with teachers due to work. By posting progress notes and grades online parents can stat abreast with their children's progress at school. great idea.
This is precisely why it was brilliant to add the 'soccor mom' to the ticket...Any one politician usually has an area or a few areas of expertise that they deal in. John McCain's experience is in another area. Sarah Palin rounds out that ticket by focusing on the 'kitchen table' issues.

Barry did the same thing by adding an experienced foreign affairs advocate to his ticket to round out the 'wholesome family values' platform he runs on!

Come on guys...apples to apples!
Bravo, Senator.

This unique & gifted leader, Barack Obama, comes once in a lifetime.

Don't mess it up, America.   VOTE for real change.

OBAMA/BIDEN '08
And I suppose that after 20 years at Rev. Wright's Trinity Church, Sen. Obama would understand the love for America and the goodness of the American people.
finally barry is getting around to talking about that mccain "experience" and "change"...mccain has been in DC for 30 years and has little to show for it...other than some much ballyhooed campaign finance laws that were struck down by the SCOTUS and the urge to surge name one signature issue for mccain...name one that benefits you and me and not him
Stay on issues Obama. hit the mccain/palin on their lies and new campaign on change but stay on the issues, we can not afford four more years of this mess.
A strong education policy is, indeed, essential for America to compete in a global economy in the 21st century.  McCain does not address education.
As an educator it is nice to hear at least one of the candidates speak of educattion?

But how will the media tear this apart while kissing up to Palin who wants to ban books, teach creationism, and do away with most things scientific, especially if it deals with global warming and extinct animals.

You know what is an extinct animal? True journalists!
He was against vouchers before he was for them, now that's change we can't believe in!
Education is the key to ending the cycle of poverty.  Yet the Republicans refuse to fund it. Their attack back will be we can't afford $1 Billion a year.  Obama wants to raise taxes. The FACT is that $1 Billion cost is less than three days in Iraq.  Repeat, less than three days in Iraq. Not months, not years.  Three dyas. Fight lies with facts.  
Barack, where do you children go to school?

How much does it cost to attend that school?

Is their tuition paid for OR subsidised by Michelle's employer?

Did your work with Bill (the bomber) Ayers contribute to this school?
Barack proves once again why he's in the back pocket of the teacher union lobbyists.
Obama, we've heard these same old promises over and over and over from so many politicians.  And, what you propose puts in more layers of government and government control of our schools.  If you really want to save money and clean up Washington, you'd get rid of these layers and layers of bureaucratic BS.

As far as schools go, I'm to the point Ithink we should go to a European system.  If you want to be a good student and work hard, you get put in the academic track.  If not, you go in a vocational track. People keep hollering about their right to a college education.  It's not a right; it's a privilege and who says I have to pay for somebody else's child to go to college?  And, please, mr. Obama, look at the job trends. In the near future, we will be two job classes: the upper with more technical skills and the lower service skills.  Technology will eliminate many of the middle jobs.  So, why do people keep pushing kids to college when the jobs aren't going to be there?  That's part of the unemployment issue now. We keep graduating people in worn out professions where there is no longer a demand.  Please get real, Obama; quit promising that every child can go to college and we'll pay for it because they shouldn't all be there, for academic and economic reasons.
Now this a bread and butter issue for me!

My main 3 factors are the war, education, and the environment and I am more comfortable with Obama/ Biden on these issues than McPalin.

I do not trust McPalin to do anything but smear and tear down others.  Not one issue other than the bridge?  Well hell, I can't eat a bridge or that million dollar hockey rink which is costing Alaskans dearly.      
Education is CLEARLY the key to the future.  We can't be a first rate producer as a nation with a 5th rate educational system.  In inner urban setting and rural settings-higher education is the difference between a good living wage and "do you want fries with that ma'am". And with Biden's wife having a PhD in Education and Michelle Obama's committment to education, we are going to get a STRONG push from the spouses for well-funded educational issues (unlike Every Child Left Behind).  Go Obama/Biden!
No way, no how, no McCain/Palin
Yes, yes, yes.

