ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Sen. Collins speaks out

Posted: Wednesday, October 14, 2009 10:59 AM by firstread
Filed Under:


From NBC's Kelly Paice
As the Senate continues its debate on health care reform, Senator Susan Collins (R-ME) released a statement today saying that she supports the efforts of Senator Olympia Snowe (R-ME) to pass the Senate Finance Committee's health care bill yesterday; however, she expressed concern over the bill in general.
 
Sen. Collins said that the Senate Finance Committee's bill "represents a substantial improvement over the costly and flawed alternative approved by the Senate Health Committee as well as the House bills." However, she continued, "Nevertheless, the Senate Finance Committee's bill falls short of the goal of providing access to more affordable health care for all Americans. The goal of health care reform must be to rein in costs and provide consumers with more affordable choices. Yet, many individuals and families would be forced to pay more for their health care under the Finance Committee bill, and they would have fewer choices."
 
The senator also expressed her concern that the Finance Committee's bill could hurt small businesses and could discourage them from adding more jobs. Also, Sen. Collins said she is concerned about how the legislation would affect Medicare: "I am troubled that the legislation would cut nearly $500 billion from Medicare, which provides care for our oldest Americans and our most vulnerable citizens. ... It should not be the piggy bank for new spending programs when revenues are needed to shore up the current program."
 
Senator Collins expressed her disappointment that the Finance Committee did not do more to contain costs, which she suggests "should have been one of the most important goals of this bill." The senator remains "hopeful" for a health care reform bill to be passed that "protects affordable health care choices, safeguards Medicare, and reduces costs to the consumer and the taxpayer especially at a time when we simply cannot afford to pay more."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

These two Maine senators are priceless.  Susan Collins must be miffed that Snowe got all the attention yesterday so now she's creating her own 'look at me!' moment.
While I appreciate Senator Snowe’s yes vote… even if all it did was let the WH ‘claim’ bi-partisanship’ (oh and make the righties heads EXPLODE which is always good for a chuckle!

When all is said & done we don’t need the Republican’ts and I for one am getting more than fed up with all the kumbaya crap!

They will NEVER support the public option and without the PUBLIC OPTION there is NO HCR!

With each passing day I’m becoming more convinced that Rahm Emmanual (sp?) has got to GO!  He’s a ‘rotton apple’ in the fruit bowl! Things ran smoothly UNTIL he climbed on board!

I didn’t work my a@@ of to get the President elected so he could pussy foot around with the dopes of nope! Rahm represents everything that is WRONG with DC – status quo & business as usual!

President Obama needs to pay more attention to David Axelrod & Co. there the ones that got him where he is… not the Hillary loving Rahm!
Healthcare reform needs a “Parody Option.” Check out “Healthcare Fighting (King Fu Mix)” at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nc1VwJOb9Y
of course, she failed to mention that she opposes a public option - which is the only thing that would achieve the goals she listed. who needs consistency or honesty?
It looks like Maine just succeeded from the Confederacy.
Of course Collins supports Snowe.  No surprise there.  Where's the real news???
And we care about her why?
In other words, Sen. Collins wants to sit on the sidelines.
Forgive my ignorance on the issue but wont the new HC bill absorb the elderly and so Medicare will no longer be needed?  Where is the documentation that explains why we would even have two different HC bills, one for the elderly and one for everybody else?  This argument over Medicare benefits and the new HC bill has been a point of confusion and frustration for me.  Perhaps someone could point me in the direction of enlightenment on this topic?
P.S. I'd rather be considered as being a boot-licker for a President that is trying to do his job, as opposed to being an ass-licker to a President that screwed up the WORLD.

Anita, Birmingham, Alabama (Sent Wednesday, October 14, 2009 11:03 AM)
_____________________

Anita Girl… My thoughts EXACTLY! I couldn’t have said it better myself! ;0)
_____________________

Congratulations President Obama on sheparding health insurance form out of the Finance committee!

This is the furthest the process has gotten in 60 years, and even though the media won't give you ANY credit, none of this would be happening without your insistence that we address health reform THIS YEAR

Nashville_fan (Sent Wednesday, October 14, 2009 10:41 AM)
______________________

I tried to convey that yesterday… not only is this historic… I also would put it in the ‘win column for the President’!  Even if the chattering class can’t seem to bring itself to do so!

I don’t know about you… but I’ve finally recovered from Friday’s ‘festivities’!  Although I haven’t been able to stop laughing at the sour grapes still flowing like a raging river from the righties!

Oh... what fun...
Senator Collins expresses concerns that many of us feel need to be addressed and they will be during the merging of the bills, amendments, debate.  Being a liberal, the public option or Wyden's free choice option is important because it will increase competition but I also know there are other equally important elements in the legislation.  I completely support the democratic senators who are pushing to have the Sherman Anti-Trust Act be applied to insurance companies.  To be honest, I did not know or remember that the insurance companies were exempt from this.  That would be helpful in getting these powerful companies, who hold life and death decisions in their hands, under control.  In many ways, employer-provided health care has made reform more difficult because those of us fortunate to have it are unaware of the actual cost for the insurance.  One of the local news stations last night did random street questioning on HCR--one lady stated that she had medicare so didn't see any need to reform the system.  Therein lies part of the problem.  Those who have health care often see no further than their own backyard.
It really should not surprise anyone that the two most courageous Republicans are the two Senators from Maine. Way to go lobster people.
SHOOTING BB's

The radical Dems, while still in charge until 2010, are shooting BB's at a battleship with their raucous health care plan.

