ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



First thoughts: Guns of September

Posted: Friday, September 12, 2008 9:24 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, Domenico Montanaro, and Carrie Dann
*** The guns of September: Just a day after Thursday’s ceasefire to commemorate the 9/11 anniversary, the presidential campaigns are now firing their heavy artillery. This is especially true for the Obama camp, which is up with two new TV ads (one has Obama talking to the camera to argue that he’s the real change agent in this race, and the other takes a tough shot at McCain’s age and computer skills). Obama campaign manager David Plouffe also issued an “enough is enough” memo to reporters and squeamish Democrats. “In recent weeks, John McCain has shown that he is willing to go into the gutter to win this election. His campaign has become nothing but a series of smears, lies, and cynical attempts to distract from the issues that matter to the American people. But as Barack Obama said earlier this week ‘enough is enough,’” Plouffe says. “We will respond with speed and ferocity to John McCain’s attacks and we will take the fight to him, but we will do it on the big issues that matter to the American people.” (That begs the question, though: Is McCain’s computer literacy a “big” issue in this election?) Meanwhile, the McCain campaign is not ready to see the spotlight move off of Palin; it's out with a new ad attacking the Dem ticket for attacking her. Everything with the McCain campaign is Palin, Palin, Palin. They don't want the spotlight off of her.

*** Role swap: Speaking of… If you want more evidence that Sarah Palin has emerged as the true principal of the McCain campaign, just look at the weekend schedule. Today, John McCain -- the party’s presidential nominee -- appears on the “The View” and “Rachel Ray”; he’s down in DC on Saturday; and then he flies to New Hampshire for a NASCAR race there on Sunday. By comparison, Palin -- the running mate -- returns to the Lower 48 tomorrow, immediately holding a solo campaign event in Carson City, NV. The campaign has made it crystal clear who the campaigner-in-chief is. And it’s not McCain. It’s an astonishing and unprecedented development in American presidential politics. Essentially, the person driving the rallies, crowds, and campaigning isn’t the person running for president. Just asking, but when are going to start hearing this from McCain camp TV ads, “I’m Sarah Palin, and I approve of this message.”

*** Palin's first interview: While Palin has become Team McCain’s campaigner-in-chief, her somewhat shaky interview last night with ABC’s Charlie Gibson suggests that she won’t be the campaign’s go-to person for the Sunday shows just yet. The kindest reviews of her performance all have the phrase "at times" -- meaning it wasn't a homerun. But it also didn’t seem to be a complete and utter disaster (like that John Edwards performance in ‘02 on “Meet the Press”, or even Bill Richardson’s “Meet” stinker in ’07). Rather, it was somewhere in between. She's surviving and Republicans will be satisfied with her performance. But how is it playing in the middle with moderates and persuadable voters? What about the GOP foreign policy establishment? Was she too scripted? Did she struggle too much on certain issues? Perhaps our biggest question: How will Saturday Night Live play it? Will it exaggerate her deer-in-the-headlights response to the “Bush Doctrine” question? Or, like those SNL skits from earlier this year, will it portray a mean, unfair, and condescending Charlie Gibson. By the way, Palin yesterday linking 9/11 to the war in Iraq is getting some extra attention.

VIDEO: Palin says she's "ready" for the job in her first TV interview since being chosen as McCain's running mate. 

*** Last night's forum: While Palin was answering questions from Alaska, McCain and Obama (with Biden in the audience) participated at last night’s forum on service and citizenship. Both candidates did fine, but you could tell Obama took this forum a bit more seriously than Saddleback. He was sharper. In fact, even though we said yesterday that the forum’s subject matter -- service -- was in McCain’s wheelhouse, we seriously underestimated how much it was in Obama’s wheelhouse, too. It helped Obama that he had a national service plan to tout and McCain didn't. The other thing to struck us about the forum is that there really was a true ideological divide on the role of government on display. Obama made a defense of government, arguing he wanted to make government "cool again." McCain talked about how government can get in the way of many issues, particularly service. The two campaigns appear to be trying to emulate the other lately, but they can't mask the fact that there are real philosophical differences in how they'd govern.

