ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Franken requests certificate

Posted: Monday, January 12, 2009 5:30 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC's Abby Livingston
If the Franken campaign was looking to rile up the Team Coleman, it succeeded today.

Earlier, the Franken campaign sent a letter to Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty and Secretary of State Mark Ritchie requesting that Franken be certified the winner of the Minnesota Senate seat recount race.

Franken attorneys wrote of what they saw as an inevitable Franken certification, and concluded, “Now that the recount is complete and the new Congress has convened, state law does not provide for further delay, and federal law requires that the certificate issue. Accordingly, we request respectfully that Mr. Franken’s election be certified by the close of business today.”

Despite that rhetoric, by far, the sharpest dig in the letter was a "cc:" to “Senator-Elect Al Franken.” 

In a move that showed that there is at least one Republican and Democrat in Minnesota on the same page, Pawlenty and Ritchie declined the request. Regardless, on a conference call this afternoon, the Coleman campaign referred to Ritchie as “Franken-friendly.”

Later in the day, the Coleman camp returned fire with a letter of its own, stating, “As you have both recognized, there is no legal basis for this request, and we applaud your subsequent refusal to issue a certificate of election that Mr. Franken has not legally secured or obtained.”

The letter went on to call the Franken move “audacious,” an “end-run,” an “attempt to short circuit judicial investigation,” and the Coleman camp viewed it with “amazement.” 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Republican Pawlenty isn't likely to go along with the request until Coleman exhausts all his dirty tricks, law suits and more expensive and wasteful challenges.

Coleman is such a hypocrite (he IS a Republican after all) because he won't do what he told Frankin to do back when it looked like he had barely won the election. Stand back for the good of Minnesota. Well, Normie, take your own advice, you hypocritical coward. For the good of Minnesota and the USA.

Senator Frankin because he's good enough, smart enough and dogonnit people like him.
Kind of hard to seat Al Franken when thee was so much cheating and unbelievable crookedness in Minnesota.

But that is just the kind of nasty things Liberals do.
Like I said, everyone knows some Franken counties had way many more votes than they had residences so it's obvious that votes for Franken were counted more than once. But you have to laugh at it because it's the way of the Dems.
And Obama is not king.
I don't think the Republicans get too hot over ANYTHING the Dems do anymore. No surprises left after Franken, Blagojevich, Burris, etc.

Like the title of an old George Strait song ...
"I've Come To Expect It From You."
Congrats to George H. W. Bush on the inauguration of your gigantic new aircraft carrier, The SS George H. W. Bush, stationed in Norfolk, Va.
Oh, like Coleman didn't do that a few weeks ago.

What-evs dudes.
Coleman would be lost in Washington as a senator. With no Bush or Cheney to guide him the guy would not know what to say or how to act. He certainly needs to step down, smell the roses and get a life of his own.
Stupid.
Franken is perfectly justified in this request since THERE IS NO MATHEMATIC WAY  FOR COLEMAN TO OVERCOME FRANKEN'S LEAD. At this point, Coleman is behaving just like Hillary during the primary. Although the math says it's over, he is still looking for some miracle by the courts that would somehow hand him the election. Unfortunately even if they count the outstanding 650 absentee ballots and remove the alledged 100 double-counted votes (that don't exist) Coleman would gain at the most 120 votes, still putting him over 100 votes behind Franken once every last vote is counted. It's over. Stop being petulant GOP. Stop hoping for the long-shot Normie.
And how does Coleman square this with the sentiment he had before the recount?  When he asked Franken to concede, since it would be in the best interests of the State of Minnesota.
Two points I would like to make. DIdnt Mr. Coleman make a statement shortly after election day that Mr. Franken should respectfully bow out in the spirit of bipartisan healing? I wonder why the same statement doesnt apply now that he is the one lagging behind.

Second point is, Since Coleman feels it isnt prudent for him to follow his own advice, the Franken camp should let the legal system run its course. Before Democrats jump all over me, I am a registered Dem, and stand slightly left of center. But I do feel, in the interest of fairness, any Democrat who cried foul in the 2000 Presidential election, and also supports Franken's certification without due process running its course is no better than the Neoconservative who worked very hard to stop the recount in Florida in 2000.

On a side note, doesnt it make ya kinda miss the old days when the US could hold an election without lawyers and judges getting involed?
republicans will do anything to stop the seating of franken, face it repukes norm coleman lost!!!! now let franken in
What we have here is "THE OLD BOY NET WORK". It appears they want to keep out anyone who might not go along with the "NET WORK AGENDA. It matters not that  they are elected or appointed. "PROTECT OUR PHONEY BALONY JOBS"
Ha.
As an American citizen, all you have to do is look at this election as another example of how pathetic our political system is.  A comedian from Saturday Night Live with no elected experience beats another liar in the Senate (it is my belief they are all corrupt and disgusting).  They should fire everyone who has been in office 12 years or more and start over.
Somebody please tell Coleman he lost already. His rotting corpse is starting to stink up the place.
I'd expect nothing less from the exuberant Franken campaign.  The GOP is apoplectic that an incumbent Repulican was bested by a former SNL comedian.  Franken is just tweaking GOP noses with this move. They knew going in that it was a long shot.  They also knew it would get Franken more press.  You go, Al!
This is nuts...  Coleman is telling the people of MN that it's HIM or NOTHING...  Is he emotionally stable?  Oh wait, he's calling it 'audacious' that he would actually loose an election...

But then, Bachmann won there also...  Yuck...
Gee, if the Senate can seat Burris without the State certification why can't they seat Franken?
jerry/corpus christi TX  Why don't you educate all of us on the corruption in MN?  I challenge you to do that.  It may interest you to know (though it probably won't since people like you prefer to cast aspersions without fact) that the State Canvassing Board in MN is made up of Pawlenty's appointees, (and yes jerry, he is a Republican) one Independent and one Democrat. The makeup of that Board is largely Republican.  Are you trying to say that they would cheat on Coleman's behalf?

So put up or shut up.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1742270

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google