ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Palin: Obama's trying to scare seniors

Posted: Tuesday, October 07, 2008 2:01 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Matthew E. Berger

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. -- Palin said a McCain Administration would protect Social Security and not tax health care, while suggesting Obama was trying to scare senior citizen voters in Florida.

“We will protect the entitlement programs that Americans depend on -- above all Social Security,” she said at a fundraiser at Jacksonville Municipal Stadium. “No presidential election cycle is complete, though, so keep in mind, without the Democratic candidate coming down here to Florida especially and trying to stir up fear and panic on this issue of Social Security.”

Palin accused Obama of exploiting the health care and Social Security issues to win votes among seniors in Florida. “If you expect any better from a guy who promises to get rid of old-style politics, you’re in for a good warning there,” she said. “Because Barack Obama has exploited this issue and that’s the way that he works.”

Palin’s choice of venue for this message was odd, however. Despite the Florida address, she spoke predominantly to Baby Boomers and younger voters at the fundraiser, and the promises to “make health care more accessible and more affordable” did not garner applause.

Palin said Obama’s health-care plan “puts expensive mandates on small businesses” and said that would lead to unemployment and layoffs.

“Our health-care plan will give millions of middle class Americans access to better health-care coverage without costing you a dime,” she said, saying middle class families would receive a $5,000 tax credit to buy coverage.

Palin suggested the new lines were needed because of Obama’s advertising campaign -- which argued the McCain plan would tax health-care benefits -- and because McCain’s health-care message was not getting through in the media.

“Barack Obama is calling that a tax,” she said. “Now, there’s no tax; that’s changing health care for the better. He doesn’t understand that. I don’t know how he captures it and spins it to being a tax on Americans. No, it’s a credit.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

(giggle)you mean those youngin's weren't keen on paying for those entitlements to their parents and grandparents...must have been from the young fascist, er, republican club...
I am an independent senior...last year a republican, and find the McCain/Palin ticket insulting to say the least.  How stupid does the RNC think people are.  The tactics are bad enough but it's a no change platform that frankly is more interested in continuing a ridiculous war than our own people.  My vote for Senator Obama will be for 4 years and if he does as well as I suspect I may vote for him again.
Palin...

it wasn't Obama that suggested you'd mess with Medicare/Medicaid... it was people within your campaign...

As for your healthcare plan... why don't you go to your campaign website and read where Johnnie boy plans on coming up with the funds... you guys (Gramm) wrote it... not Obama.

You can't be that dumb!
It is the liberal Wall Street Journal that reported that McCreep will pay, in part, for his health insurance plan by reducing Medicaid and Medicare. Got to watch that left-wing media.
Palin accused Obama of exploiting the health care and Social Security issues to win votes among seniors in Florida. And you sarah palin are accused of exploting fears of white american against a black man running for president in america. this is the pot calling the kettel black!!!! you have people calling for barack to be killed, your supporters are calling black sound engineers boys, i just wish you would go away!!!
I'm tired of Palin's hate filled messages and most Americans are tired of it too. Does she have any ideas or anything positive to say???


Obama/Biden '08
“Now, there’s no tax; that’s changing health care for the better. He doesn’t understand that. I don’t know how he captures it and spins it to being a tax on Americans. No, it’s a credit.”

__________________________________________

She had me at "I don't know"!

My god,....this may be the most ignorant woman on the planet.
sigh. more lies. mccain does tax health care benefits. his tax credit is an attempt to offset that but it comes up short. and apparently, protecting social security means privatizing a portion of it? how would those funds be doing now?
Ummm, McCain wants to cut Medicare and Medicaid, privatize social security or go away with it, tax health care benefits, and she has the brass to accuse Obama of trying to scare seniors? Sorry Princess PiggfacedPalin, but it's not going to work.
So, we should beleive and trust in a liar and a loose cannon? And by that I am referring to Palin..
Listening to Sarah Palin is like watching a child repeating bad things they heard their parents say - hard to get too upset when it is clear that they don't even completely understand what they are saying.

Notice how the media hasn't asked John McCain or Sarah Palin for any details about their plans? Why is that media? Senator Obama has DETAILS - where's the beef McPalin?

The corporate media should send the McCain campaign a bill for all the free airspace you are giving them - unprecedented.
Palin wants to protect entitlement programs by cutting medicare and medicaid. She wants to priviatize social security. This does not sound like protecting entitlement. It appears as though they are making the economic situation worse for the middle class while maintaing the tax cuts for the rich.
Did anyone ask her how McCain voted on the Social Security bill that came up recently in the Senate? Opps....... too busy campaigning to go back to vote.....even Ted Kennedy (brain tumor and all) voted on this issue. McCain certainly puts "Country First" doesn't he? He's certainly protecting seniors and their Social Security by not bothering to even vote. McCain and Palin are frauds and will be sent packing November 4th! Obama/Biden '08/'12!
I got news for you ... Decent Health Care costs more than $5,000 a year folks ... God Forbid you have something as common as a Blue Cross PPO! How do we cover the balance, Governor?  A six Pack of Beer does not constitute a health Benefit and Please don't drive the kids around after the hockey game after the six pack, Doggone it!
Huh?  Doesn't she know McCain's own proposed policies?  There is a tax credit which is far short of what even a single person would pay for a decent health care policy and McCain wants to tax the entire health benefit package provided by your employer - for the first time ever.  McCain increases taxes while Obama is providing middle-class and low income tax cuts.  

