ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



'Most scurrilous campaign in history?'

Posted: Wednesday, October 15, 2008 4:16 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Mike Memoli
LANCASTER, Ohio -- In recent weeks, Biden has called McCain and his campaign “angry” and “erratic.” Now, maybe it’s cartoonish.

The Delaware senator referred to an editorial cartoon in today's edition of the local newspaper, the Eagle Gazette, as he criticized his Republican rivals’ efforts to tie Obama to William Ayers. It showed Palin telling McCain that Obama “pals around with a terrorist,” as the two ignore men jumping from the ledge of a bank.

“I think it best captures anything I have seen,” Biden said of the spoof. “While the economy is going to hell in a handbasket, while people are losing their jobs, while things are going under, they’re running the most scurrilous campaign in modern history trying to [smear] a decent, honorable man raised by his grandparents and his mother who worked his way up, who fought in a way that few people have to fight to make something of himself.”

The visual aid helped Biden wake up a subdued crowd here, which numbered in the low hundreds for the outdoor “community gathering” at Ohio University’s Lancaster campus. Biden blamed the Republicans’ “erratic” turn to the fact that McCain had nothing new to offer the country, which he said is uniformly looking for answers to practical problems.

“This is the ultimate job application, man,” Biden said. “This is the ultimate, ultimate job interview. And that’s what it’s about. People aren’t looking for a lot of extraneous malarkey. They’re looking for, what are you going to do, guys. What are you going to do to change my circumstance?”

If that argument sounds familiar, it is. Followers of Hillary Clinton will recall that she asked her audiences to think of their vote as a “hiring decision.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

With McCain's lack of understanding about the economy, what else can he do but change the subject?
That cartoon sums it all up. McCain and Palin incite violence and hate when the American people need leadership and inspiration.

The swiftboating will not work this time@

Feel free to comment:
http://lastofourkind.blogspot.com
Hillary was right and so is Joe. This isn't a game but a serious job interview for the most powerful job on the planet. We want to know how YOU are qualified. Let the other guy tell us how he is qualified and let us decide which we want to hire. Trash talking generally won't get one a job. It shouldn't especially for such a lofty position as POTUS.
Great message about a great presidential candidate.  Obama in 08!
I kept asking myself.. "Is it just me?"  I think its been a horrible campaign this year.  To make such horrible accusations of someone running for President by a fellow congressman instills not only a potential doubt for that candidate but the government overall.  Creating a ripple of fear in the American people serves no one except the one breeding the disdain.  I am appalled at the lengths Palin has gone when she herself as been deemed as having to abusing her powers.  They do us no service, the McCain Campaign.  They are a disruptive force that should be held responsible for the damage they are causing.
I love BO and Joe!  

Common sense intelligent people for our time, unlike that other crew on the other side.  

The republican ticket is more like the Decepticons and the Democrats are more like Autobots.  McCain is more like Megatron and Obama Optimus Prime.

In this stronghold of our crisis, McCain Megatron feels Optimus Prime (Obama) fights for what he considers "the weak" or the middle class and Megatron (McCain) is fighting for the people to gain more power and continue to destroy this countries promise.

Can't wait for Nov 4th...bye- bye Megatron a.k.a. McCain!
Way to go, Joe!
Well the campaign is a job interview withthe American people. If I were a grumpy ole candidate who blamed others for everything, made up lies to project blame on to others, offered no details of what I could do for my employer and brought along a dim witted sidekick who couldn't recall if she reads anything I wouldn't expect to get elected either.  

