ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Panel: Palin 'unlawfully abused' authority

Posted: Friday, October 10, 2008 8:35 PM by Carrie Dann
Filed Under:

From NBC's Carrie Dann
The panel of legislators investigating the "Troopergate" controversy in Palin's home state has concluded that the Alaska governor "unlawfully abused her authority" in the firing Public Safety Commissioner Walter Monegan, per the AP.

More: "The investigative report concludes that a family grudge wasn't the sole reason for firing Public Safety Commissioner Walter Monegan but says it likely was a contributing factor."

*** UPDATE ***  The report by investigator Stephen Branchflower found that Palin's dismissal of Monegan was "proper and lawful" and within her executive authority, but that she violated the state's ethical code in that she "knowingly ... permitted Todd Palin to use the Governor's office and the resources of the Governor's office, including access to state employees, to continue to contact subordinate state employees in an effort to find some way to get Trooper [Michael] Wooten fired."  

Although Palin has said she was afraid of a safety risk posed by the trooper whom Monegan refused to fire, the investigator writes in the report that "such claims of fear were not bona fide and were offered to provide cover for the Palin's real motivation: to get Trooper Wooten fired for personal family related reasons."

Supporters of the governor believe that the investigation was politically motivated.

*** UPDATE 2 ***  The McCain-Palin campaign reacted to the report with the following statement from spokesperson Meg Stapleton: ""Today's report shows that the Governor acted within her proper and lawful authority in the reassignment of Walt Monegan. The report also illustrates what we've known all along: this was a partisan led inquiry run by Obama supporters and the Palins were completely justified in their concern regarding Trooper Wooten given his violent and rogue behavior. Lacking evidence to support the original Monegan allegation, the Legislative Council seriously overreached, making a tortured argument to find fault without basis in law or fact. The Governor is looking forward to cooperating with the Personnel Board and continuing her conversation with the American people regarding the important issues facing the country."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Gotcha!
New report...Palin abused her power as Governor of Alaska by "violating a statute" but broke no laws? How exactly is "violating a statute" NOT breaking a law? How does that happen?
YES...that's exactly what we want. An Administration, elected by people full of hatred and resentment. SO full of hatred and resentment, in fact, that racism and religious intolerance flow from their mouths, loudly and for the whole world to see. This new Administration then get into office to "violate statutes" over and over...oh wait...that's what we've had for the past 8 years. What was I thinking.
If we elect this dismal pair into office, we deserve what we get. What was that Palin said about the VP needing to have more power?
Classic!
Dick Cheaney got nothing on this here Pailin!  This woman is dangerous!
So much for being a reformer...
To quote a well-known Chicago reverand, "The chickens are coming home to roost!"

Obama/Biden, '08
will be fun to see her try to explain this. hahaha. I was an undecided voter untill this loon joined the ticket. I actually feel sorry for McCain I would have voted for him but this bitch scares me.



Who's the REAL Sarah Palin...  CLEARLY, We can't trust HER !!!

How do like it now Parrot Palin?

Ain't KARMA a b*tch?????  


I'm not suprised. You could tell that Sarah Palin, her husband Todd Palin, and the McCain campaign were trying to cover this up from day 1...
Hey, the rest of us already KNEW this... from mayor to governor to VP candidate, she's exposed who she REALLY is to anyone with open eyes...

They are the perfect couple:

Palin, the used-to-be beauty queen mean girl... you remember those kind of girls (every high school had a herd of them) that have very little desire for education and nothing but snarky diggs and hate for anyone that is/was their target de jour...

McCain, the has-been flyboy underachiever who never quite measured up to daddy or grandpappy's level (or rank)...

They deserve each other! And, in case you missed this bit of Keating news about how long the relationship of Keating to the McCains lasted AFTER John's reformist "epiphany":

http://washingtonindependent.com/11806/cindy

If she was in fact unlawful, how soon can we lock her up?  I'm just glad that a bipartisan committee finally agreed on something...  here's hoping there's a nice big fat lawsuit against her for this behavior, you betcha!
Oh how deliciously Mavericky! Palin is a joke. Obama-Biden '08!
Another Cheney....A LIAR...Palin is not only not qualified, she is a hypocrical LIAR, but this is OK for republicans, they love LIARS and LAWBREAKERS and HATE MONGERS and racist pigs
my god you can say what you want about his ideailogy but mcain has run the worst campian for president ever seen in history
Hmmmm, I wonder if this is why McCain is all of a sudden back peddling.  First, Obama is a terrorist, a liar, and can't be trusted, now he's not so scary after all!!?  What about it SNL, still want Palin on SNL??  Letterman??  She could really use some of your credibility about now.  Gonna Give it?
Obviously.
Stick a fork in 'em.  It's over for McCain-Palin.  American's have abundantly voiced that they are fed up with corrupt government officials.  The abuse of power by Palin will erode support for the GOP.  
looks like the pitbull needs some new lipstick...
If Palin was found to have abused the power of her office, what would she do if she were made VP? Very disturbing and what does it say of McCain's pick...coincidence? I think not. As the old adage goes, "Birds of a feather, flock together."  
The same ditch you've dug for BO now you have dug yours.You reap what you sow. It doesn't pay to be nasty to some one you don't even know.Tell John Mccain that .We don't know you.
When the pundits say she didn't break the law, she did break the law.  Because the commissioner served at her pleasure, she could fire him for no reason.  However, she broke the law because he abused her power for personal reasons.  The people of Alaska should impeach her.  And Sarah Palin should, from this point forward, keep her mouth shut with regard to Barack Obama or anything else for that fact because she has lied about everything since she became a vice presidential candidate.
Who's the real Palin?
Well; gosh darnit, look for her to maintain her innocence but inform us that she is withdrawing from the ticket  because there are only three weeks until the election and she does not want this to be a "distraction" in such an important election. Hello, Mike Huckabee, your new GOP VP candidate. That could backfire on us Obama supporters because he will pull the "Bubba or Goober" vote big time.
This just confirms what we already suspected.

