ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama talks government reform

Posted: Monday, September 22, 2008 5:11 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Athena Jones
GREEN BAY, Wisc. -- In a speech his campaign dubbed “major,” Obama talked about how he would make government more transparent and more accountable, expanding on previously announced proposals to increase efficiency and reduce wasteful spending at a time when the nation’s attention is on the plan to use $700 billion in taxpayer money to rescue the financial system.

Obama spoke about long-term proposals, including opening up the practice of writing legislation, making information about tax breaks provided to corporations publicly available, cutting federal spending on contractors by at least 10 percent, or $40 billion a year, banning gifts from lobbyists and instituting what he calls a SWAT team to make federal agencies more efficient.

Over the weekend, the senator laid out the elements he wants included in the bailout legislation lawmakers aim to pass in the coming days and he touched on them again today, while responding to news reports about Wall Street firms that are hoping to reap profits from fees related to managing the bad assets the government plans to buy in the bailout.

“Today, even as Congress debates an emergency plan to save our economy from- on the verge of collapse, there are reports that lobbyists and CEOs are already lining up to figure out what’s in it for them; to find out how they can get theirs,” he said. “Green Bay, enough is enough. It is time for us to stand up and say no more. We are gonna start doing some things differently here in America under a new president with a new vision for our economy and a new vision for our future.” 

This is the Democratic nominee’s fifteenth trip to Wisconsin during the election -- he visited 11 times during the primaries and this is fourth trip during the general election, according to his campaign. He is hoping to win over voters here and across the battleground states by portraying himself as a champion for working families and his opponent whose record does not match his new talk of “change.”

Before a crowd of about 6,000 people in an arena, the Democrat continued to link his Republican rival to the current crisis on Wall Street, criticizing McCain for saying in a television interview last night that deregulation had helped grow the economy.

 “That might be true for growing the profits of some of big corporations and the bank accounts of some CEOs, but it’s certainly not true for American prosperity.  American families since George Bush has been in office have seen average family incomes go down $2,000,” he said, going on to talk about the economic prosperity of the Clinton years.

In an attempt to use a perceived McCain strength against him, Obama hit the Arizona senator on earmarks, something has long railed against, helping him earn his reputation as a maverick.

“When it comes to reforming government waste and spending, Sen. McCain talks a lot about earmarks and here’s an area that he deserves credit,” Obama said. “He hasn’t requested many of those earmarks during his time in Congress, what he doesn’t mention is that he voted for $144 billion worth in just six years; or that he’s voted for four out of the five Bush budgets that have been filled with special interests giveaways and left us with the largest deficit in history.”

He went on to say he had pledged to slash earmarks by more than half as president and he introduced a new line of attack based on McCain’s ties to lobbyists. He took aim at McCain Campaign Manager Rick Davis, saying beleaguered mortgage lenders Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac had paid Davis nearly $2 million to defend them against stricter regulations.

Obama argued that the more than $300 billion tax breaks McCain was proposing for big companies and the wealthy that McCain were irresponsible at a time when taxpayers were being asked to fund two wars and a historic financial bailout, even though the Democrat has faced questions of his own about whether his plans for universal health care and middle class tax cuts can remain unchanged with so much taxpayer money being devoted to the bailout. Obama has said the federal budget deficit would not rise under his administration, a potentially difficult promise to given the current circumstances.

The senator was introduced by Sen. Herb Kohl and Gov. Jim Doyle and later Sen. Russ Feingold, who stressed working with Obama on ethics reform and talked about McCain as a deregulator. Obama called Feingold “One of the strongest champions of ethics reform and finance reform and good government that we have in government today.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I listened to his speech. It was coherent, understandable and right on the money. You cannot compare McCain rancid muttering and rambling about the economy with that.

Obama has a plan and a vision.
Obama is starting to lay out his plan.  McClown is probably taking a nap so he can remember what he said 3 minutes ago.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122204781847961747.html
Once again, Obama gives a speech that uses a lot of words to say absolutely nothing.  There are no specifics, just whatever you want the words to mean, kind of like voting 'present' on legislation.

He DOES attack John McCain a great deal, and with specificity; however, he neatly leaves out some of the more uncomfortable, (for himself), details, like the amount of money HE received from Fannie/Freddie in just two years.

Not to mention how much money his buddy Chris Dodd received from those entities, including at a time when he BLOCKED legislation John McCain tried to get out of committee that would have reined them in, and perhaps averted the current crisis.

You just keep plugging your candidate, First Read.  Leave out the part of the story where the Obama campaign handed out 25,000 tickets to the event, but only six thousand,(your number) showed up.  It actually looked like a lot fewer to me, but I am no expert in crowd estimation.

I find it fascinating that, were the roles of the two candidates reversed, had McCain received all that money, not only you, but ALL of the media would be screaming for his head.  The heat would be so bad that it would be doubtful his own wife would vote for him.  Ah, but it is the Democrats with their hands in the cookie jar, so they must be forgiven, as they could only have had the most altruistic reasons for taking the cash.

And the main stream media wonders why it is going broke.
This is just a more detailed version of the  proposals and reforms that he made in his Cooper Union speech back in March 2008 for more stringent financial regulation and reforms of the financial markets.  Nothing new and it is a bit too womky.  Obama needs to take a page out of McCain's book, and come up with something entirely new to generate sizzle.  Also, promise prosecutions like in the Enron and Worldcom crisis in 2003, since people like scapegoats.  McCain did the right thing in calling for the firing of Chris Cox.  It makes him look decisive.
Finally a plan for reform instead of just saying the word over and over like McCain/Palin seem to do.  Just heard McCain lie about Obama not coming up with a plan for the bailout--guess he hasn't read the papers lately. His lying always makes me want to make another donation to Obama--I'm going broke!!!
Go away empty suit!

