ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Battleground: Narrow-victory scenario

Posted: Friday, October 17, 2008 9:02 AM by Carrie Dann
Filed Under:

The New York Times: “Confronting an increasingly bleak electoral map, top aides to Senator John McCain said Thursday that they were searching for a ‘narrow-victory scenario’ and would focus in the final weeks on a dwindling number of states, using mailings, telephone calls and television advertisements to try to tear away support from Senator Barack Obama… ‘The scenario for winning for us is a narrow-victory scenario,’ [McCain strategist Steve] Schmidt said. ‘The fact that we’re in the race at all — within striking distance with a 5 percent right track — is a miracle. Because the environment is so bad and the head wind is so strong.’”

Also in the story, Obama manager David Plouffe says that -- outside of Iowa and New Mexico -- Colorado and Virginia are the two states he believes “that Mr. Obama had the best chance of pulling from the Republican column.” Plouffe also says that they’re eyeing West Virginia.

COLORADO: Democrats now outnumber Republicans in Arapahoe County in this state, 118,026 to 113,670, with 109,397 unaffiliated voters. Back in November 2004, however, Republicans were ahead, 133,885 to 106,690. In sum, Democrats have gained 11,336 voters (a 26% increase), while Republicans have lost 20,215 (a 20% decrease). That's a 31,000-vote difference in a place where Bush won by 9,000 votes in 2004.

Here’s another fascinating stat: "Nearly half of the state’s registered voters have requested ballots by mail, compelling the Obama and McCain campaigns to kick-start their get-out-the-vote efforts — and devise new and imaginative ones. All across the state, the traditional Election Day sprint by campaign workers has changed into a nearly monthlong marathon, made all the more pressing by the tightness of the race."

Both McCain and Palin will hit the Centennial State next week.

Uh-oh. The Denver Post reports: "Colorado is among the least-prepared states to deal with potential voting-system meltdowns on Election Day, a report released Thursday says. The report -- from the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University's School of Law, Common Cause and the Verified Voting Foundation -- looked at four areas of preparedness in all 50 states. Those included polling-place contingency plans, ballot accounting and reconciliation requirements, use of a verifiable paper trail and whether the state conducted post-election audits of paper records. Colorado was among 10 states that received the worst rankings of ‘needs improvement’ or ‘inadequate’ in three of the four categories. The others were Delaware, Kentucky, Louisiana, New Jersey, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah and Virginia."

FLORIDA: McCain's trip to address a heavily Hispanic audience in Miami isn't exactly a stretch out of the candidate's comfort zone, even as he struggles to net indie voters. “ ‘I'm not going to say it's a pilgrimage to the Holy Land, but basically he's going to the cradle of the base,’ said Republican state Rep. J.C. Planas, who represents nearby Westchester.”  
 
Students and minorities are among those facing the biggest voting registration problems in central Florida.

INDIANA: Per the Indy Star, the number of absentee ballots cast in the first week of early voting tops 60,000. More: "Nearly 27,000 absentee votes have been cast in counties that usually vote Republican. Those tend to be rural and suburban areas with smaller populations. In counties that do not have a clear pattern, 14,276 early votes were cast in the first week."  
 
Twenty-five thousand people are expected in Indianapolis to attend Palin's Noblesville rally today.

NORTH CAROLINA: Early voting in North Carolina is underway, and lines are surprising some poll workers.

OHIO: The Plain Dealer lays out the details of the unfolding legal flap over 200,000 newly registered voters in Ohio.

The Boston Globe continues its Ohio series, in Shawnee, Southeast of Columbus. "A lot of folks in the Shawnee area seem to feel the same way. It's a mixture of fatalism about their station in life and cynicism that a new president will make any meaningful difference in their lives. Things are pretty bad, and they have no hope that Barack Obama or John McCain will do a darn thing about it.
 
"Shawnee and its fellow coal towns are known as the Little Cities of Black Diamonds. Fires are said to still burn in the old underground mines, but above ground the cities' spark has long been extinguished. There's still a mine or two operating in the area, but what's left largely are the industry's remnants, both human and environmental. A milky, acidic substance flows out of an old mine entrance near New Straitsville; the signs warn not to touch it."

WEST VIRGINIA: Obama’s now up on the air in this state. The AP notes: "Obama is carrying his campaign into traditionally Republican states, spending the next few days in Missouri, North Carolina and Virginia. Yesterday, he bought airtime to run ads all across West Virginia, which Bush won twice and is dominated by white voters. In a sign that pocketbook concerns are trumping any prejudices, a recent AP poll showed that Obama has inched up among whites with no college education while McCain has lost ground."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Polls, real polls, not these phony CBS NY Times polls, are showing the race is a dead heat. That means McCain is actually winning because all polls are always skewed to the Democrat.
Why am I not surprised that the Orlando area is going to be Voter center of the universe this time out?  I have family members going to Central Univ. in Orlando and I don't know that they still got to get their Vote By Mail Ballots.  I have a feeling this state is going to be a total fiasco.
Enough is enough. We're the United States - didn't we invent voting?

