ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama: ICE, ICE, baby

Posted: Sunday, November 02, 2008 9:42 AM by Domenico Montanaro

“Responding to a report that a Kenyan relative of Senator Barack Obama was living in the United States illegally, his campaign said Saturday that he had no knowledge of her immigration status and that ‘any and all appropriate laws’ should be followed,” the New York Times reports. More: “Some Democrats suggested that the timing of the disclosure could have been politically motivated, and some immigration lawyers said that for government officials to disclose information about an asylum applicant was unethical or perhaps illegal.” 

Per NBC’s Mike Kosnar, a senior Immigration and Customs official confirmed that the leak of the news that Obama’s aunt was living illegally in the United States has been referred to the Department of Homeland Security Inspector General and the ICE Office of Professional Responsibility (ICE internal affairs) for possible action. The official said, "They are looking into whether there was a violation of policy in publicly disclosing individual case information."

Now that doesn't necessarily mean that the information for the AP story breaking the news came from ICE agents or personnel, Kosnar adds. But this is the agency that would be handling the case and have the most information about Obama's aunt, along with the immigration court, so ICE is the logical place to start.

It is likely Obama’s aunt was on a list of fugitive aliens, just like thousands of other illegal immigrants. But, obviously, people live for years in the US after receiving deportation orders. Fugitive apprehension teams usually target suspects with criminal records before they go after simple immigration violators.

Hillary Clinton pens an op-ed in the New York Daily News, laying out why she supports Obama. "We cannot afford four more years of the same broken ideological policies. Barack Obama must be our President. Joe Biden must be our vice president. And Democrats must once again clean up an economic mess the Republicans left behind. We've done it before, and we'll do it again."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Obama referred to Onyango as "Auntie Zeituni" when describing the trip in his memoir, saying she was "a proud woman."
Obama's campaign said he had seen her a few times since the meeting 20 years ago, beginning with a return trip to Kenya with his future wife, Michelle, in 1992. Onyango visited the family in Chicago on a tourist visa at Obama's invitation about nine years ago, the campaign said, stopping to visit friends on the East Coast before returning to Kenya.
She attended Obama's swearing-in to the U.S. Senate in 2004, but campaign officials said Obama provided no assistance in getting her a tourist visa and doesn't know the details of her stay. The campaign said he last heard from her about two years ago when she called saying she was in Boston. This leave unanswered the extent of Obama’s actual involvement and relationship with his Aunt and what if any support he has provided her or if he had any concern for her well being.
The campaign said it was returning $260 that Onyango had contributed in small increments to Obama's presidential bid over several months. Federal election law prohibits foreigners from making political donations. Onyango listed her employer as the Boston Housing Authority. Many have speculated Obama’s campaign has been the recipient of foreign contributions.
Just another dirty political trick by "Tyrant" Bush and his lackeys of hate.  No doubt that this leak was orchestrated at the highest levels.  We need Obama to win so he can instigate an investigation into the crookedest presidential administration in history.

Still this pales in comparison to that ignorant Wicked Witch from Alaska and her totally incompetent staff of accepting and going through with a 7 minute prank call by the Masked Avengers from Montreal.  I mean how could this staff of nincompoops not figure out the ruse over the 4 days it took to set up?  Only total fools would vote for these incompetent fools of faith!

I saw my first repugnant one 527 Reverend Wright ad this morning on Moronic Joe.  Chris Matthews owes us all an apology for not thinking that McNasty would stoop this low and he owes Obama an apology for whining about Obama saying that McNasty would say anything to win.  Chris was very wrong at how low down and dirty the repugnant ones are!

Go Obama/Biden 08/12!
THANK YOU HILLARY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Well, it is questionable about this being leaked at this time but what else can you expect from the republicans? They are desperate enough to make this immaterial piece of news the headlines and of course
the media is going to support it.
Barack Obama and Joe Biden are going to win this election despite of biased media/ap, despite of the
sleeziest campaign in the history of our country being run by the republicans, despite of the
pubs total disregard to honor and integrity.
They are winning because of all the above.
The American voters are intelligent and are sick
of the irresponsible, criminal leadership we have
had these last eight years.
Yesterday on Hardball, Chris Matthews tried to get his guests to give kudos to McCain for "not using the race card" - they declined!! Wise decision - around 8pm Channel 7 aired an ad with Rev. Wright/Obama "A Radical" paid for by the RNC supporting McCain in the state of WASHINGTON of all places. We are proud of our diverse culture which has enriched our lives. McCain/Palin bring out the very worst in people - nothing to be proud of. They talk about Joe the Plumber because their campaign is in the toilet.  Time to flush - Vote Tuesday!! Boycott Hardball.
I am an aunt too, and have no idea where most of the neices and nephews from either side of my family are..not by my choosing neccessarily, but, by theirs, they are busy living THEIR lives, just as I chose to live mine..so, its no surprise to me Obama would know nothing about the status of his aaunt, I sure wouldnt discuss things like that with any of my relatives unless was a child of mine ! It looks to ME like just more desperate tatics from the BUSH-McCain camp, specially coming out at this late date right before the election..and how does McCain even know how much money she might have donated to Obama, since I dont recall him givving out his list of small donors yet ??? That would include ME..This article raises more questions than answers, as hasnt exactly been PROVEN yet what his aunts status IS..or how it should be od any interest to anyone other than iCE..she hasnt committed any crimes, is bothering no one, is FAMILY, which I thought was "off limits", but, since it isnt, what about Cindys drug habits, and
WHERE IS PALINS MEDICAL RECORDS ????? Now, that would interest ME...why dont you demand that, the other 3 canidates have released theirs !!! RELEASE PALINS MEDICAL RECORDS !
None of this aunt buisness is going to affect me, as I dont believe the sleaze about Obama anyways...
white, middle class senior in tEXAS, voting OBAMA, but, still want to see PALINS MEDICAL RECORDS
McCain paid for this informatio with the help of Bush. Should pay if they got this information the wrong way.
It seems Obama is learning about executive privilege by not admitting the truth about his aunt’s status. I could see if this was a distant family member, but this person appeared in his book. What else is he “UNAWARE” of???? Just remember you can’t have buyer’s remorse on Nov 5.

I can only say if this was a McCain issue the press would be pecking at this long after the election was over. If it was a Palin issue well the term press field day comes to mind.

This about the aunt is politically motivated. Why didn't it come out before
If this were McCain's aunt, all of Obama's slavish devotees in the media, such as Chris Matthews, would be running the "illegal aunt" story 24/7. It would be a case of "McCain must have known" or "Six-houses McCain has aunt living in poverty" or "McCain takes illegal donation from poverty stricken aunt." In reflective moments I often wonder: Do Matthews and the other MSNBC Obama worshippers ever feel a twinge of guilt about their blatantly twisted coverage? Or have they long ago forgotten the tenets of journalistic integrity, it being so long since they practised it?
At least she didn't call 911 with complaints about traffic and then spew expletives at the operator like John McCains brother did. I seem to remember other Presidents having familial ghosts in their closets. The biggest question here is where the leak came from. That is the real scandal. Once again, what they throw out comes right back and hits them squarely between the eyes.
This is a family issue, and should not be harped on by the "Insane McCain" Campaign for political greed. It sounds like some laws of confidentiality were broken here. If the "Insane McCain" and "Puppet Palin Campaigns do go on about it publically. It appears they could get themselves into some legal trouble again. Vote America!
I say she should be arrested and deported. No need for her to receive any special treatment.
Three issues here a) info may have been leaked b) she has been living here illegally c) Obama  may/may not have known

Question then: Why is the emphasis for Clinton and others concern only issue a) when her violating her deportation order and, more importantly, Obama's insistence he knew nothing of this should clearly be the focus. His aunt may indeed be the innocent football, but this close to the election it is others, including Obama, who are kicking it.
Don't know who leaked this, but it is certainly no worse than Obama comparing ICE Agents to the Nazi Gestapo, which belies his campaign saying "any and all appropriate laws should be followed."
Hillary for Senate majority leader!!!
If a US Citizen is a fugitive, that info is public knowledge and his picture is posted in the post office.

An illegal alien is a fugitive from a deportation order, and this can't be publically disclosed because it's an invasion of her privacy ??????? !!!! ??????
AS HILLARY CLINTON DID- 18 MILLION CRACKS IN THE CEILING-GO VOTE AND LETS SHATTERED THE GLASS CEILING BY BREAKIN ALL BARRIERS!

GO VOTE FOR CHANGE, EMPOWERMENT, CHOICE, HISTORY AND GOING BEYOND THE BARRIERS!

I VOTED FOR OBAMA EARLY-NOW IT IS TIME FOR ALL OF YOU TO MAKE HISTORY-VOTE EARLY OR JUST VOTE-OBAMA NEEDS EVERY SINGLE VOTE!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1626632

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google