ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Back from Iraq, with Sen. candidates

Posted: Wednesday, December 24, 2008 4:33 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC’s Lauren Appelbaum
After returning from Iraq, Afghanistan and Germany this afternoon, Gov. David A. Paterson (D-NY) held a media availability with two New York congressmen, Representatives Steve Israel and Anthony Weiner. Reporters peppered them with questions concerning the replacement of Sen. Hillary Clinton's seat in the United States Senate.
 
"Whatever people say, whatever people want to infer, whatever people choose to think, that decision is one that I'm taking very seriously, because I'm being asked to substitute for the public, which will give its final verdict two years later," Paterson said at LaGuardia Airport, Marine Air Terminal in Flushing. "And I assure you, no person will influence me, coerce me, or in any way cause me to do anything other than what is my best judgment."
 
When asked about Caroline Kennedy, Paterson knocked down the idea she is the front-runner but said little more in specifics about her. He stressed he would not be announcing his appointment until Clinton is confirmed as Secretary of State.
 
Paterson called fellow traveler Israel "highly qualified" for the position. The two had met in the governor's office on Friday, Dec. 12th to discuss Israel's interest in the seat. But Paterson explained they wanted to avoid upsetting anyone because they were spending so much time together during this trip. He said they had no intention of discussing the seat during the trip but did discuss newspaper articles, which included quotes "sounding more like the prelude to a high school prom than the choosing of a United States Senator."
 
"We found it rather amusing," Paterson said, "but we were much more engrossed with the plight of our troops in Afghanistan and in Iraq and the prospect of peace in those regions."
 
When reporters asked Israel why he wants the appointment, the congressman focused on his current obligation as a member of the House of Representatives, which he said he was doing during this trip.

"I'm sure that the governor will make the best decision for the people of the state of New York," Israel said.
 
Weiner declined to answer any questions pertaining to this topic.

"This is a decision for the governor to make and the governor alone, and he'll have to make those judgments," the congressman said. "I want to be the only member of the congressional delegation not commenting on this for a while."
 
The three officials also stressed Iraq's situation has improved, but Afghanistan's situation has worsened. Paterson said he was "quite amazed" at Iraq's progress and credited the Iraqi people for choosing democracy over an Al Qaeda-led government. Regarding Afghanistan, however, Paterson said the situation was "deteriorating" due to greater border conflicts and the Taliban.
 
"Iraq is as good as it's going to get; I've never seen it better than I saw it in the past two days," added Israel, who has been to the region six times. "But I have never seen Afghanistan more challenging than I have seen it. It has deteriorated badly."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

good for patterson not to reveal his hand.
Why is a GOVERNOR going to war zones ?

Does New York have a foreign policy ?
Why not stick to governing New York

Now he's probably done it
Watch for Gonad the Barbarian to make another foreign trip
We need Governor Gonad here in California to pass a budget, not wandering the Earth
Forget Arnold as a Senate candidate in 2010
He has NO SUPPORT !
He's bungled the budget
What has he been doing all these years ?
The deficit is worse than EVER

Still I hope Patterson makes a good choice
there seem to be a lot of qualified candidates in NY
Kennedy, Cuomo, Rep. Nydia Velazquez...


Bush internal report released clears administration of any improper actions or contacts.

