ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Bush -- wistful, defiant, defensive to end

Posted: Monday, January 12, 2009 10:28 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From NBC's Domenico Montanaro
President George W. Bush struck a wistful and, at times, defensive and defiant tone at a press conference he called the "ultimate exit interview."

"I've had my time in the klieg lights," he said. "You might catch me opining" from time to time, but, he added, he wishes his successor, President-elect Obama "all the very best." 

In what is believed to be likely Bush's last press conference as president, he discussed a wide range of topics, including the news of the day (Gaza, the impending stimulus package), as well as reflecting on his legacy and mistakes made.


Video: President Bush says he hopes the tone of Washington is different for his successor and forcefully defends his record, arguing the country is safer because of his time in the White House.

The president's ire went up when pressed about the federal government's response to Hurricane Katrina and whether the United States has lost "moral standing" in the world.

"Don't tell me the federal response was slow, when there were 30,000 people pulled up off roofs," Bush said. "That's a pretty quick response."

He added, "There's more that could have been done, sure."

Bush defended, however, the decision not to land Air Force One in the region, because it would have diverted needed police resources, and then the media would have criticized that, he said.

Defending America's 'moral standing'
On America's image in the world, Bush said, "I strongly disagree that our moral standing has been damaged."

He acknowledged that it "may have been damaged among some of the elite" in Europe, but not with the rest of the world. He said to ask Africa, India and China about America -- that they would see it as a place that promotes freedom.

"Those are few countries" that view the U.S. in a poor light, Bush added. "I disagree that people view America in a dim light. I just disagree with the assessment."

He went on, saying that if he wanted to be popular -- in some parts of Europe, in particular -- he would blame Israel for everything in the Middle East, join the International Criminal Court and support Kyoto -- though he called it flawed.

"I wouldn't worry about popularity," Bush said, adding, "I'm concerned about the country."

'Mission Accomplished,' rhetoric, Abu Ghraib, WMD among mistakes, disappointments
He repeated a list of his mistakes, including the "Mission Accomplished" banner and some of his rhetoric. (In the past, he has cited saying "Dead or Alive.") He listed Abu Ghraib and the non-existence of weapons of mass destruction as disappointments. Bush reiterated his stance that history will judge him, but that there is "no short-term history."

'Israel has a right to defend herself'
On the current fighting in Gaza, he repeated his administration's stance that the U.S. is "for a sustainable ceasefire."

But he said there would not be a sustainable ceasefire if Hamas continues firing rockets into Israel. The president identified smuggling from Egypt as one of the biggest problems and said that working with Egypt is key. He also warned against those who provide arms supplies to Hamas.

Bush reiterated that "Israel has a right to defend herself." He did add, though, that he hopes Israel will be mindful of the innocent. Asked why there was not peace in the region, he said, "That's a good question. ... It's been a long time since there's been peace in the Middle East."

Greatest threats
The president said the greatest threat remains one to the "homeland." He identified North Korea as a great threat because of a potential for a "highly enriched uranium program," though he acknowledged that there is a debate in the intelligence community as to how large a threat it actually is.

"They're still dangerous," Bush said, adding that "Iran is still a threat."

GOP can't be anti-immigrant
On how the Republican Party recovers from defeats in the last two election cycles, he said, "This party will come back, but this party's message should be" one of inclusion. He cited immigration as an example, stressing that the problem is "the image that came out is that Republicans don't like immigrants." Bush said the party "has to be compassionate and broad minded."

He then reflected on the 1964 elections when his father lost a bid for the Senate -- downballot of Lyndon B. Johnson. He cited that in 1966 "there was a resurgence" and said it could happen again.

In defense of the bailout
Bush insisted that the $700 billion bailout was necessary and that it has allowed the financial markets to begin to "thaw."

Hoping for different tone
Bush again also lamented the tone of Washington.

"I hope the tone is different for [Obama] than it is for me," said Bush, who also commented that Obama's swearing in will be "amazing." In Washington, Bush said, there's a lot of "needless namecalling."

"The rhetoric got out of control," he said. "Frankly, for the system itself, I hope that when people disagree with Obama they treat him with respect."

Bush added, "No question there will be critics, and there should be. ... I just hope the tone is respectful; he deserves it, and so does the country."

The media "misunderestimated" Bush?
With relation to the media, Bush left it with one more so-called Bushism.

Bush said he disagreed with some stories that were written, but overall he respected the press -- though he thinks the media, at times, "misunderestimated" him.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Yeah, there's no short term history, but this fool ain't wine or cheese.  He won't get better with age!
Don't tell you anything, W!  Yeah, the world has experienced 8-years of no one telling you anything but what you wanted to hear....and look at us now!

