ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Rangel admits to 'mistakes'

Posted: Wednesday, September 10, 2008 12:49 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under: ,

From NBC's Mike Viqueira
Ways and Means Committee Chairman Charlie Rangel says he did not receive any "cash proceeds" from rental of his Dominican Republic vacation property, but admits that rental income that was put toward his mortgage payment should have counted as income.

"What I now know is that although I have not personally received proceeds in cash, the fact that any reductions to the mortgage actually counted as income and should have been reported as such," Rangel writes in a letter to Speaker Pelosi, which he read aloud on camera.

Rangel was compelled to appear before the press in the House gallery for a second time this year to defend himself against charges of ethical impropriety. This visit came in the wake of reports that he failed to report 20 years worth of income from the property, and that he, in fact, owes both federal and local back taxes on same.

House Republican leader John Boehner has called for Rangel to step down from his Ways and Means post, citing the fact that as chairman of the panel Rangel is charged with writing tax law, while at the same time neglecting to pay his own taxes. Rangel says he will unilaterally ask the House ethics committee to look into the matter, making this the third ethics complaint he has made against himself this year.  

"I really don't believe that making mistakes mean that you should give up your career," Rangel said.

Rangel appeared for more than an hour and delivered a performance that was at turns cajoling, admonishing toward the press, vindictive and self-deprecating -- with regard to his weight (he claims to have lost 10 to 15 pounds after he was pictured on the cover of the New York Post, asnooze in a chaise lounge on a white sandy beach at or near the property in question).

Rangel was accompanied at the presser by his lawyer, Lanny Davis. He released three volumes of information, one for each scandal, that contained correspondence, copies of leases, news clippings, etc.

All are intended to demonstrate that Rangel has nothing to hide and that he will answer any and all questions regarding these matters.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

No way!! Not a dishonest politician. Can it really be? Looks bad for Ol Charlie this time. Maybe he better go down in the cellar with his buddy Barney and hide.
Obama's plan for change is the best road map out of this quagmire in Washington. The people have to start somewhere in trying to clean this mess up. We can't send in people like Wyatt Earp anymore so Obama is the next best choice.
Could this be the first article in days without the name Palin in it?
Try it in your broadcast MSNBC!
He should step down...but then so should most of congress.  After all, if it's ok to work with Keating, it should be ok to pay for your mortgage with rental income.  
I'm an Obama supporter, and I do believe Rangel needs to step down...all those whom abuse their power in that way need to step down. On both sides of the aisle.
Charlie,Charlie,Charlie: Even I know you have to claim rental property. Shut up, pay your taxes, and please do us no more harm.
What kind of double talk is this.  He didn't receive "cash" but the money went against his house paymenht.  Well you don't get cash from the airlines on your frequent flyer miles, but the IRS still considers it income when you buy a ticket with them.  This is the Chairman of Ways and Means who writes the tax laws and he doens't know what he should report as income? Give me a break.  
Charlie Rangel is a GOOD MAN

But, you gotta follow the rules
and you gotta be HONEST

Put this in context:
Jack Abramoff
Tom DeLay indictment and resignation
Mark Foley and Congressional pages
Bob Ney and his corruption
Curt Weldon and his daughter's government contracts
Rick Renzi'e land deal
Don Sherwood's mistress' strangling
Jon Porter's illegal fund raising
Crooked Richard Pombo and John Doolittle's friendship with Jumpin' Jack Abramoff
Jail bird 'Duke' Cunningham (top gun?)
And don't forget 'Wide Stance' Larry Craig
and Senator 'Crooked Ted' Stevens

I won't even mention Scooter Libby, Alberto and the rest of those crooks
Hey, why don't you guys cover this new sleazy McCain ad where he says Obama is teaching sex ed to kindergartners when he actually passed legislation to protect the from pediphiles??!!
Let's keep the Democratic failings front and center; while refusing to report on the Republican lies.

MSM = Shiny Objects & simple soundbites

Is it too much to ask for some actual journalism today?
Unlike a repugnant one Charlie Rangel admits making a mistake and will allow an investigation.  No repugnant one is this honest and would just lie about the charges not being true and would fight any investigation by claiming it was politically motivated.

Sounds like Charlie needs a better accountant.  His accountant has obviously screwed up for 20 years by not asking the proper questions that would have brought the income to light.

In my several decades of tax preparation I've found that the republicans are the worst tax cheaters of all!

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
Obeuy the law, Charlie
Thanks for admitting your mistake....


Now, when will George Bush and John McCain admit that IRAQ WAS A DISASTER ??

Isn't it about time

When will Bush and McCain ADMIT THEIR MISTAKE ??

There WERE NO WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION !

When will Bush ADMIT HE LIED ABOUT WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION ??
What a joke.  Rangel negotiated a good deal for himself, then made a mistake in how it was accounted for that has virtually no effect on how much tax he paid.  The basis of his property increases, but his depreciation deduction also increases.  Net effect: ZERO.  And there is no evidence that this "good deal" resulted in any politcal favors being granted.  John Boehner is once again just trying to score cheap political points from a non-issue.
Lawyer Ball!

Something tells me he didn't really violate the tax code, depending on which accountant/tax attorney you talk to.  That is one huge pile of code, and is always subject to interpretation.

