ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain on IRAs and 401ks

Posted: Friday, October 10, 2008 1:18 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy

LA CROSSE, Wis. -- Briefly mentioned in McCain's stump speech at a rally here this morning was a new call on investors to hold onto to IRAs and 401ks.

"My friends, we have to protect investors, especially those relying on their investments for retirement," McCain said five minutes into his remarks. "Current rules mandate that investors must beginning to sell off their IRAs and 401ks when they reach age 70 and a half. To spare investors from being forced to sell their stocks at just the time when the market is hurting the most, those rules should be suspended."

And that was all he said on the matter.

Video: Speaking in Wisconsin, John McCain says Barack Obama hasn't been straight with Americans over his earmarks requests or his tax and spending plans.

As we saw with the way McCain rolled out his new mortgage plan at last week's debate, it's not uncommon for his campaign to rollout new policy with little flourish. This paragraph seems central to McCain's message today, and after the rally a campaign spokesman released a fact sheet with further information.

"John McCain proposes that Congress waive this requirement which, by force of law, is making seniors sell their retirement assets at substantial loss," spokesman Brian Rogers said. "There is no reason to force the unlucky few who find themselves currently hitting this mandated timeframe to sell holdings at a time when our stock markets are in turmoil."

Democrats largely ignored McCain's morning call, but they did pick up on another word inserted elsewhere in an otherwise standard comment on the seriousness of America's housing crisis.

"Under my orders as president, the Secretary of the Treasury will carry out a home ownership resurgence plan," McCain said, referring to his mortgage plan he announced at the debate. "The United States government will support the refinancing of distressed mortgages for homeowners and replace them with manageable mortgages so people can stay in their homes. You have to realize the American dream. The funds aren't new, but the priorities will be when we put the financial strength of our government back on the side of working families, with so much on the line."

The Obama campaign quickly pointed to an interview that McCain gave to ABC's Charlie Gibson last night, in which he said that his plan to purchase distressed mortgages would use "new money if necessary." Numerous outlets have reported a tepid response at best to McCain new mortgage proposal from Republicans on Capitol Hill.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

During the GOOP primaries, John McCain stated, "I really do not understand the economy". In light of his "the economy is strong", and his desperate attempt to speak about the mortgages in a way that even Wall Street Republicans laughed at.....he is absolutely accurate. He does not understand the economy.
Does he really think I would trust his advice?  I was taught never to trust a dishonest man.

But, of course, he has 7/8/9 houses, 13/14/15 cars, and over 100 million dollars.  Me?  One house, one car, one mortgage, and one teachers' pension.  

I've made it so far NOT trusting men like Senator McCain.

Obama/Biden 08/12
FR, Did he also mention Ayers? Or has he realized that is falling on deaf ears and tried to steer back onto the high road?
<<As we saw with the way McCain rolled out his new mortgage plan at last week's debate, it's not uncommon for his campaign to rollout new policy with little flourish.>>

McCain:  "Okay, you guys run about 80 yards downfield and I'm just going to fling it up there and hope one of you catches it!"
Just another worthless idea from the King of the Kingdom of Idiots!  And just what are these retirees supposed to live on?  Their good looks?  Just plain stupid and not realistic, just another nefarious attempt to bamboozle people with another unrealistic idea that's nothing but politics.

Hey not too long before we hear from the real Trooperghate investigation.  Since the criminal McCain campaign released a pre-emptive whitewash report last night we know that the real deal will show that "Sinister" Sarah abused her power as Governor Avon Lady.  Ding Dong Prison Calling for "Sinner" Sarah.

Hey good job to the reader who pointed out that "Manchurian Candidate" McCain was palling around with commies.  His former jailer now supports him, wonder what "Tailhook" Johnny will do for him?

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
And that was all he said on the matter.
********************************************

And that is why he is going to lose the election.

http://thepajamapundit.com/
The "new money" to which he is referring will be all allocated by the time any candidate for president gets into office. Just another campaign promise to get votes. Do not vote for Unstable McCain/Unable Palin.
He can't even remember what he said a day or two days ago?  Can you say incompetent???????
What?  Huh? Maverick? Idiot? Troopergate? Keating Five? Pitbutll Pig? Suspend campaign? What? New Mortgage Scheme? Huh? Todd Palin? What ? huh? Maverick? Racist? Cancer? Abortion Rights? what ? huh? Maverick? Idiot!! Yes McCain is an IDIOT!!!
I heard the estimated cost of this is about 1.3 Trillion. Where's the money coming from? If you just print more money, inflation kicks in. How about it, McCain campaign, how are you going to pay for it?
ZZZZZZZZZZZZ.oh oh what did McCain say something? Oh well...ZZZzzzzz...
Next....
Please if OBAMMA dont want to help pay peoples mortgages and help small business he knows better than all you losers who cant pay for what they got talked into by a fraudulant baNKERS ,come on you know 700 billon is going to help all the people who deserve it how would helping people do better. GET OFF THE BOAT BEFORE YOU SINK ALL OF US im with obamma let those losers go who cant afford a mortgage. It looks like Obamma will get the same pass BUSH got .
Senator McCain needs to get a handle on the economy. He ought to propose that taxpayers buy up 401Ks and IRA's at 100% of value too.

