ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama advisor questions 'aunt' story timing

Posted: Saturday, November 01, 2008 2:17 PM by Carrie Dann

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones and Carrie Dann
Speaking to reporters today, Obama chief strategist David Axelrod addressed reports that Zeituni Onyango, the half-sister of Obama's Kenyan father, has been living illegally in the United States for four years. Axelrod expressed some skepticism about the timing of the news, which first broke in the Times of London and was confirmed by the Associated Press in the waning days of the presidential race.

"The campaign issued a statement on that," Axelrod told reporters, "And I don't have anything more to add to it, other than I think people are suspicious about stories that surface in the last 72 hours of a national campaign.

"I think that they're going to take that," he added, "They're going to put it in that context."

In a statement earlier today, the campaign said that "Sen. Obama has no knowledge of her status but obviously believes that any and all appropriate laws should be followed."

Campaign finance records indicate that Obama's aunt donated $265 to his campaign.  The Obama team said today that the money would be refunded, as foreign nationals are not permitted to donate to presidential campaigns in the United States.

Onyango has lived in a public housing complex in Boston since an immigration judge turned down her request for asylum in 2004.

*** UPDATE ***  Senior McCain campaign advisor Mark Salter declined to comment on the story, per NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy.  Salter told reporters on McCain's plane that "it's a family matter."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It is illegal for the INS to release information on individual cases, and according to the AP this info was released by senior administrative officials.

It is illegal for the sitting executive to utilize federal agencies to influence an election.  That is the real story here, not the decisions made by a half-aunt of Obama that hasn't spoken with him in two years, no its the complicit involvement of the politicized DOJ, INS and McCain/Palin campaign to illegally use a position of power to release information illegally to influence an election.

Thankfully, I believe a majority of Americans see this for the disgusting partisan electioneering it is.

Goodbye and good riddance McCain/Palin glad to see the back of ya.
Was this suppose to be the October surprise, as in big game changer???  Try again.  Yes the timing is very suspect, but it won't work.  Anyone who would not vote for Obama because of this was not going to vote for him anyway.  What a pathetic attempt.

In other news, Cheney endorsed McCain, lOL.

Already voted Obama/Biden, 08
"*** UPDATE ***  Senior McCain campaign advisor Mark Salter declined to comment on the story, per NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy.  Salter told reporters on McCain's plane that "it's a family matter.""
WAS THIS AN ATTEMPT AT FEIGNING GRACIOUSNESS? We see right through it.  This isn't a "family" matter. This is a personal matter...his aunt's personal matter...not his.
This was timed and planned. PERIOD.

I'm going to pass out water to waiting voters. I've had ENOUGH!
Don't care.
More "Dirtbag Politics" from drudge and the McCrap campaigns...Can you imagine if McCain and Palin get elected?  How can people in this country really think that McCain can turn this country around? His only qualification is being a POW. Political name calling, slander, and lies surround the Mccain campaign. Has Obama attacked Mccain for the Keating 5, Hagen, or his ties to Terroists? NO! So wake up America...we deserve better.
its a family matter that mccain knows about no doubt, but it doesn't mean a thing to the american voters, your october-november surprise did not work this time, the american people was not fooled, obama will win
This is a family matter only, and has nothing to do economically moving our nation forward. America has a lot of economic, and foreign policy issues to handle right now. This is a joke to even bring up! Who cares!!
its a family matter that mccain knows about no doubt, but it doesn't mean a thing to the american voters, your october-november surprise did not work this time, the american people was not fooled, obama will win
MEDICAL RECORDS of Sarah Palin are much more important; since Obama's Kenyan Aunt is not running  for VP!

FR: Please bring attention to why Sarah Palin has not released her MEDICAL RECORDS? THIS IS HUGE; SINCE SHE CAN BARELY STAND UP STRAIGHT; I SUSPECT PSYCHOLOGICAL PROBLEMS ARE BEING HIDDEN. INSTEAD OF WHO IS OBAMA WE NEED TO KNOW WHO SARAH PALIN IS!!! !!!
Source: AlterNet.org

The old civil rights campaigner wanted to see an African-American elected president in his lifetime. Studs Terkel was 96.  Rest in peace.


Just like Studs Terkel Obama stands up the arrogance of corrupt power.  www.thenation.com/blogs/thebeat/379041

Now Fox News has defined Obama as a socialist because of ugly remarks made by that hateful Greta and Hannity. Personally, I think any low information voter who listens to Fox News gets sweep up into disinformation. What’s best for the welfare of this nation is an Obama/Biden administration.
The right wing will spend 4 million this last to smear and lie. Don't be duped.

As Obama said the question now becomes is not--- ARE YOU BETTER OFF 4 YEARS AGO; RATHER, ARE YOU BETTER OFF FROM 4 WEEKS AGO?

Voting McCain as Joe the dumber Plumber says... and we get more of the same last 8 years of or 4 more years mystifies me.

Beverly, the voter
Vote EARLY for self and country if you haven’t; vote Nov 4th
Vote Obama/Biden; I did.

there was a comment, mccain knows, but their october surprise will not work this time, we the american people are tired of the same old politics and lies, we need a change, and that change is obama,
When is McAi campaign going to release information on his black relatives that are living in poverty, that he refused to help or share the wealth.  Is he ashame that his black relatives might embarass him?  His great grandfather in tenessee did father children from several of his slaves women, and some of the decendand, who alson share his name are still around, some are not doing well down in the country in Tennesee.
At this point, should anyone question the timing?  The more McCain watches his chances at a win slipping away, the lower he sinks.  If somehow Johnny Mac should actually pull this off, I don't think too many people will still find him worthy of holding the position.  He wins, but still loses.

And it WILL look a lot like the Bush years of late, because our mainly Democratic Congress will spend the entire time fighting with the Executive Branch instead of being able to get something done.
Yeah funny how that timing worked out to be just 3 days before the election.  Just another desperate dirty political trick from the crookedest duo to disgrace the White House.

Obama's reaction is as always grace and honesty.  I hope she gets to stay here rather than go back to Kenya where she will no doubt be in danger.

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
I wonder how many of Obama's illegal relatives ,that He does'nt know about live in the USA?
Really?  72 hours to election day?  

What is really going to be irritating is that EVERY FREAKING NEWS ORGANIZATION WILL DRUM THIS TO DEATH!!!  Come on, already!  All I hear from the GOP is "Liberal media!"  All I see on the news are McCain soundbites attacking Barack.  How about covering the HOPE that IS Barack Obama!  FIGHT BACK, MEDIA!!!  Go after the crap that spews from Palin and her supporters for once!!!  
WOW. . is this the ONLY THING the GOP can up with ???
What a disaster. . .   and now the employees at the immigration service, and the Homeland security department will have to answer questions about leaking a story like this. . .. obviously to interfere with the election !!!   If it turns out that someone in the McCain campaign pushed this information. .well, of course they don't want to comment !!!!  I think voters will see thru this tactic. .VOTE for Obama anyway, so the end result, will be embarrassment for the McCain campaign, and someone losing their job ??  The GOP has become a bunch of liars; criminals; sleaze merchants; and more. . .it's no wonder their party ID is DOWN, and will remain so, because the McCain rallies have turned into Klan meetings, and it's so  obvious !!!
The United States deserves better. .and we'll have it on Tuesday.
If this is the best the Republicans can do for an October Surprise, they are going to lose big time.  
$265. Bless her heart. It's probably all she had to give to her nephew.

Imagine that. She won't even have the satisfaction of donating to her own nephew. Yet the GOP corporations can hire illegals for years and years and years, INCLUDING Mitt Romney, yet no one cares.

Exploitation of illegal immigrants. Did you know illegal immigrants are also fighting in our 2 wars? Yet for some reason, that's acceptable.

Hypocrisy is everywhere. And it stinks.
It certainly does have all the earmarks of a Republican "dirty trick." The AP also reports that they couldn't confirm or deny whether or not the McCain campaign or Bush Administration had anything to do with the release of the information. That also suggests to me that the story is suspiciously timed although we may never trace the fingerprints. In the end, though, if that's the best the Republicans have on Obama (and it's not even about Obama), then I don't think it damages him all that much, if at all. Even in the Gallup (likely) poll, which is more conservative than its expanded version, Obama is up by 10 points. That's amazing this close to the election.
This dirty trick finally made up my mind? This really is sickening? That some unknown entity would try to sabotage Obama's campaign, by fingering his aunt for an immigration violation. Did some sleazy group allied to the Republicans hire an investigator, to look for a skeleton in the closet?
I'm an Independent and will be definitely voting for Obama now. It just shows what the other side will lower themselves to win. We don't need people like that, in power. Not that the Democrats have not reverted to dirty tricks. Some of my family are in dire need of health care. My step daughter who died with cancer, found insurance companies implying she had a pre-existing condition so that they could deny her coverage. She passed away this year.
I don't mind paying my share of taxes, but I draw the line in supporting every illegal alien who slips pas the border patrol.
We don't need McCain's platform of a $5.000 dollar credit, when we can sweep to one side greedy health insurance companies. Outside of Obama's contribution for America's future,
I resent his insistence in giving 37 million illegal aliens, NOT 13 MILLION, according to the Tucson sector Border Patrol union local 2544 (with an additional half-million coming every year) a blanket amnesty.
A massive financial impact on our economy by importing the worlds poor. However, I respect Obama's foreign policy, his rebuilding our interior infrastructure, neglected by the Bush mob. No more outsourcing without financial consequences or selling America to some countries that hate us.
As to the illegal immigration conflagration? Once it comes up for a vote, they will have withstand the angry voice of millions of Americans. Enough is enough from the open border zealots. www.numbersusa The truth!
c'mon, we know you are hard up for news, but this is ridiculous.
Anyone who read 'Dreams of My Father' understands that the man's Kenyan relatives shouldn't be an issue.  Why?  His grandfather had more than one wife and the 'grandmother' he met in Kenya is actually his step-grandmother, though she raised Obama's father.  Sen. Obama only met his father once, when he was 10 yrs old.  His father had more than one wife, even had more than one white wife, and he had many children.  Obama did travel to Kenya after college to try to find his roots and meet some relatives and found that there were so many people that could claim him that it began to sound ridiculous.  I, personally, wouldn't hold him responsible for all his many half-aunts, half-grandparents, or half-sisters/brothers.  Just as I won't hold Sen. McCain responsible for the black relatives he has that are descended from his family's days of slave-owning.  In truth, Barack had a white Kansan mother and white grandparents.  His Kenyan father was absentee, and he was raised with a half-sister.  The IMPORTANT family is his own - Michelle and his beloved daughters.  He shows us daily the example of family values.  Maybe that mixed up childhood and the strange heritage of his father gave him the incentive to prove that he can set a better example.  The aunt story is just another chunk thrown up on the wall and it's not gonna stick.
Nice of the campaign advisor to say it's a family matter and decline to comment. I'm sure Palin won't hit Sen. Obama with that at a rally in the next 12 hours.
Thank you McCain campaign for a little bit of compassion.

I just hope you share your information with Sarah Palin—the attack dog and campaign liar and agitator.
It's a "family" matter?!? Please. Whatever Mark Salter...just another way to plant seeds of doubt.
And we are supposed to care about this why?  The big surprise is Salter has no comment!!

Obama/Biden 08/12
AUNT   DIDNT KNOW SHE WAS ILLEGAL

AYERS    DIDNT KNOW HE WAS A TEROSIST

REVEREND    DIDNT KNOW HE HATED AMERICA

KHALIDI   DIDNT KNOW HE WAS A PLO TERRORIST

MICHELLE   DIDNT KNOW SHE WAS NOT PROUD TO BE AMERICAN

GO AHEAD IDIOTS VOTE FOR HIM TO DESTROY AMERICA=HE ONLY ASSOCIATED WITH THE ABOVE  WE WILL HAVE A CIVIL WAR IN THIS COUNTRY
So what?  This story is nothing to report.
What??  No comment from the McCain team??  Their surrogates will continue to try to milk this story.  Obama has addressed the issue, now move on.  This is simply another example of those who oppose Obama trying to make you fear him.  Of course they'll have no evidence to back up their claims.  Oh they may try to point you to a website, claiming that website has the "real story".  But what they don't tell you is that the website is run by someone against Obama.
With as many problems our country is having these days, our focus should be on the issues affecting our country, not on nitpicky trivial nonsense.  The McCain campaign needs to tell us what a McCain presidency would do to help Americans.  The problem is he can't.  His programs mostly mirror the programs of the Bush administration.
America is better than that.  If you haven't made up your mind, its time.  Both campaigns have gone on long enough that if you don't understand their positions, you must have been in a coma or simply haven't been listening to either of them.  There is no "smoking gun" story that will change the dynamics of the race.
It will be interesting to see how gracious the losers will be when Obama wins on Tuesday.
Senior McCain campaign advisor Mark Salter declined to comment on the story, per NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy.  Salter told reporters on McCain's plane that "it's a family matter."

This is a real pickle for McCain. He cannot play this up to the delight of his base with out risking the political wrath with Hispanic voters in AZ, NV, NM and FL that he seems to have already overlooked. That is what you get when you relegate voters as second class citizens.

McCain and his wicked witch from Alaska are following a the white red herring up the North but have completely failed to look in the rear view mirror across the ENTIRE south.
I'm not surprised at all!  I live in Taxachusetts and public housing is funded by OUR tax dollars.  She most likely gets the usual welfare check, Mass health (free) oh food stamps and a free pass on the public transit system.  

Now he wants all illegals to be given drivers licenses!   Then she can get more government funding and perks.  Soon the whole country will be taxed the way we are now plus some.  

I think it is only appropriate that the truth speaks volumes all on its own.  

I still want to see a valid birth certificate from Obama.  Otherwise I will consider him ineligible by our own laws to hold the presidential office.
Todd - I have to say, listening to Sarah Palin on your channel is making me wanna puke.  Does this team, the McCain Palin duo, have ANYTHING to say to offer the country a plan for what they will do to help us?   I have never ever seen such desperation and flat out lies from a candidate for president.  They call themselves Christians and then lie right to the American peoples face.  And in the process, try to tear down Barack Obama in any way, shape or form they can.  It's sick.
And what the hell does this have to do with Obama's candidacy? Can't wait to hear how Hannity spins this one. Poor guy...he'll have to fall back on Britney Spears filler stories after next Tuesday.



G.O.P. is certainly pulling at straws.
Sad and disgusting behavior!



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1625096

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google