VIDEO: NBC's David Gregory discusses last night's forum with MSNBC's Chris Matthews.

*** McCain’s college grad problem? Over the last several months, the chattering class has hashed and rehashed Obama’s weakness with working-class white voters. But does McCain have a problem with college-educated whites? Consider: In the final NBC/WSJ poll before Election Day in 2004, Bush led Kerry equally among non-college whites (52%-42%) and college-educated whites (54%-44%). But in the August NBC/WSJ poll, McCain led Obama significantly among non-college whites (51%-33%) but narrowly among college-educated whites (46%-43%). The GOP presidential nominee improved those college numbers in the most recent NBC/WSJ poll (to 51%-43%), but that’s still below Bush’s numbers in October 2004. McCain needs to improve his standing with college whites to win. It will be interesting to see how Palin plays with these two groups. Will she create a wider rift between college and non-college whites for McCain, or help close the gap?

*** A “Values” snub? Yesterday, we reported that McCain was skipping the Family Research Council’s Values Voters Summit. And it also looks like FRC’s Tony Perkins isn't thrilled with how his summit's being treated -- he won't even accept a video presentation from Palin. Writes CBN’s Brody: “The Brody File has learned that the offer of a short video from vice-presidential nominee Sarah Palin to folks at this weekend’s Value Voters Summit has been turned down by its president, Tony Perkins. A source inside John McCain’s campaign tells me that Palin was set to record the video Wednesday in Virginia before she left for Alaska. But when the McCain campaign approached Perkins about offering the video rather than a personal appearance Perkins said, according to numerous witnesses, ‘That’s not enough.’”

*** Every electoral vote matters: How important is every single electoral vote? Consider that Obama is spending parts of two days this weekend in New Hampshire. The state, worth just four electoral votes, is one of the four closest according to our calculus.  

*** On the trail: McCain appears on The View (along with his wife Cindy) and also does Rachel Ray. Obama is in New Hampshire, campaigning in Dover and Concord. And Biden raises money in Texas.

Countdown to the first presidential debate: 14 days
Countdown to the vice presidential debate: 20 days
Countdown to the second presidential debate 25 days
Countdown to the third presidential debate: 33 days
Countdown to Election Day 2008: 53 days
Countdown to Inauguration Day 2009: 130 days
 
Click here to sign up for First Read emails. 
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Do you realize what Biden is going to do to Palin in their debate. Especially when he gets to challenege her and if he is able to ask questions. Palin's canned and repitative responses are going to make her look so silly and out of touch. She is way out of her league. But she'll still draw some votes for McCain simply because she is a hockey mom.  
Are all Alaskans this polluted and convoluted?
Obama will win this election, but he must put Hillary and Bill in certain VIP position. He needs the Clintons to win. The repubs know this and are still trying to divide the two democratic camps. Dems are starting to come back around to their party, even if they loved Hillary. I will be voting democratic because of the issues, issues, issues...
Here is one thing I just don't understand.  For decades the republican party has been arguing agaist affirmative action, against quota based hiring, against quota based admissions and against what it sees as preferencial treatment givin to minorities and women.  They claim that people should be evaluated solely on the basis of their merit and ability.  Then we get Governor Sarah Quaylin and all the republicans can argue is that it is sexist to criticize her record, it is sexist to ask hard questions, her gender is the reason why people should vote for her, and as the comedian rush limbaugh says "we have the babe on our ticket".  What happened to the merit-based argument of republicans?  What happened to voting based on ability?  As an aside, if sarah Quaylin can't handle the heat of this campaign (exemplifed by the manufactured pseudo outrage over the the lipstick comment) then how can she possibly handle the pressure of standing up to Putin, Kim Jong Ill, Ahmadenijad?  If she can't handle softballs from Obama she won't be able to defend us against real terrorists.
This election is nothing more that a pass/fail I/Q test. After the past seven years I am cautiously dubious. Americans appear to like shiny objects.
They seem to like seeing people from their old high school clique beat out the smart kids.
Oh well $50 more dollars from the screaming VISA card to Obama then down to the phone banks. Small goals. Three electoral votes from Montana.
Even Ronald Reagan the biggest hawk to be in the White House KNEW WE COULD NOT fight the Russians.... McCain/Palin are not even near his ability and leadship....
Ronald Reagan also knew that after his 1st term after giving tax cut after tax cut to the wealth that he had to raise those taxes because of the deficit.....
Maybe it would be smart if the GOPS who hold up Reagan as a model should read his record....
More tax cuts to the wealth WILL NOT NOT  READ THE HISTORY

She also said she has as much experience as any other VP canidate... ONLY ONE I CAN COME UP WITH IS DAN QUAYLE..... Does  she know how to spell potato?????