Questions:

Is Biden still alive and well?
Is Hillary lying too, like Pelosi?
Is it over for Harry Reid in Nevada?
Is Olympia Snowe playing the Dems for fools?
Is Anita Dunn helping FOX NEWS's ratings?
Did Lynyrd Skynyrd diss Obie on Hannity?
Has Obie recovered from the Olympic NO to Chicago?


Full Moon
Palomino
Bad Chihuahua ... and the rest.



Feisty Redhead Roselle, IL:

Happy to oblige. These Bush-whacker supporters are insulting. They'll eventually learn that our silence isn't due to stupidity. We just refuse to defend all manner BS or for that matter buy into theirs. lol, lol, lol
Susan Collins sounds like she wants the public option....... Thats the only way to rein in cost!!!!
I tried to convey that yesterday… not only is this historic… I also would put it in the ‘win column for the President’!  Even if the chattering class can’t seem to bring itself to do so!

I don’t know about you… but I’ve finally recovered from Friday’s ‘festivities’!  Although I haven’t been able to stop laughing at the sour grapes still flowing like a raging river from the righties!

Oh... what fun...

Feisty Redhead Roselle, IL
==================================================
Oh Feisty, I have recovered . . . and I too am enjoying the loud wailing of the President's critics . . . how dare ANYONE give him credit for ANYTHING? lol lol lol lol lol

Those damned Norweigians didn't get the memo that we are supposed to ridicule the President no matter what . . . CURSES! :)
I was a little concerned about medicare cuts since I just made the pack this past month. However, I was not aware that medicare covers gym costs as I noted in one article. Sorry, that's beyond the pale for me. The old folks need to work in the garden, clean their house more often, take each-other for walks and cut the gym fees on medicare. With the price of gyms a cut there alone might cover the loss.
Congratulations to the president and boos to all who voted against. We need healthcare reform NOW.
We need more like Senators Collins and Snowe as true conscientious and honest bipartisanship is the only way they can ever objectively and rationally fine tune reform to be truly effective.  Too liberal or too conservative or continuing as is, can't be the answer.  But how do you get more to put their personal interests aside to be honestly conscientious?  It seems against their nature.
TV ads are currently trying to sell Senator Jon Kyl as being sincere in protecting Medicare and as wanting to get health care reform right, trying to present him as being conscientious for the average American.  … Why?  Kyl’s history clearly demonstrates his stubborn and arrogant strong support for everything favoring Special Interests and as just being a ‘puppet’ for the powerful and influential few, always being persistent in boldly repeating their scripted subterfuge, word for word.  Are they starting their manipulation of public opinion to try to sell him so he can be one of their primary ‘puppets’, aggressively doing their bidding?  If you recognize just how drastic the costs were to the average American with the Bush-Cheney ‘puppet’ presidency, you better hope we never see the likes of Palin-Kyl.  Talk about gross dishonesty, self-indulgence, arrogance and being sociopathic without any conscience, either one could make Bush look like an altar-boy.
You braying & dancing Dem supporters DO realize this HealthCare plan does nothing until 2015-though higher taxes will begin paying for it in 2011, right?
Democrats = Socialists.

Complete control of individuals for the collective good.  Socialism destroys the creation of wealth.  Equalizes poverty for everyone.
You can call it historic all you want, but:
dems tried to rush this 1000+ page bill thru in august before anyone could find out what was in it. So much for the one's transparency.
Those who wanted answers about this bill and its costs (which keep going up) got smeared as "nazis" "un-american" but no lasting answers.
obama's promises of keeping your plan if you like it are deliberately dated promises. And the MSM refuses to fact check on him.
You really think the gov track record with ss, medcare, fmae/fmac, the post office (I mean it just got bailed out, and all) this massive gov entitlement which is just in DRAFT form(which is all the CBO was allowed to work projections from) is going to end any differently?
Explain how this shell game won't end in ruins like all the other political football entitlements.
I'm glad for Susan Collins stand and statements.
Congrats to the government, which runs all programs and departments smoothly and efficiently.  They do a real bang up job containing costs and promoting competition.  Oh wait, they don't have competition because unlike a private company that raises pricing to pass increased costs on to the customer (who can find another company if they don't like the pricing) the government just takes more money through taxation from the people (and they don't have any other options).  How is that competition?  Sounds like a monopoly to me.  Also, everyone wants to tax "the rich" or somebody else to pay for these programs...but raise YOUR rates 2 pennies and it's anarchy (see $4 gasoline in past years)!  The hypocrisy would be funny if it wasn't so sad.
I am appalled that you would consider supporting a bill that isn't even written yet.  It is downright disgusting that you would join a group that doesn't even allow us, an AMERICAN CITIZEN to read and know what they are proposing.  My representative, Mr. Sensennbrenner told us at the last townhall meeting that many of these meetings are closed doors and they aren't even invited, much let clued into as to what is taking place.  Are you truly concerned about reform or is it more about power and clout.  I believe that as an AMERICAN  citizen I am entitled to have a copy of the proposed plan in my hand 72 hours before it is voted on.  Is this another railroad job.  The finance committee of which the "turncoat Mr. O. Stone  supported doesn't even have a plan in hand.  What has this government come to...a disgrace to democracy.  Swanhild Tess


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=2098272

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google