ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



SEC chairman responds to McCain

Posted: Thursday, September 18, 2008 4:42 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC's Mark Murray
SEC Chairman Chris Cox just released this statement: "While I have great respect for Sen. McCain, we have sometimes disagreed, and this is one such occasion. The SEC has made plain that we have zero tolerance for naked short selling. In this market crisis, the men and women of the SEC have responded valiantly as they always do -- with the utmost dedication and professionalism. Addressing the extraordinary challenges facing our markets, the independent and bipartisan SEC has taken the following decisive actions."

More: "I very much appreciate the strong and immediate support of the president. As someone who has been in public life for over 20 years, I know as well as anyone that occasionally this sort of thing can come with the territory. The best response to political jabs like this is simply to put your head down and not lose a step doing the best job you can possibly do on behalf of those you serve. For my part, I plan to do just that. I leave the political campaigns to pursue their own course."

There is also the question whether McCain -- constitutionally -- could actually fire Cox if he were president. A 1935 Supreme Court decision said that FDR overstepped his bounds when he tried to dismiss a commissioner at the Federal Trade Commission.

However, the McCain camp argues that McCain could remove Cox as chairman, since the president gets to designate one of the SEC commissioners as chairman. "Not only is there historical precedent for SEC Chairs to be removed, the president of the United States always reserves the right to request the resignation of an appointee and to maintain the customary expectation that it will be delivered,” said spokesman Tucker Bounds in an email.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

With mccain's amount of errors coupled with sarah's we are in BIG trouble if they see the oval office
old quick trigger john and his "well thought out" executive decisions.
Wow!  McCain & Palin getting slapped by 'both sides'!!  tsk-tsk!  'tis not a good day for thee 'ol' boy' McCain!!
I mean WOW, Keep trying Mr McCain Maybe the bafoon will vote for you!
Of course McCain could do whatever he wants - He is McBush and they don't need guidelines, rules or even a constitution to get in their way.

That's some pretty crooked straight talk rhetoric he's got going on.  Too bad he has no grasp of the situation.  I just heard AIG's CEO is getting a $7M severance package.  r u freakin' kidding me?  Don't we have a say as to whether or not he is fired with cause?  How do these greedy b@st@rds live with themselves?  Un-freakin'-believable!
Hey, it may be semantics, but the President does not have the absolute authority to fire the Chairman of the SEC!!!

http://blogs.abcnews.com/politicalpunch/2008/09/from-the-fact-2.html

Anybody with a firm grasp of the US Economy should know that!

Bottom line, it's empty rhetoric...Old Man yells at cloud!
The end of the "Uptick Rule" that is a major cause of these componies' stock values to droping at unreal rate was implemented and defended by Cox. He must go and the Uptick Rule should be restored.
"Yea...and we're Republicans so we don't follow the law anyway!...and we do whatever we want to and then cover it up or claim Executive Privelage!" added Tucker Bounds
McCain is a hot head and he repeatedly shows it. We need a strong steady hand at the helm of our government.

If it were left to a McCain / Palin ticket, we would be having WWIII with Russia now and would be bankrupt to boot.

No, no... no McCain, please God no!


http://laststopmidwest.blogspot.com
The President of the United States DOES NOT HAVE THE AUTHORITY to fire the SEC Chair, because the SEC is an independent regulatory commission. After a lifetime in the Senate and two runs for the Presidency, McCain still doesn't know what it is, exactly, that the President can and cannot do.

Back in the 1930s, McCain was born and President Franklin Delano Roosevelt "fired" a member of the Federal Trade Commission; later, the Supreme Court ruled the President had acted unconstitutionally.

There is no amount of spin from the McCain-Pain campaign that can explain McCain's lack of understanding about this basic separation of powers. It looks like McCain knows as much about the economy as Palin knows about foreign relations. The fundamentals of his campaign are about as strong as the fundamentals of our economy.
mccain stinks and Obama rules!
McCain has gone out of bounds and over the edge in calling for the Chairman of the SEC to be fired, especially given McCain's shakey grasp of economics. The current POTUS gets to make that choice, not a candidate for that job. It doesn't make McCain look any better or smarter to be making such rash comments for political gain (or in this case, probably political loss). He must be getting REALLY desperate...
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com/
Or he could have said 'whasup dawg'? Isn't that what modern gangsters say when they've just been rolled over on by one of their own?
So now McCain wants to re-write history to his advantage.  Of course, that's what he's been trying to do this entire campagin by lying about his own record.

Maybe he should stop trying to sound like a politician and give up some REAL answers.
Sound like McGrumpy and Caribou Barbie are on the same page with this one.  Let's just fire people without cause.

Sorry McBush we won't welcome you to the White House.