GOD BLESS ALL OF YOU IN TEXAS TODAY..WE ARE ALL THINKING ABOUT THOSE IN HOUSTON AND GALVESTON
Two weeks ago Obama wanted a UN Security council resolution to Russia’s attack on Georgia. Apparently Obama was not aware that Russia has veto power.  Considering he touts himself as a member of the Senate’s Foreign Relations committee he should be well aware of Russia’s veto power.
And here’s Obama on Palin two days BEFORE her speech at the RNC, “My understanding is that Gov. Palin’s town, Wassilla, has I think 50 employees. We've got 2500 in this campaign. I think their budget is maybe 12 million dollars a year – we have a budget of about three times that just for the month.” To be fair Obama was asked to compare his experience to hers. But one wonders why he didn’t compare his senate experience with her governor experience which has a budget of $11 Billion and 29,000 employees. And besides doesn’t he have a campaign manager?
Obama is the one who's crawled into the gutter in this election. He is the who's using bigoted, sexist, mysoginistic tactics to try and win.
McCain and Palin have been extremely tolerant of the personal attacks.
We the people see how angry, mean spirited and vitriolic Obama's words are, and we will reject his brand of snake-oil-salesmanship in favor of true Patriotism, service, and selflessness.
Yes, I am a Democrat.
But...my country comes first!
McCain/Palin '08'!!!!!
J. Merle Stanley, Westchester, NY
----------------------------------------------------

Um--- dude - are you crazy or just blind.

All I have to say is this.  If John McCain wins this election, and the result is the next four years look like the last eight, then I will most likely not have a home to live in, or a job to go to, I won't have health coverage for my children.

These are the stakes in this election for me - and it is why I am voting for Barack Obama

.
AS BILL CLINTON SAID .... OBAMA IS A FAIRYTALE.

Give it up obama ! you're fighting a losing battle !
Without Hillary and her supporters, we're done thanks to you !
Discourged (Sent Friday, September 12, 2008 10:02 AM)
-----------------------------------------------------

If we wanted negativity we'd join the GOP...take this garbage somewhere else
Obama is the one who's crawled into the gutter in this election. He is the who's using bigoted, sexist, mysoginistic tactics to try and win.
McCain and Palin have been extremely tolerant of the personal attacks.
We the people see how angry, mean spirited and vitriolic Obama's words are, and we will reject his brand of snake-oil-salesmanship in favor of true Patriotism, service, and selflessness.
Yes, I am a Democrat.
But...my country comes first!
McCain/Palin '08'!!!!!
J. Merle Stanley, Westchester, NY (Sent Friday, September 12, 2008 10:07 AM)
-----------------------------------------------------

You have to be deaf, dumb, and blind to believe this....do me a favor since i know you have internet access....

Go to the nonpartisan site FactCheck.org and count the number of BS ads per side.  People like you voting in this election will be the demise of our country.
Let's get serious. Is the White House and the Vice Presidents Office prepared to become a "Daycare Center"? Are these Offices prepared to be a hangout for a husband and kids distracting the Vice President from performing her "Very Important Duties As A Co-Leader" of our Nation? Is her Husband going to be her head advisor when we as a Nation are hiring her on "Her Merits" not his? From what I see, Sarah Palin needs to stay in Alaska where they condone the above. Enough is Enough
Chuck & Co.

I think you missed something in Gov. Palins answer to the "Bush Doctrine" questions from Charlie Gibson:

PALIN: Charlie, if there is legitimate and enough intelligence that tells us that a strike is imminent against American people, we have every right to defend our country. In fact, the president has the obligation, the duty to defend.

