ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain gets grilled on 'The View'

Posted: Friday, September 12, 2008 3:21 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC's Abby Livingston
This morning, it was a scene on “The View.”

With gender issues and campaign rhetoric reaching a near boil, McCain sat on the hot seat of the couch on this popular daytime talk show.

McCain laughed, not flinched, when co-host Joy Behar said off the bat, “I said to him before that I believe that after -- if he's elected, he will go back to the old John McCain that he used to be unless the Republican base has him by the short hairs. “ 

And the questions only grew more heated. Despite the fact that McCain has been a regular on the morning show circuit for years, and loves to engage with angry town hall-ers, it was from this gang of women -- including a movie star and stand-up comedian -- that McCain faced some of his fiercest questioning of this campaign season.

On the topic of Palin, Barbara Walters asked, “What is she going to reform, specifically, senator?”

McCain replied, “First of all, earmark spending, which she vetoed a half a billion dollars worth in the state of Alaska.”

Walters said, “She also took some earmarks.”

McCain replied, “No. Not as governor, she didn't. She vetoed -- “ Walters interjected, “As mayor.”

(In fact, as the AP and others have noted, Palin requested nearly $200 million in earmarks this year alone, although that amount is down from previous years.)

McCain followed up with, “Uh, well, look, the fact is that she was a reform governor, she took on a Republican governor of her own -- incumbent governor of her own party and defeated him. She sold the airplane. She fired the chef.”

Walters then said, “She sold the airplane at a loss.”

McCain, amid audience laughter, said, “Well, you wanted her to keep it?”

Walters sighed and said, “No, I wanted her to at least get her money back.”

Then Joy Behar jumped in, confronting McCain about the controversial ads his campaign released this week. She said, “There are ads running from your campaign. One of them is saying that Obama, when he said, 'You can put lipstick on a pig, but it's still a pig' was talking about Sarah. There's another that says that Obama was interested in teaching sex education to kindergartners. Now we know that those two ads are untrue. They're lies. And yet, you at the end of it, say, 'I approved these messages.' Did you really approve them?”

McCain disagreed with the angle of the question. “Actually, they're not lies. “

Walters then pushed McCain on his past use of the lipstick and pigs expression, but he conveyed that it was apples and oranges because he was talking “about a health care plan.” Walters then countered, “Yeah, but he [Obama] talked about change. He wasn’t talking about Sarah Palin.”

McCain then said, “Sen. Obama chooses his words very carefully. OK? He shouldn't have said it. He shouldn't have said it. He chooses his words very carefully. And this is a tough campaign, but I would be glad to come on this show with Sen. Obama. I have asked Sen. Obama to join me in town hall meetings all across America.

Behar added, “That would be good for Sarah and Joe Biden, too.”

McCain answered, “That would be -- yes. Sure, the top of ticket leads, and if we had done what I asked Sen. Obama to do, because I've been in a lot of other campaigns where I have appeared with the opposition, in front of the people and listening to their hopes and dreams and aspirations. I don't you'd see the tenor of this campaign.

The issue ended when Walters said, “You bring us Sarah Palin, we'll ask Barack Obama.” 

After commercial, the conversation shifted to abortion. When asked about the issue, McCain said, “I believe Roe v. Wade was a very bad decision.” And the predominantly female audience groaned. He continued, “I think it was a very bad decision, but I've thought that other decisions of the United States Supreme Court were bad decisions.”

Later, when his wife Cindy joined him on the couch, she too, was pressed on the issue. She said, “Well, I'm pro-life. I always have been.” Walters asked if that sentiment excepted rape and incest, Cindy answered, “Yes. My husband and I agree on this issue.”

The McCains were then pressed on their real estate holdings. Walters asked, “How many houses do you have?”

Cindy replied, “You know something, that's not part of this campaign. we're fortunate to come from a family, in particular, my dad and my mom who worked very hard to give me the best they could. and we are fortunate to be able to live a good life and to share and give to other people who are not as fortunate.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Good!!!  Americans are standing up and calling B.S.

Now back to the issues so we can get this country back on path.
Cindy McCain answers questions better than her husband.

