ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



The S word, again

Posted: Wednesday, October 22, 2008 12:29 PM by Carrie Dann


From NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy

GOFFSTOWN, NH – After nearly a week of dedicating most of his stump speech to Joe the Plumber and Obama’s promise to “spread the wealth around,” McCain slightly shifted his focus today to hit Obama harder on his government spending proposals. But before he jumped to the new material, McCain couldn’t forget about Joe entirely.

“Every once in a while, my opponent gives us all a little glimpse of what an Obama presidency would be like in the real world,” McCain said. “And last week his campaign actually found itself on a detour into the real world -- in the driveway of Joe the Plumber.”

Without calling Obama’s plan socialistic himself, McCain prompted the crowd to respond as such by saying that “before government can redistribute wealth, it has to confiscate wealth from those who earned it, and whatever the right word is for that way of thinking,” to which several members of the crowd yelled what they felt the right word was: “socialism.”

On government spending, McCain said that his opponent’s plan requires “150 billion dollars” in new spending, citing amounts of money that Obama has pledged for education, energy, infrastructure and healthcare. 

“Does anyone seriously believe that these trillions of dollars are going to come from only the very highest income earners?” McCain asked the crowd of over 2,000 gathered at St. Anselm College. “Even his supporters are skeptical. Democratic Senator Jay Rockefeller of West Virginia said of these plans, quote, ‘There’s not enough money to do all this stuff.’ An influential newspaper called his claims, quote, ‘neither politically nor economically plausible.’ That critique came from the editorial board of The New York Times, and when Barack Obama loses them you know he's gone too far.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

McCain ought to quit this STUNT called 'Joe, the Plumber'.   We all know, by know, that this was a set-up to try to fool the voters again.

VOTERS ----D0N'T BUY THIS GARBAGE!   Again, America - let us show McCain and Palin that we are NOT STUPID as they think we are.


VOTE OBAMA/BIDEN '08
What McFossil is scared about is his own taxes. With Obama's plan, it's McMoneybags that has to pay a bit extra. Just think about it... his wife is a billionaire but he is so greedy that he still collects his military benefits. Benefits that could help injured veterans.  he is one of those FAT CATS that you all despise. What he is doing is trying to persuade you to vote against what is best for you so that he can keep his numerous homes and continue living the good life.
I'll bet the vast majority of Americans have no clue what "socialism" really is. If they enjoy Medicare, Social Security, Labor Unions, Unemployment Insurance...These are all socialist economic initiatives--and were denounced as such by the Republican/ Conservatives of the day..
I wish all Americans would take a crash course in American History.
increased taxes is not socialism, its the effect of years of tax breaks for the wealthy and corporations during the Bush administration.  The give the rich more money theory has bankrupted our nation and morals, giving way to the philosophy of greed and self interest instead of putting "country first".

McCain the hypocrite, slandering without remorse one of the truly visionary figures of our time all in the vain hopes of getting the position he deserves.  

Sen. McCain, being a POW may get you elected to congress and the senate, but it doesn't qualify you for the presidency, and your stubborn claim to continue the direction of the worst president in U.S. history disqualifies you from being a valid option in this election.

new times and debunked theories demand new ideas, and Sen. McCain has not had any during this entire campaign, choosing instead to focus on character and celebrity of his opponent to gain support.  FAIL!

http://horneddevil.proboards98.com/index.cgi?board=iduspolitics&action=display&thread=62
Simply put, ROLLING BACK present tax cuts for the wealthy back to the Reagan era simply does not define socialism. It is another false claim borne out of desperation and dangled before those constituents who simply don't know any better but to spread further falsity within the ranks. McCain's distorted campaign rides solely on divisiveness, innuendo and false claims. He is such an embarrassment that is precisely why so many public conservatives are seen publicly bailing his sinking ship. Like spouting "trickle down economics" that tried and tested theory no longer holds water and is all full of leaks. Let's put and end to the drips and those who profess its 20th Century use applicable to the 21st.

VOTE EARLY! VOTE TODAY! BRING A CROWD OF FRIENDS!

