ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



In 'policy speech,' McCain slams Obama

Posted: Friday, September 19, 2008 11:32 AM by Carrie Dann

From NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner and NBC's Carrie Dann
GREEN BAY, Wisc. -- In what was dubbed a ‘policy speech’ by the campaign, John McCain addressed members of the Green Bay Chamber of Commerce this morning, giving a distilled version of his plan for the economy that offered few new specifics but ample critiques of his opponent’s proposals to fix the nation’s money woes.
 

Video: Presidential candidate John McCain lays out his plan to reform the U.S. financial sector and its regulation, and also proposes tax cuts for workers.

In his remarks, McCain repeated his plan for the creation of a Mortgage and Financial Institutions trust, which he described as “an early intervention program” with the mission “to identify institutions that are weak and fix them before they become insolvent.”

“The underlying principle of the MFI or any approach considered by Congress should be to keep people in their homes and safe guard the life savings of all Americans by protecting our financial system and capital markets,” he said. “That has to be the fundamental principle.”

McCain did not identify how the MFI would fix these institutions, but he did differentiate it from the Resolution Trust Corporation, which McCain said acted reactively rather than proactively. 

Turning to the economic proposals of his opponent, McCain described Barack Obama as a Washington insider immersed in the environment of negligence that created the current crisis. "We've heard a lot of words from Senator Obama over the course of this campaign," he said. "But maybe just this once he could spare us the lectures, and admit to his own poor judgment in contributing to these problems. The crisis on Wall Street started in the Washington culture of lobbying and influence peddling, and he was right square in the middle of it."

The GOP nominee stressed the ties of Jim Johnson and Frank Raines, who he calls advisors to the Obama campaign, to the mortgage giants many blame for spurring the current financial collapse (It's the same criticism also voiced in a series of television and web ads created by the McCain campaign in the last 48 hours.)

Offering a comparison of each candidate’s tax proposals, McCain also said that Obama has “continuously shifted his position on taxes.” 

“Senator Obama has simply not given Americans good reason to trust him with your tax dollars,” he said.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Obama is whack. Biden is whack.

You've got to stand for something or you'll fall for anything. That's just a small part of the reason I like John McCain.
What a joke this MFI plan is.  The first two letters say it all.  He gives no plan, just slams Obama for the problem he helped create over his 26 year career of being in big banking's pocket.  We can't trust the fundamental deregualtor to now become the fundamental regulator.  That's just putting the fox in charge of guarding the hen house.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
Blah Blah Blah verbal diahrea.

Shouldnt Obama and Biden simply reply to McCain.

Phil Graham, Phil Graham, Phil Graham
“Senator Obama has simply not given Americans good reason to trust him with your tax dollars,” he said.

And, Sen. McCain, you have?????
So he's against the "alphabet soup" of regulatory agencies, but he's advocating adding another agency?

Like we can trust this fundamental deregulator with becoming a born again regulator.  As always "Herbert Hoover" McCain is light on specifics and heavy on Obama bashing lies.

Now he's saying no more bailouts and next week I'm certain he'll change his tune as we watch the Bush League administration bail out more of their Wall Street white collar criminal supporters.

Obama/Biden 08/12!
Yawn...
McCain cant slam anyone , he has no policy, doesnt
understand policy, he gets his policy from the bushies he he let take ove his campaign. He has to wait on a dailey basis to find out what to say and where to say it. We all know McCain does not speak for the McCain campaign.

Obama/Biden
marty
Even McCain's most ardent supporters feel the pain when he is stumbling through his notes. His message is always lost unless it is read later. You can't help but think of him cheating at solitare then putting on that big phony political grin and waving his stubs when he wins. He has wanted to be president for all the wrong reasons even before he took money from Keating. It is very sad to watch any senior embarrass themselves in this way.
I listened to Obama on CNN Live and his measured and intelligent manner sure gives me a lot more confidence than McCain's flailing about, searching for the populist answer.
There are several extremely capable people working on the problems with our economy; John McCain is not one of them.
"Slam!!" It's McCain v. Obama, in a smack down media inspired cage match for "WWEF", the World Wide Election Federation!!!! "Afford no man quarter, be he the looser!!!" It's a duel to the death! NO medical care will be provided!!!

BTW...if the race is too close to call, Emperor Diebold will make the final decision about who wins or looses this election!

Whats that you say Emperoro Diebold....your voting machines have McCain at 48%?

McCain Wins!!!! So let it be written, so let it be done!

America really is the modern day Rome. It's repulsive and compelling at the same time.