Why in the hell, in 2008, are we constantly hearing about states that can't accurately and efficiently collect ballots?
.
OBAMA'S "SPREADING THE WEALTH" ---- CODE WORDS FOR TAKING MONEY FROM THOSE WHO

HAVE EARNED IT ... AND GIVING IT TO THOSE WHO HAVE NOT!   ALSO KNOWN AS "SOCIALISM."

.
50% OF OBAMA'S SO-CALLED MIDDLE-CLASS TAX CUTS WILL GO TO THOSE WHO PAY NO

TAXES!!!  ... SPREADING THE WEALTH! ...  SOCIALISM THRU TAXATION!
.
===>>>   SPREAD THE WORD ---- OBAMA WILL RAISE OUR TAXES.
McNasty's narrow victory plan will lead to a big defeat!  Barack has the correct strategy for winning by playing offense in so many red states that he just can't lose as he turns many from red to Blue.

Isn't it hilarious that Hillary whupped Obama badly in West Virginia yet now Obama has a chance to turn it Blue.  That's very telling and should indicate a huge change election victory for Obama.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
The only way McCain/Palin can win is to manipulate the election as the Republicans did in 2000 and 2004. They are working on this process now in Ohio by purging the voter rolls, and I'm sure they are doing something in Florida just as rotten.
I am interested to see how Obama's unprecedented ground game plays out.  If college gets actually shake their hangovers and go vote this time, and the pollster underestimate the African-American turnout, this could be a landslide. IF, IF , IF......
The McCain campaign is focused on tactics.  The Obama campaign is focused on a message that resonates with the people.  Tactics have brought the race closer than it has any right to be, but the voters are sick of tactics over message, and we can't afford it any longer.
ALMOST HEAVEN!!!! Come see us Barack!!

We will continue to work hard to turn WV blue.
The newest most disgraceful Rick Davis like lie from the McCain campaign is their Robo-call, trying to tie Obama to terrorism. Rick Davis should be fired. Rick Davis should have no place in political discourse. Rick Davis should be unmasked and unmanned.
don't count your chickens until they hatch, or in this case, vote!
Poll watcher:
Please post the links to your "Real polls" so we can all be see where you get your "real" information from
The greatest feeling one can experience as an American is exercising one's right/responsibility to vote. On Wednesday I proudly cast my ballot for Obama/Biden. What a great feeling. What an honor.
I really enjoyed the levity from last nights Al Smith fundraiser. Both candidates looked great and both were hilarious. It was a nice break from the filth being promoted by the McSame campaign. It breaks my heart when I see the clips of the white people that are so ignorant and hateful towards our next President, Barack Obama. Get used to saying America! President Barack Obama.
Don't let up now. Everyone: Please vote!
Obama/Biden 08'
I would imagine any decent republican would be
upset, disgusted, dismayed and embarressed by
the tactics the RNC has resorted to.
There is no room in our great country for a
political party that has disregarded all
honor and integrety to try and win an election.
Our country is not based on lies, dirt and
the American voters are too intelligent to
give any attention to this swiftboating.
Enough is enough. We're the United States - didn't we invent voting?

Why in the hell, in 2008, are we constantly hearing about states that can't accurately and efficiently collect ballots?

Paul Miller, Woodbridge, VA (Sent Friday, October 17, 2008 9:19 AM)


Because it's the government doing the collecting. These are the same people that liberals want to manage their health care, take over their banks, and run their lives from cradle to grave. And they can't even manage to collect ballots.
Yes, there will be some close battleground states. And sometimes it is hard to cut through the spin and see what is really happening.  McCain will get the wingnut conservative vote, the evalgelical vote, the racist vote. Moderates and independents will split.