The right to strike first in the case of an IMMINENT threat has been well established for years in International Relations and is not controversial.  The whole point of the Bush Doctrine was to go beyond "pre-emption" to "preventive war," in which we reserved the right to strike first against an potential and emerging enemy IN THE ABSENCE OF an imminent threat.  That is the whole point of the Bush Doctrine and the basis of the fierce foreign policy debate that preceded the Iraq Invasion and has continued since.  Palin either did not know what the Bush Doctrine was (which seems likely) or she deliberately avoided endorsing it and instead endorse the position held by Obama and Biden.  THIS IS NEWS, people!
IMO, McCain's lack of computer skills is a very important issue. It speaks not only to his ability (or lack of it) to adapt to a changing world but also to his capacity to gather and analyze information independently, unfiltered and uncontrolled his immediate entourage of friends and advisors. We can't afford another president who allows himself to be isolated and manipulated into wars and other policy disasters by the Cheneys and Roves of the world.
That lipstick remark had nothing to do with Palin, it had to do w/ their NEW STOLEN change slogan. The Republican's will do anything to avoid the issues. McCain himself has use that same expression over, and over. If their so offended why did she call herself a Pit Bull W/ lipstick. Here in Seattle 71 a year old woman just got attacked by 2 of them they had to be shot, the old woman is still in the hospital, her joke offended me!
I am not sure how Gov. Palin's interviews wasn't a win for her? She answered the questions intelligently and thoughtfully. I have less doubts about her now.
Andrew, Pittsburgh, PA (Sent Friday, September 12, 2008 10:02 AM)

----------
Are you for real? Man, get a clue! She made so many factualy errors in her interview, I can't count them all!  Go to some of your own research at FactCheck.org, and you will see that she doesn't know what she's talking about!  Thoughtful? Please!
"Yes, I am a Democrat.
But...my country comes first!
McCain/Palin '08'!!!!!

J. Merle Stanley, Westchester, NY (Sent Friday, September 12, 2008 10:07 AM)"

You are a lot of things but you are NO Democrat.
SARAH PALIN FOR PRESIDENT,
JOHN McCAIN FOR FIRST DADDY.
TODD FOR FIRST NANNY
RUSH LIMBAUGH FOR FIRST DRUG DEALER.
I'm rollin' on the floor right now, can't stop laughing at the pitiful arguments coming from the repubs today.
Obama is the one who's crawled into the gutter in this election. He is the who's using bigoted, sexist, mysoginistic tactics to try and win.
McCain and Palin have been extremely tolerant of the personal attacks.
We the people see how angry, mean spirited and vitriolic Obama's words are, and we will reject his brand of snake-oil-salesmanship in favor of true Patriotism, service, and selflessness.
Yes, I am a Democrat.
But...my country comes first!
McCain/Palin '08'!!!!!
J. Merle Stanley, Westchester, NY (Sent Friday, September 12, 2008 10:07 AM)

-----------
For someone who was such a Hillary supporter in the primaries, your ardant support for the most uneduated ticket in history, says to me you are really a republican, or a psychopath, or someone sitting alone in his padded room with a computer.
How in the world can she attach 9/11 to the Iraq war that makes no sense what so ever. Its a disgrace to even associate one with the other since one really had nothing to do with another. We need to really focus on Afganistan.  
Computer literacy is the top National Security issue.

America faces millions of attempts to hack into our systems every single day.  Can a candidate who doesn't understand computers really protect every secure piece of information our government has?

Or does the media want us to rely on experts, like we relied on experts like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac?
Cyber-terrorism is on the rise.  You don't have to crash planes into Wall Street to bring it down today.  Crashing the internet or, worse, hijacking it, is all that's needed.

Whether net neutrality lives or dies has more to do with our freedom moving forward than we might imagine.  A President who doesn't understand the internet and the issues surrounding it is unfit to lead.
HOW??? Can anybody say it's no big deal to not know how to use a computer? It has been a huge part of why so many people are getting so involved this election. The computer and internet have provided a freedom of knowledge, you no longer have to hope your library has it. There are many people Johns age, who use the computer.He has had more than 8 yrs to catch the wave.... but I guess he likes to sit in a puddle of denile.
The comments from the obama gang here are really a Disgrace to your guy - HOPE & Unity - seems like he is a FRAUD!!!!  The DNC is very aware they picked the wrong, weak candidate - he will NEVER be elected.

