ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Palin: Ahmadinejad 'must be stopped'

Posted: Monday, September 22, 2008 10:13 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From NBC's Domenico Montanaro
Palin has an op-ed in the New York Sun, with what would have been her remarks had she still been attending an anti-Iran rally.

She calls for sanctions on Iran's Central Bank and asks for a "call for action" against the country. "We gather here today to highlight the Iranian dictator's intentions and to call for action to thwart him. He must be stopped. The world must awake to the threat this man poses to all of us."
 
And this: "Earlier this year, Senator Clinton said that 'Iran is seeking nuclear weapons, and the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps is in the forefront of that' effort. Senator Clinton argued that part of our response must include stronger sanctions, including the designation of the IRGC as a terrorist organization. John McCain and I could not agree more. Senator Clinton understands the nature of this threat and what we must do to confront it." 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

This idiot will get us all killed--Palin that is.
really, sarah, and i bet you figured that out all on your own, I'm sure he is shaking in his boots at the though that sarah, a person that had to go to 6 colleges to get a undergrad degree. i bet this moment that iran is dismantling there reactor right now!!!
what i dumb statement!!! from a nobody!!!! hillary and barck can say this, even mccain can say this, joe biden can say this, sarah you should go back to the(i told congress thanks, but no thanks!!!)
No this woman and McBush must be stopped they are going to drive this country straight to hell.She is a fringe lunatic that gives religion a bad name and he is a war monger the two of them in power will be the end of any chance of world peace. Her meeting with world leaders will have the same effect it has when I hear her. I wish she would just shut up and go away. Unfortuanantly if people believe the the hype for what ever reason they chose . She could be in charge in no time. Very  unfunny and scary .
Too bad Clinton chickened out.  I still can't believe she did that. Scared? Pouting? Or, afraid Sarah would get more attention? Just not the HRC I thought I knew.

Question:  If Obama wins, will he take his oath on the Bible or Mao's Red Book?
Stop using Hillary Clinton like if you and her are buddies!!!  Hillary doesn't back you!!  Shameful pandering to women!  Women on this blog: Don't you feel offended by Palin's naked attempts to pander to you??!  Seriously, don't you?  I would like to know what you ladies think.
So now she is a saber rattling foreign policy expert?

How, pray, would this country be able to afford a war with Iran after giving Wall Street 700 billion?
Nice try, Sarah.

Clinton called for "tougher sanctions," yes.  What she DIDN'T call for was a gleeful enthusiasm to "bomb, bomb, bomb...bomb, bomb Iran!"

If McCain/Palin get in, we'll have plenty more needless wars.  Why talk to people, why negotiate with people when you can just drop a bomb on them?

It's the Republican way!
lol

Who wrote this?

Why?

Do they really think we are THAT stupid to believe that Gov. Palin has developed an opinion on Iran in 3 weeks? Even if she did, why is this coming from her and not John McCain? Who cares what she thinks about it?
Yes, yes it's true we have all been sleeping. Thank goodness for the 3am Palin wake-up call to the rescue. Yawn....
Sqwaaaak!  Palin want a cracker.  
Does the hockey mom know how to reference anyone other than Hillary Clinton and John McCain?  Hillary Clinton doesn't agree with anything that she does.
"The world must awake to the threat this PALIN PERSON poses to all of us."
But before he is stopped, you must stop lying. And if you truly believe in your religion that condemns lying, then you are a hypocrite. You cannot lie and be deeply religious at the same time.
Ehh, Iranian dictator? Ahmadenijad is democratically elected president.

And this woman could be a hearbeat away from the presidency... scary!
"Dictator" is she talking about Ahmedinijad(sic)? He is the PRESIDENT of Iran. He was elected. Iran is a theocracy led by the Ayatolla Khomeni, but she wasn't talking about him. This woman seriously has no knowledge of world affairs at all. What is really sad, is that you know her handlers proof read this, and even they didn't know the structure of the Iranian government. Sad... Truly sad... Please don't put these imbeciles in charge again.
Bomb, Bomb, Bomb...Bomb, Bomb Iran has another chorus member.  Don't ever expect the neocons to give up until they trigger the Apocalypse.  This woman qualifies as a Right Wing Nut Job!
Palin: "John McCain and I could not agree more."