Obama/Biden 08!
How about Big Gummintconfiscating the MUCH SMALLER wealth of the middle class to redistribute it UPWARD for a ruinous tax break for the rich---the beginning of the end of our healthy, Clintonian economy?  I'd call that "CORPORATE SOCIALISM!!"
BTW, free-market capitalists, when do I get MY $150,000 clothing spree?
McCain throws socialism around like some of us aren't collecting social security and on medicare.
They would really like to be able to say "Communist" but they realize that they need to use code words. The old fool and his tattered campaign doesn't get it. It won't work.
John McCain:  As Joe Walsh said to Joe McCarthy:  "Have you no shame?"  John McCain will return to Arizona a bitter man.  It is too bad.

For those who know of Charlie Cook, he is one of the best political analysts in the country.  Log on to Huffington and read Charlie's article, "Six reasons why this election is over."  Again, I agree with Charlie.
***yawn***

McPalin has no new ideas of his/her own . . . all they can do is attack and slime the opponent

I grow weary of their schtick . . . as does the vast majority of the country
Barack would be a socialist if he proposed nationalizing the textile mills and sewing shops to redistribute the cost of Sarah Palin's wardrobe.
John McCain says, “...before government can redistribute wealth, it has to confiscate wealth from those who earned it,..."
Now correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't this what the government already does?  They "confiscate" some of my wealth each and every pay period and then "redistribute" it to fund Social Security, Roads, Homeland Security, etc, etc.  

Mr. McCain, by your own definition, I already live in a socialist society.  What are you going to do about it besides accuse others of being socialist?

John McCain did support the bailout right?  And I am sure he is not going to tell us Social Security is bad.  Aren't these things forms of socialism?  
McCain is having a terrible time explaining how the Bush tax cuts for wealthiest Americans (which McCain will continue to promote) helps the economy. This "joe the plumber" comedy routine is not making the right point to voters, rather the contrary is true ...

McCain will turn to racial lines to get support from uneducated white people as his message of hate and division seems to work well within that target market (how sad).


Independents look to solutions to the issues at hand.


Independents are interested in JOBS.


Independents want calm rational leadership.


Independents Vote Obama!
Conclusion:  McCain, but it seems most of his followers, have no freeking clue what socialism actually is.  If you think the US isnt socialist, you really havent been paying attention, have you.

This is typical 20th century Cold War thinking.  McCain is stuff in the past and he is keeping you with him.
There goes Johnny Flip-flop again, relying on the New York Times whenever it suits his purpose while his campaign slime masters say the paper isn't even a news medium.
mccain is right. the rich should get to keep all of the money. screw the middle classs.
Isnt this the time to show the 2000 video of McCain with Chris Matthews where McCain is the one who says the rich should pay more taxes.

Also should it be pointed out that in Alaska there is no state income tax and "My Friends" the taxes paid by oil companies is sent to the citizens. That is called "Share the Wealth".
Absolutly, it is what it is, I am a Democrat but I am most certainly not as far left as Obama.  For some reason we seem to think its not socialism, but that is what it is when you go too far left.  You take from the haves/wealthy to give to the have-nots/poor, socialism is all about everyone being equal.  And that is what Obama wants to do, he even came out and said so.  Why does the media seem to think this is not a policy of socialism? Fascinating that we are supposed to blindly follow the media to the conclusion this is an unfair attack that is some how not true.  Are we that blind? Or do we just not care enough to pay attention?
On government spending, McCain said that his opponent’s plan requires “150 billion dollars” in new spending, citing amounts of money that Obama has pledged for education, energy, infrastructure and healthcare.  
john you just don't get it.
if we can invented 700 billion in out banking system because the republican let the greed and non regulation almost bankrupt our country, then why not spend money and reinvest in america, our bridged and roads are horrible shape, our education system is getting worse every year, and our health care system is a joke, yes he wants to spend money on those things, but you want to just give it away to the rich, corporate welfare, so if we need to choose between corporate welfare or investing in america, john its time to invest in america!!!
How many more days do we have to listen to this old fool?  I can think of an S word for his campagin: SHAME!
Earth to McCain:  We are spending 10 billion a month in Iraq - Where is that money coming from?  What is wrong with Obama's plan to spend 150 billion on education, energy, healthcare and infrastructure (creating jobs) for Americans?  You do love Americans don't you McCain?  Get some new material.
Hopefully American sens "old white haired dude" packing on 11/4, so we no longer have to hear his inane whining.
Speaking of socialism...Mccain has lived the socialist life for 72 years...not one day in his life has he been off the taxpayer dole...

If we were collecting a cool quater mil a year and near free cadillac healthcare from the taxpayers like Johnny boy we could all claim to be making it on our own...
I actually listened to McCain's speech and could not get over the blantant misinformation he was spewing to the public. He took words out of context and twisted them around and with the use of his air quotes made it sound so scary. I wanted to stand next to him and counteract each of his statements with the truth.

What I did not hear was anything about his plan. He wants to tax our healthcare benefits, give tax breaks to the wealthy, and offers nothing but "opportunity" to the less fortunate. I would like to see how far we get paying our mortgages, bills, food, and gas with opportunity.

The majority of us make less than $250,000, so we benefit more under an Obama plan. McCain is for big business. He does not have to worry how he is going to put food on the table, where he will sleep, or how his bills will get paid. It seems he just doesn't want to pay more taxes, which he would have to do under an Obama plan.

Americans are smarter than McCain thinks. If you think you are better off than you were 8 years ago, vote for McCain, because that is what you will get 4 more years of the same. But if you want to move forward into the 21st century and bring change to Washington that we truly need, vote Obama/Biden.

Obama/Biden 08!! Vote now.
The usual McCain rhetoric "if I say it enough people will believe it" or "it is true, because I say so". I believe more than half of the people screaming the "s" word don't even know what they are screaming about! I wish they would listen for themselves what Obama's plan really says instead of repeating the ridiculous sound bytes McCain and Palin use.
empty wagons always makes the most noise...
If McCain's only realistic path to victory is voting fraud, we should expect it. That is why early voting is important.
That's right as the GLOBAL ECONOMY TANKS let's just continue with the LIES,SMEARS,and DOUBLE TALK from the republicans. I get more frustrated everyday, they just don't get it! McCain can't stand up on the issues because he's been with BUSH these 8 yrs. Palin can't stand on the issues, she's to busy shopping and doesn't quite know what they are! ENOUGH!!!!! I can't wait for Nov4 to vote for OBAMA/BIDEN
I'm tired of hearing the "earned it" quote over and over. My 8 hours of work is worth the same as your 8 hours and I am sick and tired of people trying to tell me that someone who works 8 hours a day digging ditches and working their !@#$'s off is somehow a slacker who works less than those who sit at a desk working 8 hours a day drinking their Starbucks while they try and figure out how they will spend their next bonus.

No I'm not advocating socialism, communism or any other "spead the wealth" type ideals but who sets the bar when it comes to worth? Who decides what kinds of jobs are worth more than others?

It's not education because some of the most educated people make little $$$ so when people talk about distributing wealth from those who earn it to those who do not.... who are they talking about because I see hard working people who make $30,000 a year who work twice as hard as those making six figures.

So those making six figures work and those who are just trying to pay the bills while working multiple jobs do not?

Confiscation of wealth? Can someone please tell him that taxes by their nature are a redistribution of wealth?  

Keep throwing things at a wall and see if they stick.  

It's time for this election to be over. PLEASE for the good of the country let it end.

PS...Joe the Plumber who cares...the funniest thing I've heard is McCain's claim that Obama is keeping this guy in the news...one question HOW?
The real S-word to keep in mind here is:  SUCKER.  

As in anybody dumb enough to fall for anything coming out of McCain's mouth these days.
They call him (Obama) socialist now, but come November 5th we will all call him President of the United States.

God Bless America

Obama/Biden 08 and 12
Jon Stewart has a video clip of mccain at a town hall answering a question from the crowd about raising taxes on the top 2% and asked if this was socialism-mccains' response was that it wasn't.  Let's see that video here please.  I'm sure others will be very interested in seeing it.

mccain's buzz word just went - Poof!
Hey McCain...Is taking my tax dollars and sending $600 Billion of it to Iraq, not redistributing the wealth per your agenda?  Just wondering why that's any different?  You speak of an inequity of asking the high earners to pay more.  How are they feeling now that we are paying for all their mistakes?  Maybe those of us on the lower end are necessary for them to be successful, so maybe they should chip in for all of our well being.  Probably better thoughts than continued Billions for your war...
The RNC, the neo-cons and nut cases like Palin, Bachmann, and Hayes are giving us a real dose of fascism.  Intollerant demagogues.  What a shame for the republican party.  

This small town veteran, blue collar former republican is voting for Obama.  Sen. McCain is fake in every way.  I have no respect for an adulterer who joined Chas. Keating in ruining American lives and is now letting the extremes in his party divide the country.    
Jon Stewart has a video clip of mccain at a town hall answering a question from the crowd about raising taxes on the top 2% and asked if this was socialism-mccains' response was that it wasn't.  Let's see that video here please.  I'm sure others will be very interested in seeing it.

mccain's buzz word just went - Poof!
What a horrible old man he has become.  It is sad to see that what once an a man in good standing stoop so low in order to win.  These are probably the same crowds that shout "terrorist" and "kill him." I guess that he feels that he can go for broke now.  I would rather see my tax dollars go to help build schools and provide help to people who are unable to help themselves (unable, not unwilling) than to see it go to a CEO more rich folks.
Guess what Johnnie, we are all socialists now since the big flippin Rescue Plan.  Some rescue, watching my savings go down the tubes.  It wouldn't matter what John McShame/Fallin spewed.  I kind of see the Charlie Brown effect whenever the dumb and dumber twins are on TV. You know the wha wha wha.

Obama/Biden 08/12  
bomber,,,,,,,,,,,You sly sled dog,are you going to spring for a new wordrobe for your boy Joe?Are you going to admit that if your war was over that money could be spent more wisely here at home instead of rebuilding Iraq?Yes Obama will be using some of the tax money that you and your well to do wife will have to pay, but being the All america boy I'm sure you won't mind paying your fair share.
Mccain, you have no room to talk! Didn't you vote for the bailout? That's socialism too! You're not fooling me anymore!  I'm voting for Barack Obama - and I'm proud of it!
This Socialism argument is absolutely ridiculous. Obama's plan doesn't raise the $250k+ tax bracket any higher than it was under Clinton's presidency, and the working class has been absolutely decimated by payroll tax increases -- which skyrocketed under Reagan and have never been substantially cut -- without corresponding wage increases and cost of living drops. Quit calling it Socialism: it's called a work ethic.
Well, McSocialist came up with a socialist proposal during the second debate, saying the government needs to buy Americans' bad mortgage, meaning the government should reward Americans for engaging in reckless mortgages. Now, he is calling Obama a socialist out of desperation and dishonor. This old man wll know is days are over on November 4.
Paging Dr Phil, paging Dr Phil!

John and Sarah don't even know they're drinking Senator Obama's koolaid! OBESSED
McSame sure has become a pathological liar. Obama was never "in the driveway of Joe the Plumber."

Even if Obama was touting socialism, as the
liars on the Repugnant Party ticket, claum, I would take that before their brand of fascist constitution busting.

Let's put these right wing liars out to pasture, America. We need to get on with cleaning up Bushist's huge messes.
where is the money coming to go to the corporate tax cuts and the tax cuts for big oil?  that will come from fees and taxes paid by the middle class
Like it or not, paying taxes is our price for civilization.  A significant part of my paycheck supports it.  What makes the wealthy so different?

If wealthy people don't want a minor increase in taxes, perhaps they should consider living in Canada or Europe (where taxes are exceptionally higher).  

Or perhaps they would consider living in Columbia or Mexico, where getting ransomed is a possibility.
We can't grow our way out of the loss of tax revenue from McCain tax cuts/policy.

Heck with all of the Corporate Welfare, subsidies, and bailouts...we are already a socialist nation.  Heaven forbid we actually pay for these programs rather than running up the credit card.

Look at Iceland, they did the same thing and now they are broke. No one will lend them money, they face Hyper-inflation...because the followed the same model that we have had for the last 8 years.

It's time to do an about face.

Thank you Senator (and Future C.I.C.) Obama
What a stretch.  Ask any of these people to define socialism.  I'll bet they can't.  This redistribution of wealth Mccain keeps bringing up....the richer pay more.....is the way its been since we've had a tax code.  Is Mccain saying we should do away with taxes altogether?  All these grand ideas he has are gonna have to be paid for somehow.  Someone must pay for schools, roads and all the other public facilities and services we all use.   What is Mccain's plan?  Let our kids and grand kids pay for it?  Print more money?  Mccain, stop the BS, talk about things realistically, and maybe you can save a crumb of dignity for your "straight talk" legacy.....because right now, no one is listening accept your precious base.
McLiar doesn't know what to say, or when.  The S word- well, McLiar is afraid that his own benefit from socialized MEDICARE, Military benefits, etc., will show his own hypocracy!

The economy is in the toilet, maybe he can use Joe the Mythical Plumber to unclog everything.  Oh, I forgot, Joe the Mythical Plumber owes taxes.  Guess, Joe doesn't believe in being pro-American by paying his share!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1580011

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google