ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain: Examining Keating

Posted: Tuesday, October 07, 2008 9:08 AM by Domenico Montanaro

The AP looks at Keating. "The Republican senator's lawyer in the case, John Dowd, told reporters in a conference call Monday that McCain had been the victim of 'a political smear job' by Senate Democrats. When a reporter noted that McCain himself has spoken contritely about his role, Dowd responded, 'I'm his lawyer and I have a different view of it.'"

More: "Once close to Keating, McCain received $112,000 from him, his family and associates. The senator and his family also flew in Keating's plane to the Bahamas and -- in the events that triggered the Senate investigation -- took up his cause with financial regulators as they were investigating the businessman. Keating eventually went to prison. McCain eventually repaid $112,000 to the U.S. Treasury and reimbursed Keating for the trips. The irony of the Keating case is that McCain received the mildest ethics committee rebuke of the five senators in 1991, and was kept as a defendant because he was the only Republican. The special counsel in the case had recommended that McCain and one of the Democrats be dropped as defendants. But Democrats, who controlled the Senate, refused to take all the heat for the scandal and all five remained in the case to the end."

And once six-degrees games are brought up, there are more where those came from… AP writes: "McCain has past connections to a private group that supplied aid to guerrillas seeking to overthrow the leftist government of Nicaragua in the Iran-Contra affair. … The U.S. Council for World Freedom was part of an international organization linked to former Nazi collaborators and ultra-right-wing death squads in Central America. The group was dedicated to stamping out communism around the globe. The council's founder, retired Army Maj. Gen. John Singlaub, said McCain became associated with the organization in the early 1980s as McCain was launching his political career in Arizona."

The New York Times writes that big business is a not a fan of McCain’s health-care plan. “American business, typically a reliable Republican cheerleader, is decidedly lukewarm about Senator John McCain’s proposal to overhaul the health care system by revamping the tax treatment of health benefits, officials with leading trade groups say. The officials, with organizations like the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the Business Roundtable and the National Federation of Independent Business, predicted in recent interviews that the McCain plan, which eliminates the exclusion of health benefits from income taxes, would accelerate the erosion of employer-sponsored health insurance and do little to reduce the number of uninsured from 45 million.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Now that McCain has decided to go for broke, let us all take a deep breath and realize that as I have said, he lacks the temperament and the judgement to be POTUS.  

McCain has always been a crook and if you examine his so called maverick stance, it was all a gamble rather than a coherent policy stance.  Look at this below

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/10/07/politics/main4505539.shtml
McCain's campaign was stupid to bring character attacks on Obama.  Surely they knew that this would bring the Keating scandals questions to the forefront.

http://thepajamapundit.com/
Even if I accept that both Dems and Repubs are to blame for the current Financial Fiasco we are all experiencing right now, I am completely unwilling to accept the complete lack of leadership and accountability going on in DC.  The bailout with all its pork is a complete insult to the American People.  The CEO grilling on the Hill is shining a light on the extent to which power corrupts.  I will be perfectly honest here, I am not certain that Obama has all of the answers right now.  But what I know for sure is that McCain does not seem to have ANY of the answers.  In fact, I don’t believe he understands the questions.  His entire life experience gives me the impression of someone who fumbled through at the bottom of expectations.  When he has wanted something, he’s taken it.  He has shown a complete lack of character in how he treated his first family.  He showed a complete lack of character with the Keating 5, which occurred when he was 58 years old (this wasn’t that long ago, people).  The way he has run (or allowed others to run) his campaign has further shown a lack of good, principled judgment.  Obama may be a risk; but McCain is a dangerous certainty.  I will not vote for the man who is showing himself to be a hollow, selfish, liar.  No Way, No How, No McCain!
AP writes: "McCain has past connections to a private group that supplied aid to guerrillas seeking to overthrow the leftist government of Nicaragua in the Iran-Contra affair. … The U.S. Council for World Freedom was part of an international organization linked to former Nazi collaborators and ultra-right-wing death squads in Central America. The group was dedicated to stamping out communism around the globe. The council's founder, retired Army Maj. Gen. John Singlaub, said McCain became associated with the organization in the early 1980s as McCain was launching his political career in Arizona."
---------------
Just liked that part... you know, guilty by association.  It's a simple biblical principle: Judge not, lest ye be judged - with the same measure... Matt. 7:1.  All this done, during McCain's adult life, Ayers, well, Obama was eight - and I'm sure he wasn't directly involved in Ayers' activities.
"The irony of the Keating case is that McCain received the mildest ethics committee rebuke of the five senators in 1991, and was kept as a defendant because he was the only Republican. The special counsel in the case had recommended that McCain and one of the Democrats be dropped as defendants. But Democrats, who controlled the Senate, refused to take all the heat for the scandal and all five remained in the case to the end."