Actually that's pretty funny, given that the McCain staff wrote her remarks, which then were repackaged for this article.

But then again, maybe she can see the Straits of Hormuz from her front porch, too.
She can't see Iran from Alaska so what gives her the right to say that? Shoot a moose, have a beer, drop a nuke on Iran, all in a days work.
i guess palin & mccain's own advisers don't know that iran has a democracy! when the speak abut ahmedinijad as a dictator, they are speaking about someone who was elected!
Hmmm, wonder which Bush flunkie wrote the piece??
Senator Clinton does know what to do....Elect Barach Obama and begin meaningful negociations.....

But don't take my word for it, or Sarah's for that matter....just ask Clinton.
She is 100% correct ! We must stop them or there will be a big war. These peple are not mentality  safe  with neclear weapons. I know Obama wants to talk o them as beg them to behave. But I take offense to that, ONLY in a Obama lead America would we as AMERICAN beg again country ! Just not right !
No  Obama here !!!!
Please, please, Sarah, just cool your jets for a couple of minutes. Barack's got the whole thing under control. Obama will give Ahmadinejad a quick talking to, and then he'll see things our way. Soon enough both Barack and Ahmadinejad will go bowling together.
Join in the chorus....Bomb, Bomb, Bomb, Bomb, Bomb Iran.  You call yourself a change agent????  Whats your husband's take on this subject???  Does he have last word??

Bob, Chicago
Someone please stop this manical liar before she hurts herself in addition to 300 million others!  

This is pure lunacy! It is getting much too perposturous to even respond to intelligently.  

mccain/palin/bush/cheney/rnc have crossed the line into insanity.  Their desperation is fueling the most inept, dangerous and pathetic campaign. They are succeeding at palin causing justified fear among voters.
I think we must first awake to the threat of what the Republicons are doing to our country.
After reading the "remarks" she would have made she dares to accuse the Democrats of turning the protest into a partisan political affair?

What she just gave was a stump speech and that is exactly what the organizers of the event appear to have not wanted.

There is a term for what Governor Palin has displayed...lack of judgement.
Sooooo, does Palin think she is running as Clinton's VP candidate?  
Bomb Bomb Bomb, Bomb Bomb Iran.
Bomb Bomb Bomb, Bomb Bomb Iran.
bomb Iran, thats McCain's plan
plans to bomb Iran.

Bomb it with drones, bomb it with planes
bomb Iran.
Bomb Bomb Bomb, Bomb Bomb Iran.
Bomb Bomb Bomb, Bomb Bomb Iran.

i could go on, but i think you get the point...

How much of Iran's current view has to do with the unchecked Neo-con agenda carried out over the past 30 years?  
Is McCain able to achieve peace in the middle east when it is obvious that his only interest is military victory in a place where victory is impossible?  (The surge didn't work, paying enemy combatants not to shoot at our troops is why violence is down. and the political goals of the surge are far from being met...)

leave your war rhetoric at the  door political barbie.

Boycotting all talk of that person
Now who believes Palin wrote the op-ed piece?  Who believes Palin understands the complexities of the situation as well as the ramifications?  Would Palin have been able to write this a month ago?  Would Palin be able to have an in-depth discussion on this issue or when will she discuss this issue with someone not just read a speech or give a sound bite answer.
This is like all the other junk mail we all get every day. Just recognize it for what it is and throw it in the trash.
This person would make us all into Kamikaze pilots. The mere fact that she makes these kinds of statements after being exposed to the International scene for just three weeks is astounding and reckless beyond imagination. This isn't Alaska, Senator Palin. This is the big leagues and you're not ready. You may never be.
i wonder who wrote the op-ed for her. she didn't know what iran's central bank was before someone briefed her on it last week.
Nice speech - obviously written by members of the Bush team.  This woman is totally unqualified to be McCain's running mate.  She did not have a passport until 2006 and her stated qualifications to be one heartbeat away from the Presidency is Alaska's adjacency to Russia.  Very scary.  
"asks for a "call for action" against the country."