No record, no experience, no thanks.
I'm not really sure I understand the underlying point this reporter is trying to make when she describes Barack Obama's speech today as dubbed by his campaign as "major".  Is she implying that it was not meaningful?  I try to watch all the significant speeches...stump or "major".  I can tell you that Obama's speech today was much more "major" in content than watching John McCain stand up and read word for word from a note card - when it is very obvious he doesn't really even understand half of what he is reading.  I love it when the conservatives say they media is in the tank for Obama...give me a break...the media LOVES John McCain...they always have.
Why anybody would vote for McCain is a puzzle to me. For weeks now his campaign had done nothing but lie and keep lying even when proven they are lying. Palin is worse than McCain - and by the way who is on the top of this ticket, seems like she is according to her words and being the major celebrity here.
Good speech Barack. But please, list all the reforms you ever implemented and the results of each. Go all the way from your years as a Community Organizer through your state senate years, and your time in the US senate. Take your time, we have all day to listen.
Was Obama at Lambert Field?
In short, McCain is an idiot.  We have already voted an idiot into the White House.  TWICE.  We can't afford a third time.

GObama

How's the polar bear population in Green Bay these days? They on their way back?
Wow, you guys really took McCain's criticism of the Media seriously - afraid he's going to do to you what he did to the NYT??

Seriously, in the story about McCain's reaction to this (earlier today - a couple stories down) - you quote him extensively - never pointing to the irony of McCain's history of advocating for deregulation all the while he is now suddenly calling for it -- Yet you will comment on what you percieve to be shortcomings in Obama's tax plan...
McCain accuses Obama of being in bed with Fannie and Freddie and now Obama accuses McCain of the same.  Are both telling the truth, both lying or what is the story?  I am an Obama supporter but I hate all these over-lapping stories.  Do they all play for the same team, and that team not being the American people.  I am so weary of being manipulated.  All the arguments used are so circular.  
Wisconsin is getting pretty tired of the lead Democrats in the state. Doyle raised taxes, after he said he wouldn't. Feingold is slightly less liberal then Obama, but still way out on the fringe. Kohl has fielded one of the worst teams in the NBA. He's also silent about everything. He votes once in a while, but you never hear a peep out of him. We call him 'Silent Sam'.

Democrats have been very harmful to Wisconsin in recent years. Time for a change, because Enough is Enough!
Challenge...and I know no one will take it.

I want to hear from a woman why they support repubs/Palin.  Trick is, you cannot mention Obama/Biden, you cannot quote speeches, and try to explin with issues.  I want to know why
Will someone please tell me when George W. Bush became "KING" of the United States ? Or are we now living in a dictatorship ? Maybe it's time for us to pack up and move out of the country.
McCain talks about transparency 2 years after Obama co-sponsored the Federal Funding Accountability and Transparency Act (S. 2590), with senator Coburn. Go to USAspending.gov, it's an awesome site, created from that piece of legislation.. it shows you where government money is spent.
McCain is a DISASTER

I dont know how anyone could vote for him, i just dont
BHO: Obama argued that the more than $300 billion tax breaks McCain was proposing for big companies and the wealthy that McCain were irresponsible


Of course, those "Tax Breaks" Obama complained about funded a lot of jobs in Wisconsin. You know, jobs like making cheese, paper, beer, etc. So take away those "Tax Breaks" Barack, then you can explain why unemployment is at 20%.
Wisconsin voters are Packer fans. Obama is from Chicago. You do the math.
I am glad to hear Senator Obama bringing up the hypocrisy  of the whole earmarks talking point... as if somehow McCain's not asking for them for the state of Arizona (which has, actually, be shown to be untrue in at least one instance on http://politifact.org/truth-o-meter/statements/719/)

makes him a reformer. It doesn't. The 20+ years he's spent in Congress backing up every single reaganomic-based piece of legislation to do away with regulation and oversight is something that the American public is NOT going to forget.

Bush is an idiot, yes... and McCain has voted with Bush. But worse, McCain is a crook and liar... he's the quintessential wolf in sheep's clothing.

My, what BIG lies you have!

No how, No way, No Welfare for Wall Street!
What a novel thought -- spending the nation's money only on projects that make efficient use of the money, and cutting out projects that are inefficient or no longer effective in solving a problem.
The economy is the worst thing to happen to this country in decades.  Neither candidate has much to offer but now they are reduced to trying to learn some "economic" karate to defend their ignorance.

This guy says its a whole bunch worse than anyone thinks. I read his article on Sunday.  I remember how bad the 1930's were from my parents.

www.market-timing-wbbusin.com

He's always ahead of the curve but that is his business
While I like Obama, I'm not so naive as to think he's somehow less removed from the power base in NY and Wash than John McCain. Americans are voting for the possibilities these candidates represent NOT the possibilities as they should be.
I'm not sure I'm comfortable with a $700 Million bailout when, ultimately, we don't even know the extent of the problem AND no one with a straight face can tell us that it's going to prevent a depression anyway. It will, however, increase the debt to over $11 Trillion and send the $US dollar into decline. I am also sure that the American people have been an afterthought for decades in the WH and on both sides of the aisle in both houses.
You mean to tell me, that shooting from the hip (like McCain and his dufus pick do) isn't being fiscally responsible? You mean to tell me that McCain had not  put any thought into this problem before he popped off and accused Obama of "not having a plan, not reacting as a president should have done?" Sounds to me like he just wanted to be the first to react, not giving a hoot about "country first?" Sounds like a problem, doesn't it, Republicans? You chose him, he chose her! How do you get out of this mess?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1434118

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google