ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



The governors react to Obama

Posted: Tuesday, December 02, 2008 6:32 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under: ,

From NBC's Mark Murray
ABOARD A TRAIN FROM PHILADELPHIA TO WASHINGTON, DC -- Democratic governors who attended this morning's meeting with Obama in Philadelphia said they were impressed with the president-elect's listening skills and engagement, as well as his commitment to make the states full partners in trying to solve the nation's economic troubles.

Montana Gov. Brian Schweitzer told First Read that Obama and Vice President-elect Biden said they wanted to hear the governors' opinions. "You hear that all the time in politics, but here is something I saw both Joe Biden and Barack Obama doing -- I saw them taking notes."

Schweitzer continued, "If you've been involved in political meetings, there is a dance that's done, and that's where the politician says, 'Now I want to hear your ideas.' And somebody will stand up and say something. [But] they don't take any notes, and they don't ask any questions back. So you're not even sure they're listening. But in this case, he was responding to each one of the questioners." 

New Jersey Gov. Jon Corzine added that Obama is a great listener. "Too often, executives are not listeners, and they think they have all the answers. He is anything but that."

Said Colorado Gov. Bill Ritter, "I campaigned really hard for Barack Obama, and one of the things that I said continually as I campaigned is that we need a partner in the White House -- that we needed someone who would listen to the some struggles as we face at the state level. And I think today, even though it was the first meeting, today was really a testament to why I thought Barack Obama was the right person to be elected, because he is a person who listens, he is a person who engages."

"I just thought it was a wholesale success."

These interviews were conducted aboard an Amtrak train carrying more than a dozen Democratic governors who were leaving Philadelphia to head to Washington, DC. (Nathan Gonzales of the Rothenberg Political Report, who also was conducting interviews with these governors, dubbed it the "Gov Train." You can sing it out loud: "People all over the world, join hands. Start a Gov train, Gov train...")

And while it wasn't too surprising to see these governors praise a fellow Democrat, Republicans also had kind words for the president-elect.

Observers said that Republican South Carolina Gov. Mark Sanford asked one of the tougher questions at the meeting when he expressed concern that an economic stimulus would continue to increase the size of the deficit. "I generally believe the course we are on is a real problem -- both near term and long term," he told First Read in an interview after the meeting.

But he also said that Obama and Biden were engaging. "I would give them great kudos," he said.

And Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, as mentioned earlier, said this after the meeting: "[T]he campaign is over, and I so appreciate the meeting we had, and I am quite optimistic about moving forward in a bipartisan manner as to forge this partnership between states and the federal government... I appreciated also that President-elect Obama is looking for specifics from governors -- what it would be that we can do, what our states can offer."

Of course, it's very early. And no doubt that things could quickly change. But right now, governors seem pleased about the prospect that they'll have a partner in the White House.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

After watching a few clips of the meeting, I was most impressed with Obama reaching out to ALL of the Governers.  However, not to put a damper on things, but in the press conference afterwards, Sanford, who said we ought to count on entreprenuership etc.etc., and Palin who spoke in a foreign language (her own) are still stuck in the past.  We are in a massive mess, we need a massive push in a new direction. Obama was presidential, Palin was low rent - could not even call PE Obama by that title, she stumbled and continued to call him Senator.  Regarding Joe Biden she referred to him 'I tried to convince America that Governers were the best for the job, but her I am and VPE Biden is over there'.  She is so disrespectful, and has no clue.  Imagine her meeting powerful foreign dignitaries and leaders?  I don't think she will even be a governer after this term.  People have her number.