Obama will get the AA vote, and the youth vote.  Yes, the under 25 age group will vote this time. Actually Karl Rove knew about how to activate and organize communities.  So does Obama.  Think about it.  If half of the people who gave hard earned dollars to the Obama campaign go out and work for Obama in the last four days, that will be over a million volunteers. They have worked too hard to quit now. See you at the polls.
If Obama wins in West Virginia that will speak volumes.
Though the election is no way CLOSE to being finished, I am excited to see our nation...state by state with increased voter registration and excitement for the presidential election.  May we all vote with forethought and conscience and not with bitter resentment or fear of race of color.  This nation was built on unity NOT on our ability to cut another down to raise ourselves up.    
The mere fact that the McBush campaign is talking about a NARROW-VICTORY scenario shows how bleak things look for the Republicans.  I think it's going to be a blowout.  Obama will win at least 300 electoral votes.  Obama is underperforming in the polls because young and AA voters are not traditionally selected for these polls.  The African American voter is extremely energized and I heard if they increase their turnout by 1 - 2% it's going to be LOOOONG night for the McBush camp Nov. 4th.  I'm expecting them to increase turnout by at least 10%.  GAME OVER!!
Noblesville is NOT Indianapolis.  It is about 40 minutes northeast of downtown, and not even in the same county as Indianapolis.   It was one of the key centers of "white flight" out of the city of Indianapolis in response to busing and integration in the 1970s, mainly for rednecks who couldn't afford the tonier burbs of Carmel and Zionsville or even the upper middle class areas near Geist Resevoir.  It is the darkest red area with any sizeable population in the Central Indiana area. The local nickname for the town is telling:

NOBLETUCKY

Indianapolis itself is deep blue, largely surrounded by purple.  The district covering downtown Indy just elected the second Muslim member of Congress, Julia Carson's grandson, in a special election.  So please don't call it an Indianapolis event.  
Obama: 334+ Electoral College Votes - Take it to the bank.

Get out there and vote!
Poll Watcher: Kind of cherry picking your polls, right ? Just like Drudge? Drudge looks at the old model of voting in the Gallup poll. The new model of voting in the other Gallup poll has Obama up by 6. Not to mention the new LA Times and Bloomberg poll today which have him up by 7.... And OBama's leading in Missouri now. And the AA turnout in places like Georgia is unprecedented.
   If McShame's "Pal's" can see a Narrow-Victory scenario, then I can see "Russia" from my house....
With all the help Obama receives from MSNBC, particularly from Chris, Keith and Rachel, how can he lose? And Rachel, the sarcasm is not cute.
I am a democrat, but the only fairly unbiased program I have seen lately is Joe in the morning on MSNBC.  
NO WHERE does Obama say he will give tax credits in excess of taxes paid.  Your soundng like McSame, just make up a punch line or Failin, "I don't want to answer that question but ....Get your FACTS right first
Nope, Sorry, Not Happening!

The media would have you believe that this election is close, but what us folk out here on the beat know is that this one is pretty much wrapped up.

There's a group of us down here in Florida who are making rondom calls in our respective cities, and we've totalled well over 5000 calls over the past 3 days, and 64 out of every 100 calls say they're going Obama in this election...

Guess what? We know something that you pundits don't know ;) So with that, I'm turned off entirely with this whole polling thing. These networks have lost all credibility with me, cause we're finding out first hand that there are angles being played by the media. (Y'all need to keep it real)

Only the McCain supporters are focusing on the polls. Us Obama supporters are out here on the grind. Making calls. Knocking on doors. Pulling out our lap tops SHOWING the facts. Busting our butts, getting things done... Working for the people, just as Barack Obama is sure to.

CHANGE IS BUT 18 DAYS AWAY!
'STAY FOCUSED'
One question.  Why are the McCainiacs having all kinds of orgasims over one Gallup poll that shows a mere 2pt gap between Obama and McCain (with Obama leading, no less) when every other poll (including a Gallup Expanded poll) shows Obama ahead by 4+?

Face it, McCainiacs.  Your man lost this thing the minute he decided to abandon his honor and dignity by running a scorched-earth negative campaign and chosing a hopelessly unqualified running mate.  All he has left is to try and walk away with some shred of dignity left.

Obama/Biden '08!
http://jawillie.blog.com
TAXES!!!  ... SPREADING THE WEALTH! ...  SOCIALISM THRU TAXATION


How about spreading the weath through bailouts.  Thats not socialism, right??????
McCain's selection of Palin has cost him dearly in the Latino and Jewish communities.  It has also cost him most of the Independent support.  Palin's rallies tend to divide our country at a time we need a leader to bring us together.

When "Joe the not really a Plumber" has done 10 times more interviews in 24 hours that a VP candidate has done the entire campaign, it's really a problem.  In troubling times, leaders talk to the people in a way to raise their spirits and inspire them to think things will get better.

We have not seen this from McCain or Palin.  