Mccain is so out of touch that he actually believes the crap he says...amazing
"Haha!"
Greta, the only people with a spine in the media are the ladies on View. Keep asking these tough question ladies.
Did you watch Palin's interview yesterday? As a working mom, I am more qualified to be VP. Atleast my knowledge of the world is my own, not a script I had to memorize in two weeks. I am sure most of you felt the same way. It sounded so scripted and did not seem to come from a thinking person. What a scandal.
WOW!!  It takes 4 women (I won't count Hasselbeck)on a daytime talk show to bring the big questions!  Thank you LADIES!!!


ARE YOU BETTER OFF NOW THAN 8 YEARS AGO?  

WE CANNOT SURVIVE 4 MORE YEARS OF THE SAME BUSH POLICIES!


OBAMA/BIDEN '08

GO VIEW!!!!!!!!!

What a great job of hammering home the issues and digging out the lies and deception.

McCain, you got OWNED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
He deserves credit for going into this den of angry liberal women.  Of course, none of the angry liberals on this site would dream of giving him credit.
A reformer????  Sold an airplane (at a lost) and fired the chef????  Is that all he could think of? Heaver help us, PLEASE.  
Perhaps Mr. McCain should stop lying over and over again.  Where is Pinocchio when we need him??  His surrogate, Eric Cantor from Virginia just stood there and lied to Norah O'Donnell on MSNBC.  The GOP lies and thinks we are going to be dumb again and elect them.
This could actually be the biggest story of the day - women of The View are tougher on McSame than the MSM.  I always knew I liked Barbara!
And we continue to let him get away with the lies. When are people going to see that this is just more of the same. McCain was brought down by this style of deceitful, dirty campaigning 8 years ago and now he has bought it lock, stock and barrel. The respect I once had for this man is gone. I really have a hard time believing that a good deal of the American public is actually falling for these tactics all over again. When did the people of this great country become so gullible? There was a GOP pundit on several nights ago and, while these are not his exact words, he basically said that as long as we keep putting out stuff like the "pig" story, they (the Obama campaign) would have to keep rebutting and the real issues facing every American would not be discussed. It's disgusting to me.
Hooray.  Finally someone takes McCain to task for his reckless and irresponsible decision-making and his LIES.  It's a sad state of affairs when The View has to do because the rest of the media is too scared of the GOP backlash.
No matter where they go, the McCains will lie their backsides off.  I guess it is true:  If you repeat the same thing long enough, people will think it is true.

Unbelievable.

BTW, kudos to Barbara Walters and Joy Behar.  Maybe they should ask the tough questions at the upcoming debates.
"actually, there not lies"

John, please explain why they are not, because these are strong accusations???  

Does anyone think Obama is dumb enough to call SP a pig? no.  Do conservatives think that by saying he did, the American people are dumb enough to believe it? yes.    

McCain (whom I supported in 2000) looks more and more Bush-like everyday.  
Amazing, the women on the View ask the tough, smart questions and in doing so, put the main stream media to shame.  
I hope MSNBC Tivo'd the "View" today.  Should be manditory viewing for all on MSNBC except Keith and Rachel.

Bob, Chicago
McCain stood behind his words in attack ads.. the one on the pig...the one about education.. and ended with, If Senator Obama would have met with me at Town Hall meetings it would not have gotten like this..
so what does that mean... If Barack would have let McCain define how and where he ran his campaign, McCain would have had honor...not lied, not hired Rove/Swiftboat people... would have had some ethics..??
I don't watch "The View" but I will start now----it took real women to ask the real hard questions!

First of all she did not fire the chef. The chef was reassigned to other duties. She did sell the plane at a loss. But let's get real anyone coming into that office with the political corruption surrounding the Republican party up there would have done the same thing. Second, I can't believe he stood by the answer that she did not lobby for pork projects when clearly she had even this year. Third, I love how he skirted the issue of the latest ad lies by changing the subject to town halls. I would like to see Obama do the town halls with McCain but that was not the question. Fourth, I think it's great that Cindy's father worked hard and made the family wealthy, but the fact of the matter is someone who has grown up in wealth and privilege cannot possibly understand the issues that those of us face living paycheck to paycheck.
Why is it that everytime McCain gets backed into a corner, as in when Joy asked him if he approved the untruthful ads, he resorts to 'Senator Obama declined to go to town hall meetings with me'?  He did the same thing on the Service Forum.  The McCain camp is getting desperate.

Please, we can't have 4 more years of this madness.  Americans are smarter and deserve more.  Obama '08!

