ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton outlines approach to Iran

Posted: Tuesday, January 13, 2009 11:09 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From NBC's Libby Leist
In the first round of questions with Sen. Kerry, Sen. Clinton has given a rough outline of how the Obama administration will approach Iran.
 
"We are not taking any option off the table at all, but we will pursue a new, perhaps different approach" toward engagement with Iran, she said.

Video: NBC News Chief Foreign Affairs Correspondent Andrea Mitchell reports on the confirmation hearings for Hillary Clinton's place as secretary of state.

She told Kerry the Obama Administration has "no illusions" about the leadership of Iran and that it is difficult to predict how successful engagement will be.

"We won't know what we're capable of achieving until we're there," she said.

Clinton voiced support for more sanctions against Iran and the importance of building international coalitions to support those sanctions.

Kerry asked Clinton whether she would personally engage Iran and she said she couldn't answer that question until she had a chance to come into office get a fuller brief and consult with allies.

In her opening statement, Clinton said, "We cannot give up on peace" in the Middle East and between Israel and Palestinians. She added that the U.S. must persuade Iran and Syria "to abandon their dangerous behavior."

Here's part of Clinton's opening statement: "We must also actively pursue a strategy of smart power in the Middle East that addresses the security needs of Israel and the legitimate political and economic aspirations of the Palestinians; that effectively challenges Iran to end its nuclear weapons program and sponsorship of terror, and persuades both Iran and Syria to abandon their dangerous behavior and become constructive regional actors; that strengthens our relationships with Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, other Arab states, with Turkey, and with our partners in the Gulf to involve them in securing lasting peace in the region.

"As intractable as the Middle East's problems may seem -- and many Presidents, including my husband, have spent years trying to help work out a resolution -- we cannot give up on peace. The President-elect and I understand and are deeply sympathetic to Israel's desire to defend itself under the current conditions, and to be free of shelling by Hamas rockets.  However, we have also been reminded of the tragic humanitarian costs of conflict in the Middle East, and pained by the suffering of Palestinian and Israeli civilians. This must only increase our determination to seek a just and lasting peace agreement that brings real security to Israel; normal and positive relations with its neighbors; and independence, economic progress, and security to the Palestinians in their own state.

"We will exert every effort to support the work of Israeli's and Palestinians who seek that result. It is critical not only to the parties involved but to our profound interests in undermining the forces of alienation and violent extremism across our world."

*** UPDATE *** Clinton: 'Goal is to end the North Korean nuclear programs'
Clinton used tough language on North Korea this morning during questioning from Sen. Murkowski (R-AK). She said, "Our goal is to end the North Korean nuclear programs" and "We have got to end North Korea as a proliferator."

Clinton voiced support for the six-party process started in the Bush administration which includes a working group of China, Japan, South Korea, the US and Russia to deal with North Korea. She said this is a framework she and Obama think "has merit" and "is a vehicle for us to exert pressure on North Korea in a way that is more likely to alter their behavior."

Clinton told the panel the entire North Korea policy is under review, including the recent negotiating record of the U.S. and North Korea, and that she has had lengthly discussions with Secretary Rice about the latest diplomacy.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It took me along time to get over my n egative impression of HillaryClinton because of the antics that occurred during the primaries and I can honestly say that I wasn’t too happy with her as Secretary of State but I respected Obama’s choice because in the end HillaryClinton was the one who put party first; she could have dragged this out during the convention but she had more class and dignity and in her most powerful speech she showed that it wasn’t just about her but it was about all of us.