Compare Obama, Bush, and McCain's economic speeches.  Almost every day that Bush speaks about the economy, the market tumbles.
Monday, Obama reveals his economic stimulus package, the market has it's biggest point gain in history.
Tuesday, the market is up.  Then, McCain speaks and the market tumbles.
TAXES!!!  ... SPREADING THE WEALTH! ...  SOCIALISM THRU TAXATION


How about spreading the wealth through bailouts.  Thats not socialism, right??????
Let me tell you whats wrong with a narrow victory scenario...it only works if there is a heaping helping of racism thrown in to scare middle class whites into thinking blacks will take their women and jobs...and you cant lead a nation after winning that way racists
West Virginia is not a Republican state but in Presidential elections. It has a Democratic Governor, two Democratic Senators, an overwhelmingly Democratic legislature and a US House Delegation of two Democrats and one Republican. The Democrats there are more socially conservative and Bush won by exploiting social issues and some fears about how environmental reforms would effect jobs in the coal industry. This year a very bad economy gives the Democrats a much better chance.
Joe is not a socialist.  He is willing to work 12 hours a day because the benefits of his labor go to him and his family. When it no longer benefit him and his family, he will do just enough to get by.  Then where will the victim society get their freebees?
When you say "Spreading the wealth" I assume you are talking about Obama's plan to fairly tax those making over $250,000.  The wealthy in this country have had the government in their pocket the last 8 years and as a result, the middle class has fallen farther and farther behind while the top 1% put fuel in their yachts.  The economic strength of our country is dependent upon the existence of the middle class.  Minimum wages and unions have helped build our economy, but the economic policies (Trickle-Down) have undermined working people.  We have seen our standard of living actually decline for the first time since the Great Depression.  If rich people don't like paying fair taxes, they should fuel up their yachts and go elsewhere.  If you disagree with me, give Warren Buffet a call - he thinks the McCain (Bush) tax cuts are UNFAIR to working people.
Senator McCain voted against the minimum wage increase fifteen times! During that same period he voted himself a raise every single year!  Nuff said.
NO, 50% OF OBAMA'S SO-CALLED MIDDLE-CLASS TAX CUTS WILL NOT GO TO THOSE WHO PAY NO TAXES!!!  A taxpayer cannot reduce his taxes below zero!  More taxpayers under Obama will pay no taxes.  More will pay less taxes.  Obama has offered a plan that actually shifts the tax burden off the backs of people who live paycheck to paycheck, and onto the backs of the wealthy.  The wealthy will pay what they did in the 90s again.  Plus, all those middle class folks who will be paying less soon will be returning more to the economy than did the rich under the failed "trickle down" economics of the Republicans.
"Enough is enough. We're the United States - didn't we invent voting?"

No Paul, I believe it was the Athenians long before Christ that invented voting, or maybe the Europeans before Columbus even sailed across the pond.

I live in SW Missouri near Springfield. When Biden announced his visit here the Rep. leaders said they didn't know why he would come here since there's so very few Democrats in the area. What a suprise they will get on Nov. 4th. We may not be be loud but we are many. It's just hard to put out a yard sign in the rural areas for fear of being shuned.
-
AP/YAHOO Poll of 873 Democrats; 650 Republicans shows OBAMA 44%, MCCAIN 42%...
.
THESE POLL NUMBERS MAKE IT CLEAR:
.
"THE ELECTION NOW IS A MATTER OF VOTER TURNOUT"...
.
TURNOUT THE MCCAIN SUPPORTERS --- AND MCCAIN WILL WIN!
.
ACORN'S FRAUDULENTLY REGISTERED VOTERS WILL NOT SHOW UP AT THE POLLS ----  

IF THEY DO .... THEY MUST BE IDENTIFIED & ARRESTED ....
.
Polls are worthless they are just a snap shot in time. Nobody can tell what a voter will do in the privacy of the booth. Give me a break.
This is extrordinary that Obama who didn't do well at all in West Virginia's primary is now trying to take it from McCain.  Either this means that Obama has so much money to spend that he can do anything or he is actually doing very well.  States are changing all over the place.  There are few states that are staying as they were; just the big ones.  
I pray every night that 2008 won't be a reprisal of 2000, but I am afraid it is a possiblity.  You watch, Obama will win the popular vote, and somehow, McCain will come out on top.  I hope I'm wrong, and all the smart, resonable and open-minded people get out the vote so its such a landlside that there is no question, but the republicans are so good at stealing elections that it scares me.
with the polls (gallup--in particular) tightening, watch for Obama to win this election by about 7%.  I think his 30 minute TV buy will sway about 2% back to his side....  

The reason why McCain is continuing his negative ad's and attacks is because the lead has shrunk and they have nothing else to attribute it to.  The problem for McCain is, the polls aren't closing fast enough and alot of early voting is already taking place.

What Obama needs to do is... run the McCain ad that shows McCain the "next president of the US"...

... it's a great WAKE UP call and should dissipate voter complacency


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1560313

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google