So it was just political then right.
I guess so because the Dem they are talking about was John Glenn who is helping out the Obama campaign. SO obviously Obama is just trying to smear McCain.

Once close to Keating, McCain received $112,000 from him, his family and associates. The senator and his family also flew in Keating's plane to the Bahamas
******************************************************

Poor McFossil....sure sounds like a "victim" to me!
HIS LAWYER???

Now THERE'S a credible spokesman, right? Same guy, if I recall, who did his best to put lipstick on Cindy McCain's drug crime.
McCain should have left Ayers alone. BUT since he didn't, turnaround is fair play and Obama was wise to throw Keating into the mix. Many younger folks don't know much about the scandal, which is why I made it my business to pass on the keatingeconomics.com link to everyone I could think of.  I understand McCain was behind in the polls, but low grade tactics I thought was beneath him.

McCain doesn't sincerely believe Obama is a terrorist, but apparently some in his and Palin's rally audiences do with the shouts heard yesterday.  Truly the Republican nominee has taken a dive and they are pulling that simple puppet Palin right with them. They're even back to having crowd warmers bring up Barack's middle name as a cheap and racist shot.

Shame on you John McCain. Shame!

Obama/Biden '08
Famous McBush quotes " I would rather have my campaign lie through there teeth to win an Election than talk about the economy" , I have this marker right here for vetos I will  make them famous you will know their names.  Hey John one question who placed all the pork on the Bail out thing. Are you going to drop a few names???? Does Sarah Palin wear a flag pin ??? And why is Morning GOP Joke have his head so far up Sarah Palins Skirt ????
McCain/Palin are the new keating Two!!! Clueless Idiots!! Idiots!! Idiots!! Scandalous Idiots!! Who think negative attacks will persuade americans to forget about this horrible economy, Clueless Idiots!!!
I think its about time the issue of the Keating 5 was brought up.  In my mind I figured this would only become necessary if things got nastier than anyone would have imagined and they have.

So McCain wants to tie Obama in with weather underground Ayers  during the time Obama was 8.  

People have short term memories I guess, I recall the S & L cisis of the 80's vey clearly why?? Lincoln Savings and loan in RI was the loan company my inlaws had alot of money invested what they did not lose was a frozen asset for a long time.  I was a very young woman at the time and watched as they struggled to make ends meet as they could not gain access to their MONEY!!..  This speaks directly to McCains Judgement and his PAl Keating whom went to jail.  He was also sanctioned by the house and he got off easy.  This is relevant to his presidency as it shows that he has followed the same course of deregulation even after the S & L crisis  One would think he would have learned a lesson from that.  So the next time Palin defends her postion as relevant to the Ayers issue and Obama conection, it should be pointed out that McCain was in the thick of it all with Keating and the S&L crisis.  And if more is needed pehaps the issue of his relatinship with Liddy is relevant too.  Again it goes to Character and judgement and an ability to make good decisions.

I know I dont want a president that  has not only not learned from his mistakes but also how soon he puts them to the side.  Dirty fighting at its worst, Im glad Obama is calling McCan for his past actions that are well  documented and not just fodder for the rumor mill as the Ayers issue is.

Suz, western NY
I love how McCain supporters love to stammer on and on about how McCain was exonerated by the Keating investigators, but somehow manage to forget the part about how Congress censured him for lacking judgment.
Well well well!!!




Smear? SMEAR??
No end to the lies. I am old enough and was there during this thing. McCain is guilty as heck. It was as always McCain ducking and dodging using connections to get out from under with just the slap on the wrist.

It is another case for why we should hang politicians. Back then it faded as who cared if the people in Arizona wanted a slime ball crook in their senate seat what differance to the rest of us?

ooops!

And besides....What else does a defense lawyer say?? His words are useless, they are offensive to anyone with a brain.

If you are to young to know just look it up. Do you really belive all the "poor me, I'm innocent" crap from mcCain? I hope not.