The Administrations response to Katrina is already written......the response was ZILCH!  Your defiant response to the question doesn't change one thing.  The voices in your own head are still giving you the wrong intel!  

The dragging death of James Byrd, you absolutely ignored, just as you did Katrina victims.  After all, it was only Black folk!

Will Condi be allowed to visit you in your new digs in North Dallas.  Afterall, the homeowners may get upset that a Black person is in their neighborhood, which may be against the rules that were only changed in 2000.
It will be a LONG 8 days. Good riddance!
Domenico - I owe you an apology for jumping the gun on your B-Rod story. I jump the gun on your intentions – compared it to bigotry.

Although, I do feel that some of your past stories did deserve that type of condemnation, this one didn’t.

You are an outstanding journalist and I appreciate your efforts.

Thank you and GOD BLESS AMERICA

Don't let the door hit you in the you know what shrub...you've plunged us into two unwinnable wars and damaged our economy beyond imagine...thanks for nothing and good riddance
"Don't tell me the federal response was slow, when there were 30,000 people pulled up off roofs," Bush said. "That's a pretty quick response."

Yeah, and some had been there for more than a day. Then relief of other sorts such as housing and medical care came eventually, when they felt like it. Was that fast too, George? How delusional can this man be, for crying out loud?

On America's image in the world, Bush said, "I strongly disagree that our moral standing has been damaged."

I know people in Europe and, Georgie, you are dead wrong. Because of you we have a very low moral standing with most of the world.

"I hope the tone is different for [Obama] than it is for me," said Bush, who also commented that Obama's swearing in will be "amazing." In Washington, Bush said, there's a lot of "needless namecalling."

It will be, George, as the Democrats and especially Obama are more willing to reach across the aisle and be less partisan than your GOP buddies have been. Guys like Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity and their ilk will become less relevant now.


So he had fun, how nice for him.

Meanwhile the country and many of its citizens suffered and continue to do so.

This man simply does not get it.

Using the lame excuse he didn't want to have Airforce 1 land in Louisana and draw needed security to cover him, who needed him there?  What was needed immediately was emergency supplies, quick funding and decent housing to help these unfortunate victims.  His lack of understanding of the extent of the devastation and the suffering is hard to comprehend.

President Bush, go into retirement and leave us to sort our your mess.  May we hear no more from you and your administration who enabled you to do such a lousy, morally bankrupt job.

Good riddance!  I hope the MSM who also enabled you to ruin the country by not pursueing the obvious and giving you a free pass, will let you slide into the obscurity you so richly deserve.
Ask Joe Wilson, Colin Powell, and others what happens to those that disagree!

Such a crock!

Deny, Lie, Coverup!  Be Gone W!
I like to think it will be easier to disagree with Obama and be respectful because he won by such a 'mandate'.  For Bush, so many of us believe he was appointed by a corrupt Secretary of State in Florida and a Supreme Court that was partisan.  Instead of bringing the country together, it delegitimized (is that even a word?).

At any rate, I for one am happy to see these eight days go by at rapid pace.  I wasn't a huge fan of Hillary's; but her stump speech where she said the moving van will back up to the whitehouse and the entire nation will breathe a sigh of relief seems more relevant and germaine than ever today.  Heckuva job there, Bushie.
He has every right to attempt tempering negative perceptions of his legacy, but personally I would like to see at least some acknowledgement that he understands the view of vast damage he's done to our national reputation, security and spirit. I wouldn't expect him to agree with the view, but I would at least like him to acknowledge it exists.
let us continue to hang Katrina around his neck!  Nevermind the lack of response or planning the Gov & Mayor displayed, or the FACT that those were THEIR reponsebility!  Yeah, it's all Bush's fault, that democants let people die in LA and when Bush went to help them it became HIS FAULT that the Gov & Mayor did nothing up-front, and nothing later on.  Blaming Bush is FUN!
Congrats to Pat Boston, Giants lost.
Condolences to Pat NY, Giants lost.

You both write well and have a clear vision of the big picture.  I enjoy reading your comments.

