ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton foundation releases donor list

Posted: Thursday, December 18, 2008 1:33 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC's Domenico Montanaro
After more than a year of public debate, the Clinton Foundation released its list of donors today, a move widely viewed as part of a deal between the Clintons and Obama to ensure Clinton's appointment as Secretary of State.

It's a splashy list that includes foreign entities, including Saudi Arabia and Dubai; controversial characters close Clinton, like Stephen L. Bing and Frank Giustra; charities, like the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, UNITAID of the World Health Organization and the ambiguous Children’s Investment Fund Foundation; and celebrity organizations, like the Elton John AIDS Foundation and the Princess Diana Memorial Fund

The nearly 3,000 Web-page list is here and is listed from largest donors to smallest. We'll update with more, but here's a quick sampling from page 1.

$25 million +
UNITAID
, a group administered by the World Health Organization

Children's Investment Fund Foundation: There's very little information on the London-based group's Web site as to the source of the funds, but the New York Times wrote: “Christopher Cooper-Hohn and his wife, Jamie, follow a simple economic formula: he makes money, and she gives it away. Mr. Cooper-Hohn runs the Children's Investment Fund, or T.C.I., a successful -- and controversial -- hedge fund that has become a gadfly to corporate giants like CSX, the American railroad. Ms. Cooper-Hohn leads an affiliated charity, the Children's Investment Fund Foundation, which uses some of the profits that T.C.I. earns to finance programs for underprivileged children. The partnership has made the Cooper-Hohns the most generous philanthropists in Britain. Last weekend, their foundation reported a $439 million ($856 million) jump in funds for fiscal 2007, reflecting $324 million in donations from T.C.I. and the Cooper-Hohns. In an interview, Ms. Cooper-Hohn dismissed the notion that the charity is a ploy to soften Mr. Cooper-Hohn's hard-charging image. … It worked with the Clinton Foundation to cut prices of H.I.V. drugs for children in a housing project, and it shepherded economic and nutritional programs for children and families affected by H.I.V. and AIDS in India.”  
$10M-25M
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

Stephen L. Bing, Clinton friend, who was written about in Vanity Fair by Todd Purdham: "Burkle’s usual means of transport is the custom-converted Boeing 757 that Clinton calls “Ron Air” and that Burkle’s own circle of young aides privately refer to as “Air F--- One.” Clinton himself had arrived on the private plane of another California friend, the real-estate heir, Democratic donor, liberal activist, and sometime movie and music producer Steve Bing, whose colorful private life includes fathering a child out of wedlock with the actress Elizabeth Hurley and suing the billionaire investor Kirk Kerkorian for invasion of privacy, alleging that private investigators for Kerkorian swiped Bing’s dental floss out of his trash in a successful effort to prove that Bing’s DNA matched that of a child delivered by Kerkorian’s ex-wife, the former tennis pro Lisa Bonder. (The suit was later settled out of court.) ... Bing, 43, who helped finance Shine a Light, the recent Martin Scorsese documentary about the Rolling Stones, and who has given tens of millions to environmental and other causes dear to Clinton’s heart in recent years, is described as very well read, thoughtful, interesting—and willing to stay up long into the night indulging Clinton’s craving for conversational companionship." 

Frank Giustra, Canadian mining financier. Clinton traveled to Kazakhstan with Giustra, where they both met and dined with the lightning rod 19-year president of the country. "Mr. Nazarbayev walked away from the table with a propaganda coup, after Mr. Clinton expressed enthusiastic support for the Kazakh leader’s bid to head an international organization that monitors elections and supports democracy," the New York Times wrote. "Mr. Clinton’s public declaration undercut both American foreign policy and sharp criticism of Kazakhstan’s poor human rights record by, among others, Mr. Clinton’s wife, Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York.

"Within two days, corporate records show that Mr. Giustra also came up a winner when his company signed preliminary agreements giving it the right to buy into three uranium projects controlled by Kazakhstan’s state-owned uranium agency, Kazatomprom. The monster deal stunned the mining industry, turning an unknown shell company into one of the world’s largest uranium producers in a transaction ultimately worth tens of millions of dollars to Mr. Giustra, analysts said."

Citi Foundation, former Clinton Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin is director and senior counselor there. And Lisa Caputo, who was Hillary Clinton’s press secretary, is executive vice president of global marketing and corporate affairs for Citi.

Tom Golisano, Paychex (payroll processing) billionaire New Yorker, who ran and failed in three bids for governor. He is thought to have a networth of $1.7 billion; was named one of Forbes' 400 Richest People in America. He carries around $1,000 to $2,000 dollars in cash on him in a money clip. He doesn't use a wallet.

Fred Eychaner, Democratic donor, Hillary funder

Haim Saban, producer most notably in the 1990s for Power Rangers. He also created the soundtracks for cartoon hits Inspector Gadget, He-Man.