And after what we have just gone through with Roland Burris the Clown and his traveling circus, HillaryClinton has now fully regained my support and respect; HillaryClinton in the end she showed what Roland Burris is morally bankrupt in showing and that is her integrity.
In other words, by just reading what's written here, Hillary said, absolutely nothing.
So is Barak changing his stance on how he will go out andstart dialogue immediately or is Hillory being overly cautious? It certainly sunds likea mixed message. I wonder if Barak will let Hillory do diplomacy in her own way. I guess I'm still not totally trusting Clinton.
I hope that the new administration will work on creating a Department of Peace that has its own secretary. If we want to bring peace then why is there not a department that represents this? A lot of people do not know that the founding fathers wanted to create this department, but it never happened. Obama please make this happen.
This outlines a straight forward, pragmatic and diplomatic approach to the Middle East including Iran.  The phrase, "including my husband", sticks out like a sore thumb.
... and now we have the possiblilty of Kerry helping to shape foreign policy from Congress? Laughable.
Excellent!  Despite this accurate assessment of the challenges, we have to give always give peace a chance.  Each small step brings us closer.
Brilliant Opening Statement by one very smart woman.  It was nice of Madame Secretary Rice to also invite Hillary and Gen. Jones to dinner on Monday night.  This is the way this country needs to operate from now on....no matter what party is President.
You DO mean president Clinton, don't you?
a new day for america's approach to diplomacy is almost at hand. a long needed in a change of direction is much desired as well as needed. obama, biden and hillary will bring an intelligence, forward thinking philosophy and international inclusiveness that this country should have incorporated in the bush administration. we will witness far better results from our state department in 4 years than we saw in 8 years of bush/cheney diplomacy.
I'm not going to miss Condi Rice. Maybe her fashion statements, but not her steely gaze diplomacy, which never actually brought peace to any situation. Welcome Hillary, Welcome Kerry, Welcome Barack and Joe.
Until we end our blind support of Israel We will not see peace in that part of the world
Hillary clinton,new sworn-in senator speach to the foreign relation committee approve the US-backed aggression in the middle east,especailly against the palestinians,,,,it also stamped that muslim world must be kept away from the new technologies in arm-races as comapare to the others countries,,,during last 30 years US has established asraelis army No one in the ranking with the new weapons and new strategies,,,but it is not faire to imbalance the power,,,it will creat a jungle law for our new world generation
If one or the other side (Israelis or Palestinians) would learn that in order to practice their religion freely and in peace it does not require that they do so in a location where they feel they need to live in the territory or near the relics of their past, we could give one or the other side Texas. Many Nations could volunteer to help one or the other side make the move to Texas (through funding and transportation) and the two sides would be separated by thousands of miles. Plus the fact Iran's desire to build an atomic warhead that could reach Israel might subside after they realize it was the Israeli's who took us up on our offer to move to Texas. On the other hand if it were the Palestinians who took the Texas offer Iran would see how good a neighbors the U.S. have become with the Palestinians (now owning, living and profting in Texas) and would want the U.S. as friends as well, and would be willing to give up their nuclear bomb desires to develop and maintain this frienship with the U.S.
We cannot give up on peace, said hillary clinton, well we can see the affect of pres-elect obama, on her. remember she said she would wipe iran off the map during the primarys, well she must have had long diussions with barack and the tone has changes.
iran to me is not as scarry as they were under the bush administation, the obama administration however will never give up on peace but will not give in to any body, so Israel you may want to get all your bombing out of the way now, because after next week that will all change for at least 4 years.  
If she would have been given the opportunity to the Precidancy...it would have been remarkable!
So Hillary gets confirmed, resigns from the Senate and taking her place Caroline Kennedy. It is all a matter of formality. Dot them i and cross them t.
Hillary Clinton - "We won't know what we're capable of achieving until we're there," she said.

In other words, "We have no idea what we are doing and do not have a plan."