A lot of pundits quibble over little issues, but I think one of the biggest issues Obama has to face is what to do about Bush and Chaney.  Yes, torturing is illegal. It is against the Geneva Convention.  It is flat out wrong.  Yet the Bush administration condoned it. What is Obama to do?  Prosecute because they broke the law? Or show forgiveness of Biblical proportions?  I suspect Obama would like to walk away and not address this issue. There will be a lot of critizism that Bush/Cheney should be punished as no one is above the law. To go there would be politics as usual. It will take great wisdom to do the right thing.
In her AIDS-scarred South African township, Sweetness Mzolisa leads a chorus of praise for George W. Bush that echoes to the deserts of Namibia, the hills of Rwanda and the villages of Ethiopia.

Like countless Africans, Mzolisa says she will always be grateful to Bush for his war on AIDS, which has helped to treat more than 2 million Africans, support 10 million more and revitalize the global fight against the disease.

Democrats and Liberals hate this fact as it debunks the lies and hate they spread about President Bush.

Josh Larson, FL


Give credit where credit is due, to all the racist blogging in. Contradicts a lot of trash talking going on here, unless you feel Africans are unworthy?
...outrageous...

Only war crimes prosecutions can correct this.

GoodBye Cowboy George, you have a Yellow streak up your back that won't be missed. Running from the Fight with Al-Quida to go after Saddam has left America vulnerable. Thanx for nuttin !

Everything you have EVER layed your grimy hands on, has turned to Crap, to bad it took American's 6 year's to figure that out.

Your last 7 day's can't pass enough !
He has done nothing that is positive, look at the unemployment, everyones salary is less, but he and the politicians are not hurting. He killed over 4000 soldiers in Iraq for an unjust cause. I do hope he has a hard time sleeping for the rest of his life.  He will go down as the worst president in History! He does not read history so he won't know anything anyway.
I don't believe this guy! What planet is he living on?He raped the country and then asked if it was good for you too. Failure to see your own failures is a sign of a sick disconnected personality. He's going down in history as one of the worst, if not the worst, president ever. The only success he and his party have accomplished is showing America how NOT to run a country. I hope it's not too late to turn things around and that Washington learns from Bushs failures.
I believe that history will be kind to George Bush.  No matter how much we have ridiculed, disrespected and criticized our president, you can not ignore the fact that some of his policies and leadership decisions have kept our country safe since 9/11.
A full 90 percent of donations to fund Barack Obama’s Jan. 20 inauguration have come from well-heeled fundraisers — including Wall Street executives whose companies have received federal bailout money.

A total of 207 fundraisers have collected $24.8 million of the $27.3 million in donations disclosed by Obama through Thursday, according to an analysis by Public Citizen commissioned by The Wall Street Journal.

Slightly more than 2,000 donors accounted for the $27.3 million raised, but 378 of those people each contributed the maximum $50,000 allowed by Obama, raising almost 70 percent of the total, or $18.9 million, the analysis found.

Wall Street employees have been the largest single source of private donations, and many of the contributions have been channeled through financial-services executives who have put together bundles of donations worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.

“The preponderance of large donors and the fact that so many come from an industry receiving government handouts comes as the president-elect has sought to keep his inauguration free of special interests,” The Journal observed.

Something smells very fishy here. Change we need!
Didn't hear the whole thing

Did he defend the Gestapo tactics of torture?
(excuse me, enhanced interrogation techniques)

I'd like to hear him defend that

What is the difference between the CIA and the Gestapo?

Kinder, gentler torture ?
Ron, Indiana: Thank you for the compliment. I enjoy reading your posts as well. We begin a new journey shortly. This time, we're all in this together. If Obama fails, we all fail.

And yes, it's always a good thing when the Giants, Jets and Yankees lose. Always. And they feel the same way about us up here. (smile)
Thank god for a caring an honest president.
I think Bush should have finally thanked the Supreme Court of the US, esp. Fat Tony Scalia and Sandra Day O'Conner, for getting the president gig for him. Bush is the best possible example of why the Supreme Court has no business interfering in elections.

I am so NOT OVER Bush v. Gore.
Notice how on Idiot Boy's watch the banking industry has consolidated and how there is less competition than ever before.  Heckuva job Georgie Boy!