The prospective employer would not employ someone who through their own misery would eventually make all the other workers a miserable lot. An employer would want to hire someone who has confidence in themselves without attacking others, who smiles a lot and who did not bring to the interview with them a half witted dunce who thinks she can perform the job duties required because she can see them from her back door.      
I have seen much worse in my life.  Think back to the Nixon days.  Look at what the Republicans tried to do to Bill Clinton.  The only elements that do come close has been the treatment of Palin on cable news and online and the truly scurrlous lies and rumors about Obama, primarily on the internet.  The far left and the far right both have much to be ashamed of in this election. Especially the so called "main street media".  Disgrace from those who would call themselves journalists like these eyes have never seen.
This statement by Biden shows just how evil the Obama campaign is. Nothing Obama does or has done can be questioned according to Obama's campaign. Obama can stand there and rattle of McCains different associations for hours, but the second McCain does the same, Obama is crying like the baby he is. You know, hanging around terrorists that mean harm to the people of this country IS a bad thing. Listening to hte black separatist rants of a Rev. Wright and calling him your mentor IS a bad thing. Having a blind eye towards a sweetheart land deal with a lobbyist money machine like Rezco IS a bad thing. Working closely with a voter fraud outfit like ACORN IS a bad thing. These are Obama's associatons, his pals, his mentors, and the people that produce the money for his campaigns. To try and turn this back on McCain is scurrulous.
Well, I cast my hiring decision today.  Early voting opened this morning in Tennessee.  There were about 100 ahead of me in line and by time I got in the door, that many behind me and they kept on coming.  It was amazing.  People crossing the parking lot on walkers, canes, in wheelchairs, carrying portable oxygen.  These folks were determined to vote!  I saw many whole families - mom, dad and the kids - lining up to take part in history.  

What an humbling experience!  
This true.  Our nation has real problems, however, the Republican base wants to talk about the 1960s.  And John McCain, who missed the 1960s, has a complex about the time period - rememeber is quip about Woodstock.

If John McCain brings up Ayers or Wright, he will fire up his base, but further lose the independents and Reagan Democrats.

I want McCain to lose, so I am hoping he brings up as many divisive issues as he can!  It will reinforce how out of touch he is with the real America.
Biden does not get the big crowds that Palin does. He seems comfortable with the relative lack of attention.  We trust him to govern well.  He's just bidin' his time, knowing he is assured of sharing an important role in the government of this country.  Meanwhile, Sarah is enjoying pallin' around with McCain and soon will have that much valued quality time with her family!
haha i love how biden always says "malarkey" he reminds me of my grandfather.  and, of course, he's completely spot on, as usual.
I've been voting in presidential elections since '76, and to the best of my recollection I have to agree that the McCain campaign is the most scurrilous of any that I can recall.  I actually was for McCain in 2000 and as we started the 2008 season he was my first choice.  But all of McCain's lies and twisted attacks made me rethink things.  So that, plus the obviously better grasp of the economy and energy that Obama has, made the choice simple.  Obama/Biden in '08!
I will take Obama/Biden over McCain/Palin anyday. McCain has said absolutely nothing that has any meaning on the economy and I'm tired of listening to him and his campaign's grousing about Obama's "lack of character." If anyone has proven that they are deficient in the "character" department, it's McCain. He picked an idiot for a running mate and his campaign has been ugly, shameful and insulting to the American people.
In this stronghold of our crisis, McCain Megatron feels Optimus Prime (Obama) fights for what he considers "the weak" or the middle class and Megatron (McCain) is fighting for the people to gain more power and continue to destroy this countries promise.

Can't wait for Nov 4th...bye- bye Megatron a.k.a. McCain!

----------------------------------------------------

Haha...McCainatron and Obamus Prime
Anyone outraged about the group wearing the "Palin is a (vulgarism for female anatomy" t-shirts and shouting "Let's stone her old school!" ????  Seems everyone likes to talk about nastiness on the right, but the news won't even report on the nasty, vicious attacks coming from Obama rallies.  
The Obama campaign has received small amounts from thousands of people.  This is in the form of a pyramid (if you will grant me this example).  This is the way we need to get back on track.  Small amounts of money (through job creation) to thousands of people.  Poor people, working poor people, middle class and concerned wealthy people.  A pyramid can't exist without a large, supporting base.  That is why the trickle down doesn't work.  There is no large supportive base.  Republican theory attacks a problem from the top down.  Obama and Biden have the solution correctly (in my opinion) aimed at working from the bottom up.  It doesn't matter how wealthy Walmart is or how many prices they cut.  If you ain't got the dough, it ain't gonna go!
I just voted early.  So did many others.  And as I overheard various conversations in this republican stronghold called Orange County CA, I heard one name repeated most often.  It had 3 syllables.
October Surprise.