She is nothing but a power hungry, blindly ambitious racebaiter.

It is beyond time for you guys to call her and John MCCain on what they have doing this past week.  I am truly ashamed that this racial rhetoric started here in Fl and was allowed to continue all the way to Minnesota.  

What does it take for one among you to say Enough?? I don't accept John McCain's toning down, it should never have started, when it did he should have stopped it.   That would have been the honorable way.

As for Sarah Palin, send her back to Alaska and let the voters there take care of her.  She should be recalled.
Wow. Definitely not new politics.  ALL OLD POLITICS and Dick Cheney like!  Not good!  Obama truth outwins Palin by 12-0.
Holy mother of Hockey moms! This type of behavior would even make my Chicago alderman blush!
Maverick = nice way of saying you don't much get along with anyone, especially those who make the mistake of disagreeing with you.
Well, well, well, look who's pedestal has developed some cracks.....


Obama/Biden '08
Who IS Sarah Palin?  Do we REALLY know her?  
In the VP debate, she spoke of being grateful the Constitution allows the duties of the office of Vice President to be expanded.  (UNTRUE)  Now we have confirmation she "unlawfully abused" authority as Alaska's Governor.  A frightening pattern.  Please let this end the discussion of whether she is qualified.  She is not.
"The fundamentals of my CAMPAIGN are strong."

Go back to one of your thousand houses and ship Barbie back to that island that she can see Russia from.
How can we trust the McCain/Palin administration?
Giving new meaning to "Trust Me". Palin can not claim that this was a setup by the Democrats!!! This was going on before she was vetted (NOT!). The decision was unanimous 10 Republicans and 4 Democrats. Guilty of Abuse of Power!!!!
10 republicans 4 democrats

What spin are they going to put on this report?
Mccain's zoo knew she was guilty all along.  Thats why they have tried to shape the PERCEPTION so IF it came out, they'd be ahead of it, IF it did not come out then they succeeded in stalling until AFTER election when it WOULD NOT MATTER anyway to Mccain if he wins or loses.  Mccain LOVES to gamble.  TO those NOT IN THE rabid base, this is devastating.
Wow!  Makes you wonder if the GOP will be able to carry Alaska! She seems to have some real dissention going on up there.  She gets skewered by her own party minus a couple of blind loyalists... Gov Palin was the best choice for the ticket?  Yikes!
And she wants the office of Vice President to have more power!  Scary!  Sha-na-na-na, Sha-na-na-na, Hey! Sarah, GOODBYE!
The Alaska Legislature's findings are a confirmation of past practice and a possible foretelling for her future propensity for mis-use in the future, at the state and national level. Power seems to corrupt her and her husband, and the more absolute the power, thmore absolute the corruption.

It appears that she might well follow the path of VP Cheney, as she indictated in the VP debate that she envisions the powers of the VP Office as expandable.

It would be wise of the Alaskan Legislature to rebuke her, her husband and their efforts. Perhaps this would be a lesson in energy for her...the limits and control of power.
So who is the REAL Sarah Palin?

Something about glass houses comes to mind. After being sprung on the national electorate merely weeks ago (with Troopergate looming unresolved), who is she to raise questions about Obama fully discussed in April? Payback's a Bitch - how appropriate!
Not a big surprize! It's not like you can send out your own report clearing Palin of everything the night before, and expect us to belive that she would'nt be found guilty! We are not that daft McCain!
Let's see: associations with the Alaska Independence Party, abuse of powers of the Governor's office, charges per diem for resident expenses and family member travel, spouse involved in elected office matters; HUM, sounds more like Dick Chaney or Carl Rove in lipstick and heals rather than a pitbull.  

Surprise, surprise...
Vindication and Victory!!
What other proof does anyone in America need of McCain’s loose cannon status.
Vetted? Are you kidding me?
Soul mate? that I believe. 2 jackass vicious politicians.
Maverick my butt….
Country first my eye….

The lies begin to completely unravel..
Good bye and very good riddance to McCain and this sick ugly bigot from Alaska in 2012 as well I say.

Now lets get on to the business at hand.
We must all still get out and vote for Obama.
Lets give him the mandate needed to really change DC and our country.
Was there ever any question?
You really need to point out that this committee had a disproportionally HIGHER number of Republicans than Democrats.  It was somewhere in the neighborhood of 11 Republicans to 4 Democrats. I honestly don't remember the exact number but the point is that this was not only a bipartisan committee-it was a LARGELY republican committee.  Its an important fact to acknowledge in EVERY REPORT you have on these findings.
Hillary, Obama and Biden were on donkeys in a boat when the boat rolled over. Who got saved?

........ America.
Now THAT'S change you can believe in!  Hahahaha!  OBAMA-BIDEN '08!!!!
Is anyone shocked?

Power used to personal agendas -  NoCheney '08
When is the other shoe going to drop about Todd and her participation in the Alaska Sessionist movement as recently in 07 and 08?  
Of course she abused her power! She is not used to losing - successful basketball player, beauty queen, hiring a PR firm to improve her image - This girl is addicted to power and winning to the point that it excludes integrity. Spoiled brat or 'Alaskan Princess' comes to mind.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1531677

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google