I've never been a big fan of the view - but well done ladies!!!  I'm glad someone finally forced him to give some "straight" answers!
Old man, you're driving me up the wall with this passive-aggressive behavior regarding the negative stance your campaign has taken!

Are we to understand that you aren't responsible for the negative stances and flat-out lies in your ads against Obama...that he's responsible because he wouldn't agree to town halls with you?

"You won't appear with me?  Take that!  You made me do it to you!"

It makes you petty and childish.  Is this how you plan to deal with Putin, Chavez and Ahmedinejad?
I think we actually be witnessing the fall of the Republican Empire and the birth of a nation! Way to go ladies!
The only thing that I agree with as stated above by Sen. & Mrs. McCain is that the number of houses they own is not part of this campaign nor should it be.  On everything else, as printed above, Sedn. McCain either skirted the issue (stating that he's asked Sen. Obama to join him in town halls does not explain why his ads went so negative and false) or outright "misspoke" (from the little: she didn't fire the chef, she reassigned the chef.  Who then continued to cook for her kids.  To the large: his attack ads were, in fact, lies.  The sex-ed in particular is a bit hard to stomach).
McPain was so shady with his responses. He couldn't answer the question about what or who in Washington Palin would reform. He claims that his ads this past week are true. Come on McPain if you believe what you are saying you really are clueless.
Eventually, issues will need to be discussed and that will be the end of McCain. I just hope that people pay attention to the debates.
Even when confronted with his lies to his face, McCain just keeps lying.  Thank you Joy and Barbara for calling him on them.  
...Those Women on "The View" had John McCain squirming like a cat on a hot time roof....It was sooooo funny.  Can't wait to see him in the debates!!!!
Good job ladies. You nailed. Thank God am not the only one who is dissapointed wit their lies.
Thank god for the ladies on the View to ask the real questions the American people want to know.  We deserve to know the facts and the media prefers to talk about lipstick and other nonesense!  Wake up and do your job and report the facts to the American people!!! We are electing a President not the next"American Idol"!
As McCain appears to be keeping all of his plans on how he is going to resolve concerns on the American public, I do have another question for him.  He has stated that he can save $100 billion by eliminating earmarks, but according to factcheck.org, that is not substantiated by the facts.  I would appreciate his response to such a statement or is this just another of his rhetorical questions that we are supposed to believe because he "says so"?  Thanks
"He deserves credit for going into this den of angry liberal women.  Of course, none of the angry liberals on this site would dream of giving him credit. "


Thank you! What verve it took to take a couple hard questions! Truly, anyone who talks to Barbara Walters without hiding behind the skirt of a vicious librarian/moose-shooter is a True American Hero and deserves to be President for Life.



" and we are fortunate to be able to live a good life"


Very, very good. Sort of the priviledged class?

"and to share and give to other people who are not as fortunate."

Name two.

Let's have the View Hosts moderate the upcoming Presdiental and Vice Presidential debates. Perhaps then we might get some answers.

Are the rest of you as tired as I am of hearing McCain say if Obama had agreed to the town hall settings with McCain that his campaign (McCains)  would not have been as negative and nasty as it has been. Since when does McCain get to set the design, formula and structure of this campaign and if he does not get his way then since when does he have the right to turn negative and nasty? McCain's comments are a poor attempt to excuse his behavior and he knows it.  
the chef wasn't fired, she has been re-assigned; 'failin' has asked for earmarks ($200 million);  considering the government in alaska was in bad shape before failin came along, anyone who ran for office would be a reformer.  mcfailin can distort the truth for only so long, eventually the truth will prevail.    
Seems to me like McCain has found a blanket excuse for the dirtiest campaign tactics his campaign can dredge up.  Since Obama decided not to do the town halls, that justifies anything and everything.  Lies, distortions, distractions; it's all because Obama refused to do town halls.  If only we'd done town halls everything would be friendly and clean.  No doubt it helps him sleep at night and still believe that he's Mr. Straight-talk, but when are the voters going to wake up and realize he's a big league hypocrit fooling himself with a lame excuse!
So what is this crap he keeps saying (he said it last night during the Service Forum too), that if Barack Obama had only agreed to his request for 10 town hall meetings, the tenure of his campaign wouldn't be in the gutter.  

Are you kidding me???????  Is that what he's going to do to world leaders??  "You bully you, you didn't give me what I want so now I will trash you"???  