Sometime between July - August 2008.

McCain:  Mr. President, please ignore your commanders on the ground in Afghanistan calling for more troops and equipment.  Please ignore the Afghan situation through October.

Bush: Okay, but it could escalate to a point of costing many American lives.

McCain: That's the price we'll have to pay to wake up the American people to the fact that electing a liberal democrat to the White House would be the worst choice they could make.

Bush: Okay, John, I'll employ a hands-off policy.

McCain: If the situation doesn't escalate on it's own by the 3rd presidential debate, you might have to take action by sending out patrols in order to show weakness and draw in the enemy, en masse.

Bush: Okay, John.  You've come a long way in eight years.  You'll make a fine president.

McCain:  Thank you Mr. President.

Bush:  Good-by.

McCain: Good-by.

Hillary was right and so is Joe. This isn't a game but a serious job interview for the most powerful job on the planet. We want to know how YOU are qualified. Let the other guy tell us how he is qualified and let us decide which we want to hire. Trash talking generally won't get one a job. It shouldn't especially for such a lofty position as POTUS.
"Why does it take a very competent black man to run against a very incompetent white man before a black man can make it to the white  house" - FE
Trish Bazek, Texas,

Maybe you should do a little research of your own about McCain's associates. Do you realize he has 177 former lobbyist working on his campaign? Do you know his ties in the past to people like G.Gordan Libby? The Keating 5? Do you know his REAL story of being a POW and singing the moment he was captured??? Please, before you throw stones at Obama, look at your candidate and tell me then that he's a better candidate for becoming POTUS.....because he's NOT!
Your candidate is toast, so you better get use to calling barack Obama, Mr. President.
If you think McCain's smear campaign hasn't incited hatred, go to the Fox website and read the political blogs.  It's a very sad day for America.  
I have never been able to watch as much as I have this year, you know, we were woking. But, I am so afraid for my country, and what these people have done, to my constitution, to my bill of rights, for the way the world looks at us, and as Mr. Biden said, we are going to hell in a handbasket. We have to stop it, with this election. I am old enough to remember John Kennedy, Nixon, the atrosities that Henry Kissinger pulled, all of that. We need Obama, and Biden. And we need our constitution brought back! And as Donald Trump said, George Bush should have been impeached!!!!! (let's see if this gets printed)
I think it is unforgivable the way Sarah Palin incites unfounded hatred against Barack Obama. Having grown up around Dallas, and being old enough to remember, I don't want to go through the horror of another assasination, or even an attempted one. Does no one remember November 22, 1963 ? Shame, shame, shame on you, Sarah Palin !!!!
This is indeed the "most scurrilous campaign in modern history."  McCain/Palin have stooped to a level unheard of in presidential elections; they have gone way over the top; much farther than the Bush/Rove campaigns even thought of. Innuendo and outright lies are the staple of this  cmpaign; Honor, honesty, and integrity have gone out the window. How  can voters with ingtegrity consider voting for this ticket?
Its kinda funny how both campaigns seem to be lifting stuff from Hillary. I'm a full-on Obama supporter but I also have a lot of respect for Hillary. She has some great ideas for this country. Hopefully a "President" Obama will seriously consider appointing her to a high cabinet position, perhaps Secretary of State or Attorney General.
Trish, it's not the rattling off these so-called associations, it's the actual hate and violence expressed by some of your comrades at McCain and Palin rallies, that are incited by the false rhetoric and not throttled down by your candidates. This is much like the sixties when it was anticipated that narrow minded bigots would resort to these same tactics. And that is the truth.
Joe is such a great asset.