McCain/Palin - much better choice for our country.
Palin's interview was horrible. Naive. Deer in the headlights. Scripted answers.

Let the self-destruction begin.

http://www.rodneyhopper.com
The Republicans do understand one item in poitical races.  You have to win before you can govern.

Therefore, anything can be made up and put on TV if it will help acheive the goal.

If the American voters let them get away with it one more time, they deserve the results.
Two things: how long will it take for the polls to reflect independent's disapproval of McCain's gutter politics?
And, when will Obama's campagin go back to rallying thousands of people on the trail?
As a freshman in high school in October, 1962, the talk of war with Russia was quite vivid. I remember looking up in the sky for the trails of the nuclear missiles coming in. How casually Sarah Palin said we should go to war with Russia over the situation in Georgia, is absolutly frighting.
"His (sen. mccain) campaign has become nothing but a series of smears, lies, and cynical attempts to distract from the issues that matter to the American people." for the good ol' gop, it has also become, and more importantly, about suppressing the vote. while democrats have out-registered more voters - new, young and try-again, for the most part these voters have done so on the hope this time would be different, this time maybe their could be real change; but the last days (with the complete facilitation of the msm) have shown these new voters, it has not. people see these "lipstick on a pig" ads, shown over and over again by the msm, and they say, "it is just politics as usual - forget about it!
Question: How many of you "Americans" have any clue what it takes to be a VPOTUS?  I doubt any of you do -- there are no classes in school on the subject, and if there were, no one would take them.  As for experience -- we have career politicians running the US Capitol who have been around for quite some time and have accomplished almost nothing during that time (remember, Congress is now doing worse -- with only two years since the last election -- in public opinion than the president) -- so what does the experience matter?  It really doesn't -- Joe Biden is no more prepared than Sarah Palin -- he's just been a lousy politician longer.  That all being said, it sure seems an aweful lot of people on here are VP experts based on the way all of you so freely trash other people who are willing to take the job AND put up with your senseless blabberings.

As for me -- I'd hate the job, and wish well anyone who would take it and do something good with it.  From what I've seen over the past 20+ years, the following acronym seems to always be true:

L = Lenin
I = Is
B = Best
E = Especially
R = Right
A = After
L = Liberty's
S = Stolen

And we all know who these people are. Enough said.
"Comparing McCains computer skills to the Presidency would be like comparing a corp CEO and mopping the floors of the restroom.

NOT a real important issue !

Independent Texain"
-----------------------------------------
What a rediculous comparison.  I am a high tech computer worker.  I guarentee that any CEO today knows how to use a computer, email, internet...

My 74 year old Mother-in-Law knows how to browse and use email.

Oh, another thing, I am also a CEO of my company.  We are small but I still help clean the office.  John and Cinday spent $250,000 last year on their housekeeping personnel.

Out of Touch -- wrong temperment -- decietful campaign -- political choice for VP -- run by lobbiest -- war mongering fool.

Wake up America -- and look at your children every morning (tell them you love them) and think hard and long about what kind of country, government, future we are leaving them!
Is "I didn't blink" the same as I didn't think
when asked if she would accept McCain's VP offer.  
How comforting to know that she won't be blinking
or thinking when her finger is on THE BUTTON
The DNC chose the wrong candidate and now all they can do is live with it.  

If the best argument they can muster is that McCain does not use a computer, they are finished!

And, yes, I think they are finished!  THe opinion of 1/2 of the Democratic voters (that Clinton was the better choice) should not have been ignored!

I just want to remind those nay-sayers out there speaking about Palin's "foreign policy experience" or lack thereof.....