Does this mean yet another war?  From my observations of the attitudes of the McCain/Palin ticket, I would have to say that it does.

Have we learned NOTHING?  I really don't know that I'll live long enough to see an end to the disaster caused by the Bush/Chaney ticket (after all, I'm 70).  I certainly don't see any HOPE for a change to the better if they are elected.

How - - - please tell me HOW - - there is an 80% preference rate for Obama on the economy, on the plan for Iraq and health on this site.  But it is still declared a close race by the main stream media.

I just PRAY that the people of the United States wake up and give their total support to Senator Obama.  No human is perfect, but he's the best we have right now.

Obama/Biden    PLEASE!!!!!
Palin and McCain are both shameless.  They'll do anyting to FOOL Hillary supporters into voting for them.  When in reality they hate the Clintons and everything they stand for.  For all you Clinton supporters out there who blame Obama for not choosing Hillary as his Veep, you are blaming the wrong people.  It is the super right wing Palin adoration committee, who would have come out in droves to vote against Clinton and made up most of her negatives for being a Veep candidate.
Wall Street is our greatest threat right now, Madam Palin. Can we focus please?
Were these her thoughts & ideas . . . or someone else's?

Was she reading from a script?

When is she going to start talking to the press?
When is she going to appear on Sunday talk shows?
When is she going to take unsolicited questions from Americans?

Until then she is not showing she deserves to be VP, let alone a heartbeat away from the Presidency.
Im sure Sarah's part in this op-ed was her signature.
Oh give me a break. How much you wanna bet Palin did not pen that op-ed piece herself. LOL AHMADINEJAD is one of those words/names that is not included in 'spell check"
oops meant NOT included in spell check:) LOL
When will Gov. Palin learn that she is not, and never will be, Hillary Clinton.  Hillary is not too keen on making victims pay for their own rape kits!
"Sinner" Sarah must be stopped as she is the biggest threat to our national security, along with her warmongering running mate.  We cannot allow this wicked witch to run amok on the international scene or we'll be in neverending wars for decades to come.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
Really? I for one cannot take this bimbo seriously. Her lines are scripted, her stmp speach is a broken record, she has little to no substance, yet the polls are tied in most areas ? Are there that many racist in this country that would rather see the "dipstick / Lipstick "  party in the office ? How sad!!!
What a very good speech indeed. No wonder New York Democrats bullied the organizations that invited her to disinvite her. Those tactics remind me what happens in Venezuela, hell no wonder liberal Democrats have a secret affections fro Hugo Chavez.
Ready for World War III?

Obama/Biden for thinking before they react..
First of all, you know-nothing moron, Iran's president was elected, just like GWB.

"A call to action."  Well. Isn't that special? This woman is an idiot.
McCain/Palin

More wars, less jobs.

If they knew anything about Iran, then they would know that Ahmadinejad is not the power in that country.  The real power lies with the mullahs.  A wise statesman would treat him as the blustering figurehead that he is.
No one disagres that Iran cannot be allowed to possess nuclear weapons. But Pailn like McCain need to put aise all their public sabre rattling and listen to those Secretaty of States (Dem and Rep.)who in a forum the other day stated the exact same position that Oabama has been recommending. First, stop all the sabre rattling rhetoric which makes matters worse and second, open up talks with Iran to seek their cooperation while leaving air strikes o nthe table as a final option.

The trouble with war-monger McCain and his Parakeet Palin is that their constant public condemnation and threats against Iran close the door to any diplomatic solutions that might be achieved to avoid military action before such talks can occur. They also give the President of Iran a world stage, legitimacy and greater support from the Iraniain people (where his reputation has not been good) by increasing Nationalistic feelings among the Iranian people by these constant threats.

It amazes me that anyone is even listening to Palin who has no clue of foreign policy matters. She is way out of her league.
Palin just be quiet for your own good. The McCain camp will not only tell you what to say, they will make you drop out of the race should you even speak up for yourself. Like quote"Palin-McCain administration" big gaffe.Oh! you forgot to mention you can see Russia from your house.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1432055

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google