Not trying to make headlines, just keeping his nose to the grind stone, connecting with people.

I love it when he says 'malarkey'. Makes me think of an Irish cop.

http://www.rodneyhopper.com
Any person who would want obama for the leader of this county has got to be crazy the man is muslin has no morals anything goes with him I  assure you he can't fix this economy he can only steal from it he would like to play Robin Hood steal from the rich and give to the poor (people who rufuse work when there was jobs) This govement was build on christian values let's keep that way
Do not blame McCain and Palin when Obama wins and
you wake up run by Anti-American people. Facts show he worked with Ayers, Wright has said God Damn America, you hear it and ignore it., Farrakan just called Obama the Messiah, you still ignore and say propaganda Check the videos, you waiting for it on the news media, you have a long wait, most are in
the Obama side. We will all get what we deserve.
Wow... Americans are suffering from ignorance.... It's o.k. to have a BLACK MAN the leader of a sports team, or event that people can cheer for and feel proud in a victory. But now that we have not just a black man running for the highest office in the free world, a position that will say to the World, "America has finally arrives in the New Millennium", we have insecure idiot's, "people that probably voted for G.W. Bush Jr.", scared of a PERSON making sense. It's as if Obama and McCain should have a "Face Off", like the movie... Maybe then Americans can justify Obama as being incompetent and McCain has the one with the silver tongue..... Wake the hell up people, we need a leader with VISION not a leader with REPRESSION......
Dear Prospective Employee Palin,
I am sorry but your application is incomplete. I noticed that you put down "I don't have to answer questions I dont like" rather than fill out the questionaire.  I see you would prefer to trash the other applicant rather than speak about job requirements.  I also note that you will not speak about anything unless everyone is looking at you.  By the way, you cannot choose the interviewer and refuse to speak to anyone else, winking at the hiring committee is sexual harrassement, and this work place doesnt tolerate racism.  I am sorry we are unable to hire you.

Thank you,

American Public
Way to go Joe!
Trish Bazek (and others):  Does it occur to you how many similar "shocking names" we would be familiar with if Obama's campaign had taken the tack used by McCain, and before him Clinton, and been willing to drag up every unsavory or questionable connection or rumor from HIS opponent's past?  The fact that the Clinton machine and the Republicans have only been able to drag out two or three connections (and those wildly exaggerated), out of all the 1000's that Obama or anyone active in politics would have, is absolutely astonishing - he must be the cleanest politician ever!  Wake up and smell the coffee.  Obama has taken a big risk: he's trusting the American people to understand that the issues matter and to not be misled by the seamy distractions his opponents can make up or drag out.  I hope we are worthy of his trust.  
Does anyone else see this campaign as not just Obama vs. McCain, but as the people vs. big business. Considering the present state of the economy, the people are finally winning.
The 1960's - who cares? Obama was 6 years old. What is Ayers doing now?  This is a new century with huge problems.  We need to be in the NOW.  Let's get it on.  We have work to do.  We need to turn the page.
Way to go - Obama/Biden!!  
Sometimes you just have to feel sorry for the John McCain supporters.  They have absolutely nothing to go on but hope and even that seems to be dwindling.  
A young friend described this election as driving a car:  if you want to go forward, choose "D" but if you want to go backward, select "R"

Made perfect sense to me!
Buy one get one free!
Vote for one great leader, get the second one FREE!

OBAMA/BIDEN 08!!!!!!
You said it all JOE.  Thanks for being you.
Trish Bazek, Texas

LOLOLOLOLOL!!!!!