This is a new world and they are still stuck in the old one.  WAKE UP!! Then again, I supported Obama/Biden and am so proud of the way things are being handled.  So let them keep it up - their days are so numbered.
For the love of god will someone send Barbie Sara back to Alaska and pull her travel vouchers, I am getting carpal-tunnel syndrom just switching channels to avoid her annoying voice and persona. I can't stand it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Stop covering her, she says nothing and never will say anything intelligent!!!!
"...And Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, as mentioned earlier, said this after the meeting: "[T]he campaign is over, and I so appreciate the meeting we had, and I am quite optimistic about moving forward in a bipartisan manner as to forge this partnership between states and the federal government... I appreciated also that President-elect Obama is looking for specifics from governors -- what it would be that we can do, what our states can offer."
--------------
no comment
obama/biden is what we need in these difficult times ahead. these guys are going to represent the country as a whole. not just dem's and liberals.

if some would not hate the man because of his party, his name, where he is from (chicago), his bi-racial background and give him a chance to at least begin to serve they may see a difference in the direction this country will be headed.

it took 8 years to get in this mess. it will take 2 to 3 years to begin to turn the corner. let's not be ugly americans. let's just be americans. these ugly attitudes and politics of division the last 30 years has gotten us into a terrible mess. let's try something different than ignorance for a change. go obama/biden
Just a simple thought: it is an enigma to me that the people in Alaska never comment when their governor leaves and stays away for long periods of time. When our governor jumps on a plane it makes headlines and the rightwing nuts question the costs of his departure and how much the taxpayers are going to have to cough up to cover his time away. Is it they are glad that she is gone and notice how much gets done there without her, or, is it because when she is there no one notices her return? Does Alaska need a "governor"?
Said Colorado Gov. Bill Ritter, "I campaigned really hard for Barack Obama, . . . ., and I expect a huge payoff.
Obama is a great leader-by-example. I've actively tried to emulate his generosity, his lack of animosity toward opponents, and his cool temperament. Hopefully more governors and leaders will take a cue from President-Elect Obama...
Clara, Kansas City:

Comment:

Really, take out the word "as" and it's at least as good as Bill Ritter's comment, assuming you take out his "some".

You're a smart person, but slightly obsessive/compulsive over Palin.

MoveOn. Somebody has to.  Might as well be you.
Thanks Mark. Excellent reporting. Interesting isn't it - it's not just Obama supporters who see perhaps "change" in governance, in tone, in exchange of ideas with the incoming Administration.

We do not hero worship Obama the way the Ronald Reagan supporters worshipped him. And still do. We just want change and Barack Obama we believe offers that to all of us.

I personally do not want to see republicans left behind if they have concrete ideas that will benefit everyone.

There appears to be a segment of our population out there - mostly males in their late 30's/early 40's who are still very naive about Ronald Reagan. They believed all the rhetoric about him. What they basically  bought into was an image. A false image. Democrats, they believe, are evil. It's what they were taught by the right wing media and even a majority of the mainstream media.

If we can open their eyes, all the better going forward. There's no reason why we can't all work together to fix what ails us in this country.

That's the change we've been looking for - for a very very long time.

What language is Palin speaking?
Joe Biden made an excellent point in his address to the Governors.  He mentioned that when he was campaigning across states- the local official accompanying him would often point to something and tell him "This used to be..."  His point was that it's time for these areas to "be something" once again.

Thank goodness we have elected officials that will actually try to get America working again.  
Wow, there were fifty Governors at this meeting.  Where were the other 7?  Didn't Obama say we have fifty-seven states?  Oh yeah, you folks would prefer to Palin bash instead of looking at your own puppets...
Sarah Palin appeals only to the most ignorant and rigid among our population...she will show up on faux news as a hostess soon
"because he is a person who listens, he is a person who engages."
Mrs. Obama gonna be using the frying pan on his head if Barack listens to Ol Bill as hard as he listens to everybody else. Real nice having Ol Bill back.
yeah cheryl I know how you feel everytime I see osama obama and his FUGLY wife I switch channels
We have to look at "the big picture." The days of tunnel vision are over. Our nation better wake up and smell the coffee. With all our bail outs along with the 168 billion economic stimulus package, that btw did nothing for our economy it is hard to understand why our government can't see the need to bail us out of our dependence on foreign oil. The high cost of fuel this past year seriously damaged our economy and society. Why don't we invest in America's Energy Independence. It would cost the equivalent of 60 cents per gallon to charge and drive an electric car. The electricity to charge the car can conceivably come from wind or solar . We need to  get on about the business of harnessing these sources of energy. Create clean cheap energy, badly needed new green collar jobs and reduce our dependence on foreign oil. What more of a win-win situation could there be? Instead of spending billions upon billions on bailouts, why don't we instead invest in renewable energy. We have GUARANTEED returns if we do this. I just read a fascinating book by Jeff Wilson called The Manhattan Project of 2009 Energy Independence NOW .This book Is the big picture.