I wonder if BHO still wants to sit down with Iran without any conditions.  He really showed his lack of experience during the campaign, but when you have adoring fans (ABC, NBC, CBS, CNN, etc) covering for you, everyone seemed willing to overlook it.  It is almost time to put up or shut up for Obama.  I hope he is up to the task.  Many US citizens will not tolerate four years of finger pointing and blaming Bush for everything after claiming he had the answers to make this country and the world a better place.
Peace happens through strength.
Hillary Clinton - you are my sHero!!! The world will be a better place with you as our Sec of State.
World Peace in an oxymoron. There are to many regional differences to try and accomplish a raport with the world. We need to back-up reassess our relationships withe each country with an eye as to "whats in it for us." We need to become the strong, rich country we once were. This free trade economy needs to stop. U.S. first and last.
The Clinton messages is the same as Bush's message. "No options will be taken off the table" (i.e., we'll bomb Iran), and we'll use "smart power," I guess in contrast to "dumb power." It is the same policy with some additional and softer sounding words. As long as we call everyone "terrorist" we won't get anywhere. The real terrorist is the Israeli government that has killed close to 1,000 people in Gaza, injured countless more and has destroyed the homes of thousands with American-supplied weapons.
A poor choice. Clinton does not have the abilities needed for the position. I agree with Bret, Litchfield IL that no one wants 4 years of finger pointing but you have to still put the blame squarely where it belongs and it belongs on the Bush administration and their horrible crimes against the US and the world after 8 years. It's a lot of work to accomplish and not enough time and all Clinton will bring to the table are mistakes and problems that will have to be cleaned up later by VP Biden and the UN.
Peace happens through strength.
.............................................
Absolutely right. Strength through integrity, conviction, support of others. Going it alone as a cowboy at noon in a Western town in 1885 doesn't show strength but to those directly associated with a conflict and then briefly.

President Theodore Roosevelt cautioned that we must walk softly and carry a big stick. There is strength if I ever saw it. Using diplomacy by walking softly but have the big stick as a back-up if all else fails. Leaders of the world aren't stupid. They know we have the big stick but they want respect and to know what is in it for them if they make nice. Just shoot first and ask questions later makes no friends and many enemies. It makes one look like a bully who goes around beating up on the wimpy kids just because he can and because he gets a kick out of it.

True leaders don't bully they use diplomacy and sanctions. Sure it takes longer but often works better, is less destructive and cheaper than using a big stick.
What are the answers?

What do you expect from Hillary Clinton if her message is similar to that of other administrations? The world sees Israel and the Palestinians (Hamas and Hezbolah) at each others thraots (for years). Iran and Syria and other Arab nations are going to back the opalestinains in one form or fashion. Israel is going to fight to survive. Iran wants a nuclear weapon and is intent on getting it. Russia is looking for a comeback as a major power player. Some countries south of our borders resent the U.S. China is passing us quickly as an economic power. North Korea is still run by a nut case, India and Pakistan cotinue to threaten one another, etc, etc. What the hell do you expect anyone nominated for Secretary of State to say, or just exactly what qualifications do they need? That they have miracle answers for all these worldly ills. Yeah right. Clinton will do her best but has no more answers than anyone else as to all these issues where events control the conflicts and will determine the outcomes. Not some desired but impractcial all-knowing, powerful Secretary of State or President as there are no such people.
i find it humourous that we have now become a countyr led by a dictatorship...wow...the power that bush ahs to singlehandedly destroy our country...as if we ahd no help and the rest of the goverment was completely helpless to stop this dictatorship...maybe everyone missed that comment the they will support the policy presented by the bush administration...it was slipped in there so well....it seems to me they played off the media frenzy of bush as the villian to get their step up into the white house...smart thinking obama?clinton!!!
WE'VE GOT PALIN UP I ALASKA. I'M SURE WITH A TELESCOPE, SHE CAN SEE NORTH KOREA. SHE CAN SEE RUSSIA WITHOUT ONE!
Hilary Clinton will do this Nation proud.  A good choice, a perfect choice.  One smart, intelligent woman.   She will hit the ground running and always in the right direction for the good of our country and the world.

B.C.  Chandler, AZ
I'm so happy to get Clinton out of the senate. Obama had better keep a close watch on her because I think she will set herself up as a shadow government and set  her own policies. She's a really bad person for government because she only cares about herself and should be put out of government period !!!
It's not "interesting to think" that these two people occupy the positions they hold.  It is a fact.  An interesting fact, but still a fact.  I know the internet has made our minds soft and allowed our language skills to be eroded, but certainly  you can do better than this.  It is interesting to think that one day, you may.
Get over it.  Hillary Clintion is a brillant woman who is fully capable of being Secty of State and yes even the President. Over the next 4 years , she will prove her worth.  Give her a chance.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1743439

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google