I guess that why McCain is fixated on the 1960s doesn't want to talk current jobs, the economy, health care and taxes.
Do you suppose if we all stop responding to any coverage that Palin is given here they will quit posting it?
I guess it does some good tho, each time I read about something she says I donate to Senator Obama's campaign
How can she say that with a straight face?  Has she not read McCain's health care plan.  It is paid for by taxing employer provided health care plans and cutting funding for Medicare and Medicaid.  And McCain wanted to privatize social security. Thank God that did not happen we would all be in an even bigger world of hurt now that the market is tanking.  
lies

same team
same tactics
same 8 year garbage going for a 9th.

this woman ... is not good...at all.

scary movie V

the palin presidency.

or "Faerie Land"

where you can say what ever you want whenever you want ...or not.

ugh send this woman back to Alaska.
November 4th can't get here soon enough.  I want this election over with especially since McDesparate/Pal-lies rallies have turned to "kill him" and "terrorist".  Please get out and vote! Vote and vote early!

Obama/Biden '08  
"...you’re in for a good warning there,” she said.

What the heck does that mean? A good "warning". Is she really all there?

How many colleges did she have to switch before finally getting a 4 year degree? Yikes, LOW expectations for sure.
MAKE HER GO AWAY!! She is a DISGRACE to hard working women everywhere!! Equal pay for Women!!! We have families too.
Isn't that something...a Republican accusing a Democrat of scare tactics.  I guess if anybody would recognize a scare tactic, it's a Republican.
McCain Plans Federal Health Cuts -- Medicare, Medicaid Spending Would Be Reduced to Offset Proposed Tax Credit for the RICH

John McCain would pay for his health plan with major reductions to Medicare and Medicaid, a top aide said, in a move that independent analysts estimate could result in cuts of $1.3 trillion over 10 years to the government programs.

McCain has said little about the proposed cuts, but they are needed to keep his health-care plan "budget neutral," as he has promised. The McCain campaign hasn't given a specific figure for the cuts, but didn't dispute the analysts' estimate.

In the months since Sen. McCain introduced his health plan, statements made by his campaign have implied that the new tax credits he is proposing to help Americans buy health insurance would be paid for with other tax increases.

Douglas Holtz-Eakin, Sen. McCain's senior policy adviser, said Sunday that the campaign has always planned to fund the tax credits, in part, with savings from Medicare and Medicaid. Those government health-care programs serve seniors, poor families and the disabled.

Medicare spending for the fiscal year ended Sept. 30 is estimated at $457.5 billion.

------------

My great aunt in Florida says that all the seniors at the condominium where she lives are up in arms about this... she DEPENDS on Medicare to cover some of the cost of all the meds she needs in her old age -- she's 82yrs. old and barely manages with Medicare and Social Security... since her retirement investments have lost over half their worth!
Hahahahaha... They say they are going to cut <1 trillion in medicare and then try to say it is Obama scaring them? Notice the quote says nothing about medicare. What a joke.
Funny that's not what the WSJ reported.  She continues to lie and misrepresent Obama.  Please all you independents out there, please don't listen.  Check the facts out before your decide.

Obama/Biden '08
You would think Palin would know McCain's positions. Who is running Mcains ticket her or John? Maybe, she could try some of thoose speaches up in MI.
She's an idiot!
So now they have her lying publicly about policy issues?  Or is it that she just doesn't understand?
Gosh darnit!  I don't think you can trust this woman!

What a surprise.
Obama is trying to "scare seniors?"  Was this in the same speech where she said Obama pals around with terrorists?

Wake up Palin!  People are hurting, we are at the brink of a depression, and you have no idea how to handle it, so you attack Obama.  This is so old...
Since when is talking about the issues exploiting them? Hey Palin, you should try it sometime, its actually quite refreshing.
Um, no.  Obama is calling McCain's healthcare tax what it is.  A tax.

Just another lie emanating from the Palin, the Wasilla Queen of Lies.
She didn't get a response because she is trying to discuss healthcare and tax policy details.  She has no credibility on matters that require intelligent thought.  She should stick to whooping it up on stage.
Imagine that, McCain and Palin are worried that Obama will appeal to old people with a better health care plan.  Same old politics huh?  I guess I would worry to if I were cutting medicare out and replacing it with a system that wouldn't work for people over 65, especially in Florida.
She's the one that doesn't understand. I wish she would shut up. I am tired of her, she's so pathetic.
Palin is a fool.  Nothing further needs to be said.
McPalin you are an idiot!!! Let’s talk about Trooper Gate did Todd answer any questions today in truth or lies? I know it runs in the family!!!! Oh and please pay yours taxes up I beleive if they are reporting this right it's 25,000.00?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1506684

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google