Nasser Al-Rashid, billionaire Saudi business owner, who owns reportedly one of the largest -- if not the largest -- yachts in the world. He has a couple of degrees from the University of Texas and is the financier and namesake of the Texas Football weight room.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

No conflict of interest here(?) Hoo-hoo!!!
B.C.Foundation is a good thing. President Clinton is a good man. He is not advocating the distruction of anything. People contributing to him feel positive energy. The Limbaugh's of the world of course will attack him because that is what they do.
I'm sure this list will make Dick Morris very unhappy. Besides, some of those contributions could have gone to prostitutes and brothels.
The Clinton's are truly the Ugly Americans.
Well, now we need to go over Hillary's votes in the Senate looking to see if there were any conflicts of interest between how she voted, and which of the people on this list would have benefitted from those votes. If there's a pattern, then Hillary's a goner.
Nice to see Bill hasn't cashed in on being President.
Remember when Billy C. used to say he made $35,000 as governor of Arkansas? My, my, how those days have past him by.
Strange, no donations from Monica.
Ignorant idiot anti-Clinton comments from jerry in corpus crispy tx, in 3,2,1....
The "Clinton Foundation"? Is that what they call fencing operations now in days?
News from Illinois is that Blagojevich is impressed.
And how many billions has been given to Bush,under the table, on top of the table,at the ranch while GB was playing Cowboy&Indians with Dicky and the boys&girl.How many Billion will Chaney make from the war,just on Halliburtons & KRB's over charges?The thing is that Slick has done good things with the money,I doubt The Bumbling Bro's will give up any of there's.
I love how many people say "more of the same" when the same people run over and over, yet when someone new tries to enter the picture, all we hear is "no experience".  Did Hillary have experience when she ran for the Senate?  Did Fred Thompson?  Did Arnold have experience before running for Governor?  She is well educated and has the desire.  Since when is that not enough?

Jackson, Seattle

Ask yourself this question about your own post Jackson. What do all of your references have in common? They all ran and were elected into their positions. Even Silly Sara Palin ran and was elected twice for two separate offices. Caroline Kennedy...okay, if you went to college and law school you can be appointed as a US Senator. Careful what you post. It might reveal too much about who's punching the keyboard. Seattle is a long way from NY. Mind your own business.
A credit to Bill:  Releasing these names is a major statement that he loves Hillary and wants her to succeed as Sec of State.  

Now the question is what will the media do with this information?  I suspect they will try to spin, twist, reshape the information into something ugly. Go for the red meat Pat Buchanan and Joe Scarbrough.
Former President Bill Clinton's foundation has raised at least $41 million from Saudi Arabia and other foreign governments that his wife Hillary Rodham Clinton may end up negotiating with as the next secretary of state.

Ouch! Looks like another Democratic scandal-controversy heading our way for 2009! The plot and line up for this comedy is getting better all the time! Only 33 more days! Get your popcorn ready!

Marcus D., Chicago

Nothing new here. Everyone knows how corrupt the Clinton's are. PE Obama is giving her enough rope to hang both she and Bill. It's called the Theory of Elimination.
Amazing...
They released the donors list for the Sec of State position....

But, the didn't disclose for the Vice Presidency


Hopefully, donors won't influence any of Hillary's decisions.
She has the brains to be a great Secretary of State

We'll nedd a great one to repair all the damage of the last 8 years
This list is a verniable Who's-who of the corrupt and infamous.
Don't Ask ? Don't Tell ?

'...Having an openly gay person serve as the Secretary of the Navy would almost certainly drive conservative Republicans in Congress to apoplexy...'

THAT'S a GOOD REASON to APPOINT HIM !!



'...AN OPENLY GAY MAN AS SECRETARY OF THE NAVY?....

Well, this would probably raise a few eyebrows.

Some top retired military leaders and some Democrats in Congress are backing William White, chief operating officer of the Intrepid Museum Foundation, to be the next secretary of the Navy -- a move that would put the first openly gay person at the top of one of the services.

The secretary's job is a civilian position, so it would not run afoul of the ban on gays serving in the military, but it would renew focus on the "don't ask, don't tell" policy as President-elect Barack Obama prepares to take office.

"He would be phenomenal," said retired Gen. Hugh Shelton, who was chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff from 1997 to 2001, pointing to Mr. White's extensive background as a fundraiser for veterans' and military causes.

Retired members of the Joint Chiefs have contacted Mr. Obama's transition team to urge them to pick Mr. White, and members of Congress said he would be a good choice for a service secretary. [...]

Gen. Shelton called Mr. White's work at both the Intrepid Museum and the Fisher House Foundation "legendary."