Merry Christmas!
Anybody but Caroline Kennedy Lopez.
Anybody.
kennedy must get that sit for paterson to have any chance fo winning in 2010
What? The gov. of New York goes to Iraq? Why? Does'nt he have enough to do stateside? who payed for that waste of time?
I'm sure no matter what the outcome, Olbermann and Maddow will find/invent some hidden agenda or story to ruin whatever happens so they can continue to spread the negativity they seem to thrive off of.
Why is Paterson going to Iraq?
He should pick the best qualified person for that position and not put someone with just a popular name.  I think Caroline Kennedy would be a good choice, but if someone that has more experience is more suited, than so be it.
Merry Christmas to all of you at MSNBC and thanks for all your work on FR.  I really appreciate this blog!!
Afghanistan has "deteriorated" badly? Hasn't America deteriorated badly also? We're not showing the Afghan people a good role model of democracy, only a model of greed and corruption. Between an insurgent fighting off a foreign invader and a greedy old man who steals billions destroying hundreds of families I would rather take the insurgent. Why are we worried about foreign terrorists destroying America when our own financial GREED TERRORISTS are doing it for them? America is it's own worst enemy. I hope our current and future political leaders work together to change that and remember their oath when they are sworn in: To defend America from all enemies, foreign and domestic. The oath should say to defend America from internal greed and corruption. Where most politicains would rather swear in on a stack of hundred dollars bills, President-Elect Obama is swearing in on Abe's bible. I think that says a lot about his character in choosing Abe as a role model.  
Afghanistan has "deteriorated" badly? Hasn't America deteriorated badly also? We're not showing the Afghan people a good role model of democracy, only a model of greed and corruption. Between an insurgent fighting off a foreign invader and a greedy old man who steals billions destroying hundreds of families I would rather take the insurgent. Why are we worried about foreign terrorists destroying America when our own financial GREED TERRORISTS are doing it for them? America is it's own worst enemy. I hope our current and future political leaders work together to change that and remember their oath when they are sworn in: To defend America from all enemies, foreign and domestic. The oath should say to defend America from internal greed and corruption. Where most politicains would rather swear in on a stack of hundred dollars bills, President-Elect Obama is swearing in on Abe's bible. I think that says a lot about his character in choosing Abe as a role model.  
I am definately pro-Kennedy!
I don't get it - now that the election is over it's ok to say that Iraq is on the right track??
Paterson is correct when he says that he will wait until Clinton is confirmed.  There is no point to appointing someone until the seat is vacated.  It is very unlikely but still a possibilty that she would not be confirmed.  
For Paterson this should be a no brainer.  Caroline Kennedy should be his only choice.  She deserves this appointment because of Pres. Kennedy's assassination.  She was deprived of his presence in all of the important times in her life: graduations, wedding, children. She is quite capable & qualified. Let the voters decide if she should be elected later.
Let's hope that these appointee will resign in good faith to let OBAMA do the selecting, or, I guess he could FIRE them all and appoint who he thinks is best qualified and shares his views.
I am sure they will find a way to appoint some one with a Jewish connection. ( ISRAEL)
Paterson says that Afghanistan has "deteriorated" badly. Hasn't America deteriorated badly also? We are not showing the Afghan people a good role model of democracy, only a model of greed and corruption. Why are we worried about foreign terrorist destroying our way of life when our own GREED TERRORISTS are doing it for them. Americans are their own worst enemies. Between an insurgent and a greedy old man who steals billions and destroys thousands of lives I'll take the insurgent. Rome collasped from within because of corruption and greed from it's leaders. Sound familiar?  At least President-Elect Obama has Honest Abe as his role model. Where most Politicians would rather swear in on a stack of hundred dollar bills he's using Abe's bible in his inauguration. We can only hope he becomes a good Presidental role model for America.
Paterson says that Afghanistan has "deteriorated" badly. Hasn't America deteriorated badly also? We are not showing the Afghan people a good role model of democracy, only a model of greed and corruption. Why are we worried about foreign terrorist destroying our way of life when our own GREED TERRORISTS are doing it for them. Americans are their own worst enemies. Between an insurgent and a greedy old man who steals billions and destroys thousands of lives I'll take the insurgent. Rome collasped from within because of corruption and greed from it's leaders. Sound familiar?  At least President-Elect Obama has Honest Abe as his role model. Where most Politicians would rather swear in on a stack of hundred dollar bills he's using Abe's bible in his inauguration. We can only hope he becomes a good Presidental role model for America.
Paterson says that Afghanistan has "deteriorated" badly. Hasn't America deteriorated badly also? We are not showing the Afghan people a good role model of democracy, only a model of greed and corruption. Why are we worried about foreign terrorist destroying our way of life when our own GREED TERRORISTS are doing it for them. Americans are their own worst enemies. Between an insurgent and a greedy old man who steals billions and destroys thousands of lives I'll take the insurgent. Rome collasped from within because of corruption and greed from it's leaders. Sound familiar?  At least President-Elect Obama has Honest Abe as his role model. Where most Politicians would rather swear in on a stack of hundred dollar bills he's using Abe's bible in his inauguration. We can only hope he becomes a good Presidental role model for America.
Watch out Caroline. Bubba used to sleeping with Senator from New York.
I hope he doesn't allow anyone to coerce his thinking in this matter.  The people need a Senator who will go into the job knowing the issues not having to "learn" them.  

Carolyn Kennedy should study up and make a run for the Senate in 2010 and if the people of New York feel she is the most qualified candidate then she will and rightfully should be sworn in.

Laura, Boston, MA
I can't imagine Hillary Clinton would want to see her Senate seat go to Caroline Kennedy, whose support for Obama came at a critical time in the primaries.
LOL--New York Democrats and supporters of Israel probably aren't too keen on you calling him a "fellow traveler," since that was code for Communist not that long ago. I can't imagine that would play too well in upstate New York!

While Caroline Kennedy did not drive the car off the bridge, nor did she have anything much to do with Marilyn Monroe, nor did she steal any elections in 1960... it is a shame she is "tainted" by her family history... blah, blah, blah.

While Obama had nada to do with the infamous Blagobitch, despises the trees Blago pees on, still, it is such a shame that he will be "tainted" by living in the same state at the same time...

The MSM logoriac circle jerk(s) about the Kennedy candidacy and the Blago fiasco just show how far off the beam these guys are. My sweet Lord!