Obama 08
Of course a president can remove an appointtee.  Good lord, First Read, READ A BOOK.
John "DEREGULATOR" McCAIN; 26 YEARS OF TELLING US THAT GOVERNMENT HAS NO PLACE UNTIL AMERICA GOES TO HELL IN A HAND BASKET AND THEN IT'S WHERE'S THE GOVERNMENT TO BAIL US OUT OF THIS MESS.

McCAIN CAN BLAME THE CHAIR OF THE SEC, BUSH, REPUBLICANS AND PRETEND THAT HE'S NOT A DEREGULATOR BUT JUST CHECK THE RECORDS ON THE BOOKS AND WATCH THE VIDEO, 26 IN TOTAL FROM JUST THIS YEAR MAKING FUN OF THE GOVERNMENT AND TELLING US GOVERNMENT DOESN'T BELONG IN OUR BUSINESS

REPUBLICANS AND McCAIN RAN UP A DEFICIT OF $10TRILLION DOLLARS GETTING "RICH AND ENRICHING THEIR FRIENDS, ENRICHING WALLSTEET AND THE CORPORATIONS"

BUT KEPT TELLING US TO APPROPRIATELY USE GOVERNMENT FOR THE VERY TAX PAYERS WHO KEEPS PAYING THESE CROOKS IS JUST WRONG.

WELL JOHN McCAIN AND HIS MERRY BAND OF CROOKS CAN GO FLY NO MORE

SEN. OBAMA 2 YEARS AGO CALLED COR REGULATION BECAUSE WALLSTREET WAS RUNNING WILD, THEY IGNORED

SO WE WILL IGNORE MCCAIN AND THE REPUBLICANS AT THE POLLS

NOW IT'S ABOUT OUR MONEY, OUR RETIREMENT AND OUR VERY LIVES, THEY CAN GO FLY
Perhaps Gov Palin's firing record has inspired McCain to acquire one of his own.
McCain believes you Act first -- Think second. What a comforting quality in a CIC.
Non story.  John is just trying to pander to the middle-class.  Nice try John, but we don't buy it anymore!!
McSame gets OWNED again.

Like Barack said today, "that's fine to fire one guy, BUT HOW ABOUT FIRING THAT WHOLE CROWD!"

Vets for Obama
Gotta love McCain speaking from his arse...

when are the american people going to see this ticket for the joke they are?  Tucker Bounds is a pathetic waste of oxygen who has no idea what the truth, honor, or basic human decency is.  i loved watching that Fox anchor make him look like a fool, not that it is that hard really...

http://horneddevil.proboards98.com/index.cgi?board=iduspolitics
Could we get Hector Sants to take the job?
I am an Orange County Dem, who supports Chris Cox. He is one of the most trusted politians in the OC and actually has more integruity then John McCain and Lipstick Palin
Looks like he would handle dissent just like BUSH 44!!!
The real question is, "Who will John McCain replace him with".  Hopefully, its not the same person who told him the economy was "Fundamentally Strong".
LOL...

Tough guy McCain is going to fire SEC chairman. Wow, he's a tough guy maverick. He's going to fire someone. Damn, look out. He's on fire and he's pissed at the SEC chairman and firing him is going to fix the market meltdown.

What a tool.
McCain is becoming more and more detached. Either McCain doesn’t know much about checks and balances or he wants to the oldest man in US history that he will say and do anything.
People how much more can you tolerate?

Stop glossing over!
No way!
No how!
No McCain/Palin!
Nobody but Obama/Biden

"I leave the political campaigns to pursue their own course".

Sounds like Chairman Cox is telling McCain to stick it up his a--.

Is this not a typicel response from McCain? Everything has to be fight, war, sabre rattling, firing, aggression, shoot from the hip for McCain. And with a VP running mate who apparently has the same kind of attitude and style this country better be darn sure that these two do not get into the Whitehouse. Otherwise these two will rip this country and any internnational relations apart.
WE AS VOTERS SHOULD FIRE EVERYONE...THIS ENTIRE GEORGE BUSH ADMINISTRATION.  THE BUCK STOPS AT THE DOOR STEP OF MR. BUSH.  SO, THEY SHOULD GO.

ALSO, MR. McCAIN SHOULD NOT BE HIRED AS PRESIDENT BECAUSE HE, AS A REPUBLICAN, WILL HIRE THE CURRENT ADMINISTRATION BACK.  NET EFFECT...NO CHANGE.
Keep making mistakes. He looks so unprofessional.
That's John McCain:

Ready, Fire, Aim!
Did Chris Cox make a pass at Cindy McCain? (That was tongue in cheek for those who want to bash my previous statement and accuse me of not reading the article.) Oh the abuse of power.....John and Sarah were made for each other.
SEC can only work with the regulations they are given.
Was McCain thinking when he said he would fire the SEC Chairman?  During time of turmole there is no logic to fire someone unless they caused the turmole or was not handling the situation.  Chairman Cox is doing his best with what was handed to him by lack of regulation enforcement by the current administration.