Eric, Salinas, CA

Bush also accepts blame for major snow storms in Midwest and North East to include earlier snow in New Orleans. Midwest having record snowfall this winter. Bush to blame.
Only 1468 days till Obama/Biden are gone!
The utter arrogance of this man and his cronies....there are no words.  CNN is running a documentary called "IOUSA" about the economic crisis that every American should see.  In it, former Secy of Treasury, O'Neill, describes how Cheney fires him and tells him to lie that he is resigning.  Apparently O'Neill disagreed with the Bush Tax Cuts and the overall economic policy in 2002/2003 and gave him the axe.  Cheney continues to lie about how prevelant a role he played...he was calling ALL the shots.  All they concerned themselves with were Oil, money and getting Sadam for "daddy"!!  May they all rot in hell!  However, prison would be more suitable!!
I didn't vote for him either time. I think he failed to grow into the position. But that doesn't mean I like reading comments from the fools I see here. Show some respect. After all, he's probably smarter than you.
Only a disrepectful, arrogant, and just plain out of touch with reality person like the dunce in chief not accept responsibility that he screwed the pouch and destroyed what good name this country had.  If he was truly a religous person he would have accepted humility and be able to asmit his mistakes and also be able to correct the mistakes.  He will go down in history as the worst POTUS period.  
Come on, LIL George had a birthday party to go to instead of going down to New Orleans,he had Brownie there doing a fine job,where is Brownie now?I have a feeling GW thinks he has did a good job,thats what his wife has said,and his daddy.I just hope the day will come,and that smirk of his face will be wiped off,same with Chaney.These two will go down as the worst and most expensive set of crooks to ever con a country into voting for them,I'm glad to say I'm not one of them.I just wish the press would have done there job instead of letting all the lies,distortions,scare tactics,control there reporting.Or is it that all the press works for Fox?Judgement day will come,one way or another.
A good speech, informal, informative and way too gracious to the press corps.

President George W. Bush defended his plicies and determination to the end. His reliance on himself is one of his strong points, NEVER letting public opinion bother him, just letting it roll off his shoulder.

Abraham Lincoln had the same critics and the same character as GWB. Even Obama admired Lincoln.

Bush wished Obama well in his endeavor as the new president, being as gracious as possible.

While many of those on this blog will diss Bush, remember that Obama is already being heavily criticized by his own party, from everything from Rick Warren to a generally conservative approach to his presidency, despite appointing a mostly liberal team of past Clinton aides. And BHO's Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, leaned much toward President Bush's policies, including the war in Iraq.

Good luck to President Bush and incoming president Barack Obama.

Bush said he could go home and look himself in the mirror and say he didn't cave to any person or group.
Too bad we all can't do the same.
Does anyone know exactly how many press conferences Bush actually did over the last 8 years?  Something tells me I can count them on all my fingers, and still have one left over to give him as he leaves.  

BTW - as for the Giants, well, there's always next season.  
He had FUN????????? What? Tap dancing on the steps while waiting for McCain to arrive? The rest of us? Not so much, George. Shows you that he'll remain a complete idiot whether he holds the office or not. I have never hated a president before this, but this one takes the cake. I can't stand looking at him anymore. What a complete and total loser.
He does not believe our moral standing has been damaged?

As an everyday American, who has traveled quite a bit in Europe over the last four years, I heartily disagree with this. I hope my next trip, this summer, my shame over being an American is gone, that I won't have to follow up with "I did not vote for him," etc.

He continues to frighten me, even as he leaves office. I am so tired of being afraid, of feeling shame, of apologizing for my love of my country.  It hurts.  Just really hurts.
All this anti President Bush is crap.  Everything from soup to nuts on him.  Who are you going to blame now that he is gone?

I thank God he was in charge on 9/11 and some of the other extraordinary catastrophies the USA has experienced.

Can anyone imagine how all of this would have worked out with a bleeding heart liberal in control i.e. Clinton - any one of them, Kennedy, Pelosi, Reed!

RHB VA  
The smirk is real.
Obama is a coward, afraid of the enemy that huants us. Bush HAS kept us safe. The lame-headed on this blog don't have the decency to be grateful. Too many
Dialy Kos readers here. Put-down artists to the max.

Clueless.  Remorseless.  Priceless.
I for one absolutely detested most of what Bush implemented as policy, but the time for throwing barbs at his administration is past.  I hope to live another 40 or more years and get the chance to see how history judges him, but right now I am more interested in what the next 6-12 months hold for our country.  That is far more important that moaning loudly about the last 8 years.  What's done is done, let's all try to work together to get thsi country back on a good path.
There is one thing that I will miss about W. Everytime he talked he made a hilarious Bushism. He might have gotten us into 2 wars and be the worst president ever, but noone will ever top the past eight years of non-stop laughter whenever he spoke. Thank you W, some parts of your presidency were fun, but thank God it's over.
To all of you illiterate I believe everything I read and see in a most slanted media (Keith Oberman, et al) you should just shut up, read a little more and be thankful that you still have your beer, you still have your cigarettes, your crack, your pot, etc, and no one has bombed you out of your home, your job, your wasted pathetic existance and you have and maintain your RIGHT to bitch.  George W. Bush didn't always get it right, but at least he didn't mealy mouth his way around it, he stuck to his viewpoint, had the mental fortitude to do what he thought was best and he HAS kept our homeland safe, not one single significant event transpired after 9/11, yet MANY attempts were thwarted because of the diligent efforts of so many.  Think about that then next time an unintelligent remark springs from your fingers.  I simply cannot believe there are that many dumbazz's living in this country.  You all should be ashamed.  What did Barack Obama ever do for anyone, other than himself? Riddle me that Batman.......
Bush's legacy should only conclude at the end of a rope around his neck.