We can start to pay for better schools by reducing the millions of dollars we send to Alaska, the second least populous state, and one of the biggest beneficiarys of federal funds.
Wow, what a shocker, Obama promising yet another billion dollar proposal.  And yet another rendition of 'poor little Barry, son of a poor white woman, who rose like a phoenix from the ashes to save the world.'    
McCain hasn't said anything about education because HE DOES NOT CARE! Geesh, how many times does it have to be said?
We are on our way to be a second tier nation - our education system ranks already below that. Education is key and the Bush Palin/McCain strategy of sitting things out won't cut it !
Obama is right. The future of this country and it's successes depend a great deal on doing a much better job of educating the next generations and allowing for more of those generations to receive a higher education. No matter what anyone says, dem or republican, this is and will remain a global economy where those countries with the best of all educational systems for their next generations will come out on top. Children who can speak more the one language and who are prepared educationally to take on the technical advances in this global economy will be the winners. If our public school system does not improve our kids will not be able to compete. Ask anyone now involved in the private sector here in the U.S. where many engineers and technicans are coming from. Not the U.S., but India, China, etc.

McCain has no clue what is needed in this country regarding the education of our youth. I have not heard a single proposal from Mccain regarding these needs. He thinks they will all be fine and have an advantage in the world if they join the military as a grunt fighting in his senseless wars. Has anyone heard any specific proposals from Palin other then all High Schools should offer a class in moose dressing?

If those females now star-struck with Palin really care about family and their kids they better think twice and look at Obama's proposals to improve the educational opportunities for their young kids. Otherwise you will be sending all your kids to Alaska to take a moose hunting class. That should make them competitive in the world today.
Obama and Biden are the true agents of change and i hope that America sees it. I teach an accounting course at the local college, i have s tudent that has been a teacher for 20 years that says that as a single parent that she can not afford to be a teacher and wanted to purse a career in corporate america. this is what Obama meant when he says that mccain just does not get it. should a professional educated middle class american leave a career they love becuse in this economy they can not make ends meet.
Obama thinks the debates will do the trick but in the meantime he is taking blows below the belt. To stir up his donors he needs to deliver a few. The education punch was a start. Forget Palin and expose McCain for what he is.
Obama is on target!

Keep hammering home these domestic issues, Barack--education, economy, energy, health care--all the kitchen table issues so important to the lives of everyday Americans.

Drive it home, show the stark contrasts between you/Joe and McSame's camp. The choice is clear--only YOU can bring the right change, the change we need.

I would keep repeating the line you stated last night in your interview with Keith O.: It may be true that Republicans are smart campaigners, but they govern badly.

What will people have at the end of the day, when the campaign has ended, the confetti is swept away, the ballons have deflated, and the snarky lines have all be said, if they choose McCain? More of the same...but to a worse degree.

The deficit will continue to spiral out of control, there will be no relief from the housing crunch, the job losses, the economic woes, the health care crisis, the education problems, the energy/global warming perils.

A vote for McCain will squander any chance at real change. A vote for you will be an investment in America's Promise and a brighter future!

We--and especially our children and our planet--deserve a fighting chance, and you/Joe are the only ones ready for a fight of this magnitude!
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com/
Taking 1 of the 550 billion dollars we have sunk in Iraq and spending it here on education sounds like the least we could do.
We've been throwing money at education for decades and it doesn't seem to improve. The only thing that has gotten better is that teachers and administrators are making six figure salaries, working 35 weeks a year, and retiring after 20 years of service with fat pensions.
Barack proves once again why he's in the back pocket of the teacher union lobbyists.
More Money (Sent Tuesday, September 09, 2008 12:28 PM)
____________
This whomever is why we need a good education system!


This is about the future of our children.  With the great education opportunities our children will receive will allow them to greatly contribute back to our society.  

I guess the republicans can care less about education or they like the idea of our children being substandard and receiving a substandard education.

Our current president..."Even you can make C's and be the next president!"    

Ah...this may be true with him, but I want more our children of this nation to excel beyond boundaries and exceed each standard.  