Sarah Palin has the highest approval rating of all the governors in the United States.

Isn't it odd that those numbers only matter if they are low and your a Republican.

How often does the media tell us how low Bush's approval rating is?  How often do they tell us that the Democrat controlled Congress's approval rating is even LOWER then Bush's!

Never.

OK.  What did I tell you?


palin a steaming pile of cow dung whom is so mad that she wasnt the vice president elect, sarah get over your loss and please try and win another government title in alaska because hopefully you will lose your reelection bid
When are we going to have enough of Sarah Palin. Today, I wanted to quote Dr. Phil to Sarah Palin. . ."it not about you!!!".  As a woman I am insulted she is trying to represent me.  I was very pleased with the clips that I saw of the meeting as a whole, Obama went straight to middle management. Just like any CEO would do. . .hear from the trenches.
I am certain that PE Obama and VPE Biden are going to do a awsome job considering what they are going to receive from President Bish. Our country is on a freefall without a parachute and it is going to take alot of hard work and sacrifices from all Americans.

My concern is the media and how they play to the negative to make a story more interesting. The way the media is already looking for the first stumble/errors that Obama will make sickens me and he has not been sworn in as our new President. I hope that we give Obama a chance to fix this mess and stop wondering if he is going to do what he promised during his campaign. With the mess that Bush has made I trully think it will take Obama's first 4 years to get our country on more solid ground. All of us may have to sacrifice and we need to be realistic and let President Obama do what needs to be done to get us out of this recession before our economy goes into a full blown depression.
I saw Silly Sara give her little speech, and it is apparent that she is bitter.  I mean, bitter!  Considering the tone the new president wants to set, and I voted for him in the primary and the general, I won't say anything more negative.  We won, what we're hearing is the death of the right wingnuts.  May perpetual light shine upon them.
I have to agree with Cheryl - PLEASE send Palin packing or better still lost.
I think that little piss ant from SC---Sanford---made a total ass of himself, but what can one expect from SC?  Recall Lindsay Gayham and Storm Thumbomb, etc.

And, I doubt any state, unless it's
Alabama, could possibly elect a dumber, more empty pin head than the Alaska moose burger queen---she's obviously an accident looking for somewhere to happen.  I just hope she "happens" back home in "Seward's folly". Couldn't they put one of those electronic ankle house arrest devices on her and stuff a clean rag in her mouth?