I didn't think we could ever have a more UN-presidential President than the one we currently have, but if this man gets elected he will actually make Bush look competent.  And that, "my friends" is the scariest thing I can imagine.

She fired the chef and got rid of an airplane! She fired the chef and got rid of an airplane! Is that it! Is that it! OMG

She probabaly sold the airplane to one of those groups she approved to hunt down and kill wolves in their natural habitat by plane or helicopter.  
Way to go Sisters of the View-thank you for being the voice for us- It takes guts and true journalism ethics to take a stand-You are my heros-

go sisters-go sisters!
LMFAO!!! I'd like to see the republicans play the sexist card with this one. I'm not one for these women network shows type but this is just pure priceless =)
It's amazing to see him lie with a straight face. Anything to get voted in again to continue the same old politics.
I give McCain a lot of credit to walk into the Den with all of the Female wolves in there waiting for him. But he does need to answer if he thinks that Mr Obama called Mrs Palin a pig or not, because if he doesn't then I guess he really did not "approve that message" By the way who exectly is running for President anyway is it John McCain or Sara Palin?
Just asking.

Obama/Biden 08'
It's a sad state of affairs when "The View" has to directly ask the tough questions, rather than the cable media, reporters, or debate hosts.
What is everyone blind? Anyone wonder how OBAMA would do on the show? McCain is being very careful using his words. Unlike OBAMA? Usually people review their speeches before going in front of an audience. This way they could decide if the Media will any of it against them. Gee I wonder, what kind of president would not review their speech? Please, people? Think about people?
Where was the "high five" Michelle Obama was greeted with when she was on The View?  Why didn't they ask Michelle about her remark "for the first time in my adult life, I am proud to be an American"?  PLEASE....the view crew is totally biased!!
If we're going to do this evenly then Obama should go on a conserative talk show (i.e. Hannity) in front of a live audience and get grilled. And believe me, he would.  Why McCain agree to this I'll never know.  Let's watch Obama stand in front of an audience and squirm while trying to defend 20 years with Pastor Wright while claiming he never knew his extreme views, and the benefits he received from the crook Rezko, and his strong friendship with terrorist Bill Ayers.  Let him stand in front of a pro life audience and talk about standing up for the weak in society while he radically defends partial birth abortion and won't even vote to allow surviving babies of failed abortions a shot to live.
Yippeee! The chicken has come home to roost!! He is an shameful figure to America today. Now get up and try again tomorrow!
I'm voting for McCain and Palin, and so are most of the women I know. Out there in 'View'land, McCain's pro-life stance might be odd, but the majority of American women in normal-America want to PROTECT life and know that ABORTION HURTS WOMEN. Thanks, Senator McCain!
Is it not funny that a show that is presented, not as a news show but as "woman's entertainment" is the one place where the tough questions were put to McCain? They had him sweating and stuttering like a busted shoplifter. I think that a few more tough questions would have sent him spinning like a Tasmanian Devil. Now it is time to put the focus where it belongs..on Grandpa McCain...and forget about "The one who shall not be named" That will self-destruct on her own.
Thank you ladies!  Finally, someone flat out calling McSame out on all his lies and propoganda.  I hope America got a great view of his quick temper and lack luster responses.  I'm surprised Elisabeth kept her moth shut as much as she did.  That's why they stuck her on the end of the couch!  I hope America, especially women really understand this "trojan moose" for what it really is...nothing but the same from McSame.  So was McSame saying that his vicious lies and smear tactics are in retribution for not debating? T  This is the man with enough moral and ethical judgement to put an unknown and inexperienced VP canidate on the ticket? I love how they wanted to take the oppertunity to be seen by the masses but can't answer the simple questions. How many houses you have? What real reform will Sarah bring and what has she truely done?  I love how he has to use his POW experience as a "life vest" when he's sinking in his own rhetoric and fumbles.  I pray the young and undecided understand that they are trying to hijack hope and change.  Thank you ladies.  You made my day and I'm so glad I TiVo'd it!  I can watch it all weekend just to watch his eyes roll back and his anger display again and again over his face.  What an angry, unhonorable man!  My husband and I are both registered Republicans voting for Obama.  I want real change for my children.  Change that is just not a slogan.  They aren't change, they just McSame.  Go Obama!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1386847

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google