This looks like another McCain flying off the handle without understanding the situation or looking at long term effects.  This is not the type of President we need during very trying times.
McCain is correct about the firing.  
I know this is a disappointment for all of you MSNBC Obama "ites" who have made a sham of professional journalism with your biased reporting.  Trust me, there many women like me who know what your agenda is. I miss Tim Russert who may have been able to reel all of you in back to reporting instead of the propaganda that you report daily to soothe to your democratic base.  I used to watch you, but now I just change the channel.
McCain thought that SEC referred to the Southeastern Conference.
Gee I wish someone would fire McCain.
As a former member of the SEC Advisory Committee on Smaller Public Companies my experience with both the staff at the SEC and Chairman William Donaldson and the Chairman Chris Cox was instructive to me. As a financial advisor to and a financier of micro and small cap companies who were getting the short end of the investment community's attention we had a respectful, comprehensive and ultimately successful response while working to advocate market reforms. Mr McCain may catch a headline but the public will not be well served by firing Mr Cox.
McBush said he thinks, “The fundamentals of our economy are strong.” He said this on the same day that the DOW plummeted, and since then, it has continued to plummet, and only starting to rebound today…who knows about tomorrow. Remember when you told us the economy was not your strongest subject McBush? Thanks for not lying to us on that one.

http://lastofourkind.blogspot.com
I agree with Obama in his New Mexiico Speech
FIRE THEM ALL

OBAMA/BIDEN 08
FIRE THE DUDE THAT DID WHAT YOU TOLD HIM TO????

It's the SEC chairman's responsibility to carry out the policies/laws that are given to him.  I don't think he's not culpable at all--but I KNOW that the policies of deregulation got us where we are.

Who got us here??
Who loves deregulation??

Phill Gramm.
John McCain.
Sarah Palin.
It's a little late for Mr. McCain to be calling for the SEC to come down hard on Wall St. when he was the one that helped take the teeth out of the SEC with his desire to deregulate everything. This is what happens when you let the market take over without ANY rules---Greed becomes king.

Can someone tell me what exactly Mr. McCain's plan is? First, the economy is strong, then we're in crisis; then, it's form a commission to study it while Americans are losing their jobs at an alarming rate and Wall St. crumbles; then, it's fire the SEC chief and start regulating everything after he's called for deregulating everything for at least 10 years. Enough is Enough!
McCain will fire his own mother if it will get him into the office!  Desperately seeking ANYTHING that could get him elected...will say or do anything!

This is what it has come to...huh...SAD!
If we are to blame anyone we should start with ourselves.  American's oversimplification of the government is part of the problem.  We have vilified the important role of government with a "throw out the baby with the bathwater" mentality.  Replacing it with an unrealistic "the freemarket will do what is right".  Right for who?  

We don't want any taxes but we complain because we don't have services.  We don't want government oversight of food, drugs, safety, water, etc. but we want to be fixed by the government everytime something goes wrong.  

Look at the number of red states suffering under the hits of gustov and ike.  How many want less government and less taxes if it means that they can't get food, water and shelter?  

As someone said today government needs to be not to big, not to small, not to impotent and not to agressive, but just right.  This means that you have to bring a common sense to the art of balancing the roll government needs to play in our lives vs the oversimplified view promoted by most politicians.  

I'm tired of the quick sound bites vs. dialogue.  

I watch the blogs and see this play out in a rude and nonsensical dialgue most of the time.  

What about thought vs. knee jerk sound bites even within the blogs.  
What I hate about McCain and Palin: neither of them think before they make threatening statements.  The office of the presidency is not a game show (yes, it turned into one with Bush admin).  This is a place where you hope the P and VP take careful, intelligent thought before they announce a strategy.  Americans, you will not get that from a C student (Bush)...we learned that lesson after 8 embarrassing years.  You will not get it from an ex-POW or a hockey mom with little educational background and political background.  For once, aim for a smart, well educated person, who gives great thought to his words and actions.  This crazy shot of threatening words to the SEC Chairman was not helpful, especially in our current financial/economic crisis.  It is a little bit like killing all the firemen because they couldn't get the raging fire out!  Easy for McCain to point his finger and get out his hatchet.  Obama/Biden '08/12.  Thank you.
John McCain is flailing about.
Senator McCain should fire HIMSELF!
Me thinks McCain protest to much. This is the man who made the SEC toothless. McCain talks the talk but sure can not walk the walk. Besides as he informed the ladies on the VIEW he is a strict constructionist on the Constitution. This means those activists judges and those amendements can all be washed away with McCain as President.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1419991

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google