NONE of our founding fathers had foreign policy experience, rather they had SMALL, LIMITED experience of "backwoods towns" as you high horse liberals would say....and I'm PRETTY SURE they ran this country just perfect
I honestly don't know what makes me more afraid...(1)the fact that the Republicans are working overtime to keep the discussions in the "news" cycle as far away from SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES as possible...(2)or, that Ms Palin (who is very likely a good person, a wonderful wife and mother, and an excellent govenor, but whom I'm not AT ALL convinced should be a heartbeat away from the most powerful influential position in the modern world) has CLEARLY become the surrogate presidential candidate, because the formal candidate is about as exciting and inspiring as watching grass grow(see concern #1)...(3) or that the "news" media has been and continues to be complicit in this fascinating display of obsfucation and misdirection by NOT CALLING THE REPUBLICANS OUT MORE FORCEFULLY ON THEIR BS...(4)or, finally, due to the combined, cumulative effects of 1-3, there is a REAL and PALAPABLE possibility that a critical mass of Americans will be duped into selecting McCain and Palin as our "new," maverick leaders in this very dangerous and wacky world
Sarah Cheney Palin said the Iraquis were linked to 911.  That proven lie is what the headlines should be.
Barack Obama will navigate the complex and fast-moving changes of the 21st century.  John McCain shoots from the hip.

IQ matters.
Today Paul Krugman and I are on the same page.  He argues that “how a politician campaigns tells you a lot about how he or she would govern.”  He writes that there is a direct “relationship between the character of a campaign and that of the administration that follows.”  I agree.  Since McCain is lying to the American citizens in his campaign, it is clear that he will lie to the American people if he gets into office.  The Bush/Cheney administration has lied to the nation.  This country has been lied to far too much and far too long.  McCain/Palin offers more of the same.  We can not afford it as a nation. The American people were lied into a war.  McCain/Palin cannot be reformers because their campaign has proven that they are liars.  They will make government worst. We can not afford four more years of liars in the White House.  Enough!  We need the truth and change that will work! Not liars masquerading as reformers.
Blizzard of Lies
Paul Krugman
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/12/opinion/12krugman.html?_r=1&ref=opinion&pagewanted=print&oref=slogin
Please tell us how a guy that voted with Bush over 90% of the time is going to take this country in another direction!!

Same foreign policy, same domestic policy (led by the same economic cronies), he's in big oil's pocket... how is he going to shake up anything?  

Iam a New Hampshire voter and a real fan/supporter of Hillary Clinton, i "probably" would have voted for Obama in November,although i will never figure out why Obama did not choose Hillary Clinton as his running mate, but now that  Mccain that  has chosen Palin as his running mate, i most assuredly WILL vote for Obama in November. Obama is  in New Hampshire  for two days this weekend, as well as McCain being in the state on Sunday, Biden was in NH on Wednesday. Its nice to have the national focus on Nh again, its been a "long time" since our primary!
I agree 1000% with Chuck from NY.  It's America's future seriously. We have to ask ourselves how can we trust McCain who lies every day to get elected. Chuck from first read is also right. He hinted in Morning Joe: In games, McCain can get many penalties as he can to win the game. If Chuck noticed it, I wish reporters are not cheering the tricks. The real American spirits are honesty, justice, and sincere. At the end, we all will suffer. You might not feel it today, it will be tomorrow. Media is our eyes and ears and I hope they cherish their power and not joke our fate.
Computer skills important? Duh!

We have enemies sitting in caves using laptops to plan and execute attacks......

shouldn't our president be able to step into the 21st century by using technology?

Or is tech stuff as pesky as that Constitution thing people insist on using?
never in my life have i seen liberals so scared. really funny. you should be scared obama may win this thing.i just hope he doesent totally destroy all our freedom.Time all you college idiots read what this man really believes in oh sorry I forgot you were so buisy partying in college you didn't learn to read by the way if you think John McCain is so dumb strap yourself in the seat of a fighter jet and try to fly it you idiots. Think I will go listen to RUSH or FOX can't stand any more of this liberal msnbc trash.
Dear John - save your campaign money and let the dem's campaign for you. Their idiocy is plenty. As a hedge...post the lib's comments that we see here in venues like this.
It's interesting to see that almost everone posting on here supports Obama.  Apparently those supporting McCain actually work for a living and don't have time to waste posting long, boring comments on blogs.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1382249

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google