ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



A 'cap and trade' refresher

Posted: Tuesday, July 14, 2009 5:26 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From NBC's James Rankin
Here’s a quick quiz: Who said the following?

"A cap-and-trade policy will send a signal that will be heard and welcomed all across the American economy, and the highest rewards will go to those who make the smartest, safest, most responsible choices."

President Obama? Henry Waxman? Nancy Pelosi?

Actually, that was candidate John McCain

, way back in May of 2008. Which is all the more interesting given former running mate Sarah Palin’s anti-cap-and-trade op-ed in today’s Washington Post. In her opinion piece, Palin berated Obama for creating a job-kiling “cap-and-tax dead end,” despite having run on a ticket that mostly supported similar policy goals.

But her running mate -- McCain -- was an ardent supporter of cap-and-trade legislation during his run for the presidency. He distinguished himself during the Republican primary as a candidate who took climate change seriously and openly criticized the Bush administration’s lukewarm stance on the issue.

Don’t count on him to automatically line up behind Obama, however. Earlier in the year, McCain had some harsh words of his own for the president’s plan, calling it a “giant government slush fund that will further burden our businesses and consumers.”

“I still believe that it is the time to address this critical international issue, but my vision for a cap-and-trade system is as a mechanism to lower greenhouse gases in our atmosphere, not as a revenue generator for the federal government,” said McCain.

At issue was Obama’s plan to auction off carbon credits to polluters. McCain instead prefers to distribute credits free of charge. The Waxman-Markey climate change bill that narrowly passed the House last month proposes to give away 70% of the available carbon credits while auctioning off the remaining 30%. As legislation begins to take shape in the Senate, it should be interesting to see where McCain comes down.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hey Domenico Montanaro ...

[Palin berated Obama for creating a job-kiling “cap-and-tax dead end,” despite having run on a ticket that mostly supported similar policy goals.]
--In fairness to Palin, I think that she had mentioned on the stump that she disagreed with Sen. McCain on this issue.  My recollection is that she said she would work on changing his mind.


Something else that is left from the 'cap and trade' bill is an all-of-the-above strategy, which I think more Republicans would support and would be a more bipartisan bill.
Why are you people quoting Palin???, the woman has s*** for brains. She doesn't know what she's talking about, she's faking it, that's what she does best, FAKE IT with a wink and "Old school" beauty pagent instructions.

I have no respect for this WOMAN, because she doesn't respect herself.
This is bar none the largest attack on property rights in 100 years!
We all know McCain was trying to be all Mavericky - if Obama said potaaaayyyto, McCain said potahhhhto.

And look where it got him.  Moving in.

moving ON,...(hate those typos when attempting sarcasm - sh!t happens).
So the Waxman-Markey bill COMPROMISES and does some of what President Obama wants and some of what Senator McCain wants. Now if only the republicans could recognize it as a compromise, instead of saying that if it isn't 100% there plan, President Obama is NOT being bi-partisan.
Well isn't that pleasant. Obama accepts responsibility. Big deal. He may accept responsibility, but he doesn't accept the consequences, that's left for the people that are suffering because of his decisions.

Your plan ISN'T working Obama. It's making things worse. You're just to proud to believe you little experiment of spending trillions of dollars has neither 1) Created ANY jobs, 2) Allowed the banks to make more credit available. 3) Helped one person, one individual.

You're a failure Obama. Face the facts and quit spending money you do not have.
Kris Jenkins, NC (Sent Tuesday, July 14, 2009 5:21 PM)
_____________________________________

Dearie and your suggestions to get out of this fiasco would be WHAT??  

Nice rant NO substance (except spoon fed right wing nut job talking points),ideas, solutions or suggestions! So so typical of the GeeNoPee!

Next! Moving right along!
And your point?
Palin disagrees with McCain?  So what?  In the primaries, Joe Biden called Obama "naive" with his foreign policy ideas and said "the presidency doesn't lend itself to on-the-job training".  And Hillary Clinton told us that all Obama had as experience was "a speech".
The liberals in government keep loading up companies with more and more taxes and regulations. Then they wonder why the jobs are shipped overseas.
And John McCain did not win. 'Nuff said.

He needed Palin to appeal to conservatives. 'Nuff said.
"Actually, that was candidate John McCain, way back in May of 2008. Which is all the more interesting given former running mate Sarah Palin’s anti-cap-and-trade op-ed in today’s Washington Post."
------------------------------------------------------
Nah, not so interesting.  Nor terribly surprising.  Apparently the "higher calling" that compelled Sarah to ditch the Alaskan electorate was becoming a trial lobbyist for the coal/oil/petroleum industries- or any others that would benefit from less regulation of carbon emissions.

Of course, anyone who believes that this lobbying exercise/op-ed came from the same brain that produced the frantic word-salad-spewage of the resignation announcement, is likely in need of some fresh oxygen to his/her brain as well.  Also.
“I still believe that it is the time to address this critical international issue, but my vision for a cap-and-trade system is as a mechanism to lower greenhouse gases in our atmosphere, not as a revenue generator for the federal government,” said McCain.
==================================================
So we don't want a REVENUE GENERATOR FOR THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT? It wouldn't help us pay off the taxpayers? I am so confused by the posters on this site. I would think if the government made money we won't have these stimulus plans.
Someone wrote that Palin's article, put her name on it and sent it into paper.  It did not have a clue of sounding like Palin-ite talk, whatever that it.
Of course she does not agree with McCain, she did not know what McCain supported or did not support!
I read the article, it was a joke!
Just my thoughts
Of course Palin is against cap and trade. She lives and breathes Alaskan OIL.

McCain, her running mate touted cap and trade as the greatest thing since sliced bread. Now he lost so cap and trade, which obviously actually must have been a good idea, is bad because there is no Republican President to push it through. The party of no says no unless one of their own loves it. They refuse to compromise, they refuse to cooperate, they refuse to do anything but sit on their butts and just say no, pathetic hypocrites that they are.
why are the dems so dead set on making America a third world country that is whats happening, tax the hell out anybody or any company that makes money, drive them to india or china. their green wacko polices make no sense in almost no return verses cost. millions more will lose jobs, the energy efficient light bulbs is just one of their wacko ideas, break one in your house then call hazmat to clean up the mercury. no to crap and tax!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1996391

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google