This was the saddest 8 years in the history of America. This president did not care about people but instead his ideology and crazy desire to force democracy in a region that does not want it.So many lives have been lost especially the many Iraqi's that go unmentioned along with over 4,000 Americans. History should remember him as the worst person to ever hold the office and expose the criminality of this administration that will never be prosecuted for it.We,the American public must also realize that we are responsible for foolishly electing this group of criminals.This was a terrible mistake that not only we have to live with but generations to come must do so as well. May God help us all for we are just as guilty for putting Bush ands his cronies in the White House.
Bush must be suffering from a mental problem. He has been in an obvious state of denial for at least eight years and not one of his "advisors" approached him with this information. He did regularly participate in physicals, but, did any doctor ever suggest a mental evaluation? Perhaps if he did get a mental evaluation each year, the mess that was created under his tenure could have been avoided. Physical and mental evaluations should be required of every president and vice-president annually!
I for one will miss GW and his stands on abortion and his fight against terror.  All the liberals will rejoy for sure but mark my words.....wait until taxes sky rocket and the deficit explodes from a liberal spend Democratic majority.......the voters have spoken (even though 50 million of us DID NOT vote for BO)........do not even think about complaining when it gets worse due to the impending abandonment of fiscal conservatism.

Criticize, criticize, criticize, I suppose  you think you could have done better.
Your headlines on the MSN Wed are misleading and show you hate of President Bush - keep it up and you will fall to the wayside with fewer and fewer readers due to your slanted reporting
It's hard to feel sorry for yourself when it's your fault.  When I screw something up, I look to correct it, but Bush seems to think it is some mental game to not face mistakes and correct things as they go wrong.  One of my favorite expressions is: Fail quickly.  You are going to make mistakes regardless of how hard you try, but the important thing is to recognize a mistake and have the strength to admit it and correct it.  Bush lacked that strength.  Sticking to your guns when you are wrong is the worst kind of leadership and that's why we are where we are.  Bush will head back to Texas and we will face the stress of one uncorrected mistake after another.  And people voted for him twice, that's what I find amazing.  Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.  Shame on you America.
Each of you is a "Victim" and should be compensated.  Webster defines "victims as: One that is subjected to oppression, hardship, or mistreatment" so all of you should be paid something from others! Even then, you'll still bitch!
Haven’t been able to post is awhile as I was LUCKY enough to find a job in this stinking economy after only being unemployed and without healthcare insurance for 2 months!! Thanks soooo much Georgie!!

But anyway… I’m convinced we are about to open a new chapter in this great country’s history with Barack Obama becoming our next POTUS!  We the people worked our a**’s off to get him where he is and there is no doubt in my mind he will deliver to us a new way of ‘doing politics’ in this country.

Unlike the chaos and damage W has spread upon us over the last l o n g 8 years - even citizens who didn’t vote or support Obama are surprised and a touch curious about this man and what he has demonstrated so far since winning on Nov 4th!

Let us all keep in mind how we felt that evening on 11.4.08 and not let the idiots out there (you know who you are) distract us from our goals!

Let us also not forget this weekend Our next President has asked us to volunteer for a ‘Weekend of Service” – I will be helping out the homeless here in IL (and G*D knows the numbers are increasing rapidly).  So we MUST stay focused and ignore the MSM and naysayers.  WE can do this….Yes WE Can!!

As Barack said… ‘This is OUR TIME’!!

8 days and counting to a New & Improved America!
Marcus D, the only two positive things W has done highlight who he is and who his friends are.  His AIDS efforts will make billions for his drug company friends and protecting a few thousand square miles of sea that has no mining or drilling value is no compensation for opening up large portions of America's wilderness to corporate greed.  This is cheap legacy burnishing fodder and does nothing to counter-balance the endless list of horrors Bush has visited upon this country, the world and nature.

/eclectos..


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1741496

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google