He was a greedy little self absorbed snot back then and he is a much much worse person now.

Please please read this story, sums up McCain nicely without going to far at all...

http://www.rollingstone.com/news/coverstory/make_believe_maverick_the_real_john_mccain

Heee yaaah lets go back and win in Vietnam with McCain!!!
Smart people don't need the AP to tell us that McCain hands are dirty. After 26 years in Washington that goes without saying.

There skeletons in the closet! Keating is not the only one.

If McCain insist on running a negative campaign, the crew from IL will show Karl Rove and his minions how it's done. Can you say uncle?

Obama/Biden
<<When a reporter noted that McCain himself has spoken contritely about his role, Dowd responded, 'I'm his lawyer and I have a different view of it.'">>

Oh, so his lawyer's going to rewrite history then?  Good luck with that!
John Blinky McCain is a walking lie.  I just read the Rolling Stone story to come out later this month.  It's online...The Make-Believe Maverick.  Check it out.  It's no wonder this guy hates the press, with a few exceptions that helped mold his personna.  This guy is too dangerous to be president.
Hummm interesting  Mr. Clean McCain , received $112,000 from Keating  his family and associates. Mr. Clean  McCain  and his family also flew in Keating's plane to the Bahamas and .. Sound like corruption ….don you think ??
The irony of all these is that  McCain try to come across as the super clean, "Maverick"
Here are the fact about this "maverick"   left the poor first wife who weathers the, worries, hardships, and uncertainty of his survival
Applied for marriage license with his second wife but   was  still married to his first wife

He's wife is a drug addict.   What example can provide to our kids….

Left  he's FIRST wife because of her health condition

Pick a Vice-president   that her husband belong to a group advocating Alaska secession from the United State



Shouldn't the AP note that the Special Counsel in the case was Bob Bennett?  Is it any surprise that he recommended a Republican be "let off the hook?"  
Is AP saying McCain connected to Iran-Contra? Do you think McCain may have associated with people that are linked to Nazi collaborators? Would this make him guilty by association? Maybe McCain wishes he had not brought Ayers up. Seams like a lot of mud is being thrown around by both sides. Sad, McCain should stick to the issues.
The gloves are really coming off!  McCain may regret the smear tactics used against OBama.
Open up the book on McCain.. he started the tactics of going off the issues!!
He is TOO old and angry!!!!  OBAMA 08
Palin .. not even a need to comment...
McCain should never have opened this door . . . he has more skeletons in his closet than Obama does

And now he is revealed for everyone to see . . . no more "respectful campaign" gibberish . . . he is willing to do or say anything to get elected . . . and doesn't care if his taking the focus off of the economy does futher damage

What a joke . . . I have lost all respect for McCain . . . he has NO HONOR
Please go to YouTube and watch the video concerning
Mccains involvement in Keating5. It was out and
out fraud and stealing from the taxpayers.
How Mccain got off with just a slap on the
hands is certainly questionable.
And, it also supported Mccains belief that
de-regulation is the answer to everything.
Yea, right, everything but the taxpayers.
Keating was a crook and "Dishonest" McCain got off way too light in his punishment.  We can see that he did not learn his lesson and just kept in the pockets of big banking while giving them all the deregulation they needed to hang themselves.

If only "Daddy" Bush had not stopped that SEC investigation into his wayward son bankrupting his own company.  We certainly could see that from that he would bankrupt our country and sure enough he has added more debt to the national debt than almost all of the preisdents before him.

We can't afford to give the Bush Hugger the benefit of the doubt becuase he will bankrupt our country and economy if he gets elected.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
How is it a smear job when McCain had to repay the funds and was admonished for poor judgment?   But who cares if it was a smear or not, these are his types of buddies that he is willing to risk his career for.  Again "Poor Judgement".
More and more clarity. McCain Palin are the least qualified candidates to lead the nation. John's bad judgement from the past coupled with his choice of Sarah Palin as VP is a heap of evidence that he does not have the judgement to be president. How the Republican leadership has continued to support him leads me to question their entire way of thinking. This demostrates a total lack of interest in the good of the nation. They allowed McCain to continue unchecked because the possibility of winning an election was more important than the good of the nation. Continued support for McCain Palin would be a mockery of "patriotism." Patriotism is about the nation not about the party.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1504434

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google