Why should we vote for McPalin and have our children recieve the bronze star, when we can vote O'Biden and our children can fairly have the chance to get the GOLD????!!!!!

I'll take my chances with the GOLD TEAM!  

real change?
I absolutely agree with you in that the push towards education is a)important and b)not for all. And it most certainly edges out what is left of a collapsing middle class that we have in this country...which will create a larger divide between the wealthy and the poor and create a much greater burden on the government in terms of assistance programs for families who cannot make ends meet...Is he trying to create a greater divide in order to take MORE from the rich and give it to an even larger poor? I don't understand why we don't see the need to push blue collar middle class jobs that we can be proud to hold and that can create a good life for the next generation.
C A, Tuscaloosa, AL - Obama is right.

No he's not. Throwing good money after bad has been a core of Democratic dogma for generations. The education system is full of bloat, poor teachers, and choice will never be made an option so it will never improve. Obama is just another liberal stooge whose job it is to inflate the money going to schools so they in turn can give millions back to him in the form of campaign contributions. The teachers and Obama couldn't care less about the quality of education given to the kids.
Kathryn in Bham (Sent Tuesday, September 09, 2008 12:14 PM)

Oh no...apples to lemons I would say!

What is McCain doing for education is the question?

All I have heard is Palin talking about the bridge...that not bread and butter; that's a bold face lie.  

McPalin has not said one thing about education...oh but that bridge, I have heard plenty!  Enough already!    
Barack proves once again why he's in the back pocket of the teacher union lobbyists.
More Money (Sent Tuesday, September 09, 2008 12:28 PM)
----------------------------------------------------

Tell that to the 88% of Washington D.C. 8th Graders who can't read.  Wonder why when you get an exam that there are mostly Indian, and Far East Doctors taking care of people?  Wonder why we are buying so many cars from Japan?  It's not the manufacturing...it's the engineering.  And guess where they go to school...mostly in the U.S.    

He's talking about promoting education, and making it available to all...and leveling the playing field.

Let's start working toward a solution instead of fingerpointing.
Im sure most of these people fighting Obama on education are the ones who didn't make it.  Education is what keeps America moving forward and it is obvious we can do much better.  Why not improve on something that any teacher can tell you is not working.  
Keep fighting Obama,  the youth vote is going to surprise everyone come this election.  The same people the gallop polls do not count because most of us don't even have land lines anymore.  Change is coming.
In his speech, Obama spoke about paying for his proposals by winding down the war in Iraq.
888888888888

BS Obama.  You're going to send them all to Afghanistan so there will be no savings.
real change?, most public schools already have both academic and vocational tracks; at least those which aren't woefully underfunded. Just because that system isn't federally mandated or institutionalized across the board doesn't mean it isn't there. The intent is to provide equal opportunity, not mandate homogenous results.

The responses from McCain supporters on this topic prove only one thing: you may love your country, but you sure seem to hate the people living in it.

This is about the future of our children. - Michelle Zee


Back to this old song and dance I see. The education system has plenty of money. In fact, it needs to have less money, and more competition. Teachers have gotten so used to the gravey train they are on that they refuse to get better. The only thing they know is to use the kids as leverage to get more money out of hard working Americans pockets into put it into their own pockets.
Name one public school teacher that make tons of money?
We've been throwing money at education for decades and it doesn't seem to improve. The only thing that has gotten better is that teachers and administrators are making six figure salaries, working 35 weeks a year, and retiring after 20 years of service with fat pensions.
If You're Overtaxed - Thank a Teacher (Sent Tuesday, September 09, 2008 12:38 PM)
----------------------------------------------------

My soon to be wife is an instructor at a top ranked university in Chicago...she gets paid under 50K a year to teach Mathematics.  She was mentored by someone who is considered top 5 in the world for mathematics.  She has to pay her own insurance, and it cost her 40K in student loans a year to get this education.  We should have them paid off in ohhh 10 years.

You my friend are an Idiot.
Hmm...
Magna Cum Laude at Harvard Law and President of Harvard Law Review

vs.