Thats the best you can do?  Obama hasnt been rattling off oblique associations of McCain's...not until provoked.  And even then he stears it back to issues.  Have you even been watching the campaign or are you one of those ignorant voters with their fingers in the ears screaming LALALALALALALA.  You post is so full of regurgitate neo con babble, there is no way you can be that stupid.  Seriously.

Everyone one of your points has been dealt with, investigated, reopened and put to rest months ago.  I am sorry you are too busy in your own little world to pay attention to the world around you.  But please, before you open your yap, try and give your brain a chance to work.  
Trish,
I know you'll ignore the FACTS that I'm about to give you, but it's worth a try.

"You know, hanging around terrorists that mean harm to the people of this country IS a bad thing."

I have to assume that you mean William Ayers.  Mr. Ayers happens to have violently protested the Viet Nam war in the 60's.   He is now a professor and respected member of the Chicago area, lives in Obama's neighborhood, played a role in an Annenberg Foundation initiative to improve the Chicago educational system that Obama was also amember, and one time he was invited by a third party to a fund raiser at Syers' home - the fundraiser was not for Obama.

As for the "black separatist rants of a Rev. Wright (while) calling him your mentor IS a bad thing. If you had investigated a little you would have found the reasons that Obama called Rev Wright his mentor and that Wright is NOT a black separatist.  Not only that, but Obama has denounced Wright's infamous rants (and left Trinity Church).

"Having a blind eye towards a sweetheart land deal with a lobbyist money machine like Rezco IS a bad thing."  The sweetheart land deal was not sweetheart.  While Rezko's purchase of the lot next to the house that Obama wanted to purchase allowed the purchase of the house to go through. Obama admitted that asking Rezko (a land developer) to purchase that lot was a bone-headed move.  I guess admitting a mistake is less than honorable.

"Working closely with a voter fraud outfit like ACORN IS a bad thing."  First off, you might want to research ACORN a little.  They are NOT a voter fraud outfit.  If you'd done that, you'd see that the voter registration fraud was perpetrated against ACORN.  By law ACORN is required to turn in ALL voter registrations they collect.  ACORN pays people to get voter registrations.  ACORN then verifies them and sends in all registrations, flagging the registrations that ACORN was unable to confirm.

"These are Obama's associatons, his pals, his mentors, and the people that produce the money for his campaigns."  In case you're unaware, the bulk of Obama's campaign money comes from ordinary citizens. Last time I checked, his average donation was less than $100 and the number of contributors was well over a million.

Your misinformed rant is scurrilous.
Great commentaries! High level reads.
We feel very fortunate to watch and listen to MSNBC and keep the station on most of the day, and late into the night. Thanks to all you hard working people for reporting fair, intelligent, balanced and honest accounts during this tumultuous election process.  
         
I think it's sad that McCain/Palin have tried to brain wash us into believing Obama is a terrorist. Scarring us into voting for McCain will not work in 2008!!After all republicans lied to us about Iraq and weaponds of mass distruction, then they tried to tie the 911 to Iraq, now they want us to believe them, No way not this time. We all need to vote on Nov. 4!!!
To Trish in Texas:  Guilt by association is just that;
uninformed, ignorant, and circumstantial.  If you had lunch someone in your neighborhood who happened to also be a criminal (unbeknowst to you of course), would that make you a criminal by association?  Obama was 8 years old when the Weather Underground was active.  Hmmm.  So 40 years later, when Bill Ayers has been rehabilitated (ever hear of that term?), now Obama is portrayed as "palling around with terrorists" by some retard who thinks men walked the Earth with dinosaurs.  Gosh; how about the university where Bill Ayers teaches?  How about his students?  His collegues?  How about he is no longer in his 20's and has significantly changed his views?  How about you stop listening to the desperate Republican rhetoric and use your (gasp if you have one) brain?
Character does matter. Wright, Ayers, Rezko etc., are very much an issue with me, regarding obama's character.
Early voting in my state allowed me to proudly cast my vote for Sen. McCain today.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1548251

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google