McCain's mortgage proposal is terrible.

No more taxpayer money for these corrupt banks.

McCain should start showing some leadership, by removing supporters who yell things like "terrorist".  It is happening more frequently.  Today, both John and Cindy McCain looked towards the supporter, but did nothing.
Oh, and Obama wants that money too. Those 401s and IRAs? Tools of the evil ones, the Republicans. That money needs to confiscated by the government and given to deserving people (Democratic fundraisers,ACORN, Rezco Defense Fund, etc.).
Yep McCain wants us to spend more...more taxpayer money while he gives all the benefits to the rich.  Keep your policies McCain.  They are so backwards it isnt funny.  You say anything to win...when you know these are feeble policies.  But then you are trying to attract the less educated.  
Yes as McCain states the IRA and 401(k) rules require minmum distribution for investors over 70. These are not mandatory maximum but minimum payments.  It's admirable you want to waive the requirement but what about the vast majority( not your rich friends) WHO NEED to take the distribution? Your comments do not address curing the problem of rescuing their savings you just want to not force those who have significant investmetns to not be required to take them out and be taxed. Give me a plan to help INSURE their savings not one that simply removes taxation of pre tax investments of the wealthy.
obama had a 15pt lead here in WI in July. In a year when ANY Dem should be able to walk into the WH without a single campaign ad, obama struggles. He'll win anyway. The southern 1/4 of WI is in the Chicago media market...Madison Libs...Milwaukee AAs... He'll probably take WI. It's too bad that when this country NEEDS leadership it votes for "inspiration."  When we need someone to enact real reform we look to "hope."  I believe this will go down as the most f***ed up election cycle EVER!!!  We'll "make history" alright!
Numerous outlets have reported a tepid response at best to McCain new mortgage proposal from Republicans on Capitol Hill.

Outlets? Do you mean media outlets? Do we still not understand that most "media outlets" have long ago dismissed everything that McCain says and are totally in the tank for The Barack?
Need not worry. Barack will take those 401Ks from all of us and put them into a fund that all of us can take advantage of. He'll call it Social Security, or something like that.
Is he for real? What is Mccain doing? This is not the same guy I voted for in 2000. He is willing to do anything to become President. My concern is his legacy which will be stained if he happens to lose this election. People are losing their homes and here comes McCain talking non-sense.
That one seems like a sensible proposal by McCain, and I've sometimes wondered why there wasn't more personal flexibility in selling timetables - or why someone couldn't simply live off other savings and allow tax deferred retirement savings in their 401(k) or 403(b) to simply rollover into their final estate - minus the tax penalties, of course.
That's it? One at least decent idea and that's it? He's spent the last week railing about William Ayers and ACORN and inciting his lynch-mobs and THIS is all he says about the economy, besides, of course, his ridiculous mortgage buy-up.

Nov. 4th can't come soon enough.

http://www.rodneyhopper.com
There he goes again, just spouting off anything to get attention.  It's amazing how far a good man will fall just to become president.  I call that blind ambition.  America First, yea right John!

Obama/Biden '08
Oh, jeez, I wish he'd quit saying "My friends." It makes my skin crawl.

I wonder if Mrs. McCain still recognizes him?
Gosh John maybe you should guarantee the full value since September 1st for all Americans...send the bill to my grandsons...you didn't mind sending them the bill for your folly in iraq
This sick old hatemonger doesnt have a clue and most of us know that. Obama will win in November and will
inherit a economic mess that will take years to sort out. We will all hurt during this time and you will see a vibrant young man turn old in a matter of 8 years, but he will have our intrest at heart and he will really care about what happens to us. None of the above would apply to McCain except he is already old. He is to old to even understand the problems this country faces. He has never done without anything
as a matter of fact he is a spoiled man been spoiled all his miserable lying life. He has never once in his life had to worry about paying the light bill or
go easy on the milk this week, no money till friday.
This man will never be able to represent me or anyone else who has ever worried about everyday problems.
Wake up America its now or never.

Obama/Biden
marty


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1528513

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google