"He has always been a staunch advocate of our men and women in uniform," Gen. Shelton said.



The Fisher House Foundation, which White has devoted considerable time to, offers a place to stay so families can be close to military members who are receiving medical care.

Having an openly gay person serve as the Secretary of the Navy would almost certainly drive conservative Republicans in Congress to apoplexy, and White's lack of military experience -- service is not an option given his sexual orientation -- would no doubt raise questions.

But retired Gen. Hugh Shelton knows a little something about qualifications in this area, and if he thinks White would be "phenomenal," that would carry quite a bit of weight, on the Hill and at the Pentagon....'

What's happening with the Minnesota re-count ?
Any news ?
Now the question is what will the media do with this information?  I suspect they will try to spin, twist, reshape the information into something ugly. Go for the red meat Pat Buchanan and Joe Scarbrough.

Ron Indiana (Sent Thursday, December 18, 2008 2:18 PM)

So you're not concerned that the US Sec. of State in waiting may have major conflicts of interest with the doners to her Foundation? And for some stange reason you are worried about how the media will react. Weird.

And how many billions has been given to Bush,under the table, on top of the table,at the ranch while GB was playing Cowboy&Indians with Dicky and the boys&girl.

jesse St.Paul Minnesota


I don't know, why don't you tell us? If you've got nothing, as it looks you have, why don't you go back to manufactoring more votes for Franken?
Wait until the Bush library list is made public, if ever...we'll see lots of terrorist supporting nations like Saudi Arabia, the UAE and the other pretend petro-kingdoms in the ME on it...it will become clear to even the most uneducated republican that Bush sold this nation and its soldiers down the river for the almighty black gold
The Governor of Illinois is looking like small potatoes. This does not mention the hefty speaking fees that other countries gave him nor does it mention how much Bill's foundation pays Bill for his services. It also doesn’t mention where the foundations and individuals that donated got the money to donate.

If you follow the money, you begin to see why some legislation was passed and trade agreements issued.

http://ewebsmith.com/gov/JFKWarning.html
Ah, the Clinton-haters are alive and well. So predictable... so tiresome (yawn).
Nice to see that Citi and it's financial leaders like Robert Rubin are contributing to the Clintons, as thousands of Citi workers are being layed off and investors are using Citi stock certificates to line their birdcages.
It is Bill Clinton's 'GLOBAL' Iniative.  If I wanted to help the poorest people on the 'globe' I would solicit the wealthiest.  They are doing extraordinaty work. Maybe we should be saying Thank you to some of these donors, instead of vilifying them.  
Curtis T Long Island.  Granted I'm not a native New Yorker, despite that fact. Who the next Senator from NY affects all Americans.  Senators make much more decisions that affect all of America than they do just their own state.  And besides the fact the Caroline Kennedy is just as qualified for the position as anyone else they are talking about, you stumbled upon the most important issue.  Election and yes electability.  That is what makes Kennedy the perfect choice.  Whomever is appointed needs to run in a special election in 2 years and then reelection 2 years after that.  Despite many other public servants who have been languishing in lower offices, biding their time, she is the one who can afford these costly elections.  New Yorkers will get their say in 2 years whomever is appointed and I care because I don't want to see the Dems lose that seat to some wealthy Republican.  Not only will Caroline carry more status to get things done on behalf of your state than anyone else who could be chosen, her financial connections mean she can attend to the peoples' business over the next 2 years instead of being consumed spending the next 4 years fundraising.  And frankly Caronline Kennedy is the best kind of representation we could hope for.  She is running for power or clout, she already has those things.  Her last name and wealth make her exempt to the influence of monied interests.  She actually wants to serve the nation (not herself).  SO maybe everyone could cut her some slack for being who she is.  Privileged, yes.  But she didn't choose to be a Kennedy, what is important is what she has chosen and is choosing to do with it.  She has been helping people.  Her name is what it is because her family and herself has bourn a great sacrifice to this nation, the loss of their loved ones.
I am astonished by how silly some people can be.

People seem to assume that Foreign entities do not have large undocumented pools of cash available to them that they may do with as they please.  If there was a desire to make a bribe to Bill Clinton it would be achieved with no record at all.

This insane drive of some to try and connect donations made to Clinton's charitable foundations to his personal wealth says more about the obsessive nature of Clinton's critics than it does about Clinton himself.  
Now that obama knows who the Clinton's are representing, we'll see if he asks Hillary to decline the nomination.  I mean, he did say no one with ties to lobbyist and all that, right?  So, the Clinton's have ties to countries that have a vested interest in how the US leans in their social-economic policies.  Will he show he's the liar that the Conservative Right thinks he is and keep her or will he be the man everyone who voted for him and expects him to be, and man-up, show his strength as a leader and tell her to decline?

Watch out what you wish for…


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1720943

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google