OTOH, if he actually knowingly violated the law, that's different.  The House should at least slap his wrists in some way, AFTER every other congress-person's tax return is examined for similar irregularities.
roperty was a rental property that generated income.  Moreover, he admits that he has NEVER (NOT ONCE) paid tax on the rental income it generated claiming it was a mistake.  His primary excuse was that "the income had gone directly toward paying down the mortgage on the property and he had rarely if ever received income statements related to it". Doesn't that suggest that he knew the unit was generating income?  Following, as Chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee is he suggesting that he does not know that income, even if is being used to pay down a mortgage, needs to be reported to the IRS (and in his case to Congress).  I have income too (it's called a paycheck).  And, the majority of that income is automatically deducted from my checking account  each month to pay my mortgage.  Should I no longer declare my income on my Tax Return?  
Charlie Rangel is a crook! And, the easiest way to confirm that this was a scam is to look at the tax returns of the other "pioneer investors" including his friend Theodore Kheel who purportedly suggested this investment property.  If the other investors "forgot" to declare the income they received that would pretty much prove that malfeasance was involved here.

Where was all this outrage when it came out that John and Cindy were well behind on one of their seven home's back taxes.

Spare me the fake outrage Boner.

http://www.rodneyhopper.com
Hey FR crew, could someone pass along the message to fix the MSMNC.com political calendar to properly reflect that Inauguration Day is January 20th, 2009 not 2008?  I hope it gets fixed before the repugnant ones get wind of it and start bashing MSNBC.com for making a mistake.

Thanks for posting great articles and reader comments!

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
Awfully silent from the Obama camp on this subject. Unlike John McCain who took aim at his own party during his acceptance speech. If Obama is really for fundamental change in the way our government "serves" us he should have some strong words for his Dem. colleague.
Did anyone step down after real issues? Libby, Palm(CIA Leak), Guantanamo, Weapon of Mass Destruction, Lyieng to the American people, False claim to the Congress, come on guys, respect us, we are not stupid, Rangel should not even waste time dealing with this.
Why should Rangel have to pay his taxes anyway?
Awfully silent from the Obama camp on this subject. Unlike John McCain who took aim at his own party during his acceptance speech. If Obama is really for fundamental change in the way our government "serves" us he should have some strong words for his Dem. colleague.
emmett, boston
*********

Yeah...McCain sure took potshots at his party.  Mmmhmm.  That's why they are all running interferance for Palin, because made them oh so angry and goes against his party.

Get real.  McCain in in the pocket of the Rovian Party..sorry...republican party.  
I have 2 condo's in Costa Rica, like Charlie's they are cash cows.  A visit allows you to bring back $10,000 in cash without declaring it through customs.  Check the number of trips to the Dominican Republic made by Charlie over the the last 20 years, his passport will do fine, x $10,000 per trip is the amount to look for, not $75,000.
Hey Lisa, KCMO, it IS a FACT that Obama voted FOR legislation to teach sex ed to kindergarten.  And in a 2007 interview, he said "it's the right thig to do."  McCain's ad wasn't sleazy, Obama's views are.
Boehner should ask for Bush to step down!  All this Bruhaha over the personal financial trickery stuff, as americans have been tricked out of billions of dollars on every front.

The entire Bush administration should be hauled into court, under oath to answer questions about their financial dealings.  Let's just start with oil and their revenues!!!
The important thing we learned here is that when it's a Republican it's a lie, when it's a Democrat, it's a mistake.  Seems fair.
Rangel went to the Obama School of Shady Real Estate
Awfully silent from the Obama camp on this subject. Unlike John McCain who took aim at his own party during his acceptance speech. If Obama is really for fundamental change in the way our government "serves" us he should have some strong words for his Dem. colleague.
emmett, boston (Sent Wednesday, September 10, 2008 1:31 PM)

---------
He's too busy trying to debunk McCain's campaign lies about him....maybe if McCain turned back to 2000 McCain and ran a clean campaign, Obama would have the time to response to issues like Rangle...oh, and why should he anyways...Rangle is in the House, Obama is in the Senate.
He should step down.  Fortunately for Obama, Rangel was a stauch Hillary supporter and surrogate.  This is the kind of politics that Obama needs to clean up.

Go Obama
Again, it is too bad the guards at the Hanoi Hilton didn't finish the job.  America would be so much better if they had and John "Mush-head" McCain wasn't around.  Oh yea...I went there!!!
So.... I have a question....If Sara Palin is the Pig.....who is the "old Fish"?  ;)
Has anyone else figured it out that Palin is the newest thing in politics and polital campaigns. A  Stepford VP Candidate. Watch for your latest versions when some additional neo-con feamles begin running for Senate, Governors or Congress persons. The way to win. Be a Stepford Candidate, all smile, no brains, robotic to the republican cause.
Obama has his hands full with the smears coming right and left from the McCain campaign.  But, I don't think he would give Rangel a pass on this.  Don't forget, Rangel was a huge Hillary supporter so there is no long relationship or warmth there.
Regarding the "lipstick on a pig" controversy ...

Don't you get it?  It DOESN'T MATTER whether Obama meant Palin when he said it.

Why not?

Because, as we say in the legal world, she "opened the door" the minute she called herself a pitbull with lipstick?  What exactly did that mean if not that she is a tough woman who can take the heat and belongs in the political arena?  After all, politics ain't pretty.  And why else is the McCain using the slogan, "Read my lipstick"?

Because it's a commonly used and well-understood metaphor.  When Dick Cheney said the same thing about John Kerry, what did HE mean?  When Obama made a further analogy to wrapping an old fish in newspaper, did he call McCain a "fish"?  Are you going to call McCain out for HIS use of the term to describe Hillary Clinton's proposals?

Stop perpetuating this bologna.  The ONLY sexist thing here is the McCain campaign using a woman as both a sword and a shield.  She talks trash and then hides behind her own skirt.

Read MY lipstick, Governor Palin.  If you want to play in the big leagues, then perhaps you ought to grow some ... spine.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1373251

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google