As they vacation wherever, is it strange to anyone else that no one asks the really BIG questions?  Like, say:

What criminal activities got us into this monumental mess anyway?  Can we put the entire federal government and everyone above mail room boys and girls on Wall Street, Madison Avenue, et al, in jail?

Why not?

Is it too bad these fine feds/$ folks are going to be "tainted" by their own idiocy?  What a shame.

How the hell do we get out of this deep ditch (or rather, all these bottomless ditches?)

If the coffee is burning and the house is on fire, why aren't the smoke alarms going off? When do we get to wake up?  Who will ring the first bell?

Well, we aren't hearing much but tabloid spatter from our friends in the MSM, so otherwise warmly ensconced, for the time being. (Repeat last clause)

What time is it anyway?




What if an empire imploded and everyone was watching news?  Would anybody know?



Why is the governor of New York in Irag?  It seems a waste of taxpayer funds to me unless he is trying to sell some type of commerce deal between Irag & New York.  Yes supportng the troops is fine but not spending money when they can't balance a budget would make more common sense.  But then this is politics no matter how you spin it and I guess they have to justify their trip somehow.  Gee a little common sense and due diligence would go a long way to reducing our deficit problems.  That would be to obvious to all except the pols.  Time for a new era in types of pols.  You need to go to Gov. by the way of Bush.  Time for a change here also.
Paterson says that Afghanistan has "deteriorated" badly. Hasn't America's image deteriorated badly also? We are not showing the Afghan people a good role model of a working democracy, only a model of national expansionism, Wall Street greed and political corruption. Rome collasped from within because of it's weak, immoral, selfish leaders who's only role models were wealth and power. Sound familiar? Maybe our image will "undeteriorate" with our new President. At least he uses Honest Abe as his role model. Where most politicians would rather swear in on a stack of hundred dollar bills he's using Abe's bible in his inauguration. We can only hope he becomes a good Presidental role model for America and the world.
Paterson says that Afghanistan has "deteriorated" badly. Hasn't America's image deteriorated badly also? We are not showing the Afghan people a good role model of a working democracy, only a model of national expansionism, Wall Street greed and political corruption. Rome collasped from within because of it's weak, immoral, selfish leaders who's only role models were wealth and power. Sound familiar? Maybe our image will "undeteriorate" with our new President. At least he uses Honest Abe as his role model. Where most politicians would rather swear in on a stack of hundred dollar bills he's using Abe's bible in his inauguration. We can only hope he becomes a good Presidental role model for America and the world.
To be brief:  Yes, New York has a foreign policy.  We joke about it, but traditionally our foreign policy has focussed on "The Three I's": Ireland, Italy and Israel.  Moreover our National Guard and Air National Guard are mostly over in...what was the name of that country again?  Starts with I too, thus is consistent with our traditional foreign policy aims.  Finally, New York was attacked seven years ago, and we have stayed attack-free since then largely due to the NYPD, which maintains liasons with foreign police dep'ts to stay on top of the situation.  The State Dep't doesn't like it, but the hell with them.

I hope this has helped to clarify our position somewhat.  Happy New Year, everyone.
MSierra, you really have no idea who Nydia Velazquez is, do you? She's my congressional representative, and _I_ have no idea who she is. She is chair of the small business subcommittee. That's all I know, that and her office doesn't respond well.  (I'm not picking on Nydia, I used to be in Anthony Whiner's dist. and his office is only slightly better.)

As far as I'm concerned, David Paterson can appoint anyone he likes (but, please, not Whiner); I trust his judgment.  It's really between him and the people of NY, isn't it?  But everyone has an opinion and is entitled to it, whether formulated through thoughtful reflection on relevant information or simply yanked off the wire services.

For the record, I am not interested in being appointed to the seat.
why let joe sepeda post the same comment six times?

really, what kind of site moderation is that?
please try to do your job better than that.
thanks
I hope he doesn't allow anyone to coerce his thinking in this matter.  The people need a Senator who will go into the job knowing the issues not having to "learn" them.  

Carolyn Kennedy should study up and make a run for the Senate in 2010 and if the people of New York feel she is the most qualified candidate then she will and rightfully should be sworn in.

Laura, Boston, MA
Laura, Boston, MA (Sent Friday, December 26, 2008 2:36 PM)
________________

Who says Caroline would have to learn the issues.  She is already a NYS resident (and has been for more years than a lot of NY'ers.)  She is also from a political family.  Do you honestly think that, just because she has never served in public office, she automatically doesn't know the issues?
Jane Guernsey

I think a child of a deceased serviceman should be appointed, one who like Caroline Kennedy, was deprived of their father's presence in service of his country.  And one who did not have the advantages of a famous name and fabulous wealth and every advantage that goes along with it.  Personally, if someone has never performed a job, I don't feel they can represent me.

Also, why is Patterson in Iraq?  I don't know, but his constituents are certainly going there.   Maybe for that reason alone he wants to stay in touch with the situation there.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1724773

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google