894 out of 899 at the US Naval Academy

Tough choice...NOT!
Wow, what a shocker, Obama promising yet another billion dollar proposal.  And yet another rendition of 'poor little Barry, son of a poor white woman, who rose like a phoenix from the ashes to save the world.'    
voter (Sent Tuesday, September 09, 2008 12:33 PM)

888888888888888
correct, voter. Spend, spend, spend.  And, where will the money come from?  Even his proposed taxes on the rich, combined with the cuts for the lower economic class, doesn't give enough money to cover everything he has promised.  WAKE UP, OBAMATOTS.  THERE IS NO FREE LUNCH!  He's not going to "give" you a damn thing. YOU will pay for everything you get one way or another.
If Obama wants to lower the cost of higher education, he'd be looking into their practices.  Since the 70s, the cost of higher ed has outstripped inflation every year.  Why?  Some is because of government-imposed requirements.  Some is because colleges/universities think they have to build "mini cities" for the students, to serve their every whim and need.  Some is because of pure glut.  Having worked in higher ed for 16 yrs I can say I've nevre seen such waste in my life!  

When Obama talks about creating all these new jobs, who will fill those jobs?  They won't be high level paying jobs; they'll be lower level hourly wage jobs. At the same time, he's promising college for all.  So, what do you think that will do to unemployment?  People with a college degree aren't going to work in these jobs.
He's talking about promoting education, and making it available to all...and leveling the playing field.

Let's start working toward a solution instead of fingerpointing.

GP Chicago (Sent Tuesday, September 09, 2008 12:44 PM)
~~~~~~~~~~~

Lets see what kind of solutions Obama brought to the schools of Chicago. It appears, using Obama's ideas, that Chicago schools are one of the worst in the country. Now Obama wants to do for the country waht he did for Chicago.
I'm old enough to remember when the US was the leader in education, technology, and advancement.  Now we have a generation that cannot correctly compose a letter.  It's a national disgrace.  I want my grandchildren to be able to take pride in their nation as the leader in innovation.  

Bush has given us the largest government this country has ever known.  Worst of all, it is wasteful and ineffective.  We must get the focus off interventionism and nation building and put it back here at home where our problems are real and looming large.  Educate our children first, before sending trillions of dollars abroad.  Rebuild our infrastructure before propping up questionable governments in sovereign foreign states.  It's time to prioritize, people.  We simply cannot afford another four years of this insanity.
Obama is sticking to the issues.  This needs to be an issues election, not lies and personal smears. I confess that two days ago I was getting a bit nervous about the poll numbers.  But today...less so.  The country needs a President who is focused on issues, not one-line zingers.  His position papers are many: Race, Education, the War, the Economy, Energy, Farming issues.  You may not agree with his positions so don't vote for him.  But this is the high-road alternative to lies, lies, and more lies.  

The Obama team beat out Hillary and will beat out McOld.  Chuck Todd--you underestimate Barack's debating skills. He is thinking while he is talking.  McOld is talking without thinking.
Real change would be for Obama to support vouchers. Guess, what, he doesn't.
I appreciate Obama focusing on the issues while the GOP focuses on lies and one-liners.  Education is the key to our future.  Neither McCain or Palin seem to value education much.  I hope Obama isn't over-estimating the American voter.
teaching the Koran and anti american resenment is not what I would call education reform !
Obama Does Not Have Answers (Sent Tuesday, September 09, 2008 12:47 PM)

And McCain has even less.
The children are our future, we should not be putting an enormous debt on them by not paying for an illegal war.
If you truly believe this Iraq war was necessary then we as Americans should pay for it! We are borrowing money from China to fund it. There is a hidden tax when the dollar shrinks 30%, everything costs more. Do you think having the national debt going from 5 trillion to 10 trillion in 7+ years is not going to affect our children and grandchildren? Go ahead, think about it, times up,is it still a good idea to spend 10 billion a month in Iraq? We have got to face facts, we better get better leadership than we have been getting. If we choose more of the same then we truly will be walking down a very steep,narrow path with fewer good options. Time to do your homework America before we go down that path! GO OBAMA


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1367042

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google