Another day at the Colliseum, anyone?

Let's see what political bloodsport we have on tap for today....in the meantime, can you grab me something off that vendor's tray, dear...

Cigars! Cigarettes! Cold Beer! Hotdogs! Various other Fatty Foods for copious American consumption!
Seems to me the McCain campaign has been listening to pundits, and is trying to make the issue of the election about 'who u trust more'.

However, no matter what names he throws out there, as long as Phil Gramm is as involved in McCain's campaign as he is now, no other association will compare.  Especially, false associations.

So, McCain- get real.  Now that Gramm's 'mental recession' is hitting Americans so hard, it IS Obama we trust with our tax dollars.  And with Obama in office, I will keep more of my dollars.  How about on Nov 4- Sen McCain- we tell you 'thanks, but no thanks' on that presidential election bid.
Barack Obama - I want my rebate check, and I want it now!!
McCain is kidding us right?  Has his positions not shifted repeatedly over the last 48 hours?  I don't like the government takeover, I do like the takeover.  I am for de-regulation, I am for regulation.  Obama's tax plan has been consistent from the beginning.  It is McCain who can't see past the ideals of the same old worn out trickle down approach.  
For John McCain to claim that Obama's "poor judgment" has contributed to the current financial problems, and that he's "square in the middle of Washington's culture of lobbying and influence peddling" is just the latest McCain distortion of the facts, and further sign of his desperation.

It's McCain -- not Obama -- who has been part of the Washington influence scene for a quarter of a century, and whose campaign staff is run by lobbyists.

The press shouldn't let McCain get away with lies like this!
McCain's trying to have it both ways.  On one hand,he scorns Obama as being an inexperienced neophyte who's only been in the U.S. Senate for less four years (while touting the "experience" of his running mate, who's been governor of a lightly-populated state for less than two years, after being the mayor of town of under 9,000 people).

Now, McCain - who's been in Congress of 26 years! - is calling Obama the "Washington insider."  

Something tells me McCain is confused about more things than the Prime Minister of Spain...
Where's the Obama response guys?  Get with it!  This creton just enjoys LYING so much it is ridiculous!  Is that all you have left?!

Stop yelling at the clouds!!!
This county needs higher taxes. It's the patriotic thing to do. I trust people that don't know a thing about handling money spending my hard earned paycheck any way they please. Please, here, just take my money. And once you do take it, I'll be sure to vote for you over and over again because I know you are much smarter then me.
Interesting how McCain calls someone who he often characterizes as "inexperienced" is somehow an insider. This from a man who has been in the Senate for 26 years and has a campaign staffed with lobbyists. McCain talks out of the side of his mouth, not believing anything he himself says!
Well I have said it before, and I will say it again.  When America needed John McCain the most - in 2004 when Kerry asked him to be his running mate and defeat Dubya, McCain, instead of putting HIS country first and being a real maverick - turned his back on us (U.S.)  Now, we are four more long years down a deep hole - when we could have been 4 years closer to fixing all of Bush's messes.  Thanks for nothing Patriot!!!
And where, oh where, has the wolf in sheep's clothing McCain been while the Resolution Trust Company and all those other federal agencies were acting with the  reckless abandon he now describes?

I'll tell you where he was.  In the back pockets of industry lobbyists while in Washington, and out on the campaign trail, calling himself the maverick champion of deregulation.  

If he's so out of touch that he doesn't recognize the irony in proposing to create an agency whose acronym begins with "MF" and ends with "I," then he's WAY too out of touch for America.  I know no one else who doesn't get that joke.  Or maybe, just maybe, the joke is intended to be on us.  Once again.  
Blaming Obama for this crisis is like McCain't blaming Obama for $4 per gallon gas.  Its so ludicrous its laughable. How much credibility does this guy have left? He used to be somewhat reasonable and honest. Its sad really. I hope independent voters can see through all of this and vote for real change and a dose of reality.
Spin on spin on spin..didn't McCain say the government should never bail out the home profit takers i.e. (banker)...Well, John just how do you and where do draw the line on what's really going on with Americans housing remembering how many homes you have..?
Institutions not Americans are the problem..houses aren't the problem, government is the problem and by your cronies deregulating the MONEY markets and  credit vehicles..YOU John McCain were the one in the drivers sit for this train wreck in the financial sectors of this "country first"!!!!
It's land deals and bankers all over again..Keating 5

If it doesn't fix soon the republicans will let it happen again!!

We need Obama/Biden even more now...
Obama is the insider?!!!!! That has got to be the biggest laugh of the day.

I hope the Green Bay Chamber members looked more forward to their lunch then they did listening to Chief McCain speak in fork tongue.

Your grasping at straws McCain and it is showing. Big time.
He's got nothin', so he slams Obama.  This is what McCain has done on every issue.  He can't come up with any solutions himself, so he tries to smear Obama instead.  I just watched Obama's press conference and he actually took a day to meet with ecomonic experts and come up with a plan, not just for the short term, but for the future as well.  He didn't waste any time attacking McCain, he just laid out his own plan to address the crisis.  This is leadership, not school-yard bullying.
Does anyone care that while we are bailing out Wall Steet to the tune of potentially 1 Trillion Dollars (thank you Phil Gramm & John McCain) on Main Street tent cities are popping up all over the U.S.

This is not a time to even consider allowing four more years of this neglect of Main Street, USA .............

No Way, No How, No Palin/McCain!!!!!!
At this point, I am just sick of John McCain, and I liked him in 2000. The man cannot say anything without lying, and his hypocrisy is beyond belief.

It's nice that he's dreamed up this MFI plan, but considering that Obama had a similar but better plan back in MARCH. McCain has not only flip-flopped on regulation, he is also making this stuff up on the fly, which means he's stealing all the good points from Obama.
McCain, who admittedly doesn't really understand this whole economy thing, is nevetheless going on a rampage this week looking for the enemy.

Maybe it's just "evil" and "greed"

Maybe it's the head of the SEC.

Maybe it's Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Maybe it's just "Wall Street"

Maybe it's the head of the FEC (but I think that was a "senior" moment.

And in that vein, maybe it's SPAIN.

Is this Presidential?  Can we count on him to kill kittens in the Oval office when he is frustrated?

He's losing it, people.  Before our eyes.  Take off your blinders.
Wow, it truly doesn't matter to McCain what he says anymore.   Truth has gone out the window and he's just hpoing something....anything sticks.
Mccain is for himself not Country.  He should be talking about fixing the problem.  
Don't if anybody bothered to tell McCain but Frank Raines and Barack have nothing to do with one another.
Just add to the list of Mc lies. Per Howard Fineman>
The 'speech' was truely a bait and switch and it looks like the media bought it.

The sad thing is that many under informed Americans will buy it too.
Does attacking always work?  It seems Mccain is a little flat footed here.  Obama has been going after Mccain and his policies all week.  Then once the Bush Adminstration and the Congress decided to work together to get something done, Obama turns and looks to solve issues rather than play politics.  Ii it possible that Mccain was to late in his attacks and they were not timely, given the state of affairs throughout the week and acknowledgement that any plan surmised by the candidates will not effect the immediate crisis?  Also it is Friday the slow news day.  It seems for attacks to work they have to been discussed and processed in the media and in the community. But with Paulson, Bernake and Congress working on a deal over the weekend, solutions for this problem will be discusssed not attacks.  Timing is everything.  
McCain's plan = We need to fix this mess...That Obama created...in the two years he was in the Senate...

Nice try...but it was your deregulation that caused this mess and now he's calling for regulation that he stood against his whole career...Doesn't sound like a 'maverick' to me...sounds like a daisy blowing in whatever the daily poll winds are heading.

McCain = Bush = No new ideas = our country will be run by the same people that are running his campaing = Bush's 3rd term

Obama = New ideas = fresh start = end of curruption in Washington

Easy choice here people!
He's officially entered the delusional stage now...

Raines is not an advisor to the Obama campaign - FACT.

Johnson left the campaign because of the stink raised by McVain over Obama's home loan, but Johnson also left Fannie Mae in 1998, well before our current crisis began - FACT.

Obama has not modified his stance on taxes while running against McCain - FACT.

McCain is hoping he can pull the wool over the eyes of the American people and will say and do anything to get elected - FACT!
Obama is whack. Biden is whack.

You've got to stand for something or you'll fall for anything. That's just a small part of the reason I like John McCain.
**************************************************
sad when someone votes for a candidate based on their personality. Me? I would love the chance to go to college which is why I'm voting Obama.
Hey Full Moon:

"You've got to stand for something or you'll fall for anything. That's just a small part of the reason I like John McCain."

Nice lyrics.  You do know that John Mellenkamp is an Obama supporter?  Let me guess- you also believe that Springsteen's "Born in the USA" is a rah-rah patriot anthem, right?
Thanks, my friend. I'm watching my retirement annuity bounce all over the place but never reach the levels it was before you jokers took office in 2000. I really, really appreciate how you take the time to put yourself first by tearing down your opponent.

It's a nice touch. It reinforces how lame you are. Barack Obama wisely called for everyone to join together to fix this sh*tstorm you and Phil Gramm created and what are you doing? Whining about Obama?

Spare me your politics because I am certainly sparing you my vote.
You liberals really make me laugh with your blind allegiance to this Socialist and constant repeating of the Democratic talking points. You people are so angry about this mess that was created by "Bush and McCain" but somehow you don't seem to put any blame on Chris Dodd or Barney Frank. Their main job was to oversee this kind of stuff and nobody wants to hold them accountable. McCain argued for reform of Freddie and Fannie back in 2005 and was rebuffed by the like of Frank and Dodd. I suppose Obama was thinking about his run for President at this time because we didn't hear a peep from him. As usual, Obama waits for a crisis and then jumps in and says he knew it was coming even though there is no evidence of him ever doing anything proactively. But what the hell....why let facts get in the way of a good story.
Obama made much $$$ from Fannie and Freddie while others suffered.

Does anyone with any common sense here get what BHO is really about?
So, what would McCain (Palin) do if he (she) get elected ?

Keep yelling at Barack Obama ? Seems to be the plan.
Amazing! "McCain described Barack Obama as a Washington insider immersed in the environment of negligence that created the current crisis"  

Yet is this not the same McCain who told us Obama had NOT been in Washington long enough?  Is this not the same McCain that was part of the Keeting 5 (speaking of CREATING PROBLEMS)?  

Is this not the SAME McCain that has been a Senator of 20+ years and is the ULTIMATE DC insider?

Oh please.  Who writes this stuff for him?  Or does he just pull it out of his lying butt?
Why would America REWARD complete Republican failure ?

We wont.
Who was the one who was the chair of the Senate Commerce Committee?  Who was the one who was and still is a close ally of Phil Gramm, who wrote the deregulation legislation that got us in this mess?
John McCain.  Maybe he should just this once spare us the same old politically and morally bankrupt false attacks and live up to his claim to put "country first" and admit that he is partly responsible for this mess!  I'm sick of the same old trickle-down conservative garbage coming out of McCain's greedy pie-hole. He got us in this mess, Obama will fix it!
Oh McCain's quick action is to form a commission or now a new government agency (thought you were for smaller government) to come up with an idea to solve the problem.  McCain can't have a solution so lets increase government.  

Oh yeah Full Moon--McCain stands for something but don't worry he will change his mind in a few hours.

It is interesting that 4 years ago the same people who like McCain were saying Kerry was a flip flopper, but not they like flip floppers.  Oh what 4 years does to you.  McCain stands for nothing but what will get him elected.  He puts McCain First.
Let's see if I got this right.  Big financial institutions, with the permission of the administration, have sold me a mortgage I can't afford, doubled the price of a gallon of gas, shipped my job overseas and lost whatever little savings I had!

Now, I have to bear the brunt, as a taxpayer, of their mismanagement!  This is really adding INSULT to INJURY!

McSame, what off-shore account are you and the Beer Baroness using to hide your money?
It appears to me that John McCain gets up every
morning, someone hands him a piece of paper and tells
him this is what you are going to say today. He is depending on those idiots who are running his campaign to take him to the White House. I am absolutely dumbfounded how Americans are falling for
the same old Republican tricks they use every election. The country is in deep financial stress and John McCain claims no responsiblity for it. For his 26 years in Congress he now wants to proclaim
that he has solutions to our economic crisis. It's
laughable and really quite pathetic.



theres a clear act of one being irresponsible here... it's McCain.  This Clown has been shooting from the hip every since he said the fundamentals of the economy were strong.

I think the repugs are trying to show that they don't "BLINK" and it's costing them this election.  By McClown coming out everyday with a new position it makes them look incompetent.  What Obama is doing is having his economic advisors stew over the proposal that the Fed and Sec of Treasury came up with and they will then add to it... or say what they disagree with.  

McClown on the other hand is trying to jump ahead of the action that is taking place... then they had to reposition themselves time and time again!  People can clearly hear the flip-flopping that's taking place... it's almost embarassing.

almost as bad as the "Palin/McCain"... I mean McCain/Palin ticket.  This guy know's he's such a loser, he's having her put her name first in hopes that some voters will be dumb enough to think she's running for president.
FR, stop getting our expectations up by calling things like this a Slam.  I was expecting something more than the same tired McCain double speak.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1424983

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google