But, kudos for Obama/Biden, who managed to listen to their insulting insinuative diatribes w/o open offense or derisive laughter.
I Love Sara Palin!!!
Please continue the coverage of Ms. Palin.  I look forward to reading about her and seeing her on television.  She is an amazing and motivating speaker and I have absolutely no problem understanding her.  I'm sorry people are so crude and rude when speaking of her.  I often changed the channel or turned off the television during the campaign because I had had a belly full of seeing and hearing Obama.  I've had to accept that he won and the rest of you need to accept that Sarah has won a place in many American's hearts and is here to stay, I'm happy to say.
Everything PE Obama has done to this point gives me hope for the future. He is surrounding himself with some of the best minds available to him. He is reaching out to Dems & Republicans. When he opens his mouth to speak his comments are well thought out and intelligent. His concern for everything he deals with seems (and I'm sure is) real.  What a wonderful difference! I'm sure, like any other administration, this one will have it's little hiccups but I'm encouraged knowing the #1 guy is willing to man-up and take the heat when needed.  I was thrilled to hear him say the buck stops here, I can't wait until January 20.  Everything won't magically become better then but the hope I feel will seem real when the inauguration is over.
The "political politics" of "puke" by "Puppet Palin" should not be a shock to anyone. The "Dizzy Diva" will never be able to comprehend what was said at the Governors Meeting. She intellectually is so "inept" that, the concepts that Obama talked about, went right over her head. Socially, she is rude, emotionally disturbed, and does not understand proper rules of conduct/respect. She is truely a political, moral, social, and ethical joke America. Thank God this "dangerous," and very "sarcastic" individual lost the election. Go home "Puppet Palin!"
Once I 've believed these messages seem like involve to me. I 'm try to ask all peoples who I believed but  no one response ,they are all reject
and said It's my confuse or overimagine or staying high side effect.
Longtimes ago til the present they still hardly
inform me as ever before.   So !,they may shame to talk about what they d hardly reject
or its exactly not a my stuff.
Ditto ace and Clara - I enjoy your comments!
Will somebody please tell brainless Palin that she should be referring to him as President-Elect Obama and NOT Senator????????? Geesh! If she had a brain she'd be dangerous.
I have complete faith in Barack Obama, Joe Biden and the staff he has chosen.
Listening to others is such a change, but he is not only listening he is hearing.
It is going to take time to get our country back to the once great nation it once was. Sacrifices and
patience must be practiced by all of us.
If the Republicans want Sarah Palin as their "new face" for the future, you can expect Democrats to remain in power for a very long time. This woman is so far out in right field that she probabaly CAN see Russia from her front porch. She is behind in her thinking (if she thinks at all) and makes a complete fool out of herself everytime she opens her mouth. I say keep the microphone in her face 24/7; she will disqualify herself just like she did in the presidential campaign. She's an idiot.
what is really encouraging is to see that Americans are still engaged. We have a tendency to after an election go back to business as usual.  These are trans formative times in our nations history, I just hope we all embrace this opportunity to grow in a positive way.  I have faith that this new direction the people that PE Obama has surround himself with finally get that this is GOVERMENT BY THE PEOPLE AND FOR THE PEOPLE, not for lobbyist,Washington insiders etc. GOD BLESS THIS NEW ADMINISTARTION AND THE UNITED STATES
what is really encouraging is to see that Americans are still engaged. We have a tendency to after an election go back to business as usual.  These are trans formative times in our nations history, I just hope we all embrace this opportunity to grow in a positive way.  I have faith that this new direction the people that PE Obama has surround himself with finally get that this is GOVERMENT BY THE PEOPLE AND FOR THE PEOPLE, not for lobbyist,Washington insiders etc. GOD BLESS THIS NEW ADMINISTARTION AND THE UNITED STATES
No matter how rude Sara Palin is to President-Elect Obama he is our President. Her lack of respect for him shows her ignorance, and that lets all of us know who she is. She is such a low life.  
Ok, if one more person makes issue with Obama saying 57 states i'm gonna puke, first and foremost he meant 57 primary contest not states which included PR, Guam, and other US territories where votes were held.  Secondly, I would bet the farm on Obama's educational background and expertise over Palin's anyday of the year.  The elections are over, we will have a new Presdident on Jan. 20th, period end of story.
Palin is irelevant to most except the far right of the GOPer base. Let them have her, bless their pointy little heads.

Meanwhile back in the land of grownups, Obama and Biden listened AND took notes. Gee, we may actually have a team of competent folks being forged at both the national and state levels!  A pleasant change form the contemptuous attitudes of Bush-Cheney to be sure.

Change is almost here, folks. As we all know it will take time and patience but the path forward wiil lead us from the swamp we have endured for the last 8 years.

Forward march!
To Newyoker:  I couldn't understand a word you were writing.  Did you ever